FEB S1 1898
m.9 S67i 6l.0k22i
iitchock
of naterials;
9 H67i 6l-0l^2^1
;Lock $ia-oo .
the nature of materials,
17-1941
ansas city |||| public library
BiiapS bansas city, missouri
mmmw
Books will be issued only
on presentation of library card.
Please report lost cards and
change of residence promptly.
Card holders are responsible for
all books, records, films, pictures
or other library materials
checked out on their cards.
In the Nature of Materials
FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT ON ARCHITEC-
TURE
Selected Writings 1894-1940
Edited with an Introduction by Frederick
Gutheim
AN AUTOBIOGRAPHY
Five books in one volume
IN THE NATURE OF MATERIALS
The Buildings of Frank Lloyd Wright
By Henry-Russell Hitchcock
IN THE NATURE OF MATERIALS
1887 - 1941
THE BUILDINGS OF
FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT
DUEL L, SLOAN AND PEARCE • NEW YORK 1942
HENRY-RUSSELL HITCHCOCK
COPYRIGHT, 1942, by
frank LLOYD WRIGHT AND HENRY-RUS SELL HITCHCOCK
All rights reserved, including
the right to reproduce this book
or portions thereof in any form.
Fifth Printing May 1958
durintep in the united states of amerii
TO
WESLEYAN UNIVERSITY
f i T s t A. TTi 6 T i c cm ifistitution
to recognize the genius of
FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT
with academic honors
6104221
Contents
List of Illustrations
Preface
Acknowledgments
Part One: 1887-1893
I. Chicago Architecture in the Eighties and J. L. Silsbee
II. Sullivan's Maturity and Wright's Work with Sullivan
Part Two: 1889-1900
III. Wright’s Independent Work Before 1893
IV. The Maturing of Wright
Part Three: i 901-19 10
V. The Prairie Houses
VI. Non-Domestic Work
Part Four: 1911-1920
VII. From the Middle West to Japan and California
Part Five: 1921-1930
VIII. Textile Block Houses and Projects and Cantilevered Skyscraper Projects
Part Six: 1931-1941
IX. Projects of the Depression Years and the Current Revival of Activity
Chronological List of Executed Work and Projects: 1887-1941
Index
Illustrations^
Frontispiece; Taliesin West, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938- . Photo. Guerrero.
Figs. I -10 are on plates following page 14
1. Project: Unitarian Chapel, Sioux City, Iowa. From Inland Architect^ June, 1887.
2. Misses Lloyd Jones house. Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. [1887.]
3. Louis Sullivan stable. Ocean Springs, Miss. 1890. (Adler and Sullivan.) Photo. Ross.
4. Louis Sullivan house, Ocean Springs, Miss. 1890. (Adler and Sullivan.) Photo. Fuer-
mann.
5. Schiller Building, 64 West Randolph St., Chicago, 111 , 1891-92. (Adler and Sullivan.)
Photo. Barnum and Barnum.
6. Meyer Building, 307 West Van Buren St., Chicago, 111 . 1893. (Adler and Sullivan.)
Photo. Chicago Architectural Photographic Go.
7. Stock Exchange Building, 30 North La Salle St., Chicago, 111 . 1893-94. (Adler and
Sullivan.) Photo. Barnum and Barnum.
8. Project: Luxfer Prism Skyscraper. [1895.] Photo. Museum of Modern Art.
9. James Charnley house, 1365 Astor St., Chicago, 111 . 1891. (Adler and Sullivan.) Photo.
Fuermann.
10. Victoria Hotel, Chicago Heights, 111 . 1892-93. (Adler and Sullivan.) Photo. Fuermann.
Figs. 11-413 are in the concluding plate section following page 130.
1 1 . Frank Lloyd Wright house, 428 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1 889.
12. Frank Lloyd Wright house, 428 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1889. Plans.
13. Frank Lloyd Wright house, 428 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1889. Living room. Photo.
Fuermann.
14. Frank Lloyd Wright house, 428 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1 889. Fireplace inglenook.
15. Frank Lloyd Wright house, 428 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . Later dining room. [1895.]
Photo. Fuermann.
16. Frank Lloyd Wright house, 428 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . Later play room. [1895.]
Photo. Fuermann.
17. R. P. Parker house, 1027 Chicago Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1892. Front. Photo. Lane.
18. Robert G. Emmond house, 109 South Eighth Ave., La Grange, 111 . 1892. Plan.
^Figure numbers 227, 270, 272, 306, 319, 326 and 354 are omitted.
[xi]
ig. George Blossom house, 4858 Kenwood Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1892. Photo. Lane.
20. George Blossom house, 4858 Kenwood Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1892. Plans.
2 1 . Dr. Allison W. Harlan house, 4414 Greenwood Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1 892.
22. Dr. Allison W. Harlan house, 4414 Greenwood Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1892. Plan.
23. Robert W. Roloson houses, 3213-3219 Calumet Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1894. Photo. Lane.
24. Robert W. Roloson houses, 3213-3219 Calumet Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1894. Plans.
25. W. H. Winslow house, Auvergne PL, River Forest, 111 . 1893.
26. W. H. Winslow house, Auvergne PL, River Forest, 111 . 1893. Plan.
27. W. H. Winslow house, Auvergne PL, River Forest, 111 . 1893. Entrance Hall. Photo.
Fuermann.
28. W. H. Winslow house, Auvergne PL, River Forest, 111 . 1893. P-ear. Photo. Lane.
29. Chauncey L. Williams house, 520 Edgewood PL, River Forest, 111 . 1895. Photo, cour-
tesy of Art Institute, Chicago.
30. Frederick Bagley house, loi County Line Rd., Hinsdale, 111 . 1894. Pkoto. Lane.
3 1 . Francis Apartments, 4304 Forestville Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1895.
32. Nathan G. Moore house, 329 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . [1895].
33. Francisco Terrace, 253-257 Francisco Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1895. Court. Photo. Lane.
34. Francisco Terrace, 253-257 Francisco Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1895. Second floor plan.
35. Francisco Terrace, 253-257 Francisco Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1895. Entrance front. Photo.
Lane.
36. Waller Apartments, 2840-2858 West Walnut St., Chicago, 111 . 1895. Photo. Lane.
37. Project : Wolf Lake amusement park, on Wolf Lake, 111 . 1895.
38. Frank Lloyd Wright studio, 951 Chicago Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1895. Perspective.
39. Frank Lloyd Wright studio, 951 Chicago Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1895. Entry.
40. Frank Lloyd Wright studio, 951 Chicago Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1895. Entrance.
41. Frank Lloyd Wright studio, 951 Chicago Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1895. Plan.
42. Misses Lloyd Jones windmill. Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. 1896. Photo. Lane.
43. Isidor Heller house, 5132 Woodlawn Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1897.
44. Isidor Heller house, 5132 Woodlawn Ave., Chicago, 111 , 1897. Plan from Architectural
Review 1900.
45. Joseph W. Husser house, 180 Buena Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1899.
46. Joseph W. Husser house, 180 Buena Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1899. Plan.
47. River Forest Golf Club, Bonnie Brae Ave., River Forest, 111 . Front wing. [ 1 898.]
48. River Forest Golf Club, Bonnie Brae Ave., River Forest, 111 . As enlarged. [1901,] From
Chicago Architectural Club Annual, 1902, courtesy of Art Institute, Chicago.
[xii]
49- River Forest Golf Club, Bonnie Brae Ave., River Forest, 111 . [1901]. Perspective from
Ausgefilhrte Bauten und Entwilrfe, pi. XI.
50. River Forest Golf Club, Bonnie Brae Ave., River Forest, 111 . [1901]. Plan.
51. Edward G. Waller dining- room, Auvergne PL, River Forest, 111 . 1899. Photo. Fuermann.
52. Project; Edward G. Waller house, River Forest, 111 . 1899.
53. Warren Hickox house, 687 South Harrison Ave., Kanlcakee, 111 . 1900. Photo. Fuer-
mann.
54. Warren Hickox house, 687 South Harrison Ave., Kankakee, 111 . 1900. Plans.
55. B. Harley Bradley house, 701 South Harrison Ave., Kankakee, 111 . 1900.
56. B. Harley Bradley house, 701 South Harrison Ave., Kankakee, 111 . 1900. Plan.
57. B. Harley Bradley house, 701 South Harrison Ave., Kankakee, 111 . 1900. Living room.
Photo. Fuermann.
58. Project: “A Home in a Prairie Town” for Curtis Publishing Co. 1900. Perspective from
Ladies^ Home /owrna/, February, 1901.
59. Project: “A Home in a Prairie Town” for Curtis Publishing Co. 1900. Plans from
Ladies^ Home /owrna/, February, 1901.
60. Project: “A Home in a Prairie Town” for Curtis Publishing Co. 1900. Section from
Ladies’ Home /owrnfl/, February, 1901.
61. Project: “A Small House with Tots of Room in IF ” for Curtis Publishing Co. 1900.
Perspective from Ladies’ Home Journal , June, 1901.
62. Project: “A Small House with Tots of Room in It’ ” for Curtis Publishing Co. 1900.
Plans from Ladies’ Home Journal , June, 1901.
63. Project: “A Small House with Tots of Room in It’ ” for Curtis Publishing Co. 1900.
Sections from Ladies’ Home Journal, June, 1901.
64. William G. Fricke house, 540 Fair Oaks Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1902. Photo. Fuermann.
65. Project: “Village Bank in Cast Concrete.” For Brickbuilder, August, 1901. Perspec-
tive from Ausgefilhrte Bauten und Entwilrfe, pi. XII.
66. F. B. Henderson house, 301 South Kenilworth Ave., Elmhurst, 111 . 1901. Perspective.^
67. F. B. Henderson house, 301 South Kenilworth Ave., Elmhurst, 111 . 1901. Photo. Lane.
68. F. B. Henderson house, 301 South Kenilworth Ave., Elmhurst, 111 . 1901. Plan.
69. Frank Thomas house, 210 Forest Ave., OakPark, 111 . 1901.
70. Frank Thomas house, 210 Forest Ave., OakPark, 111 . 1901. Plans.
7 r . Arthur Heurtley house, 3 1 8 F orest Ave., Oak Park, 111 , 1902.
72. Arthur Heurtley house, 318 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1902. Plans.
[xiii]
73- Ward W. Willitts house, 715 South Sheridan Rd., Highland Park, 111 . 1902. Photo.
Fuermann.
74. Ward W. Willitts house, 715 South Sheridan Rd., Highland Park, 111 . 1902. Ground
floor plan.
75. Ward W. Willitts house, 715 South Sheridan Rd., Highland Park, 111 . 1902. Living
room.
76. Ward W. Willitts house, 715 South Sheridan Rd., Highland Park, 111 . Second floor
plan.
77. Charles S. Ross house. South Shpre Rd., Delavan Lake, Wis. 1902. Photo. Fuermann.
78. Charles S. Ross house, South Shore Rd., Delavan Lake, Wis. 1902. Plans.
79. Project: Yahara Boat Club, Madison, Wis. 1902. Perspective and plan.
80. Project: Frank Lloyd Wright studio house. Oak Park, 111 . [1903]. Plan.
81. Hillside Home School, Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. 1902.
82. Hillside Home School, Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. 1902. Plan.
83. Hillside Home School, Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. 1902. Living room pavilion.
84. Hillside Home School, Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. 1902. Living room fireplace. Photo.
Peterson.
85. Susan Laurence Dana house. East Laurence Ave. at 4th St., Springfield, 111 . 1903.
86. Susan Laurence Dana house, East Laurence Ave. at 4th St., Springfield, 111 . 1903.
Dining room.
87. Susan Laurence Dana house. East Laurence Ave. at 4th St., Springfield, 111 . 1903.
Bronze and glass screen.
88. Susan Laurence Dana house. East Laurence Ave. at 4th St., Springfield, 111 . 1903.
Gallery.
89. Francis W. Little house and stable, 603 Moss Ave., Peoria, III. 1903.
90. Francis W. Little house and stable, 603 Moss Ave., Peoria, 111 . 1903. Plan.
91 . Francis W. Little house, 603 Moss Ave., Peoria, 111 . 1903. Entrance.
92. Larkin Company Administration Building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. 1904.
93. Larkin Company Administration Building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Office
interior.
94. Larkin Company Administration Building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Side
view.
95. Larkin Company Administration Building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Interior
of court.
[xiv]
gG. Larkin Company Administration Building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. First
and third floor plans from The Life-work of the Architect Frank Lloyd Wright ^ p. 4.
97. Larkin Company Administration Building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. En-
trance.
98. Larkin Company Administration Building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Office
furnishings.
99. E.-Z. Polish Factory, 3005-3017 West Carroll Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1905. Photo. Lane.
100. Darwin D. Martin house and adjuncts, 125 Jewett Pkway, Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Estate
plan.
10 1. Darwin D. Martin house, 125 Jewett Pkway, Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Photo. Baxtresser.
102. Darwin D. Martin house, 125 Jewett Pkway, Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. View from lawn.
103. Darwin D. Martin house, 125 Jewett Pkway, Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Gallery.
104. Darwin D. Martin house, 125 Jewett Pkway, Buffalo, N. Y. 1904. Living room.
105. Edwin H. Cheney house, 520 North East Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1904. Perspective.
1 06. Edwin H. Cheney house, 520 North East Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1904. Side View.
107. Edwin H. Cheney house, 520 North East Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1904. Plan.
108. Project: Larkin Company workmen’s row houses, Buffalo, N. Y. [1904]. Perspective
from Ausgefuhrte Bauten und Entwiirfe^ pi. XL.
109. Project: Larkin Company workmen’s row houses, Buffalo, N. Y. [1904]. Plans.
1 10. W. A. Glasner house, 850 Sheridan Rd., Glencoe, 111 . 1905. Photo. Fuermann.
111. W. A. Glasner house, 850 Sheridan Rd., Glencoe, 111 . 1905. Plan.
1 12. Thomas P. Hardy house, 1319 South Main St., Racine, Wis. Street front. Photo. Lane.
1 1 3 . Thomas P. Hardy house, 1319 South Main St., Racine, Wis. Plans.
1 14. Thomas P. Hardy house, 1319 South Main St., Racine, Wis. Perspective.
1 15. Frank L. Smith Bank, Dwight, 111 . 1906. Photo, Lane.
1 1 6. Frank L. Smith Bank, Dwight, 111 . 1906. Plan.
1 1 7. Project; Walter Gerts (Alex Davidson) house, Glencoe, 111 . (Buffalo, N. Y.) 1906. Plan.
iiS. Unity Church, Kenilworth Ave. at Lake St., Oak Park, 111 . 1906. Side View.
1 19. Unity Church, Kenilworth Ave. at Lake St., Oak Park, 111 . 1906. Plan.
1 20. Unity Church, Kenilworth Ave. at Lake St., Oak Park, 111 . 1906. Interior of auditorium.
Photo. Fuermann.
12 1. Unity Church, Kenilworth Ave. at Lake St., Oak Park, 111 . 1906, Photo. Fuermann.
Interior of parish house.
122. Rookery Building remodelled entrance, La Salle and Adams Sts., Chicago, 111 . 1905.
[XV]
123- Unity Church, Kenilworth Ave. at Lake St., Oak Park, 111 . 1906. Detail. Photo.
Willard and Barbara Morgan.
124. P. A. Beachy house, 238 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . 1906.
125. W. R. Heath house, 76 Soldiers PL, Buffalo, N. Y. 1905. Living room.
126. A. W. Gridley house. North Batavia Ave., Geneva, 111 . 1906.
127. A. W. Gridley house. North Batavia Ave., Geneva, 111 . 1906. Plans.
128. Project: “A Fireproof House for $5000” for the Curtis Publishing Co. 1906. Perspec-
tive from the Ladies^ Home Journal^ April, 1907.
129. Project : “A Fireproof House for $5000” for the Curtis Publishing Co. 1906. Plans from
the Ladies' Home Journal, April, 1907.
130. Stephen M. B. Hunt house, 345 South Seventh Ave., La Grange, 111 . 1907.
13 1. Project: Warren McArthur concrete apartment house, Kenwood, Chicago, 111 . 1906.
Perspective from Ausgefilhrte Bauten und Entwurfe, pi. LIV.
132. Project: Warren McArthur concrete apartment house, Kenwood, Chicago, 111 . 1906.
Plan.
133. Larkin Company Pavilion, Jamestown Exposition, Jamestown, Va., 1907. Perspective
from Ausgefilhrte Bauten und Entwurfe, pi. XXXVI.
134. Pebbles and Balch decorating shop, 1107 Lake St., Oak Park, 111 . 1907. Photo, courtesy
of Grant C. Manson.
135. Burton J. Westcott house, 1340 East High St., Springfield, Ohio, 1907. Photo. Lane.
136. L. K. Horner house, 1331 Sherwin Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1908. Photo. Fuermann.
137. F. F. Tomekhouse, 150 Nuttall Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1907.
138. F. F. Tomekhouse, 150 Nuttall Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1907. Plans.
139. Project: Harold McCormick house. Lake Forest, 111 . [1907]. Holograph plan and ele-
vation study.
140. Project: Harold McCormick house. Lake Forest, 111 . [1907]. Perspective of lake front
from Ausgefilhrte Bauten und Entwurfe, pi. LIX.
141. Project: Harold McCormick house. Lake Forest, 111 . [1907]. Bird’s-eye perspective
from land side from Ausgefilhrte Bauten und Entwurfe, pi. LVIII,
142. E. E. Boynton house, 16 EastBlvd., Rochester, N. Y. 1908. Photo. Callisen.
143. E. E. Boynton house, 16 East Blvd., Rochester, N. Y. 1908. Plan.
144. Robert W. Evans house, 9914 Longwood Dr., Chicago, 111 . 1908. Photo. Fuermaim.
145. Robert W. Evans house, 9914 Longwood Dr., Chicago, 111 . 1908. Dining room. Photo.
Fuermann.
146. Robert W, Evans house, 9914 Longwood Dr., Chicago, 111 . 1908. Plan.
[xvi]
147- Avery Coonley house, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1908. Estate plan.
148. Avery Coonley house, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1908. Original garden front.
Photo. Fuermann.
149. Avery Coonley house, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1908. Garden front with
added pergola. Photo. Fuermann.
150. Avery Coonley house, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1908. Master’s wing. Photo.
Fuermann.
15 1. Avery Coonley house, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1908. Detail of wall pattern.
152. Avery Coonley house, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1908. Living room. Photo.
Fuermann.
153. Avery Coonley house, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1908. Terrace. Photo. Fuer-
mann.
154. Isabel Roberts house, 603 Edgewood PL, River Forest, 111 . 1908. Photo. Fuermann.
155. Isabel Roberts house, 603 Edgewood PL, River Forest, 111 . 1908. Plans.
156. Isabel Roberts house, 603 Edgewood PL, River Forest, 111 . 1908. Living room. Photo.
Fuermann.
157. E. A. Gilmore house, 120 Ely PL, Madison, Wis. 1908.
158. Frank J. Baker house, 507 Lake Ave., Wilmette, 111 . 1909. Photo. Fuermann.
159. Frank J. Baker house, 507 Lake Ave., Wilmette, 111 . 1909. Plans.
160. Mrs. Thomas H. Gale house, 6 Elizabeth Gt., Oak Park, 111 . 1909.
1 61. Mrs. Thomas H. Gale house, 6 Elizabeth Ct., Oak Park, 111 . 1909. Plans.
162. Meyer May house, 450 Madison Ave., S.E., Grand Rapids, Mich. 1909. Photo. Lane.
163. J. Kibben Ingalls house, 562 Keystone Ave., River Forest, 111 . 1909. Photo. Lane.
164. Frederick C. Robie house, 5757 Woodlawn Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1909. Photo. Fuermann.
165. Frederick C. Robie house, 5757 Woodlawn Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1909. Plans from the
Museum of Modern Art.
166. Frederick C. Robie house, 5757 Woodlawn Ave., Chicago, 111 . 1909. Dining room.
Photo. Fuermann.
167. Como Orchards summer colony, Darby, Mont. [1910]. Perspective of whole project
from Ausgefuhrte Bauten und Enfwiirfe, pi. XL VI.
168. City National Banlc Building. West State St. and South Federal Ave., Mason City, Iowa.
1909. Photo, from Western Architect^ 1911? courtesy of Art Institute, Chicago.
169. City National Bank Building and Hotel. West State St. and South Federal Ave., Mason
City, Iowa. 1909. Ground floor plan.
[xvii]
170. Hotel, West State St. and South Federal Ave., Mason City, Iowa. 1909. Photo, from
Western Architect^ 19 1 1 3 courtesy of Art Institute, Chicago.
1 71. City National Bank Building and Hotel, West State St. and South Federal Ave., Mason
City, Iowa, 1909. Third floor plan.
172. Project: Lexington Terrace, Chicago, 111 . 1909.
173. Project; Lexington Terrace, Chicago, 111 . 1909. Plan from Ausgefuhrte Bauten und
Entwilrfe, pi. VII.
174. Taliesin I, Spring Green, Wis. 191 1. Photo. Fuermann.
1 75. Taliesin I, Spring Green, Wis. 191 1. Plan.
176. Taliesin II, Spring Green, Wis. 1914. The Garden. Photo. Fuermann.
177. Taliesin I, Spring Green, Wis. 191 1. Dining group, living room. Photo. Fuermann.
1 78. Taliesin I, Spring Green, Wis. 191 1. Entrance loggia. Photo. Fuermann.
1 79. Herbert G. Angster house, 605 Blodgett Rd., Lake Bluff, 111 . 19 1 1 .
1 80. Herbert C. Angster house, 605 Blodgett Rd., Lake Bluff, 111 . 1 9 1 1 . Plans.
18 1. Project: Sherman M. Booth house. Ravine Bluffs, Glencoe, 111 . 191 1.
182. Project : Sherman M. Booth house. Ravine Bluffs, Glencoe, 111 . 19 1 1 . Plans.
183. Project: Avery Coonley kindergarten, Riverside, 111. 1911.
184. Avery Coonley playhouse, 350 Fairbanks Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1912. Interior. Photo.
Fuermann.
185. Avery Coonley playhouse, 350 Fairbanks Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1912. Photo. Fuermann.
186. Avery Coonley playhouse, 350 Fairbanks Rd., Riverside, 111 . 1912. Plan.
187. Project; Press Building for Spreckels Estate, Market between 3rd and 4th Sts., San
Francisco, Cal. [1912]. Model of isolated tower.
188. Project: Press Building for Spreckels Estate, Market between 3rd and 4th Sts., San
Francisco, Cal. [1912]. Perspective with link to Tower Building.
189. Project: Frank Lloyd Wright house, Goethe St., Chicago, 111 . [191 1]. Perspective.
190. Project: Frank Lloyd Wright house, Goethe St., Chicago, 111 . [191 1]. Plans.
1 91. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at Goth St., Chicago, 111 . 1914.
192. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at Goth St., Chicago, 111 . 1914. Section.
193. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at Goth St., Chicago, 111 . 1914. Photo. Fuer-
mann.
194. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at Goth St., Chicago, 111 . 1914. Street Front.
Photo. Fuermann.
195. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at Goth St., Chicago, 111 . 1914. Upper terraces.
[ xviii ]
196. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at 60th St., Chicago, 111 . 1914. Interior. Photo.
Fuermann.
197. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at Goth St., Chicago, 111 . 1914. Dining room
furniture.
198. Midway Gardens, Cottage Grove Ave. at Goth St., Chicago, 111 . 1914. Wire furniture.
199. Francis W. Little house, “Northome,” R.F.D. 3, Wayzata, Minn. 1913-
200. Francis W. Little house, “Northome,” R.F.D. 3, Wayzata, Minn. 1913. Plan.
20oa.Francis W. Little house, "Northome,” R.F.D. 3, Wayzata, Minn. 1913- . Photo.
Hollis.
200b. Francis W. Little house, “Northome,” R.F.D. 3, Wayzata, Minn. 1913- . Living
room. Photo. Hollis.
201. Emil Bach house, 7415 Sheridan Rd., Chicago, 111 . 1915. Photo. Lane.
202. Emil Bach house, 7415 Sheridan Rd., Chicago, 111 . 1915. Plans.
203. A. D. German Warehouse, Richland Center, Wis. [1915] (never completed). Photo.
Lane.
204. A. D. German Warehouse, Richland Center, Wis. [1915] (never completed). Detail.
205. Project : American System Ready-Cut Duplex Flats. 1915.
206. Project : American System Ready-Cut Duplex Flats. 1915. Plans.
207. Project: American System Ready-Cut Bungalow. 1915.
208. Project: American System Ready-Cut Bungalow. 1915. Plan.
209. Joseph J. Bagley house, Lakeview and Cedar Aves., Grand Beach, Mich. 19 iG. Photo.
Lane.
210. Joseph J. Bagley house, Lakeview and Cedar Aves., Grand Beach, Mich. 19 iG. Plan.
2 1 1 . Ernest Vosburgh house, Crescent Rd., Grand Beach, Mich. [19 iG] . Perspective.
212. Ernest Vosburgh house. Crescent Rd., Grand Beach, Mich. [1916]. Photo. Lane.
213. Ernest Vosburgh house, Crescent Rd., Grand Beach, Mich. [1916]. Plan.
214. Project: Aline Barnsdall Theater, Olive Hill, Sunset Blvd., Los Angeles, Gal. [1920].
Model cut open.
215. Project: Moving picture theater, Ginza, Tokio, 1918. Model.
216. Henry J. Allen house, 255 Roosevelt Blvd., Wichita, Kan. 1917. Garden. Photo. Carl-
son and Bulla.
217. Henry J. Allen house, 255 Roosevelt Blvd., Wichita, Kan. 1917. Photo. Reed.
2 iK Henry J. Allen house, 255 Roosevelt Blvd., Wichita, Kan. 1917. Plans.
2 19. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9iG]-i922. Plans.
220. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9iG]-i922. Bird’s-eye perspective.
[xix]
221. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9i6]-i922. Tea Terrace.
222. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9i6]-i922. General view.
223. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [1916]-! 92 2. Garden Court.
224. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9i6]-i922. Emperor’s entrance.
225. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9i6]-i922. Structural diagram.
226. Imperial Hotel, T okio, J apan, [ 1 9 1 6]-i 92 2 . Structural diagram.
228. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [1916]-! 92 2. Details in court.
229. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9i6]~i922. Bedroom.
230. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9i6]-i922. Bedroom.
231. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [i9i6]-i922. Lobby.
232. Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan, [19 i6]-i922. Ballroom.
233. Project: Odawara Hotel, Nagoya, Japan. [1917].
234- Jiyu Gakuen School, Tokio, Japan. 1921. Photo, courtesy of Amato Endo.
235. “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave.,
Los Angeles, Gal. 1920.
236. “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave.,
Los Angeles, Gal. 1920. Plan.
237. “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave.,
Los Angeles, Gal. 1920. Court.
238. “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave.,
Los Angeles, Cal. 1920. Side view. ’’
239. “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave.,
Los Angeles, Cal. 1920. Living room. ’
240. “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave.
Los Angeles, Cal. 1920. View from below. ’
241. “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave.,
Los Angeles, Cal. 1920. Dining room.
242. Aline Barnsdall Residence A., Hollywood Blvd. and Edgemont St., Los Angeles Gal
1920.
243. Project: Edward H. Doheny ranch development. Sierra Madre Mountains, near Los
Angeles, Cal. 1921.
244. Project: Merchandising building, Los Angeles, Cal. 1921.
245. Project: Tahoe summer colony, Emerald Bay, Lake Tahoe, Cal. 1922. General plan,
from de Fries, Frank Lloyd Wright.
[XX]
246. Project: Tahoe summer colony, Emerald Bay, Lake Tahoe, Cal. 1922. Big tree type
cabin.
247. Project: Tahoe summer colony, Emerald Bay, Lake Tahoe, Gal. 1922. Barge for two.
248. Project: Tahoe summer colony. Emerald Bay, Lake Tahoe, Cal. 1922. Family barge.
249. Mrs. George Madison Millard house, 645 Prospect Crescent, Pasadena, Cal. 1923.
Photo. Martin.
250. Mrs. George Madison Millard house, 645 Prospect Crescent, Pasadena, Cal. 1923.
Entrance. Photo, Martin.
251. Mrs. George Madison Millard house, 645 Prospect Crescent, Pasadena, Cal. 1923.
Plans.
252. Mrs. George Madison Millard house, 645 Prospect Crescent, Pasadena, Cal. 1923.
Living room. Photo. Martin.
253. Mrs. George Madison Millard house, 645 Prospect Crescent, Pasadena, Gal. 1923.
Living room. Photo. Martin.
254. Mrs. George Madison Millard house, 645 Prospect Crescent, Pasadena, Gal. 1923.
Detail.
255. Dr. John Storer house, 8161 Hollywood Blvd., Los Angeles, Cal. [1923]. Photo. Martin.
256. Dr. John Storer house, 8161 Hollywood Blvd., Los Angeles, Cal. [1923]. Plans.
257. Charles Ennis house, 2607 Glendower Rd., Los Angeles, Cal. 1924. Photo. Martin.
258. Charles Ennis house, 2607 Glendower Rd., Los Angeles, Cal. 1924. Plan.
259. Samuel Freeman house, 1962 Glencoe Way, Los Angeles, Cal. 1924. Dining room.
Photo. Martin.
260. Samuel Freeman house, 1962 Glencoe Way, Los Angeles, Cal. 1924. Plans.
261. Samuel Freeman house, 1962 Glencoe Way, Los Angeles, Cal. 1924.
262. Samuel Freeman house, 1962 Glencoe Way, Los Angeles, Gal. 1924. Living room.
Photo. Martin.
263. Project: National Life Insurance Co. Skyscraper, Water Tower Sq., Chicago, 111 .
[1924]-
264. Project: National Life Insurance Go. Skyscraper, Water Tower Sq., Chicago, 111 .
[1924]. Section.
265. Project: National Life Insurance Go. Skyscraper, Water Tower Sq., Chicago, 111 .
[1924]. Plans.
266. Project: National Life Insurance Go. Skyscraper, Water Tower Sq., Chicago, 111 .
[1924]. Office interior.
267. Project: Nakoma Country Club, Madison, Wis. [1924].
[xxi]
268. Project; Nakoma Country Club, Madison, Wis. [1924]. Plan.
269. Taliesin III, Spring Green, Wis, 1925-
271. Taliesin III, Spring Green, Wis. 1925- . Plan.
273. Taliesin III, Spring Green, Wis. 1925-* . Living room. Photo. Hedricli-Blessing.
274. Taliesin III, Spring Green, Wis. 1925- . Bedroom. Photo. Hedrich-Blessing.
275. Taliesin III, Spring Green, Wis. 1925- . Entrance in winter.
276. Ocotillo Desert Gamp, Frank Lloyd Wright winter headquarters, Salt Range, near
Chandler, Arizona. 1927.
277. Ocotillo Desert Camp, Frank Lloyd Wright winter headquarters. Salt Range, near
Chandler, Arizona. 1927. Plan.
278. Ocotillo Desert Gamp, Frank Lloyd Wright winter headquarters, Salt Range, near
Chandler, Arizona. 1927. Cabins.
279. Ocotillo Desert Camp, Frank Lloyd Wright winter headquarters. Salt Range, near
Chandler, Arizona, 1927. Detail.
280. Ocotillo Desert Camp, Frank Lloyd Wright winter headquarters, Salt Range, near
Chandler, Arizona. 1927. Interior.
281. Project: San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chandler, Arizona. [1927.] Perspective from
gate lodge.
282. Project: San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chandler, Arizona. [1927.] Texture model.
283. Project: San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chandler, Arizona. [1927.] Section of side
wings.
283a.Project: San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chandler, Arizona. [1927.] Detailed plan of
side wings.
284. Project: San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chandler, Arizona. [1927.] Plan of central
unit.
285. Project: Owen D. Young house, San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chandler, Arizona.
[i 927 ’]
286. Project: Owen D. Young house, San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chandler, Arizona.
[1927.] Plans.
287. Project : Wellington and Ralph Cudney house, San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chand-
ler, Arizona* [1927.]
288. Project : Wellington and Ralph Cudney house, San Marcos-in-the-Desert, near Chand-
ler, Arizona. [1927.] Plans.
289. Darwin D. Martin house, Derby, N. Y. 1927. Photo. Lane.
290. Darwin D. Martin house, Derby, N. Y. 1927. Plans.
Ixxiij
291. Project: San Marcos Water Gardens, Chandler, Arizona. [1927.] Tourist Cabins.
292. Project: San Marcos Water Gardens, Chandler, Arizona. [1927.] Alternative plans and
section.
293. Project: Village service station, 1928. Model. Photo. Bureau of Visual Instruction,
University of Wisconsin.
294. Project : Village service station, 1928. Plan and Section.
295. Project: Alexander Chandler block house, Chandler, Arizona, 1927.
296. Project: Alexander Chandler block house, Chandler, Arizona, 1927. Plans.
297. Richard Lloyd Jones house, 3700 Birmingham Rd., Tulsa, Okla. 1929.
298. Richard Lloyd Jones house, 3700 Birmingham Rd., Tulsa, Okla. 1929. Plans.
299. Richard Lloyd Jones house, 3700 Birmingham Rd., Tulsa, Olda. 1929. Entrance.
300. Richard Lloyd Jones house, 3700 Birmingham Rd., Tulsa, Okla. 1929. Court.
301. Richard Lloyd Jones house, 3700 Birmingham Rd., Tulsa, Okla. 1929. Diningroom.
302. Richard Lloyd Jones house, 3700 Birmingham Rd., Tulsa, Okla. 1929. Billiard room.
303. Project: Elizabeth Noble apartment house, Los Angeles, Cal. [1929].
304. Project: Elizabeth Noble apartment house, Los Angeles, Cal. [1929]. Section and plans.
305. Project: St. Mark’s Tower, New York City, 1929. Model.
307. Project : St. Mark’s Tower, New York City, 1929. Plans and section.
308. Project: Grouped apartment towers, Chicago, 111 . 1930.
309. Project: Grouped apartment towers, Chicago, lU. 1930. Plans.
310. Project: “House on the Mesa.” [1931.] Model exhibited at Museum of Modern Art,
New York, 1932. Photo. Museum of Modern Art.
31 1. Project: “House on the Mesa.” [1931.] Plan.
312. Project: Walter Davidson Sheet Steel farm units. 1932. Model exhibited at Museum of
Modern Art. 1940. Photo. Beinert.
313. Project : Walter Davidson Sheet Steel farm imits. 1932. Plan.
314. Project ; Malcolm Willey house, Minneapolis, Minn. 1932. Model exhibited at Museum
of Modern Art, 1940. Photo. Weber.
315. Project: Malcolm Willey house, Minneapolis, Minn. 1932. Plans.
316. Malcolm Willey house, 255 Bedford St, Minneapolis, Minn. 1934. Photo. Hedrich-
Blessing.
317. Malcolm Willey house, 255 Bedford St., Minneapolis, Minn. 1934. Plan.
318. Malcolm Willey house, 255 Bedford St., Minneapolis, Minn. 1934 * Diving room. Photo.
University of Minnesota Photographic Laboratory.
[ xxiii ]
320. Edgar J. Kaufmann house, Bear Run, Penna. 1936. View from below waterfall. Photo.
Hedrich-Blessing.
321. Edgar J. Kaufmann house, Bear Run, Penna. 1936. Plans and section.
322. Edgar J. Kaufmann house, Bear Run, Penna. 1936. Photo. Hedrich-Blessing.
323. Edgar J. Kaufmann house, Bear Run, Penna. 1936. Steps to pool. Photo. Hedrich-
Blessing.
324. Edgar J. Kaufmann office, Kaufmarm. Department Store, 400 Fifth Ave., Pittsburgh,
Penna., 1937.
325. Edgar J. Kaufmann office, Kaufmann Department Store, 400 Fifth Ave., Pittsburgh,
Penna., 1937. Cypress plywood mural.
327. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
Testing sample pier. 1936.
328. Project: Capital Journal Building, Salem, Oregon, 1931. Perspective.
329. Project: Capital Journal Building, Salem, Oregon, 1931. Half plan and section.
330. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. Interior. Photo. Peterson.
331. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. Section of pier.
332. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939* I’lan.
333. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. Photo. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc.
334. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. Entrance. Photo. Peterson.
335. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. Exterior corner. Photo. S. G. Johnson and Son, Inc.
336. S. C. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. Ceiling detail. Photo. Korling.
337. S. G. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. View inside bands of glass tubing. Photo. Peterson.
338. S. G. Johnson and Son, Inc., Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis.
1936-1939. Wall of glass tubes. Photo. S. G. Johnson and Son, Inc.
339. Herbert F. Johnson house, Wind Point, north of Racine, Wis. 1937. Photo. Gottscho.
340. Herbert F. Johnson house, Wind Point, north of Racine, Wis. 193 7. Plan.
[ xxiv ]
341- Herbert F. Johnson house, Wind Point, north of Racine, Wis. 1937. Living room.
Photo. Gottscho.
342. Herbert F. Johnson house, Wind Point, north of Racine, Wis. 1937. Living room.
Photo. Gottscho.
343. Herbert Jacobs house, 441 Toepfer St., Westmorland, near Madison, Wis. 1937. Photo.
Guerrero.
344. Herbert Jacobs house, 441 Toepfer St., Westmorland, near Madison, Wis. 1937- Plan.
345. Herbert Jacobs house, 441 Toepfer St., Westmorland, near Madison, Wis. 1937. Street
front.
346. Stanley Rosenbaum house, Riverview Dr., Florence, Ala. 1939. Photo. Kidder Smith.
347. Paul R. Hanna house, 737 Coronado St., Palo Alto, Cal. 1937. Photo. Sturtevant.
348. Paul R. Hanna house, 737 Coronado St., Palo Alto, Cal. 1937. Court side. Photo.
Sturtevant.
349. Paul R. Hanna House, 737 Coronado St., Palo Alto, Cal. 1937. Living room. Photo.
Sturtevant.
350. Paul R. Hanna House, 737 Coronado St., Palo Alto, Cal. 1937. Dining room.
35 1 . Paul R. Hanna House, 737 Coronado St., Palo Alto, Cal. 1937. Plan.
352. Taliesin West, Maricopa Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938-
Photo. Guerrero.
353. Taliesin West, Maricopa Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938-
Plan.
355. Taliesin West, Maricopa Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938-
View across terrace. Photo. Guerrero.
356. Taliesin West, Maricopa Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938-
Entrance.
357. Taliesin West, Maricopa Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938-
Entrance from the pool. Photo. Guerrero.
358. Taliesin West, Maricopa Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938-
General living room. Photo. Guerrero.
359. Taliesin West, Maricopa Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona. 1938-
Mr. Wright’s fireplace. Photo. Guerrero.
360. Project: “House for a Family of $50oo-$6ooo Income.” 1938.
361. Project: Lz/^“HouseforaFamilyof$5ooo-$6ooo Income.” 1938. Plans.
362. Bernard Schwartz house, Still Bend, Two Rivers, Wis. 1939. Photo. Teske.
363. Bernard Schwartz house, Still Bend, Two Rivers, Wis. 1939. Living room. Photo. Teske.
[ XXV ]
364. Project: Ralph Jester (Martin J. Pence) house, Palos Verdes, Cal. (Hilo, Hawaii). 1938
(1940). Model exhibited at Museum of Modern Art, New York, 1940. Photo. Beinert.
365. Project: Ralph Jester (Martin J. Pence) house, Palos Verdes, Gal. (Hilo, Hawaii). 1938
(1940). Plan.
366. Suntop Homes, Sutton Rd. near Spring Ave., Ardmore, Penna. 1939. Model exhibited
at Museum of Modern Art, New York, 1940. Photo. Beinert.
367. Suntop Homes, Sutton Rd. near Spring Ave., Ardmore, Penna. 1939. Plans and section.
368. Suntop Homes, Sutton Rd. near Spring Ave., Ardmore, Penna. 1939. General perspec-
tive of projected group of four units, only one of which was built.
369. Edgar J. Kaufmann guest house, Bear Run, Penna. 1939.
370. Edgar J. Kaufmann guest house, Bear Run, Penna. 1939. Approach, from below.
370a. Edgar J. Kaufmann guest house, Bear Run, Penna. 1939. Approach, from above.
371. Edgar J. Kaufmann guest house, Bear Run, Penna. 1939. Plan.
372. Edgar J. Kaufmann guest house. Bear Run, Penna. 1939. Pool and terrace.
373. Edgar J. Kaufmann guest house. Bear Run, Penna. 1939. Entrance.
374. Project: Group of seven Usonian houses, Okemos, Mich. 1939. Model exhibited at
Museum of Modern Art, 1940. Photo. Beinert.
375. Katherine Winlder and Alma Goetsch house, Hulett Rd., Okemos, Mich. 1939. Plan.
376. Katherine Winkler and Alma Goetsch house, Hulett Rd., Okemos, Mich. 1939. Front
view. Photo. Leavenworth’s.
377. Katherine Winkler and Alma Goetsch house, Hulett Rd., Okemos, Mich. 1939. Rear
view. Photo. Leavenworth’s.
378. Katherine Winlder and Alma Goetsch house, Hulett Rd., Okemos, Mich. 1939. Inte-
rior. Photo. Leavenworth’s.
379. George D. Sturges house, 449 Skyway Rd., Brentwood Heights, Cal. 1939. Photo.
Guerrero.
380. George D. Sturges house, 449 Skyway Rd., Brentwood Heights, Gal. 1939. Plan and
section.
381. Stanley Rosenbaum house, Riverview Dr., Florence, Ala. 1939. Photo. Kidder Smith.
382. Stanley Rosenbaum house, Riverview Dr., Florence, Ala. 1939. Living room. Photo.
Kidder Smith.
383. Stanley Rosenbaum house, Riverview Dr., Florence, Ala. 1939. Detail of corner. Photo.
Kidder Smith.
384. Sidney Bazett house, loi Reservoir Rd., Hillsborough, Gal. [1940]. Photo. Born.
[ xxvi ]
385. Sidney Bazett house, loi Reservoir Rd., Hillsborough, Cal. [1940]. Dining room.
Photo. Born.
386. Sidney Bazett house, 10 1 Reservoir Rd., Hillsborough, Cal. [1940]. View from below.
Photo. Born.
387. Sidney Bazett house, loi Reservoir Rd., Hillsborough, Cal. [1940]. Living room. Photo.
Born.
388. Lloyd Lewis house. Little St. Mary’s Rd., Libertyville, 111 . 1940. Photo. Hedrich-
Blessing.
389. Lloyd Lewis house. Little St. Mary’s Rd., Libertyville, 111 . 1940. Plans.
390. Lloyd Levds house. Little St. Mary’s Rd., Libertyville, 111 . 1940. Bedroom wing. Photo.
Hedrich-Blessing.
391. Lloyd Lewis house. Little St. Mary’s Rd., Libertyville, 111 . 1940. Living Room. Photo.
Hedrich-Blessing.
392. Rose Pauson house. Orange Rd., Phoenix, Arizona. 1940. Photo. Guerrero.
393. Rose Pauson house. Orange Rd., Phoenix, Arizona. 1940. Plans.
394. Rose Pauson house, Orange Rd., Phoenix, Arizona. 1940. Living room. Photo. Guerrero.
395. Rose Pauson house. Orange Rd., Phoenix, Arizona. 1940. Photo. Guerrero.
396. John C. Pew house, 3650 Mendota Dr., Shorewood Hills, near Madison, Wis. 1940.
Photo. Teske.
397. John G. Pew house, 3650 Mendota Dr., Shorewood Hills, near Madison, Wis. 1940.
Fireplace. Photo. Teske.
398. John C. Pew house, 3650 Mendota Dr., Shorewood Hills, near Madison, Wis. 1940,
Plans.
399. Charles L. Manson house, 1224 Highland Blvd., Wausau, Wis. 1940. Passage. Photo.
Teske.
400. Charles L. Manson house, 1224 Highland Blvd., Wausau, Wis. 1940. Study fireplace.
Photo. Teske.
401. Clarence W. Sondern house, 3600 Belleview Ave., Kansas City, Mo. 1940. Photo.
Ortho.
402. Clarence W. Sondern house, 3600 Belleview Ave., Kansas City, Mo. 1940. Bedroom.
Photo. Ortho.
403. Theodore Baird house, Shays St., Amherst, Mass. 1940.
404. Gregor Affleck house, Bloomfield Hills, Mich. In construction, 1941. Model exhibited
at Museum of Modern Art, New York, 1940. Photo. Beinert.
405. Florida Southern College, Lakeland, Fla. Project, 1938; construction, 1940-
[ xxvii ]
406. Florida Southern College, Lakeland, Fla. Project, 1938; construction, 1940- . Plan.
407. Ann Pfeiffer Chapel, Florida Southern College, Lakeland, Fla. 1940.
408. Ann Pfeiffer Chapel, Florida Southern College, Lakeland, Fla. 1940. Plan and section.
409. Kansas City Community Church, 3600 Main St., Kansas City, Mo. In construction,
1941. Perspectives.
410. Kansas City Community Church, 3600 Main St., Kansas City, Mo. In construction,
1941 . Plan and section.
41 1. Project; Crystal Heights hotel, shops and theater, Connecticut and Florida Aves.,
Washington, D. G. 1940. Bird’s-eye view.
412. Project: Crystal Heights hotel, shops and theater, Connecticut and Florida Aves.,
Washington, D. G. 1940. General perspective.
413. Project; Crystal Heights hotel, shops and theater, Connecticut and Florida Aves.,
Washington, D. C. 1940. Plan of typical hotel floor.
[ xxviii ]
Preface
T his book is intended to be a sort of ex post facto catalogue of the exhibition of Frank
Lloyd Wright’s architecture at the Museum of Modern Art in New York in 1940. It
is, however, no more closely linked with the exhibition than was the book. The Architecture
of H. H. Richardson and His Times^ which I prepared together with the Richardson exhibi-
tion at the Museum of Modern Art in 1936, or the book and exhibition devoted to Rhode
Island Architecture which I arranged for the Providence Rhode Island School of Design
in 1939. The Wright exhibition at the Museum included many superb models; photographs
of several of them are used in this book. Many original renderings shown in the exhibition
also appear here. But the plan of the book is somewhat different from that of the exhibition,
although the purpose is the same : to display as fully as may be the architectural work and
projects of Wright, with particular emphasis on the expression of the “Nature of Materials,”
the characteristic phrase Wright has selected both for the title of the exhibition and of
the book.
Many things are possible in an exhibition that are not possible in a book. All who saw
the exhibition will miss the models despite the few fine photographs of them which are
included here. But if the pages of a book can hardly give the full value of the original draw-
ings that were shown in the exhibition, there are compensations. The redrawn plans, mostly
prepared by the members of the Taliesin Fellowship particularly for this book, should be
more legible at small scale to laymen, and the more even distribution of material covering
Wright’s total production tells more sequentially the story of a half century’s achievement.
The text is subsidiary to the plate section. Perhaps the most important part of it, or
at least that into which the most work has been put, is the list of executed work and projects.
There have been many earlier lists, but none has been so nearly complete or so carefully
checked for factual detail, I believe. The introductory text gives a broad historical account
of Wright’s architecture. This is supplemented by commentary captions on many of the
plates. But the generally chronological arrangement of the plates should tell the story, at
least to those familiar with Wright’s principles, more clearly than verbal explanation.
Had Grant C. Manson’s Harvard doctoral dissertation of 1940 covering Wright’s work
before 1910 been available in published form I should not have given so much space to
Wright’s architectural background and to the stages by which he came to maturity. But
in the absence of any published source in which this early development is covered, it seems
important to indicate here Wright’s early relation to Richardson and to analyze in some
detail his better known but generally somewhat misinterpreted relation to Sullivan.
[xxix]
Frank Lloyd Wright on Architecture, 1941, edited by Frederick Gutheim, republishes
much of Wright’s prolific writing of the last fifty years. With this material now readily
available, I have rarely quoted from it. No paraphrase or summary can do justice to the
statements of architectural principles which Wright has continued to make through the
years. All will realize that for the fullest understanding of an architect’s work, and particu-
larly the work of an architect who is also a brilliant writer, a direct knowledge of his written
opinions, his formal and informal statements on his own architecture and on more general
problems, is desirable. Similarly I have used only a bare minimum of biographical material.
It is impossible to discuss Wright’s architecture without emotion. Those who dislike it,
or certain aspects of it, usually dislike it strongly, as Wright would wish them to. Such
readers will find this book lacking in objectivity. For I have made no attempt at a cold,
semantic precision of statement and I even doubt whether any matter connected with the
arts can be profitably discussed without warmly connotative words and phrases. The very
selection of illustrative material aims frankly to present the greatness of Wright’s archi-
tecture in all its variety. It is not generally worth while to study buildings in pictures except
for their virtues.
I have had throughout very complete cooperation from Wright and the members of
the Taliesin Fellowship, but the book is mine and not his. Doubtless it is a quite different
sort of book than he would have prepared himself had he not been busy with the more
important work of designing and erecting buildings. The rather complete collection of
photographs and plans in whose selection Wright actively participated, together with the
perspectives of many important projects, should make it widely useful. There is in existence
no other book which pretends to cover the work of Wright with comparable thoroughness.
It seems unnecessary to give a formal bibliography — there is a full list of Wright’s own
publications in the Gutheim volume. But it may be useful to indicate the chief published
sources which give for certain periods, perhaps, a more complete illustrative coverage.
First, there are the magazines : the Inland Architect for the earliest work in the nineties,
the (Boston) Architectural Review article of 1900, the Architectural Record right through,
and the Architectural Forum of late years, particularly the first special Wright number of
January, 1938, and that about to appear. I have noted in an article in Parnassus (Decem-
ber, 1940) a few of the more important European magazine publications.
The basic books on Wright are the two Wasmuth publications, the great portfolio of .
1910, including much of the executed work and projects before that date in perspectives
and plans, and the smaller book of 1911, with an introduction by G. R. Ashbee, covering
the same period and illustrated with photographs and plans. Their confusingly similar
[xxx]
titles are: Ausgefuhrte Bauten und Entwurfe von Frank Lloyd Wright and Frank Lloyd
Wright Ausgefuhrte Bauten. After those, the other two foreign books of great importance
are The Life Work of the Architect Frank Lloyd Wright, gathering together photographs,
plans and perspectives of projects which had appeared in the early and mid-twenties in the
Dutch magazine Wendingen, and the contemporary German book, Frank Lloyd Wright, by
H. de Fries, 1926.
The two French books, one issued by Cahiers d^Art in 1928, for which I wrote a brief
and perhaps rather blind foreword, the other issued hy V Architecture Vivante in 1930, both
including material which had appeared previously in those magazines, are less important-
None of these books is easy to obtain today and I have never seen the Japanese monographs.
Thus far the American books, except for the little Museum of Modern Art catalogue of
the exhibition of the Kaufmann house in 1938, are barely illustrated at all. But Mr. Manson’s
unpublished study of the early work is presumably only the first of many detailed works of
scholarship which will appear in the near future.
Fortunately the rapid and full publication of Mr. Wright’s work in American maga-
zines in the last decade may assure us that in the future illustrations of his new work will
generally be made available soon after their completion.
This book will not entirely take the place for the more serious student of the books and
magazines that have been listed in the paragraphs above. But as they are practically unob-
tainable and lacking even in many large libraries, I have not hesitated to duplicate their
material. Nor have I felt it worth while to include iconographic notes in the Chronological
List of Executed Work and Projects to indicate where illustrations may be found of material
not included in the plates. Too much is available only in the original drawings at Taliesin.
In general, however, the photographers, of whom the addresses as well as the names are
given in the list of acknowledgments, have many negatives of Wright’s work over and above
those used here, and I myself have photographs of many unpublished drawings.
The book has the advantage of a format designed in all its details by Mr. Wright.
Although this is not a publication of the Museum of Modern Art, I hope it may be
worthy of the standard they have established for the books and catalogues issued in connec-
tion with other exhibitions, and fit to stand beside my Richardson book, which they pub-
lished, and Hugh Morrison’s Louis Sullivan, which they sponsored. For, as everyone knows,
Wright forms the third member of the triumvirate, Richardson, Sullivan and Wright, by
which American architecture is known throughout the world.
September, ig^i
[xxxi]
H.-R. H.
Acknowledgments
T his study of Frank Lloyd Wright’s work began with a careful examination of the
material sent from Taliesin for the exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art which
was made available to me and with a detailed revision of the list of Wright’s work pre-
pared at the Museum by Henrietta Calloway. For this major assistance as well as for other
continued favours I must first of all thank John McAndrew, then Curator of Architecture
at the Museum of Modern Art, and Janet Henrich, Assistant, and now Acting, Curator.
Grant G. Manson of Columbia University very kindly put at my disposal his erudition
on the early work of Wright through 1910 in conferences and correspondence. I owe to him
also many facts included in the List of Work which come from his Harvard doctoral dis-
sertation deposited in the Widener Library in Cambridge.
Two librarians, Ruth V. Cook of the Harvard Architectural School in Cambridge and
Marion Rawls Herzog of the Burnham Library of the Art Institute in Chicago, gave me
continuous and important assistance. Indeed, the thorough study of Wright and of his
Chicago architectural environment is impossible without using the resources of the Burnham
Library.
Much important information on Wright’s California work was collected for me by
Richard J. Neutra of Los Angeles and Woodbridge Dickinson, Jr., of Pasadena. Joseph
Brewer, president of Olivet College in Michigan, tracked down for me many Michigan
houses. John F. Kienitz of the University of Wisconsin, has done as much in Wisconsin.
I cannot hope to itemize all the others who have kindly replied to my letters about points of
detail. For at one time or another I have written to almost all the Wright clients and present
owners of Wright houses built since 19 1 1 and the greater number of them, as well as many
others, have assisted me with information and in some cases with photographs as well. I hope
they will accept this general expression of gratitude.
Credit for photographs is given briefly in the List of Illustrations. A very large number
of photographs of the early work come from Henry Fuermann and Sons, 410 N. Michigan
Ave., Chicago. Another important group of photographs was taken by Gilman Lane, 825
North Ridgeland Ave., Oak Park, 111 ., who has been photographing Wright’s work for many
years, and who has taken many new photographs particularly for this book. In addition to
these two sources, a great many old prints used in the book come from Wright’s own
[ xxxiii ]
files. Unfortunately these often lack the names of the photographers and so it is impossible
to give the proper credits. For the further benefit of those who may care to build up their
own collections of Wright photographs I list here the full names and addresses of other
photographers whose prints have been used.
Art Institute, Chicago, 111 .
Barnum & Barnum, Chicago, lU.
Jay W. Baxtresser, Albright Art Gallery, Buffalo, N. Y.
John D. Beinert Architectural Forum, New York, N. Y.
Esther Born, 720 Montgomery St., San Francisco, Cal.
S. A. Callisen, University of Rochester, Rochester, N. Y.
Carlson & Bulla, Wichita, Kan.
Chicago Architectural Photographic Company, Chicago, 111 .
Samuel H. Gottscho, 150-35 86th Ave., Jamaica, N. Y.
P. E. Guerrero, 37 N. Mesa Drive, Mesa, Arizona.
Hedrich-Blessing, 723 N. Michigan Ave., Chicago, 111 .
G. E. Kidder Smith, 1 33 East 62nd St., New York, N. Y.
Thorkel Korling, Racine, Wis.
Leavenworth’s, 1315 West Michigan Ave., Lansing, Michigan.
University of Minnesota Photographic Laboratory, Minneapolis, Minn.
W. Albert Martin, 963 E. Colorado St., Pasadena, Gal.
Willard and Barbara Morgan, 100 East 42nd St., New York, N. Y.
Museum of Modern Art, New York, N. Y.
Ortho Photographic Co., 1326 Oak St., Kansas City, Mo.
Roy E. Peterson, Racine, Wis.
Fred H. Reed, Wichita, Kan.
M. D. Ross, Tulane University, New Orleans, La.
Roger Sturtevant, 720 Montgomery St., San Francisco, Gal.
Edmund Teske, 1519 E. 85th St., Chicago, 111 .
Harvey A. Weber, 8827 187th PI., Hollis, L. L, N. Y.
L. S. Willis, 1 15 N. 34th St., Philadelphia, Penna.
Bureau of Visual Instruction, University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wis.
Large sections of the text were read in manuscript by Natalie Hoyt and by Professor
Hugh Morrison of Dartmouth, who also loaned me many Sullivan photographs. Their com-
ments and suggestions were of great assistance. Nor can I neglect to mention Frances B.
von Groschwitz, Ruth B. Hanson and Priscilla Hedge who typed the various drafts of the
manuscript.
[ xxxiv ]
Many of the illustrations other than photographs come from the Taliesin files, but the
greater part of the plans and several of the perspectives were especially redrawn by members
of the Taliesin Fellowship for use in this book. The plans of the Blossom and Harlan houses
were redrawn by Sebastian J. Passanesi. It is impossible to itemize further the various sorts
of cooperation of Mr. Wright and the Taliesin Fellowship. It will be obvious that without
their continuous assistance this book would not have been possible. Indeed Mr. Wright’s
position in relation to the book should be considered almost as much that of co-author
as of subject.
[xxxvl
PART ONE
1887-1893
I. Chicago Architecture in the Eighties and J. L. Silsbee
F rank LLOYD WRIGHT left the University of Wisconsin to come to Chicago in the
spring of 1887, just as Middle Western leadership in commercial building was being
established. Yet it was not the Chicago of the “Commercial Style,” of functional masonry
buildings and of the new metal skeleton skyscrapers, with which he first had contact.^
Since the completion of Trinity Church in Boston in 1877 the leading force in American
architecture had been the influence of Richardson. In 1887, the year following Richardson's
death, Chicago saw the completion of his masterpiece, the Marshall Field Wholesale Store.
At the same time he had been building two houses, the MacVeagh house on the North Side
and the Glessner house on the South Side, the latter undoubtedly his finest and most mature
masonry mansion. Richardson had no real contact with the remarkable structural and func-
tional developments which were taking place around him, although in a sense the Marshall
Field Store was the finest of all Chicago's “elevator buildings.” But he set a standard, hitherto
unknown in Chicago, of completely mature and integrated fusion of structure and design.
Wright was to be at first, both by mnate calling and by force of circumstances, chiefly
a domestic architect. Hence his early relation to the widespread influence of Richardson
upon American architecture was in the domestic field.
Various and confusing were the architectural enthusiasms of the eighties in domestic
design, yet there was generally a real identity of manner behind the nominal eclecticism.
Nor was the childish passion for the quaint, the picturesque and the whimsical, whatever
its source, necessarily inconsistent with the achievement of much real coherence of design.
The best houses were in plan freely functional, if rather cut up ; plastic in mass, with richly
sensuous surfaces of cobblestones and shingles; and often quite restrained in their use of
ornament. Such houses derived their major inspiration from the country and suburban
houses of Richardson and it is not imjust to call them Suburban Richardsonian.^
In Chicago architectural design had reached a nadir in the early eighties. The com-
mercial architects were technicians first, and little interested in design as such. Yet, because
they were using structural innovations for which there existed no apparent architectural
^The latest and best accounts of these are in Sigfried Giedion, Space, Time and Architecture, Cambridge, 1941,
Pt. V, and Thomas S. Tallmadge, Architecture in Old Chicago, Chicago [01941] Gh. IV.
^For further discussion, see my Architecture of H. H. Richardson and His Times, New York, 1936, Ch. XI-XV.
[ 3 ]
precedent, they soon found their way to a somewhat barren but expressive functionalism.
In domestic architecture, however, the same men had neither functional nor structural
reasons for refusing to ape Eastern modes. The fussy Queen Anne of New York, and the
Frangois Premier, with which Hunt had launched the social career of the Vanderbilts,®
were the ideal of South Side and North Side alike. The first imitations of Richardson’s sup-
posed Romanesque were quite as bad and most domestic work mingled elements from all
three sources.
A new day opened when Richardson himself arrived to build two houses as well as
the Field Store. But Richardson built no wooden houses in Chicago and his Glessner and
MacVeagh houses were in no sense suburban. The more mature and less incoherent pic-
turesque manner, which may be called Suburban Richardsonian, came independently in the
mid-eighties and was probably chiefly established in Chicago and its environs by J. L. Silsbee.
Silsbee came of a well-known Salem, Massachusetts, family. Before he settled in Chicago
he had practiced in Syracuse, N. Y. His New York State work, in no sense exceptional, is of
a confused Queen Anne like that of his Chicago contemporaries. As Silsbee was a Unitarian,
it may well have been the commission to build All Souls Church for Jenkin Lloyd Jones,
its vigorous pastor and Wright’s uncle, which brought him to Chicago about 1885. Curiously
enough. All Souls did not follow, even at second or third hand like most churches of the
eighties, the model of Richardson’s Trinity. Perhaps because Jenkin Lloyd Jones was already
developing his ideal of an institutional church, finally realized on the same site in Abraham
Lincoln Center almost twenty years later. All Souls had the look of a suburban mansion,
varied in mass and materials, domestic in ornamentation, and related more to Richardson’s
wooden houses than to his masonry monuments.
In 1886, when All Souls was completed, Silsbee also built Unity Chapel in the Helena
Valley near Spring Green, Wisconsin, for Jenkin Lloyd Jones and his family. This was a
simple shingled edifice, quite unornamented, and with a clarity of form and functionalism
of parts far more like Richardson’s best late work than All Souls.
At the same time in suburban Edgewater, where he lived himself, he was building
many similar houses for J. L. Cochran almost equally free from the elaborate picturesque-
ness of composition and detail of All Souls. Very soon definitely Colonial elements appear
in his work, gambrel roofs, and even the slender white Tuscan columns of his native Salem.
When Wright came to Chicago in the spring of 1887, it was with Silsbee that he first
found work, anonymously and without dependence on his family connection, since it was
® Hunt himself built the Francois Premier Borden house in Chicago in 1887.
[4]
against his Uncle JenMn’s will that he had left the University of Wisconsin. Wright was
already a draftsman of exquisite delicacy and precision. He had then had only two years of
professional training in the Engineering School under Dean Conover. As he was also em-
ployed in Conover’s private office, however, these two years had given him well-rounded
introduction to the practice of building. At this time Conover was supervising the Science
Building at the University, by H. C. Koch of Milwaukee, and also building the Chemistry
Building. The former was a clumsy, though not undignified, monument of red brick and
stone of rather rudimentary Richardsonian character; the latter was a structure of the barest
functional design in the local yellow brick.
Other aspects of Wright’s earlier education may seem now more important. Wide
reading in general literature had been encouraged by the Transcendental background of
both his parents. His mother had surrounded him in childhood with pictures of great budd-
ings; while his father had nourished his passion for great music. His contact with the artistic
content of the Froebel kindergarten method had come well beyond kindergarten age and
was, therefore, more formative. Finally, intelligent study of such great nineteenth century
architectural books as Ruskin’s Stones of Venice , and Viollet-le-Duc’s Dictionnaire, had given
him a critical background. Such broad culture was perhaps of little interest to prospective
employers.
Not surprisingly the earliest executed work by Wright, the house for his aunts, the
Misses Lloyd Jones, at Hillside, Spring Green, Wisconsin, is wholly in Silsbee’s manner
(Fig. 2). Indeed, it is slightly less advanced and more picturesque than certain Silsbee house
projects published in 1887 and 1888 which were drawn but not designed by Wright. It may
not be entirely fanciful to see in the wide windows of the house, and even more in certain
aspects of a project for a Unitarian Chapel, also published in 1887, early hints of a more
personal taste (Fig. i). But in the house he was probably responding to the family demand
for a broader outlook on surrounding nature. And as regards the chapel the polygonal ends
may be either a first expression of his later characteristic liking for the octagon, or a mere
merging of the ecclesiastical apse with the domestic bay window. Interest in the very first
designs of Wright is chiefly historical impertinence. Were we not concerned with his later
career, the signature of Silsbee’s young draftsman would be effectively anonymous on the
designs of 1887, except for the drawing of the plants, at once so exquisite and so vigorous.
Wright’s stay with Silsbee was not entirely without consequence, as a relation to Silsbee’s
work can be traced down through the Bagley house of 1894 3 °)- J^istified assurance of
ability, however, set Wright seeking new opportunities after a few months. When he was
refused a raise in pay by Silsbee, he went to Beers, Clay and Dutton, but soon returned to
[5]
Silsbee, receiving his raise. It was then he settled in suburban Oak Park, the Universalist
“Saints’ Rest,” which he was, in the score of years he lived there, to make an international
center of pilgrimage, an Ile-de-France of modern architecture.
But, before the end of the year, he heard of an opening with Adler and Sullivan. With
the construction of the Auditorium Building well under way, they were seeking a draftsman
capable of detailing its rich interiors. Wright sold himself to Sullivan with the drawings he
brought with him. There were drawings in the Silsbee manner and others in the historic
styles, based on Owen Jones’ Grammar of Ornament; there were drawings in Sullivan’s own
manner, already known as the most individual in Chicago, and even some in a manner
“perhaps original.” Now Wright’s generic apprenticeship could end; henceforth he was for
six years, and even longer, the disciple of the “Lieber Meister,” as he called Sullivan.
II. Sullivan’s Maturity and Wright’s Work with Sullivan
AS we mention the great triumvirate of American architects, Richardson, Sullivan, and
jL\. Wright, we thinlc we understand the links between them, but we often forget certain
aspects of the sequence which are implicit in mere chronology. The relation between
Sullivan and Richardson is a peculiar one. Sullivan, unlike his Chicago contemporaries, was
hardly influenced at all until after Richardson’s death, and then in a very limited way.
Moreover the influence was soon so completely digested as to be unrecognizable and hence
ultimately irrelevant. If we join in imagination Sullivan’s earliest work of 1880-1884 with
his latest great work of 1898-1899, the line clearly need not have passed through the defi-
nitely Richardsonian phase of 1886-1889 at all. Wright’s relation to Richardson was at least
as close as Sullivan’s and more lasting. While Wright’s relation to Sullivan was particularly
close and also very personal. And Sullivan’s influence on Wright even appears to have
increased rather than decreased after they separated, at least for a few years.
This influence was probably also mutual. Wright’s rapid metamorphosis in five years
from the Silsbee imitator who designed the Lloyd Jones house to the authentic and original
architect of the Gharnley and Harlan houses was undoubtedly due to his association with the
‘Xieber Meister” in Sullivan’s great years after 1887. It is not enough to say merely that
Wright went to school to Sullivan with the same assiduity that he had gone to school to
Silsbee. The Harlan house (Fig. 21), which he did on his own, and even the Gharnley house
(Fig. 9), which he did as lieutenant of Sullivan, represent something rather more than a
domestic adaptation of Sullivan’s skyscraper manner.
Recalling the drawings that Wright had shown Sullivan, a relation to Silsbee is still
evident in most of Wright’s wooden houses of 1889-1894. Historic detail, based on Owen
Jones, or other similar sources, also appears. The drawings in the manner of Sullivan, of
course, prepared the way for Wright to become a sort of alter ego of the master. But there
were also drawings which were “perhaps original” ; and original elements are very evidently
present in Wright’s independent work of these years. His originality should also be traceable
in work done for Adler and Sullivan and, as a matter of fact, Wright’s hand is generally
recognized by students of Sullivan in the houses of which Wright had charge for the firm.^
I believe it can also be recognized in more important work.
^ See Hugh Morrison, Louis Sullivan, New York [01935], pp. 132-133.
[ 7 ]
It is not often that a question of counter-influence upon the master arises so early in the
career of a disciple, actually some ten years before Wright’s own characteristic maturity was
achieved. It is not like the question whether one angel’s head in a Verrocchio Baptism may
be by Leonardo, but more like the problem, lately investigated by Fiske Kimball, as to who
in the office force of J. H. Mansart was responsible for the major innovations in French
architecture around 1700. If my conclusions are correct, it is possible that Sullivan would
never have freed himself entirely from the partly irrelevant influence of Richardson, nor
carried the “Commercial Style” to its latest apotheosis in the Carson, Pirie, Scott Building,
but for the young Wright’s association with him nearly a decade earlier. Such conclusions
should in no way reduce our conception of the true genius of Sullivan. For the supreme
quality of the Carson, Pirie and Scott Building, erected long after Wright’s departure from
the office, is, of course, due to Sullivan alone.
The early commercial buildings of Adler and Sullivan were generally smaller and less
monumental than those of other leading Chicago architects, but they were much more open
in design. In construction, they were Adler’s, easily rivalling his contemporaries in bold
functionalism, if not in scale. But they were also distinguished, as were the houses designed
by the firm in the same years, by the conspicuous ornament, coarse in scale, quite without
historic precedent and of a vital if crude originality. To contemporaries, this was Sullivan’s
great and unique contribution.
Up to 1886 and the designing of the Auditorium Building, Adler and Sullivan’s work
shows not only less influence from Richardson than the work of other Chicago architects,
such as Beman or Burnham and Root, but practically none at all. The other Chicago
architects swung gradually through various stages of only partial comprehension into the
Richardsonian orbit. But Sullivan was bowled over quite suddenly by the Marshall Field
Wholesale Store as it rose in 1886. He grasped by the response of genius to genius much of
the secret of Richardson’s most mature style all at once.
The Auditorium Building is in its exterior design the child of the Field Store, but it is
not its inevitable child. The shift to light-coloured stone and to smooth surfaces above the
base was a protest, related to the contemporary Eastern protest, against the antediluvian
gloom of the Brown Decades. The light granite of Richardson’s Chicago houses and the
smooth buff sandstone of his contemporary Warder house in Washington suggest that
Richardson himself was ready for such a change. The thinning of the piers, particularly at
the corners, the grouping of more storeys under the arches and the greater sharpness of the
reveals indicate how far Sullivan had already come toward thinking in terms of isolated
piers, how ready he was to design in terms of a sheathed skeleton and not in terms of solid
[ 8 ]
masonry. This can also be paralleled in the Pray Building in Boston, Richardson’s last com-
mercial design.
Though the relation of the tower to the main mass is awkward, the tower itself rises
above any direct relation to the Marshall Field Store into a new age. Over against the earlier
buildings which have technical claims to being the first skyscraper, this tower, though not of
skeleton construction, has a claim to be considered the first successful skyscraper design.
Doubtless it was the last portion of the exterior to be designed in its present form. The reveals
are shallower than below. The small grouped windows of the shaft suggest a continuous
pierced screen. The framed colonnade above, behind which were Adler & Sullivan’s own
ofiices, provides a more unified horizontal motif than the triplet windows above each bay of
the main building. The broad fascia of the terminal band concludes the upward thrust of
the tower more harmoniously than the conventional cornice of the main block below. The
masonry has the air of a smooth envelope covering a hollow volume. The screen-like window
penetrations and the long gallery suggest an interflow of exterior and interior space.
A similar development took place in the handhng of the sumptuous decoration of the
interior. The somewhat clumsy, coarse quality of the earlier ornament gives way to an almost
Byzantine or Southern Romanesque suavity. Above all, the new patterns are more organic,
more sensuous, more musical, as if the stiff stalks and circles of the earlier ornament had
flowered. Into the dead foliage of the past a new and rather Wagnerian life entered to pro-
duce a sort of Zukunftsschmuck^ premonitory of the European Art Nouveau of the nineties.
The rapid process of creative absorption by which Sullivan learned and passed beyond
the lesson of the Field Store must have been effectively complete by the time Wright entered
the office. Wright was taken on to assist in the detailing of the interior, not for the large scale
tasks of draftsmanship for which others already in the office were more suited. Though
Wright was chiefly responsible as draftsman for certain features of the interior, it is unlikely
that he made any original artistic contribution. At this time he was, as he has put it, only
“the good pencil in the master’s hand.”
The Walker Warehouse, designed in 1888, confirms and records, less confusingly than
the Auditorium, Sullivan’s rapid absorption and adaptation of Richardsonian design. The
three city houses for Victor Falkenau, of which the published rendering of this year was
signed by Wright, indicate how much slower and less creative this absorption was in domestic
design. These houses need neither be blamed nor credited to Wright. But in the Pueblo Opera
House of 1890 the clean cutting of the windows in the rock-faced masonry and the broad
eaves above the top floor gallery seem somewhat unrelated to the course of Sullivan’s devel-
[9]
opment. These elements suggest another hand, presumably Wright’s. The studiously Roma-
nesque character of the detail is also unlikely from Sullivan’s own hand at this date.
For this was the year the Wainwright Budding, generally considered Sullivan’s master-
piece and certainly his first skyscraper, was designed. This building and the contemporary
remodelling of McVicker’s Theatre, Sullivan’s masterpiece in the field of the ornamented
interior, must be wholly his own.
If our eyes are adjusted to the openness of Adler & Sullivan’s commercial buildings
of the early eighties, to Holabird & Roche’s Tacoma Building of 1887, and to Jenney &
Mundie’s Leiter Building of 1889, be surprised, as certain European critics have
been, at the definite sacrifices of Adler’s sense of function in the Wainwright Building to
Sullivan’s sense of form. It is hard to understand how this building can so long have been
considered the prime illustration of Sullivan’s slogan, “form follows function.” The Wain-
wright Building is manifestly, if ambiguously, of skeleton construction and is not at all
Richardsonian in design. But it is most remarkable for the quality of “style.” Possibly Saint
Louis, mellowed beyond the rugged commercial functionalism of its mid-century cast iron,
was readier for such work than Chicago, where clients did not as yet expect or want “archi-
tecture” in their tall buildings, except as a subsidiary embellishment.
The main divisions of the Wainwright design mark off a base, shaft and cap. The heavy
slab cornice represses any tower-like aspirations. The pilaster-like verticals that sheathe the
supports are not differentiated from those that are in structural function mere window
mullions. These repeated verticals, the continued thickening of the corner members, and the
careful restriction of the architecturally scaled ornament to the sunken spandrels, the broad
frieze and the capital-like tops of the vertical members, all respect universal traditions of
architectural design. “Chicago construction” and the immediate traditions of the Chicago
“Commercial Style” were subordinated to a crystalline expression of formal absolutes infi-
nitely more rigid and coherent than in McKim, Mead & White’s buildings of this time.
Here Sullivan set an architectural standard as high as Richardson’s. For Wright, the privi-
lege was to be close to Sullivan as this masterpiece took shape. But there was no chance for
delegation, as there may have been with some of the ornamental work on the Auditorium,
or with a minor commission like the Pueblo Opera House. To work on the Wainwright
drawings was to participate; and by that participation some transfusion of the creative blood*
stream took place. Henceforth there were two great designers in Adler & Sullivan’s office,
arid we are here interested in the yoiulger one.
Sullivan, within two years of entering the office of D. Adler & Go., was Adler’s design-
ing partner. Wright had risen in the office almost as rapidly, but Sullivan needed no design-
[ 10 ]
ing partner. From 1890 on until Wright left the oflfice there was, however, a division of
designing labour. Moreover, the complete freedom which Sullivan gave Wright in domestic
commissions — including even his own houses — ^bore immediate fruit. From 1889, when
Wright built his ovm house in Oak Park, through 1893, when he left Adler & Sullivan’s,
there are three kinds of products of Wright’s architectural brain ; the work he did on his own
out of office hours — in his terms the “bootlegged” houses; certain commissions of Adler &
Sullivan, chiefly houses, in which Sullivan was not interested ; and finally a few hotels, sky-
scrapers and loft buildings, which Sullivan might well have designed himself, but which
were left largely in Wright’s hands while Sullivan spent more time in Mississippi. Wright
was more intentionally and completely the alter ego of Sullivan in such work than in the
houses. But at times indications of the creative and individual force of his developing genius
seem to cry for a recognition that Wright himself largely withholds.
Wright’s own house in Oak Park precedes any commissions with which he was entrusted
by Sullivan. But this house properly opens the cycle of his independent work. It will be better
to discuss first the Adler & Sullivan commissions, even though these two types of work went
on concurrently.
The first houses which fell to Wright’s lot to design for Adler and Sullivan were Sulli-
van’s own summer house at Ocean Springs, Mississippi, with its servants’ cottage and stable,
and the nearby house and cottage of the James Charnleys who had introduced Sullivan to this
distant region. The plan of the Sullivan house as published in the Architectural Record in
June, 1905, does not correspond with the early photographs that remain. It is hazardous,
therefore, to draw many conclusions as to the original form from the present state of these
buildings. The authenticity of the stable, demolished only this year, was evident, however.
Generically, this is still Suburban Richardsonian, a single storey shingled structure with high
roofs and out-curved eaves (Fig. 3). The octagon form of the ends of the Sioux City chapel
project appears in the two bays of this stable, the ends of the main house and the picturesque
water tower and dovecote (Fig. 4). There was little or no detail on either house or stable,
except for the great and inappropriate Richardsonian arch of the stable entrance and its
curious cross-shaped windows.
Doubtless the work was unsupervised either by Sullivan or by Wright. The simplicity
was partly out of respect to the rustic environment, partly out of regard to the limitations of
the local carpenter. We are reminded chiefly of the seaside houses of Richardson and his
followers in New England and certainly of no earlier work, domestic or otherwise, from the
offices of Adler & Sullivan. The high roof, though not unknown in Sullivan’s work of this
time, is rare; whereas it is frequent on the early independent houses of Wright. Moreover, the
[11]
whole air of carefully restrained picturesqueness and domesticity is as foreign to the designer
of the Wainwright Building as it would be natural to a graduate of Silsbee’s office. It is a pity
we cannot speak with more assurance of the plans, but there is no doubt as to the blunt
T-shape of the stable and apparently of the house as well, the favorite plan type of most of
Wright’s early independent houses.
The James Charnley house in Chicago of 1891 is of a very different order than the
Ocean Springs cottages. Here there is no trace of Silsbee’s left, nor indeed of Richardson,
but rather a remarkable parallel to the “style,” in the generic sense, of the Wainwright Build-
ing. Even in these years, when the example of McKim, Mead & White’s reaction against
Richardsonian and Queen Anne picturesqueness was leading many American architects
to seek severe formality and urbane dignity in city residences, there are few to compare with
this. Moreover, there can be no question that although the general direction was Sullivan’s,
the designing hand here was Wright’s (Fig. 9). The thin Roman brick is more elegantly used
than it was even by McKim, Mead & White, who introduced it to this country. The light
stonework of smooth-cut random ashlar is skilfully treated as a base to the composition, as a
link between the projecting end bays, and as an articulated frame for the entrance beneath
the delicate balcony. The small attic windows beneath the flat Sullivanian cornice adapt the
monumental frieze windows of the skyscrapers to domestic scale. But the large, boldly cut
windows below resemble in their shape and their uncompromising directness those of the
Pueblo Opera House. The ornamental detail inside and out is Sullivanian, but the refinement
of scale is as unerringly that of an urban palazzo as if it were by Peruzzi.
The living room is at one end, the dining room balances it at the other; while the hall in
the middle is entered from a stepped entry between two reception nooks and has the main
stair in one flight along the rear wall. Such a plan is the most classical refinement of a
standard type long in general use for corner houses on narrow city lots. Beside it, Richardson’s
Trinity Rectory in Boston, technically similar, appears confused and even perverse in its
avoidance of the symmetry implicit in the parti.
Unlike the Lloyd Jones house of 1887 (Fig. 2), which is wholly Silsbee without being
very good Silsbee though of Wright’s technically independent design, the Charnley house
because of its high quality must dispute with his own house in Oak Park of 1889 (Fig. 1 1 ),
and even more with the contemporary Harlan house (Fig. 21), the honor of being Wright’s
first serious work. His independent practice began two years later with the Winslow house,
but the heights which he was destined to attain, if not all his ultimate originality, were
already implicit in these houses.
In the next year, however, the house built for Albert Sullivan and occupied immedi^
[12]
ately by Louis is no great credit to either Wright or Sullivan. But the Victoria Hotel of 1892
(Fig. 10), essentially office work, has markedly Wrightian elements in the clean-cut windows,
the projecting ornamental frieze of the top-storey and the panelled treatment of the tower.
The Schiller Building of 1891, an important work of whose drawings Wright certainly
had charge, is more essentially Sullivanian. Yet the return to arched bays and the very richly
arcaded eaves gallery, both elements omitted in the Wainwright Building, may well be the
design of a Wright for the moment plus royaliste que le roL Elements hitherto unknown in
Sullivan’s work are the coupled windows set flat in the wall screen of the rear section; the
crisply panelled bay windows of the side wings ; and above all, the motif at the top of the side
wing, the little inset balcony subdivided by a central colonette, the germ of a horizontal
instead of a vertical sort of skyscraper design (Fig. 5). These are probably Wright’s original
contribution.
The little balcony motif is of far more consequence than any hypothetically Wrightian
elements in the famous Transportation Building at the Fair. In the next year this motif
became the essential unit of design in the Meyer Building, of which Wright had general
charge of the drawings (Fig. 6). This seven-storey loft building, perhaps hardly a skyscraper
despite its skeleton construction, is the first work from the Adler & Sullivan office since
1887 of predominantly horizontal and not vertical design. Its relative unimportance make it
plausible that Wright should have had a more completely free hand in its design — ^a hand
freed as much from his own conscientious delight in being “a good pencil in the master’s
hand,” as from any external supervision — ^than in the Schiller Building. It is in function and
in expression far more in the line of the “elevator buildings” and the first skyscrapers by other
Chicago architects. And, like even the best of their work, and unlike everything which is
authentically Sullivan’s, it is also a little duU.
The Stock Exchange Building, designed before Wright left Sullivan but not executed
until 1894, is neither so dull nor so sound, but possibly historically even more important
(Fig. 7). Despite the vertical lines of its bay windows (themselves very likely a Wrightian
motif, as has been suggested for the earlier ones on the side wings of the Schiller Building)
this is also a tentatively horizontal expression of skeleton construction.^ The wide unmul-
lioned window openings are cut crisply in the wall screen, like those on the rear of the Schiller
Building, and filled with great fixed center panes with opening ends, the “Chicago Windows”
that all the commercial architects were using in the nineties. But there is something about
2 Wright’s project of 1896 for an. apartment house for Robert PerMns follows the Stock Exchange design very
closely, with very similar bay windows.
[13]
this building which is unintegrated, as if two personalities who were arriving at a break had
worked on it.
What seems significant is that Sullivan’s next skyscraper, the Guaranty Building of
1894-5, in Buffalo, perhaps intrinsically a finer work than the Wainwright, grows directly
out of the Wainwright and owes nothing to those elements in the Schiller, Meyer and Stock
Exchange Buildings which suggest the hand of Wright, On the other hand Wright’s Luxfer
Prism skyscraper project, designed after he left Sullivan, has a mature type of horizontal
screen- wall design toward which those three Adler & Sullivan buildings were leading the
way (Fig. 8).
Sullivan’s two late masterpieces, the Gage Building of 1898 and even more the Carson,
Pirie & Scott Building, begun in 1899^, seem also the natural sequel to the Schiller, Meyer
and Stock Exchange Buildings, rather than to the line that runs from the Auditorium through
the Wainwright to the Guaranty. On the other hand, they have an equally obvious relation-
ship to Sullivan’s work of the early eighties and of course also to the contemporary work of
other Chicago skyscraper architects. Indeed the Gage Building was actually built by Hola-
bird & Roche with only the fagade by Sullivan. The contrast of the Gage fagade with those
to the south, designed at the same time by Holabird & Roche, illustrates beautifully how
Sullivan’s architectural genius rose out of and soared above the merely competent function-
alism of his contemporaries.
®The original commission for remodelling an earlier building on the site goes back to 1891. There is no way of
telling whether there were projects of the intervening years leading up to the executed building. The possibility of an
earlier design before 1894 somewhat strengthens my argument.
3. LOUIS SULLIVAN STABLE, OCEAN SPRINGS,
MISS. 1890. (Adler and Sullivan.)
The first published project, for a chapd, is
definitely Suburban Richardsonian m char-
acter. This character is still maintained four
years later in the Mississippi group designed
for Sullivan, but the manner is simpler,
more formal and hence more personal
1. project: UNITARIAN CHAPEL, SIOUX CITY, LLOYD TONES HOUSE, HILLSIDE.
, 0 WA. Vrom InlavA ArchUect. June, .88^
Wright’s first executed building; designed ir
manner of Silsbee.
4. LOUIS SULLIVAN HOUSE, OCEAN SPRINGS,
MISS. 1890. (Adler and Sullivan.)
6. MEYER BUILDING, 307 WEST VAN BUREN ST.
CHICAGO, ILL. 1893. (Adler and Sullivan.)
7 . STOCK EXCHANGE BUILDING, 30 NORTH
LA SALLE ST., CHICAGO, ILL. 1 893-94.
(Adler and Sullivan.)
5 . SCHILLER BUILDING, 64 WEST RANDOLPH ST.
CHICAGO, ILL. 1891-92. (Adler and Sullivan.)
On the opposite page are grouped
three skyscrapers designed in the
Adler and Sullivan office while
Wright was there. Supervision of
the drawings of the Schiller Build-
ing and of the Meyer Building was
in Wright’s hands. Despite the
extremely Sullivanian character of
the Schiller Building as a whole,
the clean-cutting of the windows
in the rear wing and the little hori-
zontal motif above the bay win-
dows on the front appear due to
Wright’s hand. The horizontal
motif with the central colonette
becomes the consistent theme of
the Meyer Building, whose quality
is somewhat denatured by the loss
of its heavy but simple ogee cor-
nice. The horizontality of the
Meyer Building is partially main-
tained in the clean-cut “Chicago
windows” of the Stock Exchange
Building between the projecting
bay windows which recall those of
the Schiller Building. Designed be-
fore Wright left Sullivan, but not
executed until 1894., the treatment
leads directly to the Luxfer project
by Wright where frank expression
is given to the cage of the steel sk(;l-
eton. The Exchange and the Lux-
fer project also lead to Sullivan’s
late masterpiece, the Carson, Pirie
and Scott Building of 1899.
8. project: luxfer prism sky-
scraper. [1895.]
PART TWO
1889-1900
III. Wright’s Independent Work Before 1893
I T is something of a disappointment at first to turn from the exciting question of Wright’s
possible influence upon his master, or even from the superb urbanity of the Charnley
house, which he certainly designed for Sullivan, to the work done by Wright on his own
during the years he was with Adler & Sullivan. We are back once more in the world of
Silsbee, a suburban world whose physical and economic scale is very different from that of
the world of Adler & Sullivan. Something of domestic simplicity and restraint we have
noted in the Ocean Springs houses. But it is interesting to see how first in his own house and
later in somewhat larger houses, Wright began to move away from the picturesque toward
ordered symmetry and even toward academic formality.
The Oak Park neighbors used to ask if Wright’s house of 1889 were “Seaside” or
“Colonial.” In the terms of the time it was both (Fig. 1 1 ).
The greater simplicity, clarity and symmetry of the design accord well, for example,
with that of McKim, Mead & White’s W. G. Low house in Bristol, R. I., of 1887 (designed
after their academic Colonial H. A. C. Taylor house in Newport). The two bay windows of
the front, in one of which is the entrance, are balanced. The wide overhanging gable sweeps
down over these bay windows. The extremely compact T-shaped mass is broken only by a
simple cross gable at the rear. Such an orderly composition would have appealed more at
the time to advanced taste in the East than in Chicago. A long group of windows, with a hint
of Palladio in the central lunette, ran across the broad shingled gable. This motif can be
matched on James Brown Lord’s house of 1886 for Pierre Lorillard at Tuxedo Park, N. Y.
Which, of course, is not to say that Wright imitated it from that source, any more than to
claim that he emulated consciously other specific Eastern Seaside Colonial houses. The point
is that Wright at this point shared in the current development of the Suburban Richardsonian
toward clearer and more orderly design, so soon to be obscured in the East by preoccupation
with particular historic “forms.”
But if Wright’s Oak Park house of 1889 can thus in retrospect be floated in the general
current of the time, it has also elements which are quite personal to Wright. The extensive
terrace at the front, forming in Wright’s own image a stylobate, and the almost unbroken
roof, with the gable coming forward to crown the bay windows below, provide a sort of
domestic analogy to the base, shaft and cap treatment of the Wainwright Building. This
[ 17 ]
terrace is also the earliest instance of Wright’s mature practice of relating his houses closely
to the earth. The unified roof, subsuming subordinate elements beneath, is the first step
toward those hovering planes parallel with the flat prairie which are the hallmark of his
best-known later houses.
The widened doorways in the interior appear to be of the type ubiquitous throughout
the eighties, but there is a marked and, indeed, a crucial change in their expression (Fig.
13, 14). The door openings have no surrounding architraves. Instead a string course, con-
tinued around the room below the cornice and related to the pattern of articulated plaster
beams and panels on the ceiling, defines their top; and the walls beneath this string are pulled
back, as it were, to form the openings. Because of this device the interior space is really sensed
as a unity, as it only appears to be in the ordinary houses of the day when studied in plan.
Otherwise the plan is not extraordinary (Fig. 12). As in many Eastern houses even of the
next decade, there is a Queen Anne hall which is a small room, not a mere entry, but filled
with rather elaborate stairs. This opens into a larger living room, which in turn opens into a
dining room behind, while pantry and kitchen fill out the square. The chimney at the center
of the house provides both for the kitchen stove and for a living room fireplace. This fireplace
is set in an inglenook in the Queen Anne tradition. But the inglenook is here not so much an
atavism as an early hint of the way Wright was going to break up the cubic form of his main
rooms in the next decade. Similar plans were used by Wright in the nineties for many houses,
even after he left Sullivan, wherever economy demanded compactness.
The increasing use of polygonal forms in the Ocean Springs houses of 1890 as well as
a further dramati2ation of the roof by steepening the pitch and curving out the eaves to
emphasize the plane parallel with the earth have been noted (Fig. 3, 4). In the contemporary
MacHarg house the most important new element is the continuous line at the second storey
sills marked by a change from shingles to clapboards. This line, echoing the horizontals of the
stylobate and the eaves and also serving to tie together the second storey windows, was to be
almost universally used by Wright from the Winslow house of 1893 onward.
The houses for Thomas H. Gale and R. P. Parker in Oak Park and that for Robert G.
Emmond in La Grange, all of 1892, are practically identical in plan, although the Emmond
house is much the most elaborate in detail. These houses are unbalanced and quaint as seen
from the street, with a single corner tower and high hipped roof, like cottages in a fairy story
(Fig. 1 7). But seen from the side, the composition is symmetrical with the octagonal corner
bays rising two full storeys. The separate tower roofs of these bays flank the high main roof
which rises from the top of the lower storey. In plan, these houses have three minuscule living
rooms on one side, with the usual Queen Anne hall and elaborate stair on the other side in
[18]
front, and kitchen and pantry at the rear. Such planning is fussy and retardataire compared
to the fewer and larger rooms of the architect’s own Oak Park house (Fig. i8), but the com-
missions were, in a sense, mere pot-boilers.
These little houses are also, if not fussy, at least rather precious in exterior and interior
treatment. Narrow Middle Western clapboards, a sort of wooden equivalent of the elegant
Roman brick of the Charnley house, replace the more homely shingles of the Suburban
Richardsonian tradition. Whimsical screen-work, rather like that on Stanford White’s New-
port Casino, decorates the Emmond porch; and there is much intricate leaded glass in the
front door and windows.
The Gale and Parker houses are more restrained in detail. But the windows of their
octagonal bays form more continuous horizontal bands, intersected only by the corner studs,
than on the Emmond house (Fig. 17). These window bands, of course, like the long studio
window on his own house, are an early step in Wright’s development toward a new and more
open expression of wooden construction.
Two other domestic commissions of 1892 are more important. The Warren McArthur
house and the George Blossom house stand side by side in Kenwood, one of the South Side
suburban villages which, on account of his uncle’s church in Oakwood and his wife’s family
in Hyde Park, were almost as much Wright’s home territory in these years as Oak Park. Yet,
while the three houses described above are all but identical, it would hardly appear possible
that these could be the work of the same architect and certainly not that they were built
within the same year. The McArthur house is very similar to the later work of Silsbee as
represented by the Arthur Orr house in Evanston of 1888. The Colonial gambrel roof and
the front porch with corner arch orders of academic character now seem in retrospect con-
ventional enough, though they were novel in Chicago in the early nineties. There are, how-
ever, a few more individual touches to note. The bay windows at the corners, nearly full
octagons like those on the Emmond, Gale and Parker houses, are kept under the eaves and
the gable as on Wright’s own house. The variety of material is interesting, brick to the win-
dow sills and plaster above. The heavily moulded arch of the entrance door on the side con-
tinues the string at the top of the brick work, a motif elaborated on the Williams house of
1895. This gives a hint of the more individual decoration within and contrasts sharply with
the academic detail of the porch.
It is only this porch in all of Wright’s work up to this time that prepares us for the
character of the Blossom house. The McArthur house repeats on the whole an early stage in
the general modulation of the Suburban Richardsonian toward the Colonial Revival. But
the Blossom house is an example of the fuUy academic phase of the Colonial Revival which
[19]
hardly became widespread in the Middle West, or even for that matter in the East, until
about 1900 (Fig. 19).
There could be on Wright’s part at this time, as never again, an actual choice between
possible “styles,” motivated by the desire to avoid in his private work the manner associated
with Sullivan. It is not necessary to query whether the choice here was the client’s, as in the
case of the Moore house three years later, or the architect’s. In this year 1892, as all Chicago
was enthusiastically aware, the majority of the buildings for the World’s Fair were being
designed in various types of Classical academic style. And, although there were almost no
other examples in existence, except McKim, Mead & White’s H. A. C. Taylor house in
Newport, R. I., earlier than certain of the state buildings at the Fair, such academic formality
in domestic design was one possible end point to the later development of the Suburban
Richardsonian.
The front and the two sides of this house are coldly symmetrical and more papery in the
measured precision of their elegant, narrow clapboarding and thin detail than the H. A. C.
Taylor house. But other things are more significant. The conventional low hip roof is now
for the first time in Wright’s work a single sheltering unit, without cross gables, towers or
gambrel breaks, but with wide projecting eaves. Such roofs were to be increasingly Wright’s
favorites. The refinement and stylization of the Ionic order is quite personal. And by the
consistent use of the Palladian motif, in excess of any Colonial precedent, the windows could
be grouped in banks of three in every room, in contrast to the single windows of the Charnley
house.
In the plan the formality is at its most arbitrary in the front third of the house (Fig. 20).
The identical square reception room and library flanking the entrance vestibule have thick-
ened partitions to give depth to the archivolts of the door arches. These arches link the tiny,
semi-independent rooms axially together in the Beaux Arts manner. The middle third of the
house, however, combines a very large living room (in the modern sense) with a Queen Anne
living hall. An elaborate spatial composition of stairs rises in several flights at one end. A
wide and rather deep inglenook terminates the axis from the entrance; while a minor cross
axis from the library passes through two arches to the dining room at the rear.
This dining room is the finest thing in the house. Its projecting polygonal bay, boldly
breaking the symmetry of the rear of the house, reminds us of that of the dining room in
Richardson’s Glessner house of five years before and leads directly to that of the dining room
of Wright’s “first” house built for the Winslows in River Forest in the following year (Fig.
26, 28). Moreover, the continuous bank of leaded casements in this bay, by its greater length
and the greater number of angles which it crosses, is a more striking example of a horizontal
[20]
window band than those on the octagons of the little Oak Park houses. It is also closer to the
splendid bays in the English work of Norman Shaw’s followers in these years.
The arbitrary formal plan of this house does not become an archaeological strait jacket
like the revived Colonial plan with central hallway and four roughly equal rooms which
McKim, Mead & White had used in the H. A. G. Taylor house. It is hardly more than a
geometrical frame which brings order out of the irregular quaintness of the Suburban
Richardsonian tradition, and initiates the organic development toward the cross-shaped
plans of Wright’s Prairie houses after 1900.
The academic design of the exterior is related closely to Wright’s only other Classical
design, that submitted in competition for the Milwaukee Library and Museum in 1893. That
Wright on leaving Sullivan should apparently have gone over to the opposing camp of the
World’s Fair Classicists is more to be explained by expediency than by conversion. The great
colonnaded false fagades of the Fair had been received with general acclaim. The Chicago
Public Library and the Art Institute, then building by the newly converted heirs of Richard-
son, the firm of Shepley, Rutan & Coolidge, were both of academic Classical design.
Possibly also, there was a style restriction in the programme. For such reasons Wright may
well have felt that only an academic Classical design could hope to win. But the extraordinary
thing about the fagade design of this project — ^the plans are unfortunately lost — as about the
external design of the Blossom house, is that Wright at the first try should have shot so far
ahead of his Eastern contemporaries along their chosen line. The general parti is that of
Perrault’s front of the Louvre, a long colonnade above a plain base, broken with a pedi-
mented pavilion in the center. This is a much more rigid and authentically Classical scheme
than the academic Eastern architects were to use for some years yet.
Modern architects, like modern painters, need not regret that among their early works
are buildings and projects which are remarkably successful exercises in traditional design.
They answer the malicious criticism that the avoidance of conventional modes is due to
inability to manipulate them.
The one work of integrated excellence among what Wright has called his “bootlegged”
houses — and significantly the one which Wright remembers as having caused the break with
Sullivan — ^is the Allison W. Harlan house in Kenwood (Fig. 21). This we can look at not
merely with the analytical eye of historical criticism, but in sincere appreciation of a finished
and remarkably perfect work of architecture. Here all traces of the Suburban Richardsonian
or the Colonial Revival are gone and the academic virtues of order and balance are directly
adapted to functional convenience.
The plan, for all its excellence, is the chief thing that dates the house — ^there are still too
[21]
many separate rooms (Fig. 22). But the open vestibule is now pushed to one side, so that the
living room, with its range of french doors opening on the raised front terrace, extends almost
all the way across the front. The central stair hall, though ample, with the stair at the left
leading to a gallery above, is cut off at the right to provide a small library enlarged by a pro-
jecting bay window. The dining room and breakfast room extend across the rear in front of
the kitchen wing. This plan is formal in its avoidance of loose ends or casual protuberances
and in its sense of axes, but free in its adaptation to actual living, without wasting space on
areas introduced purely for balance.
In the exterior design there is a similar organic sense of order. The range of piers articu-
lating the front wall, with the open vestibule in the end bay and the french doors of the living
room in the others, produces regularity rather than forced symmetry (Fig. 2 1). Pilaster-like
members tie the storeys together at the corners and unify the subdivision of the wall into
Roman brickwork below and plaster above, as on the McArthur house. But these pilasters
are not the arbitrary coin of academic style, as on the Blossom house. They are quite as
organic units of design as the piers between the ground floor windows.
The ground plane of the terrace below is repeated firmly in the broad eaves of the hip
roof which now extends well beyond the wall line in a continuous sweep. Under the eave
across the front hung — it is now largely destroyed — a light and ornamental balcony. The
delicate cusped members of the balcony alone suggest the historic past, and that so distantly
and in such an American spirit as to recall more the Carpenter’s Gothic “gingerbread” of the
mid-century than Late Mediaeval work. It is true that the railings and soffits of this balcony
and of the smaller balcony in the middle of the side have patterns, like those on the Charnley
balcony, of somewhat Sullivanian character; but their jigsaw quality hardly suggests Sulli-
van’s terra cotta or metal. What is striking about the balconies is the suspended tenuity of
their traceried supports, the character of which is repeated in the open screens above the low
dormers of the roof. The handling of these balconies foreshadows the way minor breaks in
plan, and especially second-storey projections, were to be brought under continuous roof
planes in the Prairie houses.
If it seems that the quality of this house is higher than that of the Charnley house (Fig.
9), it may be because Wright was freer here. Certainly of all the almost precisely contempo-
rary works of 1891-92 this is the most mature. Few apprentices can ever have displayed
their own mastery so completely before setting up for themselves as Wright does in this house,
IV. The Maturing of Wright
I N the years between 1 893, when Wright left Sullivan, and 1 900, when in almost all respects
his maturity is complete, there are a great number of executed works and projects. They
need not all be discussed with the same detail as those in the last section. Most of the wooden
houses are unimportant, as well as the various remodellings, now that larger commissions
were coming his way. Many projects and several executed works suggest alternative develop-
ments which were not to be pursued now that the lines leading toward the mature Prairie
houses began to converge. The commissions of this period fall into two groups. Those of the
mid-nineties are already relatively more coherent in character than what preceded. In those
from 1897 on, the speed of development increases, until a “style” finally appears by 1900 as
sure, as complete, as original, as that of Sullivan in the Wainwright Building, yet with a far
greater breadth of immanent possibilities.
The Winslow house has often seemed very Sullivanian. But in the light of the work of
Wright done in Sullivan’s office and on his own in the preceding years it should be evident
that it is not, except in certain very minor details of foliage ornament. The plan is much more
academic than that of the Harlan house or even the Blossom house (Fig. 26). Indeed, with its
central chimney, it bears a certain resemblance to the early Colonial “five-room” plan and
yet it already offers a hint of the later articulated T and X-shaped plans. The number of
rooms is reduced, despite the relatively great size and cost of the house. Although the entrance
hall seems unnecessarily ample, the stair is no longer a conspicuous and space-consuming
feature as in the earlier houses. The living room is enlarged to fill one end of the block, quite
as so many Eastern architects were to do in adapting the late Colonial plan in this decade
and the next. The dining room, essentially a repetition of that of the Blossom house, is moved
to the center of the rear, so that in plan a main axis of extension is strongly felt. The covered
porch is brought within the main block of the house. In the project, though not in execution,
it is also connected by a covered gallery with a free-standing octagonal pavilion. This pavilion
was to balance the axially placed port-cochere on the other side.
In this almost country location on a part of Edward C. Waller’s large Elver Forest
estate, there is less of a base than at the Harlan house, but the double entrance path in front
with its central panel establishes a formal plane upon which the house rests. The broadly
extended hip roof, like that of the Harlan house, hovers over the whole front and the hori-
[23]
zontal line is repeated once more at the sill of the second-storey windows (Fig. 25). The com-
position of the ground storey is quite lilce that of the Gharnley house, with the broad windows
cleanly cut in the Roman brickwork and the entrance motif in stone broadened to enclose two
small windows on either side of the door. This stone framework is unified by a band of orna-
ment around the whole motif, which then passes across the bottom and up over the door
exactly as on Adler and Sullivan’s Wainwright Tomb.^ On the upper storey the projecting
moulded frieze in which the windows are set repeats almost identically, though with more
refined execution, that of the Victoria Hotel of the previous year (Fig. 10).
There are no elements of academic detail here. But when Daniel Burnham, shortly after
the completion of the Winslow house, with the Blossom house and the Milwaukee Library
and Museum project in mind, met Wright at the Wallers’ across the way, he tried to persuade
the younger man to go to the Beaux Arts in Paris at his expense and return to be his designing
partner. The gesture was not a fantastic one. Burnham correctly realized that at this moment
Wright was the best, if not the only, academic designer in Chicago. If anyone in Chicago
were to develop brilliantly and solidly the new academic classicism, to which the World’s
Fair had given a tremendous impetus, it might have been Wright, as the designing partner
of Burnham. But Burnham had to go his way with the assistance of decreasingly talented
designers. Wright also went his way, because he already knew that architecture could not be
split between designers and “practical men.” Indeed, he must have seen even at Adler &
Sullivan’s, so much less of a “plan factory” than Burnham’s office, the dangers of a division
in architectural responsibility. Up to this time, and working in close relation to the virtuoso
Sullivan, Wright had been more precocious as a designer than as a constructor, but hence-
forth he was determined to be both. His earliest training, after all, was as an engineer.
The rear of the Winslow house could never be mistaken for an academic design. There
the picturesque still rules. But despite a certain fussiness in details, such as the leaded bays
let into the tower, the asymmetry is compactly organized into an abstract composition of
voids and solids, verticals and horizontals, oblongs and polygons. This is extraordinarily full
of implications altogether richer and more creative than the dignified serenity of the front
(Fig. 28).
Among the later wooden houses the Frederick Bagley house in Hinsdale, built just after
the Winslow house, deserves mention. It is one of the last of Wright’s essays in the Suburban
Richardsonian and the best. Yet it is not for its gambrel roof and stylized Ionic columns that
it is notable ; but for the compact asymmetry of the plan, with its fine inglenook richly lined
^For the composition of the Tomb Wright was responsible, although its ornament, so different from the discreet
lozenge pattern here, is a particular triumph of Sullivan’s virtuosity.
[^4]
polished slabs of red marble, and the charm of the detached octagonal library with its
band of high windows, an enclosed version of the projected octagonal pavilion of the Winslow
house. Here for the last time is a house by Wright which might have seemed to Eastern con-
temporaries conventionally up-to-date, neither exotic in its originality, nor retardataire in its
refusal to use a “correct” sort of detail (Fig. 30).
The excellence of the Roloson row houses of 1894 was of a sort better understood in the
nineties than today (Fig. 23). Such superb brickwork has almost been forgotten; and the high
gables and the grouping of the mullioned windows suggest at first glance an intention of Late
Gothic style, actually very subtly avoided. Although such city house commissions have rarely
been sympathetic to Wright or even come his way, he handled these four, both as regards
ingenuity of planning and quiet dignity of fagade design, with a suavity urban-minded
Easterners like McKim, Mead and White rarely achieved, even with all the academic past
to draw on (Fig. 24). In addition to the splendidly articulated stone framework of the grouped
windows, so much more abstract than Late Gothic in character, the rich panels of rather
Flamboyant foliate ornament should be noticed. It is as if once he left Sullivan Wright felt
freer to develop his own considerable virtuosity at Sullivanian ornament.
The Roloson houses are not really at all Late Gothic, but at the specific insistence of the
client, the half-timbered Moore house in Oak Park of 1895 was (Fig. 32). The remarkable
thing, however, as in the case of the Blossom house, is not that Wright was willing to depart
from the line of what his uncle Jenkin Lloyd Jones called his “Oscar Wilde houses,” but that
having done so, the result should be on its own terms so excellent. In solid structural scale, in
the avoidance of confused picturesqueness, in the regularity of the fenestration, and in the
sense of craftsmanship, the exterior of this house is closer to actual Tudor work than the more
pictorially archaeological half-timbered houses built in the East in the nineties. Yet the large
piazza Americanizes the type clearly and frankly.
Also of 1895 are Wright’s first multiple dwellings, the Francis Apartments on Forestville
Avenue on the South Side and Francisco Terrace to the west of the Loop. The Francis Apart-
ments have always been considered very Sullivanian (Fig. 31). But the bay windows in Adler
& Sullivan’s work were very possibly, as has been said, of Wright’s design; and the suave,
urbane use of grey Roman brick and terra cotta was by this time more characteristic of
Wright than of Sullivan. Terra cotta has never been a favorite material of Wright’s because
of its lack of an organic form-giving character. But it was superbly suited to Sullivan’s sensu-
ous ornament, and it is not surprising that the ornament here, though more restrained within
a geometrical grid, is very much like Sullivan’s.
These medium-sized apartments are sensibly but not very originally planned. The lower-
[ 25 1
cost flats at Francisco Terrace and in the contiguous block on Walnut Street are more ingeni-
ous (Fig. 35, 36). The court of the Terrace is closed off from the street, unlike most of such
terraces in Chicago, with open stairs in the corners and outside entrances to the second-storey
flats from a continuous balcony (Fig. 34). So shabby has this become, in a neighborhood
blighted by semi-industrial zoning, that it is hard to imagine it with planting in the court and
flower boxes along the balcony, as Spencer described it in 1900 when it was known as “Hony-
moon Terrace” (Fig. 33).
The problem of the desirable amenities of low-cost housing will not be solved by archi-
tectural means alone; planting and upkeep are more important than at higher economic
levels and lie perhaps beyond the power of the architect to control. But this early low-cost
project by one who has been accused of having no “sociological” interests foreshadows certain
aspects of the best Dutch public housing after the last war.
The Williams house of 1895 is in certain respects retardataire, reminding us of the high-
roofed houses of the opening nineties, but it is the perfection of its type (Fig. 29). The high
roof has sharply projecting eaves with slots over some of the windows to let the light through.
The half octagons of the dining room and library are completely integrated into the general
plastic mass, while the original dormers repeated firmly the horizontal line of base, brick dado
and eave, against the dominating vertical of the superb chimney. The plan is freer than that
of the other houses of the mid-nineties, and the large living room extends most of the way
across the back, opening on a garden terrace.
The Roman brick below the window sills is extended to the rear with pierced patterns
to form an open terrace parapet. The band of plaster above is broken by the delicately leaded
windows which surround the semi-octagonal bays. The entrance repeats the McArthur house
motif of an arch rising out of the dado string-course. The artfully naturalistic arrangement
of the boulders at the base ties the more finished materials of the architecture in with the
rougher stone of the entrance terrace. This use of rough stone suggests for the first time the
influence of Japanese art.
The Ho Ho Den, the Japanese Pavilion at the World’s Fair, had had, contrary to gen-
erally accepted theory, almost no immediate effect on Wright. But the subtle and functionally
expressive asymmetry, the particular sort of naturalism of Oriental art, as he imbibed it from
Japanese wood-block prints, was to have almost as powerful an effect over the years on
Wright as it had had on the European painting of the Impressionists and the Post-Impres-
sionists since the sixties.
Wright’s own studio, contiguous to his Oak Park house, breaks wholly and all but finally
with the picturesque tradition of the Williams house (Fig. 39, 40). The functional asymmetry
[26]
is now much more formal. The interplay of planes, building up from parapet and terrace to
the different levels of the articulated mass, expresses a new and wholly personal sort of order.
This can be read more clearly in the plans and drawings than in the actual building which is
of necessity rather jammed in between the street and the pre-existing house (Fig. 38, 41).
Ceiling grilles for overhead light, stiU somewhat Sidlivan-like in their curved though
geometrical tracery, had first appeared in the dining room and the playroom added to the
house just before this (Fig. 15, 16). But in the large octagon and square grille which forms
practically the entire ceiling of the drafting room, itself an octagon rising out of a square in
three dimensions, we see for the first time the mature results of that training in pattern-
making with geometrical elements which Wright had received from the Froebel kindergarten
method fifteen years and more earlier.
Henceforth — and this differentiates Wright as much from Sullivan as from the later
“international” functionalists — there is for Wright no dichotomy between architecture and
ornament, between structure and design, between the whole and its parts. A large-scale
project of 1895 for an amusement park illustrates even more vividly than the studio, particu-
larly in its present remodelled form, the integration that was taking place. This large-scale
plan is not asymmetrical, like that of the studio, but wholly in the brilliant academic tradition
of Root’s World’s Fair plan, which Wright so much admired (Fig. 37). In the parts, particu-
larly the tail finials with their baimers, there is an extraordinarily festive spirit. Throughout
the separate edifices a profusion of cross-shaped hip roofs and cantilevered balconies make
of the total design a large-scale plastic architectural pattern. The temporary release from
the restrictions of designing medium-sized houses for prairie towns, to which he was soon to
return with final mature force, seems to have set free his imagination.
The McAfee project of the mid-nineties is in some ways more interesting than any
executed house of these years. The use of polygonal forms is more integral. The organization
of the rooms is articulated in a plan one room thick. A cross arm appears in the stair wing.
The interior space was considered as a whole and only partially broken between the main
rooms by columns, waU-spurs, and screens. Such new elements were gradually realized in the
executed works of 1896-99, the George Furbeck house, the Heller house and the Husser
house (Fig. 46). The Aline Devin project, for a lakeside house with its living quarters raised
off the ground, also led the way to the Husser house.
The Heller house of 1897 has superb grey and buff Roman brickwork and an unusually
lush moulded frieze in which the nudes of Richard Bock particularize surprisingly the generic
Sullivanian sensuality (Fig. 43). But the important thing to observe is the plan. Though
restricted by the deep narrow lot, the cross-shaped main rooms reach out toward one another
[^7]
(Fig. 44). Neat enclosure and interlocking of parts within a predetermined oblong or L or T-
shape had been at its most compact in the small Peter Goan house of 1894 Goodrich
house of 1896. Now there is an expansion from within. The space .of the rooms seems to break
out of the long oblong mass into a cross axis at the dining room bay and into a similar subordi-
nate mass, echoing the main mass, at the front living room bay. Henceforth the new plan
schemes, based on a new relation of interior volumes, and the exterior mass compositions are
the inevitable counterpart of one another.
Similar ideas appear in rather less happy form in the Rollin Furbeck house of 1898.
The most remarkable feature is the way a cross-shaped mass seems, more definitely than at
the Heller house, to rise in the third storey out of the oblong mass below. And this plastic
articulation is carried much further in the Waller project of 1899, particularly in the open
pavilion (Fig. 52).
The one-room- thick plan of the Heller house is in the Husser house of 1899 extended
to a cross shape. A staircase wing like that in the McAfee plan projects on the land side. The
dining room bay, like that of the Blossom house, projects on the other side toward the lake.
All the reception rooms of the raised main floor open into one another with only the slightest
subdivision by columns and screens (Fig. 46).
The moulded ornament of the Husser eaves galleries is the last example of such sensuous
ornament which Wright was to use and surprisingly like that at the top of the Schiller
Building of six years earlier. But the gold mosaic panel surrounding the fireplace with its
lovely flat patterns of rather naturalistic hollyhocks, copied five years later in the Martin
house, breathes a new and more Japanese spirit. (Fig. 45).
The interiors of this house are apparently gone beyond recall, but good photographs
exist of the dining room added by Wright in 1899 to the Edward G. Waller house in River
Forest. Here the great picture window at the far end, rising above the characteristic wooden
string course which defines the line of the door tops, and the articulation of the other win-
dows in groups illustrate in surprisingly developed form Wright’s new conception of interior
space. The room is no more enclosed within a single box, with holes cut through its walls.
Rather it exists within a complex of intersecting lines at right angles in three dimensions, its
space spreading out through the interstices of this framework into subsidiary areas and even
into the out-of-doors. The room is, as it were, plaided with intersecting, overlapping and
crossing volumes. A horizontal column of space, determined by the area of the great end
window, may be conceived as begimiing out-of-doors and extending down the long axis of
the room. This column of space interpenetrates the wider main space of the room, lying
below the horizontal string course, and also rises above it to the full height of the ceiling.
1 ^ 8 ]
A cluster of bands of space seem to shoot across between the mullions of the grouped side
windows and below the string course at one end of the room ; while at the other a broad cross
space, like a transept, terminates the movement in that direction (Fig. 51).
Such space composition is not immaterial, purely geometrical, abstracted in terms of
line and plane in three dimensions, like the space compositions of the “international” archi-
tects of the twenties. It is material and kinaesthetic. Indeed, if you are tall enough, the
difference between a high space and a low space may be materialized for you in a bump on
the brow. And throughout the linear elements are thickened and solidified so that they have
structural significance.
The executed houses of the late nineties, the related projects, and the Waller interiors,
were expensive. But two buildings of these years show how the stimulus of economy led to
structural innovation; and how structural innovation led to new types of expression, ele-
mental in their means, yet rich in plastic interest, without the conventional luxury of “fine”
materials or of moulded ornament. These buildings were the windmill and water tower built
for his aunts at Hillside in 1896 and the River Forest Golf Club of 1898.
In the water tower Wright was primarily an engineer, offering his solution in opposition
to a conventional open metal tower. Time has established his claim that his tower would last
longer, thus far about twice as long, as the supposedly “practical” commercial product. He
seemed to understand empirically the nature of wood. The bracing floors every ten feet
within the lozenge were like the braced articulation of a hollow plant stem, so that the tower
was in a real sense like a product of nature (Fig. 42). In the clutch of lozenge and octagon,
symbolically that of Romeo and Juliet, he found structural justification for his favorite plan
forms. The tower remains for Wright, as for most visitors to Taliesin, a beacon pointing
toward that ultimate marriage of engineering and architecture which we find in Wright’s
major works of the twentieth century, from the Larkin Budding to the Johnson Building,
from the Imperial Hotel to the Kaufmann house.
The original covering of the water tower was of shingles in the Suburban Richardsonian
tradition, but with the shingles banded to give bolder scale and more rugged character. On
the River Forest Golf Club shingles give place to siding with projecting horizontal battens.
Such a treatment was sturdier and more integral to the structure than a covering of shingles
nailed to the surface. The siding exploited both economically and artistically the intrinsic
qualities — ^the fibrous texture, the long lengths, the particular thickness — of wood as proc-
essed by the sawmill.
The front wing of the Golf Club was erected first. Subsequently the whole was
completed and then exhibited and published in 1900. Further additions, amounting to a
[293
complete rebuilding of the rear and larger portion, were carried out later. All the essen-
tial innovations appear in the first version as published in 1900, and most of them in the
original front wing, presumably of 1898. The original plan can best be described as a sort of
basilica of which the front wing constituted the “nave,” with the “transepts” providing
separate dressing accommodations for men and women, and a large “apse” at the rear con-
taining the half circular dining room. The cross plan is thus much further developed than in
the contemporary Husser house (Fig. 47, 48).
Since the arms of the cross are of different heights, the Golf Club also provides the
equivalent in exterior mass composition of the plaiding of interior space in the Waller dining
room. But to speak of mass is false. For this exterior is more a composition of inter-penetrating
spaces. The open porches at the front and at the wing ends extend the interior space out
into nature. The continuous bands of windows in the upper wall permit exterior and interior
space to flow through the wall. The continuous modular stud-skeleton of the light wooden
construction is revealed in the window muUions, while the sturdy structural lines of the hori-
zontal siding and its battens cross in front of the vertical lines of the stud-mullions (Fig. 49, 50).
Above, the low hipped roof with its continuous eaves protects the rows of windows and
the porches with equal thoroughness. At once hovering and sheltering, the roof defines the
shape of the total covered space, which is larger and differently shaped from the interior
space actually enclosed by the walls. The chimney is neither obscured and apologized for, as
on the Charnley house, nor yet given picturesque emphasis, as in the case of the fine chimney
on the Williams house. It provides a solid core of masonry to anchor the building to the
ground and also the pivot of the whole composition at the crossing of the axes. It is the point
of absolute mass about which are organized all the varieties of more or less open interior and
exterior space.
In a more vital sense than the Winslow house of 1893 River Forest Golf Club repre-
sents the beginning of a new architecture. It is not a mere Opus i, but a First Symphony.
If the essential character of its construction and design, so closely integrated as to be insepa-
rable, can be understood, almost all the work of the first decade of Wright’s maturity will
fall into place.
The work of 1900 leads directly into what has been considered Wright’s classic period,
the period of the “Prairie” houses, as christened by Wright in this year. But the houses of
1900, and even a few works of the next year or two, still have transitional elements and this
moment of crystallization merits separate consideration. The houses and house projects of
1900 group themselves into three pairs: the Bradley and Hickox houses in Kankakee; the
[30]
Pitkin and Wallis summer camps; and the two designs prepared for the Curtis Publishing
Company and published in the Ladies' Home Journal in February and June, 1901.
Publication thus made available at once the first fruits of Wright’s maturity to a wide
general public, had they cared to profit from the opportunity. At the same time Robert G.
Spencer’s appreciative and well-illustrated article in the Architectural Review of 1900 made
clear the stages by which this maturity had been reached.
Before analyzing the work of 1900, it may be well to indicate how the Chicago archi-
tectural scene had developed since the eighties. The commercial architects had continued on
the whole in the way they had started. But by 1900 the Chicago chapter in the history of the
skyscraper v/as almost over, the New York chapter hardly yet properly begun. The last great
monuments were Sullivan’s Gage Building and his Carson, Pirie, Scott Building of 1898
and 1899, his swan-song and the swan-song of an era. After this Sullivan fades gradually
from the picture, his bolt shot after a decade of intense if not profuse creative activity.
Of the old lights of the late eighties, the young men of promise when Wright had come
to Chicago, only Pond continued on his fitful and ambiguous way. But a new group was
appearing, many of them sharers of Wright’s new quarters in Steinway Hall. Of them for a
few years much was to be heard. This new “Chicago School,” quite different from that of
the eighties, owes its impetus partly to Wright and partly to the tradition of Sullivan. It pro-
duced few strong personalities and its best work has a certain anonymity. Eventually its
members either left architecture altogether or turned to a tasteful traditionalism. Foreign
visitors like the English Ashbee and the Dutch Berlage and the German Kuno Francke saw
before 1910 that Chicago architecture had come to its full fruition in the mature work of
Wright, and in the years after 1900 in that work almost alone.
The small Hickox house was built, together with the larger but less mature Bradley
house, at the south end of Harrison Avenue on the river at Kankakee, Illinois. The plan of
the house is a blunt T set sideways to the street like the Emmond and Gale houses (Fig. 18).
But the suggestion of four arms forming a cross is very strong because of the terrace project-
ing in front of the living room and the central gable above. As in the little houses of 1892
the garden front is quite formally symmetrical, but the other sides of the house are function-
ally asymmetrical. The house is slightly more commodious than the Emmond and Gale
houses, with larger rooms and a little reception nook, in Wright’s phrase of these years, a
“social office.” But the chief difference is the way in which the three little boxes of the 1892
houses have been expanded and opened up into a square central living room and two large
half-octagonal bays. Subdivision is barely suggested, the whole forming one apartment which
occupies most of the ground floor of the house. The living room opens on the terrace through
[31]
full-length glass doors, while high bands of windows are carried around the bayed ends of
the dining room and the music room (Fig. 54). As in the River Forest Golf Club the chimney
with its fireplace forms the vertical core of the house, though the cross axis here passes to the
front of it. The upstairs plan is compact and avoids as far as possible the awkwardness of
walls cut by slanting roofs. It is in the plan that there is the least change between this house
and its wholly mature twin, the Henderson house of the next year (Fig. 68).
The use of materials at first sight may seem less expressive than in the Golf Club. But
this is not altogether the case. We have only to compare it with any of the wooden houses of
the previous decade to see how successfully the light wooden stripping of the exterior plaster
covering ties the windows into the composition. By suggesting the studs beneath, this treat-
ment negates any feeling that the windows are mere holes in a solid wall. This is surely a
most valid expression of American wooden construction, despite the resemblances to half
timber which some critics see. A more probable relation is to the flat panels of Japanese
architecture (Fig. 53). The emphasis on the gabled roofs, with their tapered points modifying
the perspective, gives a curious suggestion of the oriental isometric and may well also be
Japanese in inspiration.
The asymmetrical fagade toward the street is as perfectly organized, as formal and anti-
picturesque, as the symmetrical fagade toward the garden. This indicates how little value
these terms, symmetrical versus asymmetrical, formal versus picturesque, have in relation to
Wright’s mature work. He had now learned from Japanese prints — rather than from
Japanese architecture — ^the secret of occult balance which had meant so much to the great
European painters Degas and Toulouse-Lautrec.
The larger Bradley house next door is less developed in plan than the Hickox house.
The living room opens out into subsidiary spaces, lower than the main portion, but the dining
room is more or less separate (Fig. 56). However, a covered porch on one end and a porte-
cochere on the other extend the side arms of the cross plan. A two-storey bay in the middle
of the front gable not only brings plentiful light into the living room and the main bedroom
above, but forms a strong vertical accent in the center (Fig. 55). The construction and the
design motifs are similar to those of the Hickox house, but there is more geometrical virtuosity
in the design of the leaded glass. All the furniture of the interior was especially designed to
harmonize with and complete the house (Fig. 57).
These houses are not quite masterpieces, like their immediate successors, but they come
very close, closer by far than the summer cottages in the woods for the Pitkins in Ontario
and the Goodsmiths in Wisconsin. Discussion of the way in which the general formula of the
[32]
Golf Club was directly adapted to domestic use, first in summer camps and then in suburban
houses, can well await more mature examples.
That the Curtis Publishing Company should have commissioned from Wright three
houses, two in 1900 and a third in 1906, indicates how the architectural division between the
East and the Middle and Far West at the opening of the century has been exaggerated in
retrospect. The Eastern lay public, if not the ringleaders of the profession, amid their en-
thusiasms for Colonial furniture and foreign knickknacks, still had an eye out for novelties.
This the American version of the English Studio and Stickley*s Craftsman make plain, as
well as the immense amount of Stickley’s “Mission” furniture absorbed in these years even
in the East. The House Beautiful was published in these years in Chicago by friends of
Wright and several times illustrated his work among the Chippendale chairs and the Art
Nouveau bric-a-brac. We know that little except the ephemera of this interest in creative
innovation took root. But Wrighfs work was not unknown in the East in the early years of
the twentieth century; and Messrs. Curtis and Bok may well have expected as widespread
and visible results from their sponsorship of Wright’s domestic architecture as from their
famous later and more concerted campaign for traditional “taste.” Among the bungaloid
types we vaguely dismiss as “Craftsman,” from their most enthusiastic and energetic pur-
veyor, there are traces in the East, as well as in the Middle and the Far West, of the influence
of Wright in these years, spread probably via the Ladies' Home Journal.
The first Ladies' Home Journal house, “A Home in a Prairie Town” designed in 1900,
is in conception not unlike the Hickox house. But in the more thoroughgoing development
of that conception, rather than because of the name under which it was published, it may
be considered the first Prairie house. No house of equal maturity was, however, executed
until the following year. In plan both elements of the T are prolonged (Fig. 59). Furthermore,
the covered porch in front of the living room extends the T into a cross. The eaves run
through along the side of the house at the top of the first storey. The T of the second-storey
plan rises above, its cross bar lengthened by the cantilevered oblong bays at the ends. These
bays are almost as open as the porte-cochere and porch at the ends of the stem of the T in
the storey below. Beneath the eaves of the first and second storey the windows are grouped
as in the Golf Club, though not quite so continuously (Fig. 58). And as in the Golf Club the
chimney rising above the low-hipped roof forms the solid core and anchor of the whole com-
position. Even more remarkable, because not prefigured in the Golf Club and not actually
carried out till near the end of the decade, is the way in which the central portion of the
living space is carried up for two full storeys, thus receiving light above the porch roof.
Communication is maintained by a gallery at the second-storey level across the chimney
[33]
breast (Fig. 6o). Thus the interior space flowed vertically as well as horizontally. But the
published plans also suggest the more economical alternative of placing two bedrooms in this
central portion of the second storey.
The external treatment of the plastered walls is somewhat less “Japanese” and more
masonry-like than in the Hickox and Bradley houses. But the description of the interior
recommends and the sections illustrate the stained sand plaster and the flat stripping of
natural soft wood which are henceforth to provide the characteristic treatment of interiors.
The image of the Prairie house was now essentially complete and all its varieties of the next
ten years may be seen to derive from this. No executed Prairie house is identical, but almost
all have points of plan, of mass composition and of exterior treatment in common.
Wright’s first general planning scheme, the “Quadruple Block Plan,” for a new type of
block subdivision neither romantically confused in the tradition of Olmsted’s naturalism, nor
a mere imposition of equal narrow lots on the helpless soil of the prairie was published with
the first Ladies’ Home Journal house. The house, in other words, was not just one house, it
was a unit in a middle-class suburban scheme. As in the case of the low-cost housing of
Francisco Terrace, so soon to be amplified in the Lexington Terrace project of igoi and later
years, Wright’s interest went wherever possible beyond the unit of the individual building.
It was not his lack of interest, but society’s lack of response that restricted his early develop-
ment as a “sociological” architect.
The second Ladies’ Home Journal house also designed in 1900, “A Small House with
‘Lots of Room in It’,” is intended for clients with less money. It is somewhat looser, though
possibly more strikingly novel in its asymmetrical cross plan. It is also closer to the slightly
“Japanese” expression of the Kankakee houses in its low projecting gables and wood-stripped
exterior walls (Fig. 61). The way in which the chief rooms are connected at the interior
corner of the cross, both having fireplaces in the same central chimney stack, was a more
widely acceptable, and possibly more practical arrangement than the radical running to-
gether of the rooms in a single apartment in the Hickox house and the first Ladies’ Home
Journal house (Fig. 62, 63). It was, moreover, rather more frequently used in the next decade,
even in houses which in appearance seem closer to the other model. To the eyes of the mid-
twentieth century the open terraces of this project, like those at Wright’s own Oak Park
house and at the Harlan house, seem to provide freer access to the grounds, if less complete
spatial extension of the interior, than do covered porches. But the latter were more practical
in the Middle West, for they could be and usually are screened — alas, with a considerable
loss of their value as voids in the composition.
In the case of this house, as of the first for the Ladies’ Home Journal ^ we may feel
[34]
assured that had it been built the following year, with the slight changes that adaptation to
a specific family and a specific site that execution would have entailed, it would have entered
as surely into the canon of early masterworks as any that exist. But there are several works
and projects of the next year or two which in one way or another still seem “early” in char-
acter, for instance, the Fricke house, of which the building permit is dated 1902. Its height
and its lack of the new clarity of cross-shaped plan and mass recall the last stage before the
Prairie houses as illustrated in the Eckart-Waller projects of 1899. The solid masonry-like
treatment of the plaster walls and the Sullivanian framing and columnar mullions of the
triple windows are also surprismg in 1902. Yet this house has often been published as if it
were a characteristic example of the new Prairie type. Such things help to explain certain
aspects of Wright’s influence in Europe (Fig. 64).
The “Village Bank” in cast concrete, published in the Brickbuilder in August, 1901,
may have been designed a year or two earlier (Fig. 65). But the relatively rich and naturalistic
ornamentation can be matched on the elevation drawings for Lexington Terrace in its first
form, which are dated 1901. Its chief significance is as an indication of Wright’s early interest
in a new material, of which his Unity Church of 1906 was to be the first American master-
piece.
The elaboration of the Fred B. Jones house at Delavan Lake and the markedly Japanese
character of the boathouse, even in the drawings dated 1901, is partly due to the early date.
For at least the house itself was certainly designed somewhat earlier. But the exceptional
and uncanonical character of the executed work is more due to the fact that it was unsuper-
vised. It is not worthwhile puzzling over the retardataire ambiguities of the Hills remodelled
house in Oak Park, designed in 1900, but possibly not carried out for several years. So great
is the profusion of riches of the years 1901-1910 that the problem is how to group them so
that in stressing the existence of types and classes no single masterpiece is neglected.
[35]
PART THREE
1901-1910
V. The Prairie Houses
W E think properly of Prairie houses and not of a Prairie style, not only because the
concept of closed style is false to the first principles of Wright’s approach to archi-
tecture, but because there is no necessary relationship to the prairie in the Hillside Home
School of 1902, the Larkin Building of 1904., or even in the Unity Church of 1906 and the
City National Bank of 1909, to mention some of the chief examples of non-domestic work of
this decade.
The Prairie houses might be grouped in various ways, by plan, by size and cost, by loca-
tion, by materials, or even by roof types. But basic to Wright’s architecture are his feeling
for the nature of materials and his relation to the natural environment. Had he worked at
first in the East or in the Far West instead of on the prairie his first mature houses would have
been not Prairie houses, but “Seaside” houses, or “Desert” houses. Even in this period his
“Forest” houses, some of them built in the wooded suburbs of the North Shore as well as on
the lakes of Wisconsin and Michigan, rival those of the more strictly Prairie type.
We may, therefore, consider first the masonry houses, almost all on prairie sites of more
or less open character, and then the wooden houses of two sorts, the typical suburban ones
with plaster surfaces and the more rustic ones covered with wood siding. The brick houses
are mostly large, and several of the finest of them such as the Heurtley house are unique.
The brick Heurtley house of 1902, on suburban Forest Avenue in Oak Park, is of about
the same size as the best houses and projects of the late nineties. As in some of them the living
floor is raised above a high basement. The plan is roughly a square which is defined by the
plane of the eaves of the hip roof above (Fig. 72). But as the upper storey porch off the living
room introduces a large void within the solid cube, while several small triangular bays break
out of the square to the edge of the eaves, there is no feeling of restriction. In the interior the
living room and dining room form a continuous L-shaped space, barely broken by a screen
of columns and flowing as well into the haU.
The great entrance arch with its long voussoirs and the projecting bands of the rich
orange brickwork have a solid and even Richardsonian air (Fig. 71). Projecting piers flank
the playroom windows below the living room. The entrance terrace, with its triangular end
and open slots in the brick parapet, lightens and loosens, however, the solidity of the base-
ment storey. And the screen-likie treatment of the walls above, with their windows separated
[393
only by heavy wooden mullions, is even more open. The terms symmetry and asymmetry,
have ceased to have any real meaning at this stage of Wright’s work, but it is worth pointing
out that the general form of this house is both abstract and formal, while the way the interior
is subdivided and the plastic accents of the exterior are placed is unusually free and
functional.
The marvelous placing of the Japanese cherry by the entrance, and the great old oaks,
which gave Oak Park and Forest Avenue their names, provide all the landscape effect. For
grass and trees are now the chief ingredients of Wright’s settings. The herbaceous border
which obscures the base line in the renderings of the Ladies’ Home Journal houses has been
given up. The only additional planting would have been flowers and hanging plants, particu-
larly the latter, in the superb vases at the entrance and in the flower boxes at the top of the
piers and along the porch parapet. This architecture was to be seen in relation to natural
surroundings of its own scale, the grass of the prairie plain, and the towering forest trees or
strategically placed exotic ones. But flowers and small-scale plants were to be used on the
exterior as inside the rooms, in vases and boxes, a minor, almost feminine, touch replacing
the rich plastic ornamentation on the houses of the late nineties.
The only rival among the masonry houses to the early Heurtley house is also unique, the
Robie house of 1909. Here the living quarters are also raised off the ground, but the living
room and dining room now lie in a continuous line, like the public rooms of an ocean liner,
partially separated by the chimney and stairs, and opening at the ends and all along the side
onto continuous balconies like nautical decks (Fig. 1 64, 165). In the third storey above ; a cross
element appears leading back to a service wing at the rear of the narrow corner lot. This
house, with its hovering lines of balconies and hipped roofs is almost as suggestive of an air-
plane as the more dramatically located Gilmore house in Madison of the previous year,
which is called the “Airplane House” (Fig. 157). Thus, it is more exciting than the Heurtley
house, though perhaps intrinsically no finer.
The brick work is smoother, more like machine work, the lines are crisper, and the
dependence upon the setting is less. There is also more provision made for plants in long
boxes on the outside of the structure, as if the house were a great ship carrying the world of
nature, as well as the world of abstract space, into the urban commonplaceness of Hyde Park.
The interiors have all Wright’s original furniture and even his minor fittings, and retain,
with the piety of a museum, the full character of his interiors of these years. Doubtless the
wood has darkened, and the walls have lost some of their freshness of texture and color, but
in no other early house is the ensemble more complete (Fig. 166).
In the Dana house in Springfield, Illinois, of 1903, Wright was somewhat restricted in
[40]
plan by the necessity of building around an earlier house. There were several rooms, how-
ever, which, for the first time in Wright’s executed work, rose two full storeys (Fig. 86). The
slanting planes of the gable roofs bring out a main cross form and tie together the many sub-
sidiary parts (Fig. 88). A patterned wall below the eaves, a more mature variant of the Wins-
low house frieze, fills in the considerable blank spaces between the upper windows above the
marked line of the second-storey sills. Pier-like projections flank the wing ends under the
gables (Fig. 85). But the house is empty and neglected now and it is hard to respond to what
it must once have been when the gaiety of its unusually rich decorative accessories was sup-
ported externally and internally by a profusion of flowers and plants (Fig. 87).
- "The empty Martin house in Buffalo of 1904, on the other hand, is obscured today by too
lush a growth of planting riotously rising out of the bands of masonry prepared for more dis-
creet foliage and flowers. With the darkening of the interior woodwork and walls, and above
all of the ceilings and eave soffits, the interiors have become rather dreary. The glint of the
gold mosaic around the living room fireplace and of the decorative leaded patterns in the
windows gives a hint of the brilliance and richness that was once there (Fig. 104). Of the
interiors only the kitchen with its lighter woodwork and its profusion of white tile retains to
the full its original quality.
This is the largest and most ambitious expression of the T plan. The long axis parallel
with Jewett Parkway begins with the open porte-cochere at one end and terminates with the
open porch outside the living room at the other. The cross axis at the porch end rises two
storeys, as does most of the shank of the T (Fig. loi, 102). Beneath the lower eaves and again
beneath the upper eaves on front and rear are almost continuous rows of windows separated
by masonry mullions. At the ends of the cross wing a bay below and a balcony above project
as far as the edge of the eaves overhead. The rhythms are stopped at the corners rather more
subtly than on the Dana house by pairs of piers at right angles. The hip roof is broken by two
broad low chimneys suggesting the direction of the two main axes. The adjuncts to this
house, the gallery at the rear leading to the conservatory, the conservatory itself, and the
large garage with living accommodations above, as well as the litde Barton house to the rear,
are all interesting (Fig. 1 03).
The Martin house represents externally a magnificent extension and confirmation of
the compositional possibilities of the Prairie house, but in so large a house, the type of
planning originated for a rather different scale of life was not at its best (Fig. 100). Eventually
in the Harold McCormick project and the Coonley house Wright worked out a pavilioned
sort of plan more suitable to such large houses. But three smaller masonry houses of 1903,
1904, and 1905, the Little house in Peoria (Fig. 89), the Cheney house in Oak Park (Fig. 105)
[41]
and the Heath house in Buffalo represent more effectively the more normal Prairie house in
masonry. The Little house and the Heath house, set on rather narrow corner lots, extend
their plans chiefly in a single axis, although the later Clarke addition to the Little house
developed somewhat the cross axis (Fig. 91). But the disposition and interrelation of the rooms
is a clear adaptation of the T and cross plan about a central chimney (Fig. 92). This elongated
plan type is found also in such wood and plaster versions as the Mary M. W. Adams house
or the superb Boynton house (Fig. 143).
The Cheney house is square in plan and raised over a high basement (Fig. 1 07). The base-
ment provides a well-lighted suite of rooms at the rear and also dark cellars under the raised
terrace at the front. The extension of the base by this terrace and by the approaches on
either side makes a splendid stylobate. The calm unbroken square of the wide-eaved hip roof
leading up to the central chimney shelters a plan in which the continuous flow of the main
living area across the front is backed by rooms which fill out the square behind an interior
passage. The resultant classic serenity is of almost temple-like character, surprising in a house
of medium size (Fig. 105, 106).
Masonry plays some part in several other houses and projects. The large and elaborately
formal Shaw project for Westmount, Montreal, for example, is interesting in section, as it
rises against the hillside, and also distinguished in its elegant use of random ashlar. But it is
too complex in its axial treatment, so that the scheme came to more satisfactory development
in the Tokio Embassy project of 1914, whose public character and larger size better justified
the almost French monumentality. In the Beachy house in Oak Park of 1906, brick piers
are used as supports for a generally projecting upper storey of wood and plaster (Fig. 124).
The Beachy plan is somewhat effected, like that of the Dana house, by the incorporation of
an earlier house. In general such combinations of masonry elements with wood and plaster,
although suggested in several projects, and somewhat more broadly used on the Irving
house of 1910, did not really come to fruition until the building of Taliesin in 191 1.
The fullest range of Wright’s genius in these years is undoubtedly to be found in the
plastered wooden houses. The Henderson house of 1901 is the first great example, perhaps;
but in this the modification of the expression of the Hickox house by greater horizontality of
treatment, particularly in the substitution of hip roofs for the gables, is so obvious as to
require no discussion (Fig. 66, 67, 68). And despite the excellence of its L-shaped plan the
Thomas house, also of 1901, looks backward more than forward (Fig. 69, 70).
The masterpieces begin with 1902, the year of the Heurtley house. The brick houses
stand chiefly in rather closely built suburban settings, but the Willitts house has a site in a
grove at Highland Park, Illinois. The grove has been thinned enough to let light into the
[42]
house, and a smooth iawn marks the ground plane instead of the rough forest floor, other-
wise the natural setting is unchanged. Particularly delightful is the pattern of the vertical
tree trunks against the long horizontal lines of the house and of the lawn (Fig. 73).
The plan is a broadly articulated cross, a superb development of the possibilities of the
Bradley house (Fig. 74). The space of the rooms connects at the center of the cross, as was first
suggested in the second Ladies^ Home Journal house (Fig. 62) and executed in the plan of the
Thomas house (Fig. 70). The long low hip roof extends from the porte-cochere at the right,
penetrating the two-storey central wing, across the front of the dining room to the left to
hover over the porch at that end. A two-storey cross-shaped block, its eaves set back a little
from the line of the eaves below, rises above this long sweep. The porte-cochere leads
through the somewhat exiguous front doorway into the entrance hall and reception nook.
The interior space, partially broken by screens at the fireplace, flows on into the living room
extending at right angles toward the street (Fig. 75). Then, continuing straight across in
front of the fireplace, but once more cut by a screen, the interior space flows on into the
dining room, beyond which lies the covered porch at the end of the further wing. The ample
services occupy the rear wing and thus connect with the entrance hall as well as with the
dining room. Upstairs the rooms are efficiently organized in a smaller cross.
_«=^-jrhe plaster surfaces are very evidently a continuous skin over an articulated structure,
without suggestion of masonry solidit)| The restrained wooden stripping no longer recalls
half -timber. But it serves to tie the windows into the composition. And their size and group-
ing, with wooden muUions which are manifestly a mere sheathing of structural studs,
expresses as clearly as in the best Late Gothic half-timber design, but with a purely American
lightness and tensility, the underlying wooden skeleton. Similar sand-finished plaster, stained
with colour, and similar plain wooden stripping relate the interiors closely to the exterior
expression. The delicate ornaments of nature, hanging plants and flowers, grow out of the
podium of the house itself or hang down from window' boxes or urns.
A whole group of cross-shaped houses are clearly the progeny of the Willitts house,
although they vary in the disposition of the rooms within the cross, in their adaptation to
different sites and above all in size and complexity. The Evans house of 1908 makes a par-
ticularly vivid impression because of the way it crowns a gently rising slope with urn-topped
pylons to terminate the side wings (Fig. 144, 145, 146). But the complimentary masterpiece
is the small Isabel Roberts house, also of 1908. In this the living room at the front rises two
storeys, with the interior balcony proposed for the first Ladfe/ Home Journal house, and a
superb two-storey bay nearly the width of the front wing (Fig. 154, 155, 156). Even the later
substitution of brick veneer for plaster has hardly damaged the perfection of the house. The
[43]
similar but less delicate Steffens house of 1909, now sadly blighted, suggests how effectively
tbiR type could crown a rise, like the ampler Evans house. The perspective, published in the
Wasmuth portfolio as of the Roberts house, but actually of the Melson project for Iowa City,
shows the unexpected drama of these supposedly quintessentially Prairie houses when their
two-storey bays rise above a ravine.
Other more dramatic possibilities of steep sites above water for these winged — and
indeed almost winged — houses are to be found in the Johnson house at Delavan Lake and
the Scudder project for one of the islands at the Sault — although both are of wood siding.
But the masterpiece is the Hardy house of 1905 in Racine. Here the main wing with the
dining room below and two-storey living room above projects out and also cascades down
toward the lake. Yet it is also tied to the steep slope by anchoring terrace walls and pylons
on either side (Fig. 112,113,114).
Some mention has been made of the wood and plaster houses designed like the Little
and Heath houses for narrow sites or at least upon oblong rather than more articulated plans.
Of these the Sutton house of 1907, among others, is balanced in design. The Boynton house
of 1908 is not. But its unusually large window areas and forceful vertical accents, like the
two storey stair window bay on one side, are more interesting and quite as perfectly
integrated (Fig. 142, 143).
Three other types deserve particular mention. The fundamentally square houses have
virtues of compactness and ingenuity, even though they are sometimes rather dull and
formal, like the Hoyt and Hunt houses. Then there are those which might be called T or
L-shaped except that they are more significantly like crosses — Latin crosses, placed with their
long sides toward the street. Finally, certain large and even palatial houses, like the Harold
McCormick project and the Coonley house, have plans of linked pavilion type.
It is perhaps inaccurate to call the Gridley house of 1906 square (Fig. 127). A very long
projecting one-storey porch, with the usual hip roof and parapet, balances a narrow two-
storey wing at the rear on the other side. But the thickness of the main block, the continuous
band of mullioned windows brought out to the eave edge in front, and the cantilevered slab
in the center of the lower storey, emphasize the cubic form. This sort of composition was
also very happily used in this year for the third Ladies’ Home Journal house project. As this
was to be of cast concrete there were technical advantages in the square plan, in that the
same wooden forms could be used for all sides. The roof, of course, was a flat slab (Fig. 128).
The Ingalls house of 1909 is of a much more formal type and more definitely square
(Fig. 163). Here the projecting porches and balconies suggest a cross within the square. The
more delicately detailed woodwork was always intended to be painted. Perhaps because of
[44]
its crystalline compactness and lack of true Prairie extension — ^which is so artfully introduced
into the Gridley house — this was more frequently imitated around Chicago than any of the
other types. European imitators also often followed this least genial of Wright’s house types
of these years.
The Gale house of 1909 is also more or less square (Fig. 160). But like the completely
different Isabel Roberts house it is a small masterpiece. It is also closer to what the Europeans
who were most creatively inspired by Wright’s were to come in the early twenties. Most of the
other wood and plaster houses had hip roofs and hence a very slightly weighted emphasis on
the hovering eaves plane. But this has the more abstract and less traditional slab roof, first
proposed for the Yahara Boat Club project of 1902 (Fig. 79). The slab is used in a very
different way than any of Wright roofs up to this, since it does not unify or harmonize
irregularities below but rather gives variety to the cube of the house by its own broken form.
The planes and the vertical elements of this composition have a definite structural thickness
and are not like sheets of paper hung in the air, as in so many European projects of the
twenties, but the handling of the elements is more abstract than in any earlier work by
Wright. The front toward the street consists of three horizontal elements, the usual podium-
like terrace parapet below, a lightly less extended cantilevered parapetted balcony above,
and finally the roof slab, which projects further in front than on the sides. The line of the
“wall” is marked less by the completely open screen of glass doors below and windows above
than by the flanking pylons which rise to the balcony top at either side at this point in plan.
On the left side a projection of the height of these pylons contains the entrance hall. This
lies outside the main square of the plan and is further accented by a cantilevered slab which
repeats the floor plane of the front balcony. Above this projection a slab roof extending at
right angles to the main roof over the front of the house is stopped, as are all the eaves, against
the chimney. The chimney, forming the vertical pivot of the whole composition, is half sunk
in the main mass of the house, but also rises half free above the entrance wing.
Curiously enough the plan which this revolutionary plastic invention clothes is not very
extraordinary (Fig. 161). The L-shaped living-room-dining-room is a smaller and more
unified version of those elements in the square Heurtley house, quite similar to those in several
smaller square houses of which the third Ladies' Home Journal house is the best example.
The Baker house in Wilmette of 1909 is of a very different order. It presents to the
street a long low fagade with continuous rows of windows above and below (Fig. 158). At
one end this fagade is stopped against a projecting cross arm. This cross arm contains the
living room, which is two storeys high like that of the Isabel Roberts house (Fig. 159). Beyond
this cross arm the roof of a projecting porch continues the lower eave of the main fagade.
[ 45 ]
The rear of the house is somewhat less schematic. The mass composition of the Baker house
is thus somewhat like that of the brick Martin house, but the scale is more domestic and less
monumental; and the great living room bay provides a stronger vertical accent to balance
the long horizontal lines. The clear pattern of the wooden window mullions, the plaster of
the unpierced lower walls and the delicate lattice of the diamond panes offer a particularly
happy and expressive chord of materials. As in the River Forest Club the mullions reveal
the underlying wooden skeleton of studs; the plaster forms a sheathing plane carried in
front of the studs; the diamond panes provide a penetrable screen at the point where interior
and exterior space meet. The whole is, perhaps, the most logical and consistent of all the
wood and plaster houses.
Somewhat smaller and less crystalline in composition is the Davidson house, also of
igog, in Buffalo, in which the living room bay also rises the full height of the house. But the
whole effect, today, is lost in vines and shrubs, while the Baker house has little planting
except for the great trees which arch above it.
On quite a large group of houses in this decade Wright substituted, at least in the lower
walls, the horizontal battened sheathing of the River Forest Golf Club for the plaster of the
houses described above. Most of them are summer houses in the woods beside Delavan Lake
in Wisconsin and White Lake in Michigan. But a few are in the more wooded suburbs north
of Chicago and there is one in Montecito, California.
The first to be built were the Goodsmith house at Delavan Lake and the Pitkin house
near the Sault, both of igoo. But as with the wood and plaster and the masonry houses the
type came to maturity two years later. The fine little Walter Gerts cottage at White Lake is
ahnost identical with the front wing of the Golf Club. The Ross house at Delavan Lake is
slightly larger with a very compact cross-shaped plan improved from that of the nearby
Goodsmith house (Fig. 78). The upper storey, which rises above the cross arm, has plaster
between the windows instead of the vertical board and batten treatment which gives a some-
what immature air to the Goodsmith house (Fig. 77). Although unsupervised and quite small,
this house ranks in quality with the Willitts house and the Heurtley house of the same year.
The adaptation of the cross plan to a rather steeply sloping site, with the entrance on the side
and the porch projecting out toward the Lake, reveals once more how readily Wright adapted
his houses to varied site conditions. As at the Willitts house, the woods are slightly thinned
and the forest floor grassed to provide a setting. The house, for all its somewhat rustic
materials, is not merged with the natural surroundings. It stands clean and crisp among the
trees, harmonious in texture and tone, and yet clearly man-made.
The Millard house in a thick grove at Highland Park is not especially remarkable in
[46]
plan or composition. Among the suburban wooden houses the Glasner house of 1905, at the
crest of a steep ravine in Glencoe, is the most interesting. Like the Usonian houses of the
thirties this has no separate dining room, and the whole plan is drawn out very long and
thin, iil(;e some of the projects of the nineties (Fig. 1 1 1). It even has octagonal pavilions like
several of the houses of the nineties, but these are tied into the general composition by the
square roof projections above. The striking contrast between the very low fagade on one side
and the deep base extending down into the ravine on the other and the dramatic interest of
the attached octagons make this house unique (Fig. no). The particular articulation of the
plan, which cannot be defined as cross, T or L-shaped like most of the houses of this decade,
quite as much as the unification of the living space, foreshadowed later developments in
Wright’s domestic work and prepares, despite its small size, for the two largest house
designs of this period.
Neither the project for a house for Harold McCormick at Lake Forest, which was
never built, nor the Goonley house, which many consider the culmination of Wright’s early
domestic work, fit into the earlier plan categories. The McCormick house, rising above Lake
Michigan, would have been almost like a Persian palace (Fig. 140). Pavilions, completely
surrounded by windows, are joined by a gallery, in front of which an open terrace projects
toward the Lake. Behind the gallery is a court with a very elaborate master’s wing on one
side, connected by a bridge with the living room pavilion, and a service wing on the other
side (Fig. 139). Generally low, though the pavilions rise out of the cliff on high bases, loosely
linked about gardens and ornamental pools, formally as well as organically arranged, this
private palace might suggest a group of exposition buildings as much as an ordinary dwelling.
And yet except for the size, there are none of the vulgar palatial luxuries. Structure and
expression are simple; the scale of the parts, despite their extent, remains domestic; yet the
fullest advantage is taken both of the charms of the natural site and the possibilities of rich
planting in the courts. Among all the many magnificent unexecuted projects, this is one
whose loss is particularly to be regretted, even though many of the same qualities are present
in the Goonley house.
The Goonley house has nowhere near so fine a site. But the estate was large and, with
the river at the edge, as potentially attractive as the western suburbs of Ghicago could offer.
To make up for the flatness, all the living quarters are raised as in the Heurtley house. The
pavilion treatment of the McCormick house is repeated, particularly the isolation of the
service and master’s wings, with the entrance to the court passing under a bridge (Fig. 147).
But the living room pavilion dominates the chief fagade; the dining room faces in a different
[ 47 ]
direction, and the fiaiiking galleries, in which are the stairs, are less open than in the
McCormick project.
Two of the most striking things about this house are the terrace and pool arrangement
in front of the main pavilion, and the ornamental frieze on the upper storey (Fig. 148). The
pylons, eventually linked with a pergola, extend the architectural composition out toward
the pool in which the playroom doors below and the band of windows of the living room
above are reflected. Now with the addition of the plane of the water, and above all the
pattern of reflections in it, a schematic analysis of the space composition such as was possible
for the work of the opening of the decade or even for the Gale house, would become unin-
telligible without diagrams (Fig. 49). Inside, with the ceilings now following the external
pitch of the living room roof and the flanking galleries and the stair wells open to the storey
below, Wright’s orchestration of space has also become very much richer (Fig. 152). One
may even prefer the relatively simpler organization of plane and void and line in the less
elaborate houses of this decade. But the increasing complexity points the way forward to
later periods (Fig, 150, 153).
In the frieze on the exterior of this house small coloured tiles inlaid in a tooled pattern
of straight lines in the plaster form a crisp geometrical pattern which contrasts sharply with
the Sullivanian friezes of the nineties (Fig. 15 1). Such ornamental work at architectural scale
had not been wholly unknown on the houses since 1900. The Dana house of 1903 has a some-
what similar frieze, but of a less geometrical character. But in general the ornament — ^if one
can ever properly make it a separate category in Wright’s work — ^had been restricted in the
Prairie houses to the leaded glass in the windows and the wooden ceiling grilles and the
marking strips on the ceilings. In this ornamental frieze, introducing bright permanent colour
in a discreet pattern which enlivens the whole wall surface of which it is a physical part, we
have a foretaste of the more elaborate structural ornament and the richly textured surfaces
of much of Wright’s work in the next twenty years.
[48]
VI. Non-Domestic Work
T he Prairie houses may be^ as they have generally been considered, the greatest achieve-
ment of Wright in the first decade of this century. But despite the predominance of
domestic commissions the general range of his architectural work is extraordinary. Few other
architects of this period, and surely none who were chiefly famous for their houses, also built
factories, shops and churches, schools, exposition pavilions, and office buildings, and in addi-
tion made projects for various large-scale housing schemes and even for whole towns.
The clubs Wright built, the two River Forest Tennis Clubs of 1905 and 1906, which
succeeded the River Forest Golf Club, and the unsupervised Como Orchards central club-
house in Montana of the end of the decade, are so similar to the domestic work that they
hardly require discussion. The project of 1902 for the Yahara Boat Club is, however, impor-
tant. Although not large, this project initiates a new sort of design which, in the light of
what was to follow, it is not absurd to call monumental. It is, however, the boldly cantilevered
slab roofs, providing long before the Gale house a premonition of the more abstract plane
composition of much of Wright’s later work and the work of the young Europeans in the
twenties, which gives the Boat Club its particular significance (Fig. 79). One wonders if this
motif may not have been introduced the previous year in the Universal Portland Cement
pavilion at the Pan-American exposition in Buffalo. Of this no trace in photograph or
drawing seems to be extant.
The true heirs of this project in the next few years are the Larkin Building and Unity
Church. But before coming to them a very important executed building of 1902 should be
discussed. The Hillside Home School was built beside Wright’s first house of 1887 for his
Lloyd Jones aunts. Although it has a close relation to the domestic work of the time, the
school is more monumental in construction and design. The plan is simply an H, one storey
high in the rear wing, two storeys high on the front, and with the cross bar a bridge under
which passes the drive (Fig. 82). At either end of the front wing are two pavilions marking
the two large rooms of the interior, the rest of which is subdivided into small class rooms,
opening on a corridor at the rear. These two pavilions balance one another, but they are not
identical, since the rooms within are quite differently disposed. The composition is thus
formal but asymmetrical, the asymmetry beautifully related to the diagonal slopes of the
site (Fig. 81).
[49]
The construction is unusually solid for this period of Wright’s work, comparing thus
with the contemporary Heurtley house. The lower walls are of native rock-faced random
ashlar, superbly laid and reminding one of the finest of Richardson’s masonry. But the stone
was light and flesh-coloured and has remained so in this country environment, so that the
effect is not grim or even severe. The marked batter of the pavilion walls serves to centralize
and to concentrate their design. This batter was used on the Imperial Hotel fifteen years
later. It also appears once more in the rough stone and concrete bases of Taliesin West, 1938,
and the Pauson house, 1 940, near Phoenix, Arizona.
Above this masonry substructure, made more solid by the rough surfaces and the batter,
the upper portion of the school is as open as the Prairie houses. On the pavilions the tall
windows descend between corner pylons, like those on the Dana and Martin houses, deep
into the masonry, opening on a plant-filled terrace. The simple wooden mullions which
separate the windows are unusually sturdy, well scaled to the monumental vigor of the
whole design.
The interiors have mostly been modified in remodelling the school since 1933 for the
uses of the Taliesin Fellowship, but in the living room inside the larger pavilion the original
treatment is still entirely extant. The chief feature is an enormous stone fireplace with a
large fiat lintel in the rock-faced random ashlar of the solid wall. On this is a finely cut
inscription. The bold and rough-surfaced woodwork harmonizes with the stone and is stained,
inside as well as out, a rich dark brown. A balcony in the form of an open square is set
diagonally to the cross-shape of the room itself (Fig. 84).
The use of native stone from the hills nearby, the adaptation to the hillside site, and the
absence of all compromise with suburban domestic ideals already suggest the later domestic
manner of Wright’s own Taliesin built on the next hill in 191 1 .
Superficially there could hardly be a greater contrast between two buildings than
between the Hillside House School and the Larkin Administration Building in Buffalo. This
was designed just as the School was being completed and begun in 1904. They are both large
in size and both of masonry, but there, unless we understand how the inner consistency of
Wright’s principles necessarily demands in edifices of different purpose and environment a
different expression, the similarity seems to end. Yet this tall brick structure, rising out of a
grim industrial backwater of Buffalo, dominates and even harmonizes with its environment,
in much the same way as does the school with the Wisconsin countryside. Here nothing is
rustic, everythinghas the finish and perfection of an industrial product from the hard, smooth
brick of the walls rising almost blank at the front to the amazing plate glass entrance doors
set in their flat metal frames (Fig. 9 7).
[50]
In some ways the structural expression of this building may suggest brick masonry less
than poured concrete and there is reason to believe Wright would have preferred to use the
newer industrial material had his clients been willing. For the construction makes no use of
the arch and by means of reinforced beams and lintels achieves almost as open an effect,
internally and in the greater part of the side walls, as if it were of steel or concrete skeleton
construction. But it is open at the sides merely to let in light, not so that space may flow freely
between the inside and the outside. For the outside environment is instead shut out. Indeed,
the building was perhaps the first to be truly sealed, its interior climate controlled by an early
form of air-conditioning (Fig. 94).
Too much was made by European admirers of the industrial severity approaching grim-
ness of the exterior of this building (Fig. 92, 96). They rarely realized its great scale or its
relation to the cliff -like old-fashioned factory buildings across the street. Misunderstanding
it, they merely imitated at small scale its stern forms. But Wright intended rather to humanize
and soften this severity, particularly on the entrance front, by the simple, if rigidly geometri-
cal grille, the carved fountain and above all by the planting which has imfortunately not been
maintained. The sculptured groups, generally disapproved by critics of the twenties, are now
gone. Set against the attic at the top of the piers of the front fagade, they had an important
part to play. The figures considered purely as sculpture were not altogether happy, since
no sculptor available as a collaborator seemed to know how to translate into another art the
architectural innovations of Wright. But the great globes contrasted effectively with the right
angles of the architecture and perhaps by their evident solidity helped to suggest that the
blank corner towers were hollow.
However, it is the interior of the Larkin Building which came first to Wright as a
builder and as a designer. The lighting and the space distribution of the great covered central
court, rising the full height of the building, and of the galleries opening into the court
between the vertical piers constitute its chief distinction (Fig. 93, 95). The central court
has really monumental scale and even grandeur, not unlike the finest interior courts of cer-
tain commercial buildings of the seventies and eighties, yet this grandeur is in no way un-
suited to the purposes of the building. There is little embellishment beyond the abstract
carving at the tops of the piers, so much more suited to this architecture than the human
figures on the exterior. But as always there were troughs along the parapets and other fittings
for growing plants and flowers.
The gallery offices are masterpieces of detail with which the later development of an
industrial vocabulary of design has hardly caught up a generation later. The banks of
built-in metal filing cases below the high windows, the specially designed metal desks and
[513
chairs, the first metal office furniture, already displayed to the full the possibilities and limi-
tations of mass-produced fittings of this sort. Today they seem to offer a sharply anachronistic
background to the typists of 1904 (Fig. 98).
The Larkin Building originally served as the administrative offices of a large mail order
house. It was never, as some have supposed, a soap factory. Wright built, however, one fac-
tory in 1905 for Darwin D. Martin, of the Larkin Company, and his brother, W. E. Martin,
of Oak Park.
The E-Z Polish Factory in Chicago was long forgotten and only rediscovered two years
ago by Grant Manson, who followed up a clue that Wright’s only factory lay somewhere along
the Galena division of the Chicago and Northwestern Railway by riding back and forth on
the line until he spotted it. It is of concrete construction with spandrels surfaced with brick
and horizontal windows very similar to those on the sides of the Larkin Building. The plain
fagade is terminated by open stair bays, their vertical flanking piers framing the composi-
tion. The more elaborate scheme for an open court between side wings at the rear, found in
drawings at Taliesin, was never executed (Fig. 99).
There is another industrial project for a single-storey varnish factory presumably in the
country, interesting in a day when most factories were many storeys tall and set in congested
areas for its suggestion of the practice of a much later period.
More appealing to most observers than the E-Z Factory, and actually very well known,
though not as a work of Wright, was the remodelling for Edward G. Waller, an even more
constant client of Wright’s than Darwin D. Martin, of the entrances and the court staircase
and balcony in Burnham and Root’s Rookery Building in 1906 (Fig. 122 ). This sumptuous
design, simple in general character, but rich in the almost oriental patterns incised and gilded
in the polished white marble, is curiously appropriate to the fine glass-covered court of the
Rookery.
Most of Wright’s other commercial work is of less importance, chiefly interesting for
the perfect adaptation of his domestic interior detail to store fittings, as in Browne’s Book-
store of 1908. But the Larkin Pavilion at the Jamestown exposition of 1907 (Fig. 133), and
the contemporary Pebbles and Balch shop front, both now gone, have a very special char-
acter (Fig. 134). They do not remind us of the houses j the design is crisper, more impersonal
and more finished. And they have neither the monumental scale of the industrial work nor
the luxury of the Rookery marble and gold. The Jamestown pavilion has properly a tem-
porary and festive air, a little like the Wolf Lake project of the mid-nineties. A whole exposi-
tion might well have been designed in some such way. Unfortunately when the great Chicago
and New York exhibitions came in the thirties, their boards of design not only rejected
[ 58 ]
Wright as architect, they also rejected as models such work as this which would have set an
admirable American standard for exposition design.
The little bank in Dwight, Illinois, of 1906, is a suave exercise in masonry, almost more
to be expected in the nineties than at this date (Fig. 115, 116). The Mason City National
Banlc is more interesting, looking forward and not back, but the hotel which is part of the
same project is even more important. Both the bank and the hotel, still building when Wright
left for Europe in 1910, have a richness and complexity of form which, even more than the
composition of the Gale house of 1909 and the ornament of the Coonley house of 1908, lead
the way to the Midway Gardens of 1914.
The bank is of solid brick below, but it opens out imder the slab roof into a clerestorey
between piers very elaborately ornamented in the spirit of the “capitals” of the Larkin
Building interior. Thus the whole bank seems to be a sort of treasure chest (Fig. 168).
The hotel on the other hand forms a U around a court above the open lobby and store
fronts below (Fig. 169). The articulation of the wing blocks and of the features of architec-
tural scale, such as the projecting eaves, shades over into the similarly abstract small-scale
ornament. The whole effect is somewhat similar to the Larkin Exposition Pavilion, but more
solid, — or rather, with more play of solid against void (Fig. 170). In an urban environment,
as in the contemporary Stohrs Building in Chicago underneath the Elevated, Wright aimed
at a more complex and superficially striking stylistic statement than in industrial or rural
settings. Today this reminds us superficially of the cheap ornamental novelties of the last
twenty years. Unfortunately the Mason City buildings have been too far remodelled and
begrimed to be properly studied in the original. In general, time and accident have some-
what simplified the actual variety of this decade of Wright’s work in retrospect. It is easier
today to appreciate in drawings the qualities of such designs as the Horseshoe Inn of 1908,
projected for Estes Park, Colorado, in which the vocabulary of the Prairie houses is extended
to a very large scale, than the significance of the more individual Mason City hotel and the
destroyed Stohrs Building.
After the great Prairie houses and the Larkin Building, Unity Church in Oak Park,
designed in 1905 and several years in building, is justly the most famous. Wright had been
interested in poured concrete for several years, but this was the first time he — or for that
matter anyone else perhaps — ^had used it for a monumental public edifice. He persuaded
his Universalist clients on the score of economy and attempted to take the curse off its dead
surfaces by exposing the fine pebble aggregate. The building was to Wright an exercise in
the “temple” form, square externally with solid stair-towers at the corners, cross-shaped
within with the arms above the corridors filled by sloping galleries, and amply lighted by
[53]
clerestoreys and skylights (Fig. 119). The exterior is solemn and formal, expressive of its
monolithic construction, the large scale of the parts established by the necessary thickness of
the projecting roof slab. Except for the vines that have sometimes covered it, the solemnity
is lightened chiefly by abstract “capitals” at the top of the clerestorey piers (Fig. 122). Such
a heavy mass, such restraint in plastic composition, could hold its own in any environment ; it
is perhaps almost too strong for suburban Oak Park (Fig. 1 18).
The interior is more complex, with a remarkable sort of space composition (Fig. 120).
The auditorium floor is higher than the surrounding corridors into which the space flows
beneath the galleries. Four piers define the central square out of which project the short
arms toward the clerestoreys. All minor elements, such as the balcony parapets and the grid
of the ceiling skylight, repeat an interlocking frame of lines in space. But the lines are not
mere lines, they are structural as well and contrast as thick solid members with the voids of
the plaid of space between, while the ceiling extends into outside space and is seen through
the clerestorey windows as the underside of the cantilevered roof slab. The electric fixtures
were heated frankly as part of the architecture and even their wires became a part of the
design. This was in its way as revolutionary as the specially designed office fittings in the
Larkin Building. Without a congregation the effect may be somewhat severe. And as in all
non-ritualistic churches the pulpit end of the auditorium seems to lack focus. Doubtless also
the balance and finish of the original colour scheme has been lost with repainting.
The church is entered through colonnades something like “cloisters” which connect the
church with the Parish House. These colonnades lighten the composition, recalling the
clerestoreys of the main block and of the similar but smaller Parish House block. Thus toward
the side street, where the main entrance is, there is considerable breadth and variety, the
asymmetrical balance recalling that of the Hillside Home School.
While Wright’s early houses, the Larkin Building and Unity Church, are known wher-
ever architecture is studied, his large-scale projects, which would come under the heading
of housing or city planning, have been somewhat forgotten. The massive solidity of Unity
Church, unavoidable in a first essay in poured concrete, Wright never repeated in later work
in this medium. But foreign admirers, as in the case of the Larkin Building, were only too
prone to imitate at small scale effects they had never really apprehended in studying the
original solely through photographs and drawings. On the other hand the more “socio-
logical” projects of these years ought to have been perfectly comprehensible on paper. Per-
haps they may have been more influential abroad than has yet been recognized. For the
McArthur apartments in poured concrete were published in the 1910 German portfolio
(Fig, 1 31) as well as the Lexington Terrace project, which Wright had worked on intermit-
[54]
tently since 1901, and the Larkin workmen’s rowhouse project, which is such a striking
premonition of Dutch and German reihenhauser of the twenties and early thirties. The
arrangement of the Lexington Terrace flats about an open court with balconies at the second-
storey level is not quite as much like Oud’s first worlcmen’s housing as the executed Francisco
Terrace of the nineties, but the scheme was much more elaborate and on a much larger
scale (Fig. 172). The Larkin housing project has wonderfully compact minimal plans with
continuous bands of windows above and below. The line of the street is maintained by the
roof slab, while the individual houses are marked by the inset doorways between the wide
living room bays (Fig. 108, 109). The design might well be a model for government housing
today, and is, indeed, being approached in some of the latest Defense Housing projects.
The Roberts project for a large-scale middle-class housing development in Oak Park
was confused in the Wasmuth portfolio with the earlier scheme for the Ladies’ Home Journal
of 1900, to which it is very similar. The scheme for Como Orchards, near Darby, Montana,
was also in the Wasmuth portfolio, even though it was only partially executed and then with-
out supervision (Fig. 167). Both of these plans, one for a suburban subdivision, the other for
a mountain resort, have great interest. But even more interesting were two projects for a
town of Bitter Root on much the same site, prepared earlier for the Bitter Root Irrigation
Company, though neither of them were published. Of one of these only the plan is to be
found at Taliesin, of the other only a bird’s-eye perspective. For a study of Wright as a city-
planner, they would be documents of major importance, but for this study of Wright’s archi-
tecture the drawings are at too small a scale to be very revealing.
To many Europeans the corpus of Wright’s great work seems to have closed in 1910.
Our later sections will make evident what should always have been clear, that Wright’s great
work no more closed in 1910 than in 1900.
[ 55 ]
PART FOUR
1911-1920
VII. From the Middle West to Japan and California
T he ample German publications of Wright’s early work, the luxurious portfolios of plans
and drawings of igio and the smaller book illustrated with photographs of 1911, have
made the Prairie houses of the first decade of the century and certain non-domestic work of
the same years, such as the Larkin Building of 1904 and the Unity Church of 1906, the best-
known examples of his architecture. I have discussed elsewhere’- how the great international
influence of Wright is largely derived from these books and how formative that influence
was during the next decade upon the development of modern architecture in Europe.
The work of the Prairie years seems in retrospect, despite its very great variety, to form
a homogeneous unit. Within that homogeneity there is, between 1902 and 1908 at least,,
little apparent chronological development. When Wright left for Europe in the spring of
1910 it was hardly evident that upon his return the day of the Prairie houses would be over
and that strikingly new developments would henceforth succeed one another at relatively
brief intervals. Wright’s brief trip to Japan in 1905 had not broken the homogeneity of the
work of the decade before 1910; and if he was little or not at aU influenced by travel in a
country whose art had long been particularly sympathetic to him, it was not to be expected
that even a longer stay in Europe, chiefly in Renaissance Florence, would affect him directly.
Nor did it do so.
The reasons for the change of phase in 191 1 are personal and interior rather than the
result of contact with the European architecture of the past. If the European trip had any
effect, it was rather to increase his own assurance, to stimulate his imaginative boldness and
to encourage a richness of expression already implicit in his work, but possibly somewhat
inhibited by the life of suburban Oak Park and by a series of commissions chiefly for suburban
houses. Wright was to a considerable extent a regional Middle Western architect before
1910, After 1910, with the wide acceptance of his early work by the European world as the
basis of a new architecture, he was conscious of his fame and responsive to a more universal
destiny.
The work of the decade 191 1-1920 was not homogeneous. Or at least, smce it has never
been so thoroughly published and studied, it has never seemed so. It is no part of our purpose
to refer in detail to the story of Wright’s life, so brilliantly told in his own Autobiography, but
1 “-Wright’s Influence Abroad,” in Parnassus^ December, 1940, pp. i i-i 5.
[59]
it should not only be recalled that this decade began with a sharp break with the familiar
surroundings in which Wright had worked for a score of years and with all the social impli-
cations in the Chicago world of such a break, but that the decade was broken once more in
the middle by a personal loss whose external and internal effects we need consider only as
they reacted upon Wright’s architectural career. The tremendous tragedy at Taliesin in
1914 brought to an end far more completely than the events of five years before Wright’s
happy relation to the Middle Western environment. And within a very short time the call to
Toldo and Wright’s many years of work there completed his detachment from the milieu of
suburban Chicago with which his earlier career was so closely involved.
Despite his tremendous activity in 1908 and 1909 it may well have been that the enthusi-
astic response of Chicagoans to Wright’s new architecture had passed its peak by 1910. Mrs.
Harold McCormick’s employment of Charles A. Platt from the East in 1908 to build a
traditional house in Lake Forest instead of the palatial project of Wright was probably the
symbol of a more general loss of artistic self-assurance in the Middle West. In any case the
snobbish imitation of Eastern models seems thenceforth to have increased. Even the mem-
bers of the Chicago School, who had once been so closely associated with Wright, gradually
went over to the tasteful and eclectic traditionalism of the Eastern leaders. It is hard to
balance the importance of the particular events of Wright’s personal life and their repercus-
sions on his professional career against what seems to have been an almost inevitable general
development. Chicago, so capable of accepting and acclaiming architectural innovations
since the eighties, so stimulating to Richardson at the end of his career, so capable at the
World’s Fair of providing the first and happiest illustration of the grandiose dreams of the
classicists when those dreams were bold and new, seemed to be growing old and timid.
But if in the second decade of the century Chicago was becoming too smugly con-
ventional to appreciate Wright, the outside world from Berlin to Tokio, and more signifi-
cantly from Wichita to Los Angeles, now claimed his services. But for the War and his en-
grossment with the Imperial Hotel, doubtless the extension of his American clientele to
regions far from Chicago — there is, for example, one Palm Beach house — ^would have been
even greater.
The work of 19 1 1-1920 cannot conveniently be divided, like that of the previous decade,
into a quantity of houses falling into recognizable categories and a limited group of edifices
of non-domestic character. The chief works of the period, both before and after the break,
are public monuments and not houses; and the most important house was his own Taliesin,
built in 19 1 1 and rebuilt after 1914, wholly different in scale and character from the earlier
suburban houses. Before 1915 the two chief works, about which the rest may be grouped, are
[ 60 ]
Taliesin and the Midway Gardens of 1913. In the second half of the decade the Imperial
Hotel and the Barnsdall house in California are the landmarks. To a considerable extent
each of these four chief commissions is independent of the others in materials, construction,
setting and expression; and each is of rather more individual consequence and extent than
most of the individual commissions of the earlier period.
Wright was far from being without Chicago commissions of the suburban domestic type
on his return from Europe in 191 1. The most interesting can best be discussed in relation to
his own Wisconsin house. Others are chiefly adaptations of the established Prairie house
types. His first important new commission, however, was for the Coonleys, for whom he was
also making slight alterations and additions to the house and its adjuncts which had been
completed just before he went abroad.
The Goonley kindergarten project of 19 ii, although it was to stand on the grounds of
the Riverside estate, was a wholly independent structure of marked originality of design.
The design was completely symmetrical, complex in the relation of its parts and most remark-
able for the abstract elaboration of its three-dimensional composition. The slab roof, like
that of the Boat Club project of 1902, is the most striking element in the design, emphasizing
the varying heights of different parts of the structure, projecting to form pierced pergolas,
controlling and harmonizing the complexity of the composition in an extraordinarily original
and creative way. Although the roof slab and most of the walls below the high windows are
solid and visibly of a considerable thickness, this solidity is not like that of traditional masonry.
For the whole design is articulated in terms of plane elements in a fashion already essayed
in the Gale house of 1909 (Fig. 183).
The executed Goonley playhouse of 1912 is somewhat smaller and simpler than the
kindergarten project, but it incorporates most of its innovations (Fig. 185, 186). Comparison
with the Isabel Roberts house of four years earlier, which has a somewhat similar parti, will
make evident the marked change of expression. The plan is a formal cross with emphasis on
the horizontal arm which is prolonged by the slab roof. However the projecting central wing
has a strong balance of horizontal and vertical elements. The tall windows above the flower-
box stylobate are filled with gay and festive abstract balloon designs in coloured glass — ^non-
objective pictures designed before non-objective painting had fairly begun in Europe. The
far-projecting pergola slab above lets the light through in long vertical or oblique stripes.
In the interior more than the exterior we notice a certain heaviness of membering,
which, in general, differentiates the houses of these years from the more delicately domestic
work before 1910 (Fig. 184). This is related to the general tendency toward a sort of abstract
sculpture at architectural scale, which, as in the Gale house, is differentiated from the later
[61]
European exercises of the Neo-Plasticists by the real sense of thickness in the parts and the
clear expression of different sorts of material.
A related project of completely different scale and purpose is that for a concrete sky-
scraper for the Spreckels Estate in San Francisco. The slab construction dictate a more solid
expression than the metal skeleton of typical skyscraper construction. The articulated vertical
piers set close together bear a general resemblance to those of Sullivan’s Wainwright or
Guaranty Buildings of twenty years before. But the great slotted projecting slab roof is quite
like that of the Goonley playhouse, and in that version of the project which linked a tall
tower to the existing Tower Building with a lower wing, the cross-ties of horizontal slab
elements are a remarkable exercise in wholly Wrightian abstract plasticity (Fig. i88). More
striking, however, is the other version of which the model was made. In this isolated struc-
ture, the great height was expressed by the continuous verticals on all sides of the shaft, and
yet the continuity of the shaft was broken some distance from bottom and top by a plaiding
of horizontal elements (Fig. 187).
Less than in the case of the epochmaking Luxfer Prism skyscraper project of the nineties
and the cantilevered skyscrapers of the twenties need we regret that this project did not
come to execution. For a more logical amplification of the new design vocabulary of the
Goonley playhouse, justly considered by Wright one of his most perfect works, was the
executed Midway Gardens on the South Side in Ghicago. The Midway Gardens unfortu-
nately were only destined for a decade of precarious life. They were too European in con-
ception for a country soon to accept Prohibition. But their glories can be re-created from
plans and photographs, and even something of the colour of the remarkable abstract murals
can be appreciated in the original studies.
The Midway Gardens were designed in the fall of 1913 for Edward G. Waller, Jr., and
Oscar Friedman. This Waller was the son of E. G. Waller, who had been from the nineties
a recurrent client of Wright’s. The construction was nearly complete the following summer
when Wright was called away by the tragedy at Taliesin. The Gardens thus represent the
culmination of Wright’s achievement between his return from Europe and the break in the
middle of the decade. They are also his last great Ghicago work.
The site lay along the old Midway of the World’s Fair at the corner of Gottage Grove
Avenue and 60th Street. This was not perhaps, as Ghicago was developing, an altogether
happy choice for the sort of luxurious outdoor resort that was intended, but the ground was
open and extensive, without overshadowing neighbours. The greater part of the site was left
clear for outdoor tables, with a tall enclosed structure at the front, terraces down the sides
and an orchestra shell at the rear (Fig. 19 1). It was the sort of open restaurant, casino, or
[62]
Kurhaus to be found in most continental countries. Possibly Chicago required some education
in sophistication to appreciate its possibilities. At any rate it did not attract the clientele for
which its cuisine and the musical and other entertainment fare — Pavlowa danced here —
was originally intended. So it declined to a suburban beer garden and eventually was closed
by Prohibition and demolished in the early twenties.
Here Wright, perhaps stimulated by what he had seen of such resorts in Europe, aimed
at public instead of private luxury, but not at the stodgy splendours of contemporary urban
hotels and restaurants. Instead he sought a festive gaiety, like that with which the Wolf Lake
resort project of the nineties had been filled (Fig. 37), a fresh open fantasia in which sculpture
and painting, not as independent entities but closely related to the essential architectural
conception, should play an important part (Fig. 195).
The elevation of the enclosed structure toward the street was not unlike an amplifica-
tion of the composition of the Coonley kindergarten project (Fig. 194). The main mass was
rather solid but lightened by the open-w'ork towers above and by the textured concrete blocks
above the lower walls of brick. For all its solidity this fagade was definitely inviting and
richer than anything Wright had designed since the nineties. It was also extraordinarily
versatile in the way large architectural elements such as the articulated piers and slabs that
broke up and capped the walls below, or the interesting open-work frames of the tower
tops were combined into elaborate abstract patterns. Similarly such details of plastic orna-
mentation as the textured wall surface and the free-standing statues were crystallized into
forms of geometrical and architectural character. Perhaps lannelli, the collaborating
sculptor, had not the talent necessary to execute satisfactorily Wright’s projects for Cubist
figure sculpture. But the remarkable thing is that these Cubist figures, like the finer non-
objective murals inside, are not derivative from European work, but rather almost exactly
contemporary parallels to the work of the most advanced French and German painters
and sculptors. And this parallel invention was made, not by the New York artists who
in 1913 organized the Armory Show in which such European work was first shown in
America — ^none of them were yet so advanced — but by an architect who was merely
developing abstract painting and semi-abstract sculpture as an essential component of
a new architecture.
Toward the gardens the architecture is less enclosed, even the tall restaurant structure
is opened up by terraces and projections on this side (Fig. 196). The side wings provide
covered terraces and covered galleries to protect diners from the elements and the whole
establishment from its none too appropriate surroundings (Fig. 193). The varying levels
of the garden build up toward the side wings and the enclosed edifice at the rear, the terrace
[ 63 ]
edges are marked by parapets and flower-filled boxes and urns. Thus Wright made the most
of a site without natural advantages to form a sort of amphitheatre facing the orchestra
platform and shell (Fig. 192).
It has been said of French architecture that it is either in the style funebre or the style
casino. The temple form of the Unity Church and the grey pebbled surface of its poured
concrete, the solid brick masses of the Larkin Building gave to Wright’s earlier non-domestic
work a somewhat severe solemnity. The Midway Gardens represents Wright’s style casino
at its apotheosis. It provided an American model which should have been borne in mind
in designing the expositions of the thirties. For they were dismal examples of the general
American incapacity to achieve a festive spirit in anything but folk building.
Wright’s other great work of the first half of the decade was his own house on the
family land outside Spring Green, Wisconsin. Taliesin, which has made of Spring Green
even more a center of architectural pilgrimage than Oak Park in the last thirty years, was
begun for his mother upon his return from Europe. But before it was completed he had
decided to live there himself and, despite two fires and long absences in Japan and in
California and winters spent at Taliesin West in the last few years, it has been Wright’s
headquarters ever since. But there is not a Taliesin period as there is an Oak Park one.
Oak Park is a suburb of Chicago and the environment was at least symbolic of the location
and the character of most of his work while he lived and worked there. But Taliesin is to
be found rather upon the map of the United States or the map of the world than on the
map of Wisconsin.
Taliesin quite literally grows from Wright’s native hillsides both in the choice of most of
its materials and in its close adaptation to the site. But it reaches out as well to the whole
world and it would be as incomplete without the great works of Oriental art incorporated
in its walls as without the great music of the European past which continually sounds from
its innumerable musical instruments (Fig. 177). The houses before 1910, even his own Oak
Park house (which originally had an upstairs studio and later an attached but separately
designed studio building), were houses and no more. But this was a house, a studio, a farm
and even eventually a school, a complex linkage of the elements which alone could form
the true home of Frank Lloyd Wright. This is not the place to describe the philosophy and
the atmosphere of Taliesin. It will be difficult enough to describe its architecture, since the
story is complicated by major reconstructions after the fires of 1914 and 1925, and by con-
tinual alterations and additions. But it was built once for the first time (Fig. 175): that first
form, or at least that first form as rebuilt and somewhat extended immediately after the
[ 64 ]
1914 can be re-created from plans and photographs and somewhat distinguished from
the ultimate complexity of the Taliesin of today (Fig. 269-275).
Taliesin is not on a hilltop, it is rather wrapped around a hilltop, which rises behind
and above the house. It makes no attempt to dominate the natural setting nor is it merged
with it. The materials, particularly the local stone laid in loosely projecting layers like
natural cliffs, are from the soil, but the house, except for the various solidly anchored chim-
neys and piers of the stonework, soars and hovers (Fig. 178). There are long bands of plaster,
more roughly surfaced than on earlier houses, framed above and below by sturdy moulded
wooded strings. Above this are the bands of windows whose wooden mullions as always
indicate the stud-structure of the wall (Fig. 174). Over all are the roofs, the most conspicuous
feature of Taliesin. But the roofs no longer form a simple geometrical cross shape, indeed
their very forms are varied, with gable elements and penthouses introduced among the
predominant hips. The roof complex seems like some piece of landscape, slightly abstracted
to flat slanting planes, but flowing together as freely as the space of the rooms below.
Hardly distinguishable from the architecture is the treatment of the area which the
house and studio and farm wing surround (Fig. 176). The long court is formalized by walls
and steps and pools of right angle elements which are tied in under the loggias of the house.
The great oak tree higher up the slope is literally nourished by the little fountain in the
center of a circular paved area. This forms an outdoor tea room with a curving stone bench.
The lawn on the crest of the hill is naturally of almost exactly the same slope as the shingled
roofs around and below. Yet it is sharply defined toward the lower court by retaining walls
and steps and on the open side by the long stone wall which forms a sort of frame for the
view toward Hillside. The out-cropping of rock in the slope of the lawn is cut into shallow
polygonal steps. Thus if the house participates in the informality of the landscape setting,
the setting as it enters between the wings of the house is formalized by architectural elements.
Flowers and small-scale plants in such a lay-out are but a minor embellishment, hardly more
important, considering the scale of the out-of-doors, than the flowers and green branches
which generally fill the vases in the rooms.
Much of this description of the setting is of today rather than of twenty-five or thirty
years ago. For Taliesin is not and never has been static and it is no more possible to describe
it fully at a particular stage of its growth than any other living organism. With time parts
of it have attophied. For instance, the original farm wing is today used, if at all, for other
purposes, now that a new farm group has been built beyond the next hill. Other parts have
changed their purpose slightly. The studio, for a time ffled with the apprentices and their
drafting tables, has now become again Wright’s private atelier, with the work of the appren-
[65]
tices removed to the new Hillside drafting room. But always Taliesin has been something
more than a house and more like a medieval manor, with provision, partly below the main
living rooms, partly beyond the studio, and now in the former farm wing, for the apprentices
and various community facilities.
No other of Wright’s houses, even of the period when Taliesin was building, is quite
like it, since no other was intended to serve such complex functions. But the best houses of
the decade belong recognizably to the same architectural family. They are sturdier and less
delicate in design than the Prairie houses and if of wood and plaster usually looser in plan
and composition. Moreover, most of them, like Taliesin, have sloping or hill-crest sites,
and if not actually in the woods, have the protection of much wild planting. Most of those
that were built are small, although the fine project for the Cutten house in Downer’s Grove,
Illinois, was larger than the original Tahesin. But the fine Angster house, at Lake Bluffs,
Illinois, of 19 1 1 (Fig. 179, 180), the later Hunt house in Oshkosh, Wisconsin, and the group
of houses at Grand Beach (Fig. 209, 210, 21 1, 212, 213), Michigan, all of the second half
of the decade, if they lack the Taliesin stonework, of which the Cutten house was to have
made much use, have nevertheless a commonsense simplicity, a graceful rusticity comparable
to that of the best horizontal-battened wooden houses of the previous decade in similar
locations.
The few houses of this period which were built in Oak Park and other such suburban
locations are more formal and usually have ornamentation in the spirit of Midway Gardens.
The early Harry Adams project of 19 ii, with its elaborate symmetry, rich frieze and other
elements of plastic abstract decoration, formed, like the Coonley kindergarten project, a
halfway step between the Coonley house or the Mason City hotel and the Midway Gardens.
The executed Adams house of 1913 in Oak Park, on the other hand, is a somewhat barren
and heavy version of such early brick houses as those of the Littles and the Heaths.
The later Little house in Minnesota beside Lake Minnetonka was designed in 1912 and
begun in 1913, but not completed until Wright’s return from Japan. Although of masonry,
it is both simple and delicate. The long plan, chiefly one-room thick, extends along the hill-
crest by the lake side, with subordinate masses loosely disposed at either end of the living
room, whose range of arched windows seems at first sight almost an anachronism in Wright’s
work at this date (Fig. 199, 200a).
In sharpest contrast to the Little house, with its long horizontal extension, its simplicity
and the unusually severe and almost traditional use of brick masonry, is the other large
house project designed before 1915, that for the Booths in Glencoe. The actual house as
finally completed without supervision in 1916 is barely related to the earlier project of
[ 66 ]
1911-13. But the Booth site at Racine Bluffs was not a typical prairie suburb site and the
original project was wonderfully complex, like a whirling cross, with wings and bridges
shooting out over the ravines and a tall central mass with a very open two-storey living room
and even a tower (Fig. 182). Not only was the composition very varied in mass and in the
interlocking of such structural elements as piers and roof slabs, like an elaboration of the
Gale house of 1909, it was also, like the early Adams house project, richly ornamented with
plastically patterned surfaces boldly contrasted with plainer elements (Fig. 181).
We must regret deeply that this splendid house project was never executed as designed.
But it is perhaps less significant than the American System Ready-Cut scheme of the same
years, which likewise came to no real fruition because of the break between Wright and
the sponsors of the project, Richards Brothers of Milwaukee, after 1916 and our entry into
the War.
The American System envisaged both small and medium-sized houses, as well as duplex
apartments, which were to be built of wood and plaster out of prepared units. It was, in other
words, a system of prefabrication, or at least partial prefabrication, and so various were
the possible combinations of units for which Wright prepared drawings that a very elastic
repertory of architectural types was to be available (Fig. 205, 206, 207, 208). The examples
that were built in Milwaukee and elsewhere, were unsupervised and do not give a full idea
of the possibilities. Once more we note that Wright, far from thinking only in terms of
mansions for millionaires, was ahead of most of his contemporaries in facing the problem
of mass shelter.
Wright was, in 1914 and 1915, far from being without work. But the tragedy at Taliesin
and its aftermath must have made the visit of the Japanese committee seeking an architect
for the Imperial Hotel in Tokio seem almost Hke a miracle. After the completion of the
Midway Gardens, actual building seems to have dragged except for the reconstruction of
Taliesin. The lapsed projects, the unsupervised works, the prolonged building campaigns,
and the generally reduced production of the middle years of the decade are perhaps not
entirely due either to Wright’s departure to Japan or to the coming of the War. Wright’s
architectural genius flowed fully in country houses, even at the small scale of the Grand
Beach cottages. His artistic genius rose to the opportunities of such a commission as the
Midway Gardens. His technical genius expended untold pains on the details of such a
tremendous low-cost housing scheme as the Ready-Cut houses and apartments. But neither
his genius nor his personality fitted any longer into the middle-class frame, perhaps in any
case growing more hidebound, of the suburban Middle West. Frank Lloyd Wright, no
longer of Oak Park, but of resurgent Taliesin, was ready to serve the world. In the next
[67]
years the only work which could really hold his interest, beside what the Japanese offered
him, were the elaborate project for Olive Hill in Los Angeles for Aline Barnsdall and one
fine Kansas house for Henry J. Allen in Wichita.
The first project for the Imperial Hotel, prepared at Taliesin before he left for Japan,
was much modified before construction really started a year or two later. The long story
of the Japanese episode, which had no very important architectural results other than the
Hotel, is told by Wright in the Autobiography and need not be repeated here. But when
the Hotel was finally completed it must have seemed to Wright worth all the trials, extend-
ing over six or seven years, which it had cost him.
From the first Wright had envisaged a type of construction which should provide real
protection against the earthquakes to which Tokio was subject and also against the fires
which were their inevitable aftermath. The great pools in the court of the Hotel were not
primarily for ornament, but to provide an adequate water supply in case of fire (Fig. 223).
In 1923 when the earthquake came so soon after the completion of the building, as if to try
out its vaunted strength, the Hotel survived, an island of safety in a sea of flames, as much
because of its water supply as because of its construction.
Wright has likened the special construction used in the Hotel to the balance of a tray
on a waiter’s fingers. The paired central concrete supports and the cantilevered floors con-
stitute the essential technical device in a building which is from foundation to roof all of
new materials and new devices compounded (Fig. 225, 226, 227). Wright brought out to
Tokio Paul Mueller, the engineer from the old Adler and Sullivan office force of the early
nineties, to assist him. The many ingenious things they worked out together deserve a
detailed engineering analysis for which this is not the place.^
The vast H-shaped structure, of which the main plan scheme was determined in the
first project of 1915, rests on innumerable concrete piers driven into the shallow crust above
the soft lower soil (Fig. 219). The weight of the structure is borne by the central piers and the
cantilevered floors. The outer walls are self-supporting shells of specially made brick filled
with concrete. The walls lean in against the cantilevered floor slabs and interlocked with
their edges (Fig. 220, 222).
The side wings provide the private accommodations on either side of the corridors
between the paired central supports. Every feature, from the special arrangement of the
plumbing to protect it against earthquake strains, to the built-in cupboards and the new
heating units, was the result of detailed technical and artistic study (Fig. 229, 230).
2 Contemporary accounts both before and after the earthquake will be found in the Architectural Record, vol. 53,
pp. 338-352 and vol. 55, pp. 1 18-123. The former is by Louis Sullivan.
[ 68 ]
The central block between the long side wings contains the public rooms. Lobby, dining
room, ball room and many other facilities are on the most lavish scale (Fig. 23 1, 232). Around
this block are the large garden courts with their great pools, terraced and architecturally
elaborated by parapets and richly sculptured decoration among the carefully selected and
placed Japanese plants (Fig. 223). It is in the courts that Wright’s luxurious ornamentation,
now with the able Japanese craftsmen to execute it profuse and elaborate beyond his dreams
in the Midway Gardens, is seen at its best. The curious spotted greenish lava that cuts like
cheese was turned into fantastic shapes of almost geological abstraction among the Japanese
evergreens (Fig. 228). The reflections in the pools, the contrast of the lava colour with the
dark green foliage and the brick walls behind composed a picture sufiiciently Japanese in
character, yet wholly original and personal.
Similar carved lava elaborates and enriches the masses of the building itself. To some
the sohdity of the mass, emphasized by the battered walls and by the rather heavily plastic
ornament, has seemed inexpressive of the cantilevered skeleton within. And yet the massive-
ness of the building is real enough and has a sound reason. Indeed, it was the outside win-
dows which were the chief point of danger during the fire after the earthquake. The lighter,
gayer quality of expression of the early project, quite similar to that of the Midway Gardens,
had proved inappropriate as an expression of the final structure (Fig. 222).
The necessary solidity of the structure, heavier still around the large voids of the public
rooms in the central block, and the desire to lighten, or at least enrich, the structural elements
with carved and painted decoration explains the turgidity which seems apparent in photo-
graphs of the monumental interior. Doubtless in actuality — I have never seen it — the par-
ticrdar scale, which is often hard to read in Wright’s work from photographs alone, the
elegance of the execution and above all the colour, would give a quite different impression,
more like the quiet grace of the bedrooms and the rich warmth of Wright’s own apartment
in the annex he built for temporary use while the Imperial Hotel was in construction.
A quite different spirit is evident in the project for a country hotel at Nagoya. Here a
really Japanese lightness informs every line of the structure. As always with Wright, despite
his genius for using natural elements within an architectural frame as in the courts of the
Imperial, he is even happier where he can associate his architecture appropriately with
a setting of natural beauty (Fig. 233).
The Fukuhara house at Hakone also had a superb site — ^indeed, part of it slipped off
with the edge of the cliff in the earthquake — ^and both this and the Hayashi house in a suburb
of Tokio belong in construction and expression to the Taliesin group of wood and plaster
houses. The projects for the houses for Count Immu and Viscount Inouye, like the Fukuhara
[69]
house, followed Japanese planning in having their chief rooms grouped around a garden
court. They were, however, to be of brick with something of the monumentality and the
rich carved stone decoration of the Imperial. The Bogk house in Milwaukee of 1916, though
a square block in plan, is somewhat similar in expression.
Other American buildings of the Japanese years beside the Bogk house, the German
Warehouse in Richland Center, designed before Wright’s departure and never entirely com-
pleted, and the Allen house in Wichita, begun in 1917, have much in common with the
Japanese work. The concrete structure of the Warehouse is masked with sturdy walls of
brick and capped with a very heavy and rich ornamental band of concrete blocks superbly
contrasted with the blank walls below. This marked the change of function to cold storage
on the upper storey. The plastic geometrical patterns of the blocks, so much more severe
than the forms the Japanese craftsmen were executing in lava, offer an early hint of the
pattern- textured surfaces of the California block houses of the twenties (Fig. 203, 204).
The Allen house is somewhat Japanese in disposition, with a low living room wing
and a longer two-storeyed wing enclosing a garden court with terraces and a pool (Fig. 216).
But the masonry is handled almost as simply as that of the Little house. The placing of the
wings of the house near the lot line and the enclosure of the garden court from the neighbors
is quite different from the lay-out of the Prairie houses and possibly superior now that
suburban streets were full of automobiles (Fig. 2 1 7, 2 1 8).
So much too much has been made of Japanese influence upon Wright’s work that it
is interesting to note that his actual work in the Orient has actually less of a Japanese air
than much of his early work. While the specific influence of Japanese architecture in Ameri-
can work in these years, except of course in the continued use of wood stripping on plaster
walls now restricted to interiors, is in the Allen plan.
In the Japanese years Wright’s chief American commissions were for Aline Barnsdall
in Los Angeles and included her own house, two other houses, all three of which were built,
and projects for a theater and a terrace of shops and small houses. Preparatory work on these
went on intermittently during the years the Imperial Hotel was in construction. Although
no actual construction began until 1920, the three BarnsdaU houses were in the end com-
pleted before the Hotel.
The Barnsdall Theater was an important project related to the Tokio moving picture
theater project and exists in several different versions (Fig. 214, 215). It was to have been
a tremendous structure of poured concrete, quite unconventional in plan and adapted to
the special productions Aline Barnsdall was planning with Ordynsky and Norman Bel
Geddes. Most of the versions provide for a great solid cubic block decorated with bands
[70]
of cast ornament, like the main fagade of the Barnsdall Residence A (Fig, 242), and with a
smaller octagonal mass above covered with abstract patterns somewhat like those on the
German Warehouse. Unfortunately the designs for the terrace of shops with houses above
beside the theater, running along Sunset Boulevard, were never so far developed. They might
well have been one of Wright’s most effective large-scale suburban housing schemes.
“Hollyhock House,” Miss BarnsdalFs own residence at the top of Olive Hill, was finally
built in 1920-21, but never entirely completed in accordance with Wright’s hopes. On
account of vicissitudes of ownership, it has not been very well maintained. It is one of the
rare instances of Wright’s domestic use of exposed poured concrete, immediately given up
for the textile block system of construction in the later California houses. But perhaps it
should not be considered domestic in the ordinary sense. Because of the site and the tremen-
dous size — it is one of Wright’s most expensive houses, perhaps his most expensive — the
composition is rather monumental. Near the top of the hill the main block of the house
extends around a central courtyard (Fig. 236). Despite the large windows in the projecting
living room bay, the effect except in the court (Fig. 237) is chiefly of solid wall, excluding the
excessive heat and light of the region. Perhaps this is because of the curious canted line of
the upper part of the wall above the windows, like a sort of mansard. Against this heavy
roof-like slope stand little, lacy finials, abstract hollyhocks, catching and breaking up the
brilliant light and now partially covered by the over-luxuriant local growth (Fig. 235).
To the left the fine of the house is broadly extended by subordinate wings, more open
than the main block, and by pergolas, garden walls and terraces which tie the tremendous
spread and bulk of the house firmly to the ground (Fig. 240). From a distance beyond the
rising slope of the lawn and against the distant mountains, the monumentality of the house
is reduced to domestic scale (Fig. 238).
Thinking for a moment of modem architecture abroad in these years, on account of
the War still chiefly projects on paper, we can see in Hollyhock House a special significance.
The Imperial Hotel, in its luxuriant ornamentation, was akin to the rather similar luxuriance
of one branch of European architecture in these years, particularly that of the Dutch school
of Amsterdam, whose members on account of Berlage’s enthusiasm studied Wright’s new
work closely. But in the Barnsdall house the use of poured concrete, the bold contrast of plain
surfaces and large glass areas, the experimentation with long spans and open frames, was
more parallel to the line younger men like Oud and Le Corbusier and Gropius were taking.
In the first case there was almost certainly a direct influence. In the second it seems rather
doubtful. Since in the next decade the work of Wright, to which as Oud recognized in
Wendingen the new men owed so much, and the work of the younger Europeans, who were
[71]
around 1920 beginning to crystallize their “international style,” was to seem to both sides
sharply opposed, it is worth while to point out the parallelism. This parallelism will be even
more apparent in Wright’s later California work and attention has already been called to
the Yahara Boat Club project of 1902 and the Gale house of 1909, among other prototypes.
But critics inspired by “international” principles in the twenties literally could not see
the architecture for the hollyhocks. In retrospect, whether or not we like the particular
ornament on Hollyhock House for itself, it is not difficult to see that it was only a minor, if
certainly not negligible, element in this important early concrete house. The small house
project of 1919 for “Monolith Homes” of concrete, another of Wright’s “sociological”
projects which never came to execution, we may well feel provides still another astonishing
parallel, in this case with Le Corbusier’s Citrohan project of the same year. But the more
developed version of this, prepared for Dr. Chandler in 1927, is better worth studying today.
Happily, after twenty years, the unity of modern architecture and the pre-eminence of
Wright are once again generally recognized. But it helps to explain Wright’s isolation in the
ensuing years that from the end of this decade until the opening of the thirties Wright’s
work was castigated almost as freely (and he feels, more jealously) from the left as from the
right, if the meaningless political terms may be thus used.
At a time when he had to suffer every sort of indignity in his private life, Wright, the
long-term leader of modern architecture, the forerunner whose vital contributions every-
one admitted, was cast critically and professionally into a minority. Yet if he was attacked
now as well as lauded from abroad, it was still the Europeans who continued to study his
every current v/ork and make it widely known by frequent publication. He might at fifty,
with ludicrous prematurity as it proved, be dismissed as “old,” but it could never be for-
gotten that he had been a “master” to all the younger generation. Actually he was never
more so than at the opening of the twenties.
PART FIVE
1921-1930
VIII. Textile Block Houses and Projects and Cantilevered Skyscraper Projects
T he Imperial Hotel was finally completed in 1922 and Wright then returned from
Japan for good. By this time “Hollyhock House” and the two studio houses for Aline
Barnsdall in Los Angeles were also finished and it was evident that the other Barnsdall
projects would come to nothing. But in the early twenties while Wright was still travelling
back and forth between Tokio and Los Angeles new applications of ferro-concrete construc-
tion were taking form in his mind. The more dramatic of these for skyscrapers built on the
cantilever principle that had been worked out for the Imperial Hotel was in a sense not
wholly new nor destined to come to actual execution. Discussion of the cantilevered sky-
scraper projects, whose hung screen surfaces of copper and glass were perhaps as remarkable
as their structure, can well follow that of the other new type of construction, the “textile”
cement block process, which was used in most of the buildings actually executed between
1921 and 1930.
The first crystallization of the textile block process was in a house project presumably
designed in 1921 for execution in Los Angeles just before Wright's last trip to Japan. The
idea was to combine metal reinforcement with precast blocks, running a textile-like warp
and woof of metal rods in hollowed joints between the blocks and then filling the hollows
with protecting cement. The resulting wall was not of the order of masonry wall, like most
cement block construction, nor yet like a continuous slab. It was rather a sort of mosaic
shell strengthened by the reinforcements in the joints. Moreover the same shells could be
used for inside and outside wall surfaces, with insulating space between.
This block construction was intended to be used in the large projects of 1921 and 1922
which never came to execution, the Doheny ranch development (Fig. 243), the Johnson desert
compound, and for the substructure of the Tahoe summer colony cabins (Fig. 245, 246,
247, 248). But its quality can be far better appreciated in the series of houses which were
designed in 1922 and built in 1923 and 1924 in Pasadena and Hollywood.
The finest of these and the first to be designed, according to Wright, was that for Mrs.
George Madison Millard in Pasadena, whose house in Highland Park he had built fifteen
years before. “La Miniatura,” as the house is called, compares in quality with the finest of
Wright's Prairie houses. And if it seems to differ from them entirely, those differences derive
from the most fundamental of Wright’s principles. It is, indeed, these recurrent differences,
[753
the apparently inexhaustible variety of his individual solutions, which make Wright’s archi-
tecture universal. The Chicago architect of the nineties, the Middle Western architect ol
igoo-igio, had in the previous decade received world-wide acclaim. The Imperial Hotel
is seriously described in guide books as “Old Japanese” in style! Now in “La Miniatura”
Wright seemed at. first to be establishing a regional Californian style. Actually, however,
although the insulated solidity of the house and the textured surfaces are specifically suited
to the California climate with its heat and brilliant sunlight, the house is even more the
expression of the new textile block construction. Nor is it adapted just to any Southern
California site, but to a particular one at the bottom of a ravine (Fig. 24g). In other words,
Wright’s California houses are not so much an illustration of his adaptation to a general
region very different from the prairies of the Middle West as of his capacity to renew again
and again his architectural imagination by drawing on the implications of particular uses
of materials and the opportunities of very carefully chosen sites.
The plan of the Millard house and its composition are both very simple (Fig. 251). The
house is tall, so that it may rise up out of the ravine, and because it is entered from the side
at the second floor level. The living room on this level is tall also, corresponding to two storeys
of bedrooms behind. The dining room and the services are below at the level of the garden
in the ravine. The compact scheme of the plan, the solid plasticity of the mass, contrast
sharply with the articulation of earlier houses. Yet there is a complex flow of space, outward
between the piers of the living room front onto the exterior balcony, and inward, above and
below the interior balcony, on either side of the chimney (Fig. 252). Moreover, some of the
blocks are pierced, so that points of light within and of dark without sharpen the moulded
patterns suggesting, as in the row-windows of the earlier houses, the penetration of interior
and exterior space (Fig. 253). The external mass is varied and lightened by subordinate parts,
the cantilevered balcony on the front and the bridge at the entrance (Fig. 250), and by other
minor projections. The patterns on the blocks further break up the solid surfaces into a
continuous play of light and shade (Fig. 254).
The setting of this house is marvellously beautiful. The delicate romantic foliage softens
the cubic severity of the silhouette. The water and the reflections in the pool, with the flat
terrace in front of the dining room, provide a magic carpet upon which the house seems to
float. The sides of the ravine wholly isolate the house from its unsympathetic neighbors.
One of the most remarkable, if quite coincidental, things about this house is its resem-
blance to the first houses the “international” architects were building in Europe at this time.
The use of concrete, the compact plan, the simple mass, are all quite parallel, for example,
to the early houses of Le Corbusier and the projects of the Bauhaus. It is also important to
[76]
stress the differences. After twenty years the chief difference is that this house, because of its
special construction, because of the textured surface of its cement blocks, above all perhaps
because it has a definite solidity and is not dependent on linear abstractions and paper-like
planes, but upon materials of a definite thickness and certain intrinsic visual qualities, is as
beautiful a work of architecture as it ever was. Most of the early “international” houses,
unfortunately, are today shabby and cracked, and seem poverty-stricken and barren unless
one studies them in renderings in which their abstract qualities are clearest or in the best of
contemporary photographs. Other differences, such as the sympathetic site and the more
human scale, have, of course, always been of primary concern to Wright.
The other early block houses are not so interesting, although the Storer house should
be mentioned for its grace (Fig. 255, 256), and the Ennis house for its majesty (Fig. 257-258).
Here — and this perhaps as much as the repeated units of formal pattern explains the sug-
gestion of Mayan influence — the great terrace on which the house stands is almost the most
prominent feature, while the varying height of the rooms gives an extremely plastic skyline.
But beside the Millard house, the Storer house seems to lack privacy, while the Ennis house,
crowning one of the Hollywood hills, has somewhat too much the weight and dignity of a
public monument. The Freeman house is difficult to photograph because of its hillside site,
but the fine interiors are more appropriately furnished than those of the Millard house
(Fig. 259-262) which served as an antique shop.
A few years later, at the depth of his personal troubles, Wright advised his former pupil,
Albert McArthur, in the use of the textile block system on the Arizona Biltmore Hotel in
Phoenix. The commission and the design were McArthur’s, though the character of the
design is inevitably quite Wrightian. This led to the commission to design San Marcos-
in-the-Desert for Dr. Alexander Chandler near Chandler, Arizona. Although this great
project for a hotel and several separate houses never came to execution on account of the
depression, the drawings were carried out in the fullest detail. The project remains, far
more than the Arizona Biltmore, an exciting demonstration of the large-scale possibilities
of the textile block system of construction (Fig. 281). Wright’s universal architecture found
here, perhaps for the first time in history, an adequate expression specifically suited to a
desert environment. This is equally apparent in the designs of the individual Young and
Cudney houses (Fig. 285, 286, 287, 288).
Here the texture of the blocks was simplified to the zigzag flutes of the Sajuaro cactus
(Fig. 284), while the most cunning use was made in plan of 6o°~-3o° angles, which Wright
henceforth was to prefer to his earlier octagonal forms. The vast size of this project, with
central lounge, dining room, and services (Fig. 282), and two large wings of private suites
[711
(Fig. 283) opening on to receding stepped terraces makes it somewhat difficult to comprehend
from drawings. But the superb relationship to the desert setting, as well as the remarkable
consistency in the use of the same angles from the largest plan elements to the section of the
flutes, should make plain why Wright himself admires this particularly among the many
unexecuted projects of these inactive years. He points out that the dotted line given by the
fluted blocks is the characteristic line of the desert.
While work was going forward on the drawings for San Marcos-in-the-Desert Wright
built his own temporary Ocotillo Gamp near Chandler (Fig. 276, 277). Here canvas is the
chief material (Fig. 278, 279, 280). As this camp lasted but a year or two and proved to be, in
a sense, only a preliminary study for Taliesin West (Fig. 352-359) of similar construction and
much greater size, built ten years later near Phoenix, it is not necessary to discuss it here.
The San Marcos Water Gardens, a sort of super-tourist-camp project for Dr. Chandler,
which was never executed, also made much use of canvas, which was thus for the first time
raised by Wright to the dignity of a serious architectural material (Fig. 291, 292).
Block construction of a modified sort is again being used by Wright on the buildings
now in construction for Florida Southern College (Fig. 405-408). But the last block house in
the cycle of the twenties was that built for his cousin Richard Lloyd Jones in Tulsa, Olda-
homa, in 1929. Oklahoma is neither lilce Southern California nor like the Arizona desert.
Hence we find the treatment of the textile blocks once more modified. Light is introduced not
through windows of any ordinary sort, but by alternating vertical rows of blocks with window
strips of the same width (Fig. 297). Thus, in a sense, there are neither solid walls nor isolated
apertures, but only a screen of closely spaced piers between which space flows as freely, al-
though entirely differently, as between the mullions of the horizontal window bands in the
early wooden houses (Fig. 298). Rich and elaborate as is this composition, the house unfortu-
nately had neither the planting nor the furnishing which Wright would have desired (Fig. 299,
300, 301,302). For this reason, and perhaps also because most of the blocks are unpatterned,
the scale is somewhat difficult to grasp in photographs, though not in reality. But even those
who persist in seeing it as a penitentiary many storeys high can appreciate how perfectly
coordinated are all the various heights and plan projections of the complex composition.
In apparent contrast to the somewhat Mediterranean quality of design in his textile
block buildings in Southern California and Arizona and Oklahoma — Mediterranean because
of the character of the climate and the light, not because of any respect for Spanish tradi-
tions— Wright also developed a rather Northern virtuosity of design in wood in the twenties.
In some cases such as the Tahoe cabins (Fig. 248) and the Nakoma Country Club projects
(Fig. 267), there were in the high pointed roofs intentional references to Indian wigwams.
I!78j
But in the one executed example of this sort of design, the rebuilding of the upper part of the
Nathan G, Moore house in Oak Park after a fire in 1922, Wright was so hampered by the
special conditions of the problem, that we can form no real idea whether this phase would
have been as successful as the cement block houses.
Among Wright’s Job-like trials in the twenties was the second burning of Taliesin. The
reconstruction followed in general the character of the earlier house, but the interiors were
much superior (Fig. 274). Indeed, the Taliesin living room is perhaps Wright’s finest domestic
interior, the slanting planes of the roof individualized by different sorts of wood stripping,
the stone piers and the magnificent stone fireplace forming sturdy, almost naturalistic
accents, and the screen-like bookcases and the various window groupings breaking the space
up and recombining it in a fashion defying precise analysis (Fig. 273). But the beauty of
the room is so much enhanced by its contents, the built-in Oriental objects of art, the judi-
cious mixture of boughten and specially made furniture, the colours of rugs and upholstery,
the flower and plant arrangements in the vases, that the total effect passes beyond what an
architect can ever give to a client. If the architect controls equally completely everything
that goes into a client’s house, the result will be somewhat impersonal and abstract, like, say,
the Robie dining room. If he has no control, the result will be like the Lloyd Jones interiors.
However, in many of the houses of the last few years — although they are too new, too much
on their best behavior to be quite typical — the cooperation between the architect and the
client has been happier, now that the taste of clients has been more educated toward Wright’s
standards.
The house for Darwin D. Martin at Derby, N. Y., begun in 1927 but designed a year
or two earlier, has somewhat the same vocabulary as Taliesin. But as it was unsupervised it
is not one of Wright’s really satisfactory houses (Fig. 290). Since its construction, the growth
of the planting, doubtless laid out by Mrs. Martin, who had known Wright’s work for more
than twenty years, has enormously improved it (Fig. 289).
Before we deal with the skyscraper work of the twenties one or two further projects of
a more sociological interest should be mentioned. For Dr. Chandler, in addition to the great
resort hotel, the related large private houses, and the tourist camp, a type of small block
house was designed which was intended to be erected in considerable numbers. Though
slightly larger, this was in many ways an improved version of the 1919 Monolith Homes
(Fig. 295). Since some of Wright’s work of the twenties laid him open to the siUy charge of
designing chiefly for millionaires, it is a pity this small house project is not better known.
Had some of these houses been built in that era of architectural expansiveness, they might
have been as remarkable examples of Wright’s ability to design relatively inexpensive houses
[79]
as the Usonian houses of the thirties. The plans are compact and rather enclosed, which
perhaps explains why Wright called them “conventional” houses in a variant version worked
out in 1932.
Motoring back and forth between Wisconsin and Arizona, Wright came to realize the
importance of the filling station in the American scheme of things. Two projects, one for a
village service station, of the sort that in thinly settled areas has many uses besides purveying
gasoline, and one for a less elaborate urban station, were prepared (Fig. 293). It is a great
pity that in these years, when many of the oil companies were beginning to establish standard
models of stations after the stylistic orgies of the earlier twenties, no one made use of these
designs.
In comparison with the first decade of the century Wright seems to have built little in
the twenties, when unfortunately his compatriots in the last throes of “tasteful” revivalism
were building far too much. Never was what Wright stood for so incomprehensible in his
own country. Moreover, he was continuously harried in his private life, driven from Taliesin,
and to some extent out of contact with his environment after seven years off and on in the
Orient. The wonder must be not that he built so little, but that he built as much as he did,
and that so many elaborate projects of the greatest consequence came in these years from
his fertile brain. Indeed, it would almost seem as if his brain was more fertile than it had
ever been, as if after the years in which he had concentrated almost entirely on two clients,
the Japanese Imperial Family and Aline Barnsdall, his creative potentialities were wider
and yet more expertly canalized than ever before. In retrospect it is ironic to realize how
little his range and his depth were realized in those years, how generally he was treated by
his compatriots and by foreigners alike — ^if for rather opposed reasons — as an “old master”
whose work in the world had been completed by 1910.
In the last great age of skyscraper building it is even more ironic that Wright, who had
actually worked with Sullivan on the first great skyscrapers thirty years before, built none.
But there are two skyscraper projects of considerable importance, whose cantilevered con-
struction and copper and glass exterior screens have already been mentioned. In the mid-
twenties Wright worked for several years developing an idea of 1920 for Albert M. Johnson,
for whom he had prepared the Death Valley desert compound project in 1922.
The National Life Insurance Building was to have been erected on Water Tower Square
in Chicago. Unlike most of the skyscrapers of the period it was not a solid tower stepped at
the top in conformity with the New York zoning law. The main block of the building was
very thin and from this block wings projected out on one side with light courts between.
Thus in a single building of very large size some of the advantages of widely spaced sky-
[80]
scrapers were achieved. The location, moreover, was well north of the skyscraper areas of
Chicago and the building might have been expected to stand alone, at least for some time
(Fig. 263-266).
The paired supports were in the center of the main block and of the wings and from
them the floors were cantilevered out. Thus, there was no external skeleton at all and the
sheathing of copper grilles, almost entirely filled with glass, was to be hung from the edges
of the cantilevered floors. No comparable openness of surface was achieved in executed
skyscrapers until the very end of the skyscraper building period. But Howe and Lescaze’s
Philadelphia Savings Fund Society Building in Philadelphia and Hood’s McGraw-Hill
Building in New York were both more conventional in construction and even in general
composition. This project stands with San Marcos-in-the-Desert as one of the really great
buildings of the twenties that never came to execution on account of the depression. Indeed,
as the real estate boom collapsed very early in Chicago, the project was given up just as the
Chandler project was started.
As if pursued by depression, Wright prepared his other skyscraper project, St. Mark’s
Tower, an apartment house to be built in New York in 1929 ! But of this a later development
for Washington, Crystal Heights, may now at long last be built (Fig. 41 1-4 13).
St. Mark’s Tower, like the National Life project, has its concrete supports in the center,
cantilevered floors and hung wall-screens of copper and glass. It is, however, entirely different
in planning. Within a polygon, four apartments are grouped on each floor about the central
core of stairs and elevators between the central supports. The apartments are duplex, with
high studio living room and balconies, and their various elements are most ingeniously and
compactly organized of polygonal and oblique forms within the main polygon of the tower
(Fig. 307).
A related project of the next year for a group of apartment towers in Chicago links
the polygons of St. Mark’s Tower in couples and represents a scheme of greater urbanistic
significance, since the towers were intended to rise in a much less congested area than on
2nd Avenue in New York (Fig. 308). Although better known because of ample publication
and frequent exhibition of the model, St. Mark’s Tower is the inferior as well as the earlier
version. It is some consolation to believe that the present Crystal Heights project is superior
to both.
The Elizabeth Noble apartment house project is hardly a skyscraper, but it is a model
of excellence in small apartment design. The ferro-concrete cantilevers are possibly less
audacious, but the ample planning, with rectangular rooms and large terraces before most
of the living rooms, provides what is almost like a series of superposed penthouses. The
[81]
clean contrast of plain concrete walls with very large open areas of copper and glass is curi-
ously parallel to the “international” work of the time, and devoid of the particular decorative
virtuosity of the copper grilles of the National Life or the interlocking polygons of St. Mark’s
Tower (Fig. 303, 304).
Another interesting project of the twenties for a “Steel Cathedral embracing minor
cathedrals” is certainly a skyscraper in size. Half again as tall as the Eiffel Tower, still in
1926 the tallest edifice in the world, and intended to contain a million people, it would have
been a sort of religious Empire State Building. The designs were never carried very far,
although the project appears again later in Broadacre City. And the scale is so tremendous
that it is difficult to grasp either the principles of the tenuous steel construction, or the com-
plex intersecting polygons of the plan and triangles of the exterior. It is in spirit curiously
like some of the wooden projects of the immediately preceding years, a kind of heavenly
wigwam as fantastic as some of Buckminster Fuller’s house designs of these years. But if
this project is really fantastic, and economically unrealizable even in a boom period like the
mid-twenties, it is important to recognize that the other skyscraper projects by Wright in
the twenties were not. Indeed, in retrospect we can see that they were far less fantastic than
most of the skyscrapers that were erected.
The particular decorative exuberance of Wright’s major work of the previous decade,
which continued to a considerable extent in the early twenties, definitely diminished after
the rebuilding of Taliesin in 1925. The Lloyd Jones house executed and the Elizabeth Noble
^artment project compare in directness of structural expression and restraint in orna-
ment with the finest wooden houses before 1910. Yet they are completely free from traditional
methods of construction, wholly determined in design by the nature of their reinforced block
and slab construction. To the eyes of the time Wright did not, in the twenties, seem always
at the forefront of architectural progress. But the eyes of the twenties were in many respects
rather blind. In the next decade his reputation, particularly in America — ^Europeans con-
tinued through the twenties to publish new books on his work — rose again. At long last the
prophet of modern architecture, so strangely misunderstood in the twenties, began to receive
honor in his own country.
[82]
PART SIX
1931-1941
IX. Projects of the Depression Years and the Current Revival of Activity
W RIGHT suffered more than most architects from the depression. As we have seeUj
most of the major projects of the mid and late twenties failed to come to execution.
And in the early thirties, he was no busier with actual building than his colleagues. But these
years were not inactive. He published several books and lectured widely, while the exhibi-
tion prepared for the Chicago Art Institute in 1930 circulated both abroad and at home. If
many were still inclined to think of Wright as an “old master,” a sort of ancestor of the new
European architecture which was beginning to be widely known and even imitated in
America, his lectures, publications, and exhibitions now made his work increasingly well
known at home and abroad. Most critics were profoundly shocked that the Chicago World’s
Fair of 1933 made no use of his talents. When Wright’s work was included, perhaps without
his enthusiastic approval, in the International Exhibition of Modern Architecture held at
the Museum of Modern Art in 1932, it was obvious that his work alone balanced the
European work that was shown. Most of the other work by Americans appeared derivative.
The “House on the Mesa,” prepared for this exhibition and shown in a fine model, was
a luxurious mansion, a “five-car house,” as Wright effectively described its scale. No project
of Wright’s, except possibly the Elizabeth Noble apartment house, could have displayed so
weU the similarities and the differences between Wright’s work and that of the European
leaders (Fig. 310). No house of theirs was more open or dramatic in the exploitation of
cantilevered concrete construction. No plan so clearly segregated general living space from
master’s and service wings (Fig. 31 1) — ^in the tradition of the Coonley house; no composition
handled dominating horizontals with more breath-taking ease, or achieved the ultimate in
soaring lightness by suspending the metal frames of the windows from the cantilevered roof
slab. Above all, no European house was so superbly compounded of interflowing exterior
and interior space. Landscape setting there was none, except in so far as the name implied
the openness of a western mesa, but the lay-out of pool and terraces, the tremendous volume
of the great living room, with its open screen walls, the long anchor of the more solid wings
on the entrance side, produced an abstract organism of planes and lines in space beside
which the European houses, both executed and projected, appeared earth-bound and two-
dimensional. In Wright’s own words, “the whole was integral in character, completely in the
nature of materials.” While a critic has said it “achieved a significant unity and purity of
[85]
style never excelled by the Greeks, with an integrity of means to ends never dreamed of
by them.”
Another important project of 1931 was that for the Capital Journal Building in Port-
land, Oregon. This made use of a quite different sort of ferro-concrete construction with
isolated piers. But as this construction was actually used in the S. G. Johnson and Son
Administration Building in Racine, Wisconsin, begun in 1936, it can better be discussed
later. The chief difference in the Oregon project, in which the principle of the construction
was first worked out five years before, is that the walls are but light screens of glass in metal
frames suspended from the roof slab (Fig. 328, 329).
The two other major events of Wright's career in these years were the founding of the
Taliesin Fellowship and the development of the regional planning model known as Broad-
acre City.
Earlier in his life Wright had developed schemes by which those who were his draftsmen
could share, as in no other architectural office, in a broad educational experience. This had
already been true to some extent in the Oak Park days before 1910, and a sort of minor
version of the Fellowship had been rim at Taliesin in the years 1919-24. Unfortunately in
these years Wright was in Japan or in California most of the time. Although the ideal never
fell into abeyance and Wright’s associates were always to some extent apprentices, it was
not until 1929 that Wright first prepared a scheme for adapting the old Hillside Home
School buildings of 1887 and 1902 as a School of the Allied Arts, and not for several years
more that the present Taliesin Fellowship was actually initiated. A new project for re-
modelling the Hillside buildings was made in 1932 and in 1933 began the actual work on
the Fellowship complex, which is still far from finished. The new drafting room with its
tremendously long and light wooden trusses, which Wright delights to describe as an abstract
forest, and the moving picture theater, arranged in one end of the old school building, are
the elements of greatest architectural interest thus far executed. But as more and more com-
missions came to Wright after 1935, work on the Fellowship buildings slowed down. It is no
part of the present story, which is concerned only with Wright’s executed buildings and
projects, to deal with his educational programme. But it is an ironic indication of the success
of the Fellowship that its own buildings are unfinished. For Wright has kept the members
of the Fellowship so busy as real apprentices on major architectural commissions of all sorts
that this remodelling on which they set to work in the dull years of the early thirties has
properly been neglected.
In all the preceding periods of Wright’s work there were important projects which
indicated his vital and continuing interest in large-scale problems of planning. But this book
[ 86 ]
is no more concerned with Wright as a city planner or regional planner than as an educator.
The subject merits a special volume and fortunately Wright has himself devoted a volume
to the subject as well as many minor passages in his other writings. The Disappearing City
[C1932] offers in its title the essence of Wright’s urbanistic, or perhaps one should rather
say, anti-urbanistic thesis. The thesis was superbly actualized in the tremendous model of
Broadacre City, for which Edgar J. Kaufmann provided the initial fund with which Wright
and the members of the Fellowship went to w’-ork. They worked for several years on this
project before it was first exhibited in New York in the spring of 1935 at Rockefeller Center.
It was later circulated rather widely and then withdrawn for safekeeping at Hillside. Addi-
tions and improvements to the model were made before it was shown once more in New
York at the exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art in 1940.
Broadacre City is, of course, not a city in any ordinary sense. The project covers four
square miles at a county seat and contains a vast number of individual edifices of various
types. Many of these types had been established by Wright in separate projects in the
preceding decade. Of these the members of the Fellowship made tiny models to the scale
of the whole vast scheme in order to show them not as microcosms but as parts of a coherent
macrocosm. Among the earlier projects which found a new meaning in relation to the rest
of Broadacre City were such apparently unique designs as the Gordon Strong Planetarium
of 1925 and the Steel Cathedral of 1926. Other items of less special character were many
apartment houses on the model of St. Mark’s Tower (Fig. 305) and that for Elizabeth Noble
of 1929 (Fig. 303), and the gasoline and service stations of 1928 (Fig. 293). The farm units
and the market units first prepared for Walter Davidson in 1932 (Fig. 312), were even more
important to the total theory of Broadacre City. For according to Wright’s basic ideal
agriculture of human scale and dignity should balance small industries which were to be
housed in units based on the Capital Journal project of 1931 (Fig. 329).
Of houses there were to be many types, from the five-car “House on the Mesa” project
at the extreme of luxury, down through some newly designed “two-car” houses, and the
smaller Chandler block houses (Fig. 295) of 1927 to the most minimal separate dwellings.
In 1940 houses of the Usonian type were substituted for the earlier minimal dwellings. These
minimal types of the early thirties undoubtedly prepared the way for the development of
the first Usonian project for the Hoult house in Wichita the year after Broadacre City was
first completed.
Separate designs were also made for many other types of buildings in Broadacre City.
There was a theater based on the project of 1932 ; a college, the germ of the Florida Southern
scheme now in construction (Fig. 405); schools; hospitals; one large factory for building
[ 87 ]
aerotors (for Broadacre City was to make use of new and improved methods of air transport) ;
aerotor-ports and hotels. Special bridges were designed for safe route crossings in relation
to large scale plans for long and short distance automobile traffic, a premonition of Norman
Bel Geddes Futurama of 1939, but, according to Wright, with many traffic-coordinations
and detailed solutions not to be found in that project.
One can, indeed, hardly name all the elements of a good life for which architectural
provision was made. There were art schools on the model of the Fellowship itself, profes-
sional office buildings for architects and others, and, of course, general stores, as well as an
administrative center for a minimum of county governmental activities.
So large and complex a scheme can hardly be adequately illustrated or explained here.
And indeed in essence Broadacre City is more a frame for architecture than a collection of
individual projects. But it does summarize much of Wright’s thought throughout a lifetime
and brings into coherent relationship the many remarkable individual projects of the ten
preceding years when so very little was actually built.
In addition to the remodelling of the Hillside Home School buildings for the Fellowship
begun in 1933, there was one house executed before 1935. The Willey house, built in 1934
in Minneapolis, and even more the first project for this house, designed in 1932, seem to
open a new cycle of Wright’s architecture, the cycle in which production continues so very
actively today. But the Willey house is not yet of the Usonian type; nor is it a complex and
unique structure like the Kaufmann house or the Johnson Building, begun two years later,
which signalized to the world that Wright, the “old master,” Wright, the ancestor of modern
architecture, was once more in actual building as well as in his ideas leading the world.
The Willey house is not particularly exciting,- indeed, it is rather remarkable for a
certain reduction of tension. The materials are brick and wood, no more novel than the
materials of Wright’s great houses of the opening of the century; and they are used with a
curiously quiet charm (Fig. 3 1 6). The plan has no striking innovations, except for the glazed
screen of shelves between the kitchen — ^in Wright’s terminology now the “work-space” —
and the living room (Fig. 3 1 7). The whole house is on one floor, the hip roof rising higher
over the living room, while the terrace is sheltered by an open pergola above). The earlier
project was somewhat less conventional in that the bedrooms were below and a cantilevered
wooden balcony projected in front of the living room with a parapet of lapped siding canted
outward, a favorite motif of the following years (Fig. 314, 315).
In connection with certain work of the previous decade, and even more with the “House
on the Mesa” project, exhibited in the same year the first Willey project was designed, the
strange parallelism between certain aspects of Wright’s work and developments in the work
[ 88 ]
of the European leaders of modern architecture has been noted. Little influence flowed in
either direction in these years and yet both Wright and the younger Europeans, for all their
lack of sympathy for each other’s current work, seemed to respond to some common spirit
of the times.
We can feel this once again in the Willey house in the quietness, the discretion and the
straightforward use of such traditional materials as had retained their economic advantages
in the face of the bold innovations of the twenties. With Wright this was merely to utilize
once more a mastery he had never lost, and implied no real break with the immediate past.
There was for him no difference between this continued use of brick and wood and the bold
exploitation of new materials in new types of construction. The Capital Journal project
and the “House on the Mesa” project both, of the year before the first Willey project,
in which two quite different sorts of concrete construction were intended, or the Kaufmarm
house and the Johnson Building begun two years after the Willey house was built, in which
these two types of construction were carried to execution, did not exist for him in a different
architectural world. For his architectural world was universal. Unfortunately, this was not
always the case with the Europeans, when they met the detente of the thirties, or with certain
Americans. For they had in principle rejected traditional materials in the twenties, as
Wright had never done, and their return to brick and wood was often a little sheepish and
hesitant. Wright has pointed out that he was by this time the author of hundreds of executed
buildings while the younger architects had built very little either with old or new materials.
This may explain a good part of the difference.
It is too much of a paradox to say that the novelty of the Willey house is that it is not
very novel, in terms of the innovations of the preceding decade. But it is not too much to say
that it opens with particular effectiveness a new period in modern architecture in general,
and not in Wright’s work alone. The ancestor of modern architecture sensed that the archi-
tecture of the middle of the twentieth century need not be as different from that of the
opening of the century as everyone, even perhaps he himself for a little, had believed in
the twenties.
In 1936 building really began to revive. In Wright’s architectural career the upturn is
signalized by two of the most remarkable commissions of his fifty years of building activity.
“Falling Water,” the Kaufmann house in the Pennsylvania woods, which was completed
within the year, and the Johnson Administration Building, which was several years in con-
struction, were widely recognized as classic masterpieces even before they were finished, and
amply published and exhibited. And doubtless the publicity these two works received and
the general recognition that they represented Wright’s genius in a new guise explains, quite
[89]
as much as the general revival of building activity in the following years, the very large
number of commissions that have come to him in the last five years. The majority of these
commissions were for smaller houses; and Wright believes that after Broadacre City, his
most important work has been the development of the Usonian house type for clients of
moderate means of which the first project was also of 1936. But architecture lives not alone
by the establishment of types and through the solution of generic problems but quite as much
by the thrill and the acclaim of unique masterpieces. Moreover, in the preceding years of
depression, while the sterling worth of the Willey house was recognized, it represented, as
we have said, the general architectural detente of the thirties. Now confidence in the possi-
bilities of a new architecture, so high in the mid-twenties and later so low, rose once more
with the recognition that executed buildings, not just pictorial projects, could successfully
maintain the high hopes of an architecture of innovation. Moreover innovations as bold as
any suggested in previous years had been warmed and humanized by Wright’s intuitive
respect for the nature of materials, and in the case of the Kaufmann house, by his superb
exploitation of an extraordinary site (Fig. 320).
The Kaufmann house combines two sorts of romanticism, the romanticism about
nature, which has flourished since the eighteenth century, and the romanticism about scien-
tific feats of construction, often considered of quite opposite character. A house over a water-
fall sounds like a poet’s dream. A house cantilevered over a waterfall is rather the realized
dream of an engineer. Through the forest trees, the long horizontals of slabs and parapets
seem to float in space (Fig. 322). The metal sash enclosing the rooms are hardly visible and
offer no such sense of support as the wooden and masonry mullions of the Prairie houses.
The strength of the structure is patently in the rigidity of the slabs alone and in the solidity
with which they are anchored at the rear (Fig. 321). They are anchored not only to the rock
of the waterfall edge itself, but also to the solid core of masonry at the rear of the house,
built up in great rough pylons of native stone. This stone-work offers the sharpest visual
contrast of striated naturalistic surfaces and mottled colour to the clean, precise, light-
coloured forms of the concrete. Thus, as from the beginning of Wright’s mature work, there
is a sort of plaiting in space of horizontals and verticals; light tenuous horizontal planes, here
more abstract than the sloping eaves of the prairie houses ; and sturdy, massive, articulated
verticals, rock of nature’s rock, core and heart of the whole construction. But the composi-
tion is now at once very complex and very free. Although some hint of a cross form above a
square remains, the organic order is rather that of a natural product than of geometry,
regularly modular like a crystalline structure, but beyond any simple description in geometri-
cal terms.
C90]
Although this was a rather large house, it was not expensive for its size. As it was in-
tended for a week-end retreat an openness of plan such as has hitherto been used only in
small houses was possible (Fig. 321). The living area was unified, although the many breaks
in the basically square shape suggest the functional differentiation of the different parts.
Even in the sleeping quarters above, which provide accommodations more in the nature of
bed-sitting rooms or private suites than ordinary bedrooms, there is a remarkable openness.
In them it is due more to the way in which each suite opens upon its own terrace than to any
loss of interior privacy.
As in the block houses of the twenties, inside and outside are essentially one in treat-
ment. In each room both the solid mass of the vertical masonry core and the rigid suspension
of the reinforced slabs is evident, while built-in fittings of wood humanize the scale and the
surface textures (Fig. 323). Outside steps, actually starting within the living room, lead down
into the stream. Pools hold the water for bathing purposes. Projections of the concrete slabs
are pierced to form pergola-like grilles over which plants may hang. Yet nothing is done to
interfere with the lush natural growth of the woods, or to dam the flow of the torrent. Never,
even in Wright’s work, has architecture as the product of man been so perfectly balanced
and contrasted with the natural setting. For never has the natural setting been wilder or
more superb in its original condition, and never has the work of man been bolder or in a
sense more arbitrary in its placing. But so perfect, so apparently inevitable, is the juxtaposi-
tion that one cannot imagine such a house in a different setting or a different house in this
setting. Ordinary questions of functionalism receive new answers, not because this is not a
practical house to live in, but because it is so pre-eminently a comfortable house to live in
over a waterfall.
There are no projects leading up to the Kaufmann house unless it be the “House on
the Mesa.” It seems to have sprung as suddenly from the brow of Wright as did the River
Forest Golf Club more than a generation earlier, with the difference that the world was
now prepared to appreciate it, and to receive with loud acclaim a building that seemed to
epitomize the aspirations not of Wright alone, but of all modern architects. After the
twenties, in which the direction of the European leaders and the direction of Wright seemed
sharply opposed, despite all the coincidences which we now recognize, now in the later
thirties as new coimtries, Finland and England, came to achievement in modem architecture
equalling that of France and Holland and Germany in the previous decade, architecture
could be seen to be advancing on a deeper and broader, if less “international” front. And the
Kaufmann house was one of the first and most striking demonstrations that a new cycle of
[91]
world architecture had opened, a cycle, alas, destined within two or three years for a prema-
ture end in Europe with the coming of war.
Preliminary construction of the S. G. Johnson Administration Building began in the
early fall of 1936, when the Kaufmann house was nearly finished (Fig. 327). But so novel were
the hollow tapered piers (Fig. 331), reinforced by tissues of expanded metal lath and support-
ing only their own lily-pad-like tops, that a building permit was not issued until the following
spring (Fig. 326). Nor was the building finally completed, with the furniture and fittings
designed by Wright and specially made, until the spring of 1939.
In some ways this is a more luxurious structure than the Kaufmann house, but except
for the length of the building campaign it was not relatively very expensive for an office
building. It has often been pointed out that the area could easily have been roofed with metal
trusses and quite unbroken by piers (Fig. 330). Hence the unimaginative — ^who do not include
the general public, which has flocked to visit the building ever since it was finished — ^have
never comprehended the piers. The system of construction is, of course, that intended for
the Capital Journal Building in Salem, Oregon, in the project of 1931 (Fig. 326). The piers
do not support anything. They stand like so many plants, providing the solid part of the roofs
with their own extensive circular tops, in a fashion somewhat like Maillart’s Swiss type of
mushroom columns, but entirely opposed to the post-and-lintel principle of most American
concrete construction (Fig. 336). Amazingly small at their bases, which rest in nine-inch
bronze holders, they do not break up the working space in a functional sense. While in an
esthetic sense their lithe repeated shafts, as organic as those of some hollow-stemmed plant,
really create the interior space.
For the interior space is here entirely cut off from the outside (Fig. 333). The light,
coming straight down from the open spaces between the lily-pad pier tops, and entering also
in bands below the surrounding balcony and at the top of the wall, is extraordinarily even.
Perhaps because of its points of origin, perhaps because of the pyrex glass tubes which fill
the openings, the light has a very special quality. With the special forms of the piers, there
is a certain illusion of sky seen from the bottom of an aquarium.
The walls of the building, which are but screens stopped below continuous bands of
glass tubes where the cornice would be on a traditional structure and the more solid core
of the building (ventilation system, staircases, etc.) as well as the balcony parapets are of a
specially made hard red brick, mechanically perfect, with raked horizontal joints, and a
finish as even as that of the waxed linoleum of the floors (Fig. 334). For here nothing is rustic
or casual, everything is polished and smooth (Fig. 337). The very plans and sections of the
building, with their curved corners and balanced oblique elements, suggest some large-scale
[9^]
piece of machinery more successfully than the work of those architects who have praised
more loudly, if not for so long, the machine ideal.
There are many unusual elements outside the main office space of this building — the
auditorium, the bridge, the squash courts, the garages, and the tremendous car port — ^which
deserve mention. Moreover, there are several other structural elements, such as the domed
slab of the “car-port, almost as remarkable as the hollow piers and the pyrex tube glazing.
Nor can the special steel and magnesite furniture, the first executed from Wright’s designs
since the epoch-making office furniture in the Larkin Building of 1904, be ignored. But by
the time this building was completed Wright was in the full flood of a production as extensive
as that of the first decade of the century; and already in 1937 and 1938 there are many other
outside commissions which must be discussed, as well as the construction of Wright’s own
winter camp in the Arizona desert.
The Herbert Jacobs house, the first Usonian house, was built in 1937 outside of Madi-
son, Wisconsin, for $5500. It follows closely the project for the H. C. Hoult house in Wichita
of the previous year. In 1936 a house was built for Mrs. Abby Beecher Roberts outside
Marquette, Michigan, and in 1937 a house for Herbert Johnson north of Racine and a house
for Paul Hanna in Palo Alto, California. But in all this revival of activity the very inexpensive
Jacobs house is after the Kaufmann house and the Johnson building the most important.
Although somewhat larger than the Willey house of 1934, the Roberts house, at least as it
has been altered by the client, is not an improved version, and in all this spate of renewed
production can be ignored.
The more successful and very much more elaborate Johnson house is a “zoned” house,
with four large arms projecting from a central mass in which the living areas are grouped
about a chimney. Extending the principle of the Coonley house, one cross arm contains the
master’s rooms, another the guest’s and children’s accommodations, a third the services and
a fourth the garage space. This tremendous house is in Wright’s estimation “the last of the
Prairie houses.” However, except for the interest in the zoned plan, and the tall spaces of the
living areas flowing upward around the chimney shaft to a curiously clerestoreyed roof, it
is not perhaps of great importance (Fig. 341). The new vocabulary of form and construction
in brick and lapped sidiug can be more clearly apprehended in other contemporary houses
of ordinary scale. The last of the great houses in the Prairie tradition, so magnificently ex-
ploited thirty years earlier, is less significant in the thirties than the small Usonian houses
and the slightly larger houses of similar type of which the Hanna house is one of the earliest
and best.
It may be recalled that optimists in the thirties believed that the tide of depression
[93]
would be turned and America’s housing problems solved by prefabrication. New materials
of all sorts were the hope of the prefabricators in the mid-thirties and Wright’s Ready-Cut
projects of twenty years earlier were ignored because they depended upon traditional ma-
terials. But the business world was not able to sell the new prefabricated models of the archi-
tects and technicians in any numbers, and real success, as everyone realized, could only
come with mass production. Whose was the fault we cannot be sure. But Wright was no more
successful than anyone else in jfinding sponsors for his small block houses of the twenties or
his more completely prefabricated “All-Steel” houses of 1937- Wright points out that he
offered new houses as well as new methods, while the others generally preferred to offer old
types of houses built by inconsistent new methods.
In the Usonian house, as projected for the Hoults in Wichita in 1936 and as executed
for the Jacobs in Madison in 1937, Wright, as so often before, analyzed a structural concept,
went to the heart of a way of using materials, and evolved a method of production quite
different from prefabrication as others envisaged it and more adapted to actual con-
temporary conditions. The essence of most schemes for prefabrication lies in the ideal of fac-
tory production of wall units. The essence of the Usonian house lies rather more, in Wright’s
words, in the fabrication of the whole as a unit, and in the principle of its heating. Usonian
houses rest on a concrete slab under which in broken stone filling are placed the heating
pipes. This has proved to be a very simple and efficient sort of heating, “heating by gravity,”
as Wright calls it, which puts no premium upon an enclosed plan. Thus the Usonian houses
can have the large glass areas and the open flow of rooms of Wright’s larger houses without
any sacrifice of comfort or economy. The floor slab and a masonry core in which are the
chimney, the small heater room, and the kitchen, lighted and ventilated by a clerestorey
rising above the bedroom wing, are alone of wet construction. The rest of the house is of dry
construction, which is, of course, one of the great theoretical advantages of prefabricated
construction.
The walls may be but usually are not factory-made nor do they utilize new materials,
except in their plywood centers. But they are, in a sense, prefabricated on the job, like a
sandwich, the plywood center lined on both sides with building paper and faced on the
exterior and the interior with various sorts of wooden siding screwed tightly together. Thus,
there is no skeleton of studs, and the wall sections, prepared in advance, are joined together
at the corners like a sort of box. In Wright’s words, instead of the house going to the factory
the factory comes to the house. Banks of wall-high doors between wooden mullions provide
large areas of glass in living rooms and bedrooms, while above the other walls similarly
framed windows are arranged in clerestoreys (Fig. 343). Since the heights of the different
[94]
parts of the houses are ordinarily varied, light comes in from above on all sides if desired,
while the solid lower walls provide protection from the street or from the North. Such a
principle of construction is very elastic and permits infinite variation of plan. Furthermore,
the elements in the wall sandwich may be varied. Sunk battens of redwood and wider
boards of a cheaper wood were used both externally and internally on the Jacobs house.
Several of the later houses are of cypress with lapped siding inside and out, while the Winkler-
Goetsch house (Fig. 376) is of redwood throughout.
The roofs of these houses are built up of crossed two-by-fours on four-foot or five-foot
centers, the module that underlies the entire plan and the elevations. The roof slabs are
lightened by the way in which the upper layer projects beyond the lower and are frequently
pierced to form a trellis for vines over and in front of openings like the pergola of the Willey
house. In the Jacobs house the underside of the roof was sheathed with wall board, since
replaced with a better material. In later examples plywood or the same lapped siding of the
wails, arranged with mitered comers to define by the linear pattern the enclosed space of
the interior, provide a more elegant finish. In several of the later houses also the walls are
set up not as verticals but with a slight batter, one board lapping the next like the battered
wooden balcony parapets which are so striking a feature of the cantilevered terraces of the
Johnson house, and doors are often but a hinged section of the ordinary walls indistinguish-
able but for the hardware.
The Usonian type has been much perfected and elaborated since the Jacobs house was
completed and there has been an interchange of influence between the very small houses of
the scale of the Jacobs house built for from seven to ten thousand dollars and the larger
houses in which greater expansion of plan and composition was possible but with no essential
difference in construction and expression.
The Hoult project and the Jacobs house were L-shaped with the living room at one end,
the bedrooms at the other and the entrance and services in the angle (Fig. 344). Both the
living room and the bedrooms open on the partially enclosed garden terrace, while the other
walls toward the street and the lot line are blank except for the high clerestorey windows.
The long horizontals of the wall sheathing and of the roof slab give extension and serenity
to the composition which the differing heights vary and elaborate. The Rosenbaum house
in Florence, Alabama, of 1939 is very similar (Fig. 346, 381, 382, 383).
The much larger Hanna house of 1937 in Palo Alto has a plan based on the 6o°-3o°
angles of which Wright had made much use in the projects of the later twenties (Fig. 351).
With the hexagonal module the space effects are somewhat richer or, as Wright puts it,
“more reflex” than with the four- or five-foot module which has been more generally used.
[ 95 ]
This house is also superbly placed on a hill-crest (Fig. 347, 348) whose line the broken plan
follows, with the living room opening toward the more distant view and the inner side of the
house partially surrounding a sort of court. (Fig. 349, 350).
Several later houses, such as the Manson house (Fig. 399) in Wausau, Wisconsin, and
the Sidney Bazett house (Fig. 384) in Hillsborough, California, make similar use of the
hexagonal module. Oblique wings are also used on the Armstrong house near Gary, Indiana,
of 1939, and the Nesbitt house at Cypress Point, on Carmel Bay, California, now in con-
struction.
But rather more of the small houses of the last few years are based on the square module
with more compact planning than that of the L-shaped Jacobs house. Of these one of the
best is the Winkler-Goetsch house, the only one executed of a group of seven intended to
have been built in 1939 near Okemos, Michigan (Fig. 374). Here the large living room has
ranges of glass doors on the entrance side and long windows toward the view (Fig. 377). Out
of this very open area, further lighted by clerestoreys above, are two partly enclosed areas.
One is a sort of very large inglenook with a great fireplace and bookshelves below the low
clerestorey (Fig. 378). The other is the “work-space” (kitchen) behind the chimney, with its
narrow end open toward the living room, and surrounded by cupboards and other storage
facilities. The bedroom wing extends in the other direction, the rooms opening on a grassed
terrace protected by a high wooden parapet of the same construction as the house walls.
Here, as in most of these houses, the main roof slab is cantilevered very far out at the entrance
to provide shelter for the automobile, the “car-port” which in Wright’s current practice
takes the place of a garage.
So many of these houses have been built, particularly in 1939 and 1940, and so subtly
varied are the plans and the external expression, that it becomes as difficult to cover them
adequately as the great series of Prairie houses in the years before 1910 (Fig. 401, 402). More-
over, they are all so new that they do not seem to fall into groups as readily as do the early
houses seen in retrospect after thirty years. But before closing the subject of Usonian and
related houses — a subject which is actually still very open, as several are still in construction
and others are being projected — certain houses and projects which if not unique are rather
different from the norm of the Jacobs house and of the Hanna house with which the cycle
opened in 1937 should be specifically mentioned.
In 1938 Life commissioned a “House for a family of $5000-$6ooo income” which, of
course, received tremendous publicity. In this house there was conspicuous use of masonry
in the piers between the garden doors and elsewhere than in the houses that have been dis-
cussed above. As the house was of two storeys, at least in part, the composition was also
[96]
somewhat more compact and complex (Fig. 360). The Bernard Schwartz house at Two
Rivers, Wisconsin, built in 1939, follows very closely the Life house project (Fig. 362), and the
large Nesbitt house in California now^ in construction will be somewhat of this type, though
considerably larger and more in the spirit of Taliesin itself.
The Sturges house in Brentwood Heights, California, is remarkable for its bold canti-
levering. The whole house seems to float fi'om the crest of a knoll (Fig. 379). A somewhat
similar effect at a larger scale and on a much finer site will be achieved with the Oboler
house now in construction in Los Angeles (Fig. 414). Several other late houses, while they do
not make so dramatic and extensive a use of the cantilever, are raised off the ground on
piers where the ground is low and likely to be damp.
Of these the Pew house, floating among the trees above Lake Mendota, near Madison,
Wisconsin, is a particularly striking example, with its fine rough limestone piers and the
superb carpentry — ^practically cabinetwork — of its battered walls and flat ceilings of lapped
cypress siding (Fig. 396, 397). The Lewis house at Libertyville, Illinois, is less open below
and has a base and core of brick instead of stone (Fig. 388, 391). It is most remarkable for
the rich colours and the harmonious forms of its furnishing in what are perhaps the most
successful of all the newer interiors. The Affleck house (Fig. 404), now in construction in
Bloomfield Hills, Michigan, will also be raised above a slope on brick piers and wall sections
in the manner of the Pew and Lewis houses.
Somewhat related to these Middle Western houses in which masonry plays an important
part is the Rose Pauson house of 1940 outside Phoenix. This has a solid canted base of the
local purple field stone set in concrete and a lighter wooden superstructure quite like that
of the other houses of these years (Fig. 392, 394, 395). It is in site and in the rich and solid
simplicity of composition perhaps the most striking of the latest houses.
The real prototype of the masonry of the Pauson house is the permanent base of Wright’s
own camp in. the desert on Maricopa Mesa further out of Phoenix (Fig. 352, 353). The
whole platform of Taliesin West, begun in 1938 and still being enlarged and completed, the
lower portion of the walls defining the plan, and in places the superstructure as well are of
a sort of mosaic of great blocks of the purple volcanic stone of the hills behind set in con-
crete in forms that are now canted in, now canted out in an extraordinarily subtle way (Fig.
356, 357, 358). Above this solid base the camp is of wood and canvas, an amplification of the
earlier Ocotillo Camp, with various sorts of ingenious louvers and canvas-filled screens, so
that the sun can be kept out and the cool air let in. The almost prehistoric grandeur of this
camp, its superb appropriateness to the scale and the colours and textures of the desert, is
most successfully echoed in the somewhat more conventional Pauson house.
[97]
Once more we see that Wright is not the sort of regional architect who is responsive
only to the landscape, the climate and light conditions of his native region. Most of the
newer houses were designed for and built in the Middle Western and North Eastern states.
They have, therefore, a certain similarity of character suited to their surroundings and
sharply differentiated winter and summer weather conditions. But the newer California
houses, and a fortiori those designed for the South Western desert, are quite different in ex-
pression, although the wooden elements of the construction are essentially the same. The
Schevill house, to be built outside Tucson, Arizona, of the local adobe, but with the concrete
slab below and the projecting wooden roof above of the Usonian type, will represent still
another creative adaptation to special building materials and conditions.
Not yet built for any client, another type of house projected in these years deserves
special mention. Intended first for Ralph Jester, in Palos Verdes, California, and then for
Martin Pence in Hilo, Hawaii, the plywood house is apparently a sharp break with the
Usonian model, though it merely applies the principles to a different material (Fig. 364).
Since plywood can be bent and is stronger in curved forms, all the rooms are circles, set
under a continuous slab supported on round stone piers and opening toward a covered central
area (Fig. 365). Thus a new material leads once more to a new type of planning, beautifully
adapted to a warm, equable climate, and to an expression as new and as pure as even Wright
has ever devised.
Despite the tremendous production of these last years it is hard to omit the projects,
which perpetually suggest potentialities of achievement even yet unrealized. But the Suntop
Homes in Ardmore, Pennsylvania, of 1939, of which one quadruple unit was executed, are
doubtless more important than the Jester-Pence plywood projects or certain Usonian designs,
such as the Jurgenson house and the Carlson house of 1938, in which pitched roofs, used
with extraordinary drama and unconventionality, were substituted for the more usual flat
slab roofs. In the Carlson house particularly this provides an expression of shelter from the
northern winter as specific as the expression of protection from the southern sun in the
Jester-Pence project.
In the executed unit of Suntop Homes the Usonian ideas were adapted to group hous-
ing. The four dwelling units are linked about a cross-shaped brick wall somewhat like
grouped units of the St. Mark’s Tower project of 1929 (Fig. 367). Moreover, if more quad-
ruple units had been built, they were to have been placed on the site so as to give each the
same privacy which is given in the executed unit to its four separate dwellings (Fig. 368).
The architectural vocabulary of masonry wall sections, great french doors framed in
natural wood and canted parapets of lapped siding is that of the Usonian homes, as is the
[983
floor-slab heating system only partially in effect in this scheme. However, the visual result is
very different, because the dwellings run vertically upward instead of spreading horizontally.
Thus the composition, though as>Tnmetrical on ail sides, is crystalline and centralized.
In the Usonian and related houses the design effects are extraordinarily integral. The
juxtaposition of materials; the expressive variations of height and width; the contrast of
open and closed surfaces ; the drama of pitched or flat roof slabs, here sweeping out to cover
car-ports, there cut through to let more light into the windows ; all these elements produce
compositions at once geometrically abstract and materially objective. The superb craftsman-
ship in brick and stone is sturdy and straightforward, expressing the compact structure of
units of burnt clay or the natural stratifications of stone. The cabinetmaker-like precision of
the fine redwood and cypress is both simple and rich. The only decorative elements, recalling
the leaded glass of the period before 1910 rather than the exuberance of the twenties, are
the slotted boards used in some places instead of real windows to light a passage and to
suggest the thinness and penetrability of the sandwich wall. The patterns of these slotted
boards vary considerably. But in the finest, as in the best “gingerbread” of the mid-nineteenth
century, the quality of something sawn in wood is skilfully suggested in the long leaf patterns
and the thickened stems of the geometrical plant designs. In his apparent harmony with the
general character of the architectural detente of the twenties Wright has neither given up
his interest in the more dramatic levitated structure of the twenties — indeed, he seems more
interested to free his buildings from the ground than ever before — or his belief that the most
complete architecture will always have some sort of detailed development beyond that
inherent in the structural use of the materials. In the larger projects and executed works of
the last few years this is even more evident as fresh ways of achievement are perpetually
found and tried.
The largest commission Wright has undertaken since the Imperial Hotel twenty years
before, in the number of separate buildings and the organization of the group plan the most
elaborate and complex that has ever come to execution, is Florida Southern College in
Lakeland, Florida. The project dates from 1938 and the first of the sixteen buildings planned
were begun in 1940 (Fig. 405). The Ann Pfeiffer Memorial Chapel (Fig. 407) and three semi-
nar buildings have been completed; the library is now in construction; so that the general
character of the whole can now be appreciated, although it will doubtless be many years
more before the whole group is completed.
The flat lakeside, hardly above the water level and without any interesting natural
growth, is perhaps the most uninspiring with which Wright has ever had to deal, despite its
superficial resemblance to the prairies around Chicago. Here there was little cooperation
[99]
from nature and the architect’s responsibility was the greater since he had so little assistance
from that partner with whom he has always so closely collaborated.
The general plan is rather formal like all of Wright’s group plans (Fig. 406). But there
is no academic symmetry. The interest and variety which are lacking in the contours of the
site are created by the boldly oblique patterns of the communicating covered ways between
the buildings, and the variation in height between the major and minor units. Thus the
executed chapel rises high, itself a carillon and flower tower, and its oblique planes establish
in the air over the site the chief directions of the flat pattern of the general plan. The low
seminar buildings, on the other hand, hug the ground, their flat roofs forming with the
covered w^ays a system of linlced planes parallel wdth the plane of the soil and the water.
Another major unit, the library, echoes in its stack tower the oblique planes of the chapel,
while the great circular reading room, by its size and its shape, forms a nucleus among the
lower surrounding units.
The separate buildings, woven together as one by the covered esplanades, are chiefly
constructed of cement blocks, their delicately patterned surfaces contrasted with smooth
vertical concrete slabs. The scale of the blocks is smaller than in the California work and
the Arizona projects of the twenties. The more frequent use of pierced blocks, with the
interstices sometimes filled with cast coloured glass, gives a rather textile effect, light, cool
and serene, almost feminine in the manner of crisply starched white hamburg lace. Since
the natural environment is all a matter of the flat planes of land and water in which the
quality of the light and of the air are the most important elements, the architecture, unlike
the houses in the wooded North or on the rock-ribbed desert, makes no use of wood or of
natural stone. It is, indeed, a very unmaterial architecture and yet not papery, since the
blocks give a certain visible thickness to the thin-spun, tenuously interwoven planes, and
the whole is penetrated by the air and animated by the delicate pattern of the shadows cast
by the brilliant sun.
There is an element of fantasy here, of a fantasy which Northerners may feel is as
implicit in the climate of Florida as in that of Southern California. This contrasts with the
solider and more workaday quality of the Usonian houses or of the Johnson building. Actually
as college architecture goes, this is not a particularly expensive scheme of construction. But
the economy which seems to control not only the practical aspects of the Usonian houses,
but also the straightforward simplicity of their design, does not hamper here an expression
of festive gaiety, of youthful grace, which is perhaps particularly appropriate for a Florida
college. Here there is almost nothing of the detente of the thirties, except perhaps in the
L ^00 ]
refinement of an earlier exuberance, but rather an optimism and a happy expansion toward
a more glorious future, as in the boldest projects of the twenties.
One of the boldest projects of the twenties was St. Mark’s Tower (Fig. 305). The later
version of 1930 for Chicago with its double towers linked in a line, was an even more
brilliant expression of the possibilities of the clustered skyscraper group such as was about
to come to larger scale execution under the hampering conditions of mid-town New York in
Rockefeller Center. In 1940 Wright prepared for a Washington client his own version of
Rockefeller Center to be erected at the intersection of Florida and Connecticut Avenues in
the outer residential area of the city beyond the confines of L’Enfant’s original plan. The
site was well away from the dowmtowm area, and yet like the isolated skyscrapers on Wilshire
Boulevard in Los Angeles, easily approached from all sides. Moreover, the land here rose
above the contiguous areas, while the rapid spread of commercial building out Connecticut
Avenue would seem to doom it ultimately as a residential area. But all these reasons, which
in the light of the most advanced city-planning practice made this an ideal location for such
a project, have not thus far seemed to the Washington zoning authorities to justify granting
permission for its execution. Of course the essential objection is the height, but so distant
and slender a group of towers could hardly destroy the balance of the official architecture
around the Mall more completely than do the solid urban blocks that already exist north of
Pennsylvania Avenue.
Along the avenues Wright’s project provides shops with a theater at the intersection
and a series of cantilevered slabs like shelves above to provide the parking facilities which
have elsewhere been almost totally ignored in the new buildings of Washington. The hotel
towers are grouped around the rear of the raised lozenge-shaped area, whose predetermined
form harmonizes with the crystalline patterns of the plans in detail. At the apex one tower
rises well above the others to dominate the group (Fig. 41 1).
Within the towers the suites interlock like the studio apartments of St. Mark’s Tower
and the Suntop Homes. However the interest of the project does not reside in such details,
carried out in terms of polygons with Wright’s tremendous and almost perverse ingenuity,
but rather in the brilliant urbanism of the total conception. The man who sees the city as
disappearing offers here not only a model of how the urban ideal might be maintained in
the mid-twentieth century, and a model much more realizable than the projects of the
twenties for rebuilding European metropolitan cities, but a masterpiece of urban architec-
ture, beside which Rockefeller Center itself and the accidentally isolated skyscrapers of
Wilshire Boulevard appear as timid, half-hearted compromises.
The other great project of the immediate present, the Kansas City Community Church,
[101]
now nearing completion, also occupies an urban site, but in a Middle Western city which
has quite broken its nineteenth century bounds and spread out over the hills to the south
leaving its earlier shell behind to die of blight. For all the variety of Wright’s architectural
production, the many apparently separate threads of development are closely linked through
the years and no project is ever quite forgotten. Just as Crystal Heights has its prototypes in
the Chicago apartments and St. Mark’s Tower of ten years earlier, which in turn were
based structurally on the concrete cantilevers of the Imperial Hotel, the Kansas City Church
owes much to the Theater project and the Steel Cathedral project of the twenties, which
were incorporated in Broadacre City, and ultimately to the Barnsdall theater project of the
late ’teens, to Unity Church of 1906 and even to the All Souls Building project of the late
nineties. The provision for parking about the edge on shelf-like cantilevered slabs is taken
over from the Crystal Heights project and the character of the composition in terms of
planes set on edge at oblique angles is a more solemn and solid version of the Florida Southern
Chapel (Fig. 409). But this church is too large to constitute in itself a tower. Instead, a tower
of light, formed by searchlights, will at night form a rival to the ambiguous red-glowing
steam of Magonigle’s War Memorial.
Wright is in 1941 in the full flow of production and happily as busy as in the days of
his greatest activity before 1910. Many projects already referred to are now building, many
more new projects, already commissioned, have hardly yet passed from Wright’s brain onto
paper. There can, therefore, be no conclusion to this record of more than a half century of
building. As we look back over the landmarks of this unprecedentedly long-continued career,
to the Charnley (9) and Harlan (21) houses of 1891, the Lake Forest Golf Club {49) of 1898,
the great Willitts (73), Heurtley (71) and Ross (77) houses and the Hillside Home School (81)
of 1902, the Larkin Building (92) of 1904, the Unity Temple (118) of 1906, the Cooidey
{148), Robie (166) and Gale {160) houses of the end of the decade, Taliesin, in its three incar-
nations of 19 1 1, 1914 and 1925 (174, 269), the Midway Gardens (191) of 1914, the Imperial
Hotel (220) of the end of that decade, the California block houses (249, 255, 256, 259) and
the Lloyd Jones house (297) of the twenties, the Kaufmann house (320) of 1936 and the
Johnson Building {330), the Usonian and other houses of the last five years, the Florida
Southern College and the Kansas City Church now in construction, it seems almost impos-
sible that one man can have designed and built so many edifices which have entered the canon
of the world’s great architecture. But the best thing of all is that we need not look backward
only. Like Wright, we can look forward to a continuing production of equal vitality. For his
creative vigor is in no way reduced, but rather increased by the long years of its continuous
exercise. Indeed, after the ten dull years from 1925 to 1935, it is as if Wright’s energy, long
[102]
pent-up as regards executed work, though not, as we have seen, as regards major architec-
tural inventions on paper, now flowed with renewed force. We need not regret that so many
major projects remain unexecuted. For we can feel assured that their best qualities will
eventually come to execution in the continuing work of succeeding years.
Of Wright, as of Titian, we may believe that in the eighth decade of his life and the
sixth of his architectural career more work lies ahead which will equal in every way what is
past. Wright has physically outlived the generation of the traditionalists, in the moment of
whose triumph Kimball could write of Sullivan’s and Wright’s architecture as “a lost cause” ;
professionally he seems to be outliving the generation of the great European innovators of
the twenties. In 1941, as forty years ago in 1901, or even a half century ago in 1891, Wright
seems to stand poised for new triumphs at the opening of a great phase of his career.
[ 103 ]
Chronological List of Executed Work and Projects: 1887—1941
y^LTH OU GH many lists of Wright’s work have been prepared and several of them pub-
lished, none of them are very complete and most of them are quite inaccurate. The
most complete listing, that in Grant Manson’s unpublished Harvard doctoral dissertation
of 1940, covers only the period through 1910. Manson has very generously permitted me to
collate this list with his. To him I owe all the dates established from public records in the
early part of the list, but my interpretation of other sorts of evidence often differs somewhat
from his. I specifically owe to Manson my knowledge of the Roloson houses of 1 894 and the
E-Z Polish Factory of 1905. We have also on the basis of our joint familiarity with the
Taliesin collection of drawings discussed many points of detail.^
Beyond 1910 my list is based on that prepared for the exhibition at the Museum of
Modem Art, chiefly the work of Henrietta Galloway. However, the Museum list has been
enlarged and altered almost beyond recognition from additional material at Taliesin and
by the correction of most of the individual dates through correspondence with clients and
others.
I have not included the many new commissions of 1941 which had not taken form on
paper when I was at Taliesin in May. The completeness of this list is relative. For both
Manson and I have heard of early work about which we cannot obtain adequate informa-
tion. In the later period, which has been less studied, there are even more likely to be items
that I have missed. Among the Taliesin drawings there are hints of projects and possibly
even of executed work about which but little can be learned even from Wright. I have
included such things only when the existing drawings were relatively complete or the designs
themselves of exceptional interest.
The text and the arrangement of plates follows in general a chronological order. In
this list an attempt has been made at the impossible; a detailed consecutive itemizing of the
architectural production of Wright’s brain. It will be realized that much of the diagram-
matic appearance of consecutiveness is false. But the only hope of arriving at a generally
true sequence was to pretend in detail to a precision which is actually somewhat absurd.
Since earlier lists have been so excessively casual in their dating, with certain important
II should specifically state that I do not owe to Manson my knowledge of the Orrin S. Goan project, but to informal
tion on early drawings.
[ 105]
buildings dated more than five years too early or too late, it seemed worth while to aim, at
least, at a high degree of accuracy.
The followmg notes explain the principles that have been used in preparing the list :
Within each year the items are arranged alphabetically, the executed work preceding
the projects, which are always indicated as such.
Boldfaced dates are established by building permits or from similar public records.
They are, in a sense, absolute; but they are hardly more accurate than those determined
from published announcements of commissions, directory lists, private records or contem-
porary inscriptions on drawings. Building permits granted late in the year presumably imply
construction the following spring. Where construction is known to have begun before the
permit was issued or considerably later such facts are given. Sometimes the permit date and
sometimes the actual date at which construction started has determined the place in the
list, usually the earlier of the two.
Some building campaigns extended over several years. This is indicated, when known,
by a dash following the date and a note if the building was not effectively completed within
the year following that of the entry. In the absence of any other records, I have used the
latest contemporary date on drawings, as this usually agrees with the date of construction
where both are known. But there is always a possibility of error in mistaking for contem-
porary ones approximate dates added later to the drawings.
Projects differing markedly from executed work are separately entered with cross
reference to the executed work.
The absence of a date to the left in the list (which is indicated in cross references and
illustration captions by putting the date in brackets) may in some cases imply an uncertainty
of as much as several years, in others merely the lack of firm evidence. Notes of early pub-
lication or exhibition — otherwise usually not included — or of the clients’ appearance in
directories at the given address often fix a terminus ante quern. Such a terminus, with other
indications, has often been considered sufficient to justify a precise date. Exhibition and
publication of early work, unless otherwise noted, was in the Chicago Architectural Club
exhibitions held at the Art Institute and in their catalogues in 1894, 1898, 1900 and 1902.
There were also later exhibitions at the Art Institute of Wright’s work alone in 1907; about
1916 (indicated by [1916]); and in 1930. This last exhibition travelled widely here and abroad
in following years, possibly with some changes in the material. Finally in 1940 there was the
exhibition at the Museum of Modern Art in New York which this book memorializes.
Bracketted items are not to be considered entirely Wright’s work. The various reasons
are given in separate notes.
[106]
Estimated costs, generally given on building permits and sometimes mentioned in the
press, are entered in the list when known. Of course they represent at best only rough
approximations of actual cost. Allowance must also be made for changing construction
prices in the past fifty years and in different parts of the country. It is unfortunate that this
information cannot be more complete, but in most cases it might have offended the clients
to give costs for work of the last decade or so.
1887 Project: Misses Lloyd Jones (?) house, Helena Valley, Spring Green, Wis. (effec-
tively a more elaborate preliminary project for the house below; published in the
Inland Architect j 1887)
1887 Project: Unitarian Chapel, Sioux City, Iowa (published in the Inland Architect,
June, 1887)
Misses Lloyd Jones house, ^ Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. (published in the Inland
Architect, February, 1888; extensively altered as part of the Taliesin Fellowship
complex, 1933- )
1889 Frank Lloyd Wright house, 428 Forest Avenue, Oak Park, 111 . $4,000 (new dining
room and then a playroom added in mid-nineties; studio, v. 1895; other additions
and alterations up to 1909 ; subdivided into three apartments after Wright’s return
from Europe in 19 1 1)
1890® [James Charnley house. Ocean Springs, Miss.] (unsupervised; probably modified)
W. S. MacHarg house, 4632 Beacon Avenue, Chicago, 111 . (MacHarg first listed at
this address in Chicago Directory, 1891; demolished)
1890® [Louis H. Sullivan house, servants’ cottage and stables. Ocean Springs, Miss.] (un-
supervised; enlarged)
Project: Henry N. Cooper house and stable. La Grange, 111 . (based, according to
Wright, on a design prepared previous to joining Sullivan)
1891® [James Charnley house, 1365 Astor Street, Chicago, 111 .] (later addition to south)
^At this time Wright was working in J. L. Silsbee’s office. The style of this house is essentially Silsbee’s, as is true
of the two projects of 1887 listed above.
3 Works of the firm of Adler and Sullivan. The dates are in general those given by Hugh Morrison in his Louis
Sullivan, New York, W. W. Norton F1935]. As Sullivan’s chief lieutenant in design from about i8go until he left Adler
and Sullivan in 1893, Wright certainly designed the Ghamley house in Chicago and was chiefly responsible for the
other works of Adler and Sullivan here listed, particularly the houses. For that matter, Wrightian elements, equally due
to his hand, can be readily distinguished in other Adler and Sullivan work of these years. See discussion, above, pp. 6-14.
[ 107 ]
1892 George Blossom house, 4858 Kenwood Avenue, Chicago, III. (garage later, v. 1907)
1892 Robert G. Emmond house, 109 South Eighth Avenue, La Grange, 111 . (porch en-
closed, resurfaced)
1892 Thomas H. Gale house, 1019 Chicago Ave., Oak Park, 111 . $3,000
Dr. Allison W. Harlan house, 4414 Greenwood Avenue, Chicago, 111 . (commissioned
and possibly begun in 1891 ; balcony altered)
1892 Warren McArthur house and stable, 4852 Kenwood Avenue, Chicago, 111 .
1892 R. P. Parker house, 1027 Chicago Avenue, Oak Park, 111 . $3,000 (built by Thomas
H. Gale for Parker’s occupancy)
1892® [Albert W. Sullivan house, 4575 Lake Avenue, Chicago, 111 .] (occupied by Louis
H. Sullivan, 1892-96)
1892® [Victoria Hotel, Chicago Heights, 111 .] (remodelled)
1893'^ Walter Gale house, 1031 Chicago Avenue, Oak Park, 111 . (front terrace destroyed)
1893^ [Meyer Building, 307 West Van Buren St., Chicago, 111 .] (cornice removed)
Municipal Boathouse, Carroll Street at Lake Mendota, Madison, Wis. (demolished)
1893 William H. Winslow house and stable, Auvergne PL, River Forest, 111 . $20,000.
1893 Project: Library and Museum competition, Milwaukee, Wis. (exhibited, 1894)
[1894] Frederick Bagley house, loi County Line Rd., Hinsdale, 111 .
Dr. H. W. Bassett remodelled house, 125 South Oak Park Ave., Oak Park, III (Dr.
Bassett first listed at this address in Oak Park Directory, 1 895 ; demolished)
Peter Goan house, 108 South Eighth Ave., La Grange, 111 . (upper story resurfaced)
1894 Robert W. Roloson houses (4), 3213-3219 Calumet Avenue, Chicago, 111 . $27,000
(remodelled as apartments)
1894 Francis Woolley house, 1030 Superior Street, Oak Park, 111 . (resurfaced)
1894 Project: Orrin S. Goan house. La Grange, 111 .
“Works of the firm of Adler and Sullivan. The dates are in general those given by Hugh Morrison in his Louis
Sullivan^ New York, W. W. Norton ^^935]. As Sullivan’s chief lieutenant in design from about 1890 until he left Adler
and Sullivan in 1893, Wright certainly designed the Ghamley house in Chicago and was chiefly responsible for the
other works of Adler and Sullivan here listed, particularly the houses. For that matter, Wrightian elements, equally due
to his hand, can be readily distinguished in other Adler and Sullivan work of these years. See discussion, above, pp. 6-14.
*The W. I. Clark house, 21 1 South La Grange Road, La Grange, 111., was published as Wright’s in the Inland
Architect in 1894, vol 24, no. i, but it was actually designed by E. Hill Tumock, an Adler and Sullivan draftsman. It is
not clear how Wright’s name came to be attached to iti but probably Tumock used Wright’s name in announcing the
commission. j. j
1894 Project; A. G. McAfee house, on Lake Michigan, Chicago, 111 . (exhibited and pub-
lished, 1900; a slightly variant plan for James L. McAfee also exists)
1895 Francis Apartments for Terre Haute Trust Company, 4304 Forestville Ave.,
Chicago, 111 .
1895 Francisco Terrace for Edward C. Waller, 253-257 Francisco Ave., Chicago, 111 .
Nathan G. Moore house and stable, 329 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (published in
the Inland Architect^ 1898; terra cotta bay windows by Fellows, c. 1914; rebuilt
after fire, v. [1923])
1895 Edward G. Waller apartments, 2840-2858 West Walnut St., Chicago, 111 . (de-
signed to be built at the comer of Jackson Blvd. and Kedzie Ave., but actually
erected without supervision contiguous to Francisco Terrace)
1895 Chauncey L. Williams house, 520 Edgewood PL, River Forest, 111 . (dormers on
front and left and remodelled after 1900)
1895 Frank Lloyd Wright studio, 951 Chicago Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (remodelled as two
apartments after Wright’s return from Europe in 19 ii)
1895 P‘ Young alterations, 334 North Kenilworth Ave., Oak Park, 111 .
1895 Project: Jesse Baldwin house (based on McAfee project of 1894)
Project: Luxfer Prism Company skyscraper (two versions exhibited and published,
1898)
1895 Project: Wolf Lake Amusement Park for Warren McArthur, on Wolf Lake, 111 .
Project: house, name unknown (published in the Architectural Review^ June,
1900; similar to Walter Gale plan)
1896 H. G. Goodrich house, 534 North East Ave., Oak Park, 111 . $2 700 (altered internally)
Misses Lloyd Jones windmill “Romeo and Juliet,” Hillside, Spring Green, Wis.
(resheathed with siding instead of shingles, 1939)
Charles E. Roberts remodelled interiors, 321 North Euclid Ave., Oak Park, 111 .
(executed gradually over several years)
Charles E. Roberts stable, 317 North Euclid Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (altered to serve
as a dwelling about 1929)
Project: Mrs. David Devin house, on Lake Michigan, Chicago, 111 . (exhibited and
published, 1900)
1896 Project : Robert Perkins apartment house, West Monroe St., Chicago, lU.
[1093
1897 George Furbeck house, 223 North Euclid Ave., Oak Park, 111 . $15,000 (porch en-
larged)
1897 Isidore Heller house and stable, 5132 W oodlawn Ave., Chicago, 111 .
Henry Wallis boathouse, South Shore Rd., Delavan Lake, Wis. (demolished)
Project: All Souls Building, Oakwood Blvd. at Langley Ave., Chicago, 111 . $100,000
(published and exhibited in 1900; designed in association with Dwight Heald
Perkins; v. [1901], Abraham Lincoln Center)
1898 Rollin Fui’beck house, 515 Fair Oaks Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (later additions and in-
ternal changes)
River Forest Golf Club, Bonnie Brae Ave., River Forest, 111 . (front wing built first;
completed, exhibited and published, 1900; enlarged and altered, v. [1901]; de-
molished 1905)
1898 George W. Smith house, 404 Home Ave., Oak Park, 111 .
1898 Project: Mozart Garden remodelling for David Meyer, State St. at 55th St.,
Chicago, 111 .
1S99 Joseph W. Husser house, 1 80 Buena Ave., Chicago, 111 . (demolished)
1899 Edward G. Waller remodelled hall and dining room, Auvergne PL, River Forest,
111. (demolished)
Project: Cheltenham Beach for Norman B. Ream and Edward C. Waller, 75th to
79th Streets on the Lake, Chicago, 111 . (published in the Architectural Review^
June, 1900)
Project: Robert Eckart house. River Forest, 111 . (published and exhibited in 1900)
Project: Edward C. Waller house, River Forest, 111 . (exhibited and published in
1900; a separate and more advanced design than the above; but as Mrs. Eckart
was Waller’s daughter both probably relate to a single potential commission)
Project: house, name unknown (published in the Architectural Review, June, 1900)
1900 William Adams house, 9326 South Pleasant Ave., Chicago, 111 . $6,000 (plan prob-
ably provided by the client, Wright’s builder since the Winslow house)
igoo B. Harley Bradley house and stables, “Glenlloyd,” 701 South Harrison Ave., Kan*
kakee. 111.
1900 S. A. Foster house and stables, 12147 Harvard Ave., Chicago, 111 .
[no]
1900 Warren Hickox house, 687 South Harrison Ave., Kankakee, 111 .
1900 E. H. Pitkin house, Sapper Island, nr. Kensington Point, Desbarats, Ont., Canada.
1 900 Henry W allis (H. Goodsmith) house, South Shore Rd., Delavan Lake, Wis. (unsuper-
vised ; sold by Wallis to Dr. Goodsmith upon completion)
1900 Project: “A Home in a Prairie Towm” and first version of Quadruple Block Plan,
for Curtis Publishing Co. (published in the Ladies' Home Journal, Februar)^, 1901 ;
there is an alternative unpublished and less advanced version of this house)
1900 Project: “A small house with lots of room in it’,’’ for Curtis Publishing Company,
(published in the Ladies' Home Journal, June, 1901)
1901® E. Arthur Davenport house, 550 Ashland Ave., River Forest, 111 . (front terrace
removed)
E. R. Hills remodelled house, 313 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (drawings dated 1900 ;
work carried out by Nathan G. Moore for his daughter, Mrs. HiUs, a year or two
later)
Fred B. Jones house, boathouse, gate-lodge and barn, “Penwem,” South Shore Rd.,
Delavan Lake, Wis. (unsupervised; the drawings indicate continued construction
of the separate edifices through 1903 in the sequence given)
1901® F. B. Henderson house, 301 South Kenilworth Ave., Elmhurst, 111 . $10,000 (second-
storey covered porch added over original terrace in front of living room)
Robert M. Lamp cottage. Governor’s Island, Lake Mendota, Wis.
River Forest Golf Club additions, Bonnie Brae Ave,, River Forest, 111 . (altered and
enlarged at rear and sides; exhibited and published, 1902; demolished, 1905)
1901® Frank Thomas house, 210 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . $10,000 (built by James C.
Rogers, Mrs. Thomas’ father; resurfaced)
1901 Universal Portland Cement Co. Pavilion, Pan-American exposition, Buffalo, N. Y.
(demolished)
1901 Edward C. Waller gateway, stables and gardener’s cottage, Auvergne PL, River
Forest, 111 .
Henry Wallis remodelled gate-lodge. South Shore Rd., Delavan Lake, Wis. (gate
and fence demolished)
®Most of the work of igoi and early 1902 was done in association with H. Webster Tomlinson. There is no reason,
however, to believe that Tomlinson had any effect whatever on Wright’s rapidly maturing style.
[Ill]
1901 T. E. Wilder stables, Elmhurst, 111 . (demolished)
1901 Project: Lexington Terrace for Edward G. Waller, Lexington St., Spaulding Ave..
Polk St., and Homan Ave., Chicago, 111 . (this project was reworked in 1909, q.v.)
Project: Abraham Lincoln Center, Oakwood Blvd. and Langley Ave., Chicago, 111 .
(exhibited, 1902 ; a later development of the All Souls Building project of [1897] in
association with Dwight Heald Perkins, v. 1903)
Project : “A Village Bank in Cast Concrete” (published in the Brickbuilder, August,
1901)
Project : Heniy W allis house, Delavan Lake, Wis.
1902® William G. Fricke house, 540 Fair Oaks Ave., Oak Park, 111 . $12,000 (remodelled
for Emma Martin, v. 1907; detached pavilion since demolished)
George E. Gerts double house, Birch Brook, Whitehall, Mich.
Walter Gerts house, Birch Brook,® Whitehall, Mich.
1902 Arthur Heurtley house, 318 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (remodelled internally as
two apartments)
Arthur Heurtley remodelled house, Les Cheneaux Club, Marquette Island, Mich.
1902 Misses Lloyd Jones Hillside Home School, Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. (incor-
porated in Taliesin Fellowship complex, v. 1933- )
1902 Charles S. Ross house, South Shore Rd., Delavan Lake, Wis. (modified)
George W. Spencer house, South Shore Rd., Delavan Lake, Wis.
1902 Ward W. Willitts house and gardener’s cottage, 715 South Sheridan Rd., Highland
Park, 111 . $20,000 (cottage altered to serve as garage)
Project: Delavan Lake Yacht Club, Delavan Lake, Wis.
1902® Project : Victor Metzger house, Desbarats, Ont., Canada
Project : John A. Mosher house
1902 Project: Yahara Boat Club, Lake Mendota, Madison, Wis.
1902 Project: Edward C. Waller house, Charlevoix, Mich. (v. 1903)
Project: house, name unknown. Oak Park, 111 .
®Most of the work of 1901 and early 1902 was done in association with H. Webster Tomlinson. There is no reason,
however, to believe that Tomlinson had any effect whatever on Wright’s rapidly maturing style.
® There may be several other early houses at Birch Brook of Wright’s design, probably unsuperv'ised variants, but
so modified as to be unrecognizable today; v., however, [1921].
[ 112 ]
igo3 George Barton house, 1 18 Summit Ave., Buffalo, N. Y. (built by Danvin D, Martin,
Mrs. Barton’s father)
1903 Susan Lawrence Dana house, East Laurence Ave. at 4th St., Springfield, 111. (incor-
porating an older house)
1 903 W. H. Freeman house, Hinsdale, 111. (unsuper\dsed ; altered in execution)
1903 [Abraham Lincoln Center, Oakwood Blvd. at Langley Ave., Chicago, 111.] (exe-
cuted by Dwight Heald Perkins alone ; much simplified externally, although based
on the earlier projects, v. [1897] ; [1901])
1903 Francis W. Little house and stable, 603 Moss Ave., Peoria, 111. (additions made for
Robert D. Clarke, v. 1909)
1903 W. E. Martin house, 636 North East Ave., Oak Park, 111. (subdivided into three
apartments)
Scoville Park fountain, Lake St., Oak Park, 111.
1903 J- J- Walser, Jr., house, 42 North Central Ave., Chicago, 111. $4,000
Project: Robert M. Lamp house, Madison, Wis. (different from executed house,
V. 1904)
Project: Chicago and Northwestern (?) Railway station, Oak Park (?), 111. (3 ver-
sions)
Project: Charles E. Roberts quadruple block plan (24 houses), Chicago, Fair Oaks,
Superior and Ogden Aves., Oak Park, 111. (based on the Quadruple Block Plan of
igoo published in the Ladies^ Home Journalj February, 1901, but with somewhat
different houses; an alternative scheme with still differently planned houses on con-
ventional narrow lots also exists)
1903 Project: Edward G. Waller house, Charlevoix, Mich, (different from 1902 project)
Project: Frank Lloyd Wright one storey studio-house, Oak Park, 111.
Project: house, name unknown.
1 904 Edwin H. Cheney house, 520 North East Ave., Oak Park, 111. (garage later)
1904 Robert M. Lamp house, 22 North Butler St., Madison, Wis. (bricks now painted;
storey added on top)
1904 Larkin Company administration building, 680 Seneca St., Buffalo, N. Y. (now
Larkin retail store)
[ 113]
1004 Darwin D. Martin house, conservatory, garage, etc., 125 Jewett Pkwy., Buffalo,
N. Y. (slight alterations by W right, 1914)
Project; Hiram Baldwin house, Kenilworth, 111 . (different from executed house,
V. [1905])
Project: Robert D. Clarke house, Moss Ave., Peoria, 111 . (before Clarke’s purchase
of Little house in 1905)
Project: Larkin Company workmen’s rowhouses, Buffalo, N. Y.
1904 Project: J. A. Scudder house, Gampement d’Ours Island, Desbarats, Ont., Canada
1904 Project: Frank L. Smith bank, Dwight, HI. (different from executed bank, v. 1905)
Project: H. J. Ullman house, North Euclid Ave. and Erie St., Oak Park, 111 . (the
Ullman house built in 1905 by Robert G. Spencer is quite different from Wright’s
project)
Project: house, name unknown. Highland Park, 111 .
1905 Mary M. W. Adams house, 103 Lake Ave., Highland Park, 111 .
Hiram Baldwin house and garage, 205 Essex Rd., Kenilworth, 111 . (entrance and
interiors altered)
1905 Charles E. Brown house (Evanston Model Home), 2420 Harrison Ave., Evanston,
III.
1905 E-Z Polish factoiy for Darwin D. and W. E. Martin, 3005-30 1 7 West Carroll Ave.,
Chicago, 111 . (top floor rebuilt after fire, 1913)
1905 W- A. Glasner house, 850 Sheridan Rd., Glencoe, 111 .
1905 Thomas P. Hardy house, 1319 South Main St., Racine, Wis.
1905 W. R. Heath house, 76 Soldiers PI., Buffalo, N. Y.
A. P. Johnson house. South Shore Rd., Lake Delavan, Wis. (unsupervised)
1905 Lawrence Memorial Library interior for Mrs. R. D. Lawrence, Springfield, III.
1905 River Forest Tennis Club, Bonnie Brae Ave. and Quick St., River Forest. 111 .
(burned, 1906; v. 1906)
1905 Rookery Building remodelled La Salle and Adams St. entrance lobbies and balcony
in central court, La Salle and Adams Sts., Chicago, 111 . (entrances considerably
modified)
[ 114]
1905 Frank L. Smith bank, Dwight, 111 .
Project: Charles W. Barnes house, McCook, Neb.
Project: T. E, Gilpin house, Kenilworth Ave. and North Blvd., Oak Park, 111 ,
Project : Single-storey varnish factory
1905 Project: Harvey P, Sutton house, McCook, Neb. (different from executed house,
V. 1907)
Project: house on a lake.
1906 P. A. Beachy house, 238 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (incorporates an earlier house)
K. C. de Rhodes house, 715 West Washington St., South Bend, Ind. (published in
1906)
Grace Fuller house, Hazel Ave. and Sheridan Rd., Glencoe, 111 . (exhibited in 1907;
demolished)
1906 A. W. Gridley house and barn. North Batavia Ave., Batavia, 111 .
1906 P. D. Hoyt house, 318 South Fifth Ave., Geneva, 111 .
George Madison Millard house, 410 Lake Ave., Highland Park, 111 .
Frederick Nicholas house, Brassie Ave., Flossmoor, 111 . (unsupervised)
W. H. Pettit mortuary chapel, Belvidere cemetery, Belvidere, 111 . (unsupervised)
1906 River Forest Tennis Club, Lathrop Ave. and Quick St., River Forest, 111 . $3,500
(Charles E. White, Jr., and Vernon S. Watson, associated; moved, 1920, from
original site at Quick St. and Bonnie Brae Ave., and enlarged by Vernon S. Watson)
1906 C. Thaxter Shaw remodelled house, 3466 Peel St., Montreal, P. Q., Canada
1906 Unity (Universalist) Church and Parish House, Kenilworth Ave. at Lake St., Oak
Park, 111 . $35,000 (designed and possibly begun in 1905)
1906 Project: Richard Bock studio house, Maywood, 111 .
Project: Mrs. David Devin house, Eliot, Me. (exhibited in 1907)
1 906 Project : "A Fireproof House for $5000,” for Curtis Publishing Co. (published in the
Ladies' Home Journal j April, JQOj)
Project: Walter Gerts (Alex Davidson) house, Glencoe, 111 . (Buffalo, N. Y.) (ex-
hibited in 1907; differs entirely from executed W. V. Davidson house, v. igo 8 ;
slight alterations were made to Walter Gerts’ River Forest house at this time)
[115]
Project: R. S. Ludington house, Dwight, 111 . (exhibited in 1907)
Project: Warren McArthur concrete apartment house, Kenwood, Chicago, 111 .
Project: C. Thaxter Shaw house, Westmount, Montreal, P. Q., Canada.
Project: Elizabeth Stone house, Glencoe, 111 . (exhibited in 1907)
1907 George Blossom garage, 49th St. at Kenwood Ave., Chicago, 111 .
E. W. Cummings Real Estate office, Harlem Ave. and Lake St., River Forest, 111 .
(first listed in Oak Park Directory, 1908 ; demolished)
Col. George Fabyan remodelled house, Batavia Rd., south of Geneva, 111 . (six
houses for rent may have been designed but not executed for Col. Fabyan; no
drawings for them remain at Taliesin)
Fox River Country Club remodelling for Col. George Fabyan, Geneva, 111 . (burned
about 1912)
Stephen M. B. Hunt house, 345 South Seventh Ave., La Grange, 111 .
1907 Larkin Company pavilion, Jamestown Tercentenary exposition, Jamestown, Va.
(demolished)
1907 Emma Martin alterations to Fricke house, and new garage, 540 Fair Oaks Ave.,
Oak Park, 111 . (v. 1902)
1907 Pebbles and Balch decorating shop, 1107 Lake St., Oak Park, 111 . (extensively
altered)
1907 Andrew T. Porter house, HiUside, Spring Green, Wis. (basement dining room,
1938)
1907 Harvey P. Sutton house, 602 Main St., McCook, Neb. (designed in 1905; rebuilt
from original plans with some modifications after fire, 1932)
1 907 F. F. Tomek house, 150 Nuttall Rd., Riverside, 111 .
1907 Burton J. Westcott house, 1340 East High St., Springfield, Ohio
Project: Harold McCormick house and adjuncts. Lake Forest, 111 . (worked on for
several years; a house at Lake Forest for Harold McCormick was built by Charles
A. Platt in 1908)
Project: Andrew T. Porter house, Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. (larger, slightly
later than executed house)
igoS E. E. Boynton house, 1 6 East Blvd., Rochester, N. Y.
1908 Browne’s Bookstore, Fine Arts Bldg., 410 South Michigan Ave., Chicago, 111 .
(demolished)
1908- Avery Coonley house and stable, 300 Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 . (pergola and
french windows of playroom, gardener’s cottage, [1911]; stable altered as garage,
1912; playhouse, 1912; slight further alterations ini92i;v. [i9ii],v. 1912)
1908 Walter V. Davidson house and garage, 57 Tillingham PL, Buffalo, N. Y. (two
rooms added lately over garage)
1908 Robert W. Evans house, 9914 Longwood Dr., Chicago, 111 . (porch enclosed about
1913)
1908 E. A. Gilmore house, 120 Ely PL, Madison, Wis. (altered later to serve as fraternity
house)
1908 L. K. Horner house, 1331 Sherwin Ave., Chicago, 111 .
1908 Isabel Roberts house, 603 Edgewood PL, River Forest, 111 . (resurfaced with brick)
Dr. G. C. Stockman house, 31 1 First St. S. E., Mason City, Iowa
Project: Frank J. Baker house, Wilmette, lU. (different from executed house,
V. 1909)
1 908 Pro j ect : E. D. Brigham stables
1908 Project: Dr. W. H. Copeland remodelled house, 408 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 .
(different from executed alterations, v. 1909)
Project: William Norman Guthrie house, Sewanee, Tenn. (identical with executed
Baker house, v. 1909; published in Ausgefuhrte Bauten und Entwurfe^ 1910)
1908 Proj ect : Horseshoe Inn for Willard H. Ashton, Estes Park, Col.
1908 Project: Francis W. Little house, Wayzata, Minn, (different from executed house,
V. 1913)
Project: J. G. Melson house. Mason City, Iowa (identical, except for site, with
Isabel Roberts house above, published in 1910)
Project: Moving picture theater
1909 Frank J. Baker house, 507 Lake Ave., Wilmette, 111 .
1909 City National Bank Building and Hotel for Blyth and Markley, West State St. and
[1173
South Federal Ave., Mason City, Iowa (now Adams Building and Park Inn; much
remodelled)
1909 Robert D. Clarke additions to Little house and garage, 603 Moss Ave., Peoria, 111 .
1909 Dr. W. H. Copeland alterations, 408 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (unsupervised and
modified in execution)
1909 Mrs. Thomas H. Gale house, 6 Elizabeth Gt., Oak Park, 111 .
1 909 J. Kibben Ingalls house, 562 Keystone Ave., River F orest, 111 .
1909 Meyer May house, 450 Madison Ave, S. E., Grand Rapids, Mich. $16,000 (wing
added to rear, 1920)
1909 Frederick G. Robie house, 5757 Woodlawn Ave., Chicago, 111 . (garage altered)
Oscar Steffens house, 7631 Sheridan Rd,, Chicago, 111 . (published in Frank Lloyd
Wright Ausgefilhrte Bauten 191 1 ; altered)
George G. Stewart house, 166 Hot Springs Rd., Montecito, Gal. (published in
Ausgefuhrte Bauten und Entwilrfe 1910)
Peter C. Stohr building, shops, tearoom, etc., underneath elevated, Wilson Ave.,
Chicago, 111 . (demolished)
1909 W. Scott Thurber art gallery, Fine Arts Bldg., 410 South Michigan Ave., Chicago,
111. (demolished)
Project : Harry E. Brown house, Geneva, lU.
Project: Larwill house, Muskegon, Mich.
1909 Project: Lexington Terrace for Edward C. Waller, Jr., and Oscar Friedman (1901
project reworked with new facades)
Project: Mrs. Mary Roberts house. River Forest, 111 . (different from executed house
for Mrs. Roberts’ daughter, Isabel, v. 1908)
1909 Project : Edward C. Waller bathing pavilion, Charlevoix, Mich.
1909 Project: Edward G. Waller small houses for rent (3), River Forest, 111 . $3500 each.
Project: Town of Bitter Root for Bitter Root Irrigation Company, nr. Darby,
Mont, (two different versions, possibly five years or more earlier)
1910'^ [J. H. Amberg house, 5 05 College Ave. S. E., Grand Rapids, Mich.]
’’Upon Wright’s departure for Europe in the spring of 1910 several house commissions were handed over to
Herman V. von Holst, with whom was associated Marion Mahony from Wright’s office. Some drawings for the Irving
[ii8]
Como Orchards summer colony, Darby, Mont, (designs published in Ausgefuhrte
Bauten iind Entmilrfej 1910; the final form of the Bitter Root project; central club-
house and group of cottages executed without supervision; part of clubhouse and
many of the cottages now demolished)
1910’^ [E. P. Ir\dng house, Millikin PL, Decatur, 111 .]
Universal Portland Cement Co. exhibit, Madison Square Garden, Madison Square,
New York, N. Y. (exhibited [1916], in exhibition at Art Institute, Chicago, of “Work
done since spring of 1911,” sic; published in Frank Lloyd Wright Ausgefuhrte
BauteUj 191 1 ; demolished)
1910 Rev. J. R. Ziegler house, 509 Shelby St., Frankfort, Ky. (unsupervised)
Project: Frank Lloyd Wright house and studio, Viale Verdi, Fiesole, Italy (exhi-
bited, [i 916] in exhibition of “Work done since the Spring of 191 1,” sic)
1 9 1 1 Herbert C. Angster house, 650 Blodgett Rd., Lake Bluff, 111 .
191 1 O. B. Balch house, 61 1 North Kenilworth Ave., Oak Park, lU.
Avery Coonley gardener’s cottage, Scottswood Rd., Riverside, 111 .
19 1 1- Taliesin I, Frank Lloyd Wright house, studio and farm buildings, Spring Green,
Wis. (begun for Mrs. Anna Lloyd Wright, Wright’s mother; burned, 1914, then
rebuilt; V. 1914- ;v. 1925- )
19 1 1 Project: Harry S. Adams house, Oak Park, 111 . (different from executed house,
V . 19^3)
19 1 1- Project: Sherman M. Booth house, Glencoe, 111 . (different from executed house,
V- [1915])
Project: Sherman M. Booth summer cottage
Project: Avery Coonley greenhouse, Riverside, 111 .
19 1 1 Project: Avery Coonley kindergarten. Riverside, 111 . (different from executed
playhouse, V. 1912)
19 1 1 Project: Arthur M. Cutten house. Downer’s Grove, 111 .
Project: E. Esbenshade house, Milwaukee, Wis. (exhibited, [1916])
Project: Madison Hotel for Arthur L. Richards, Madison, Wis. (exhibited, [1916])
house are signed by Wright and he made preliminary sketches for the Amberg house. The Adolf and Robert Mueller
houses in Millikin Place, Decatur, 111., were designed and built by von Holst and Mahony. The whole Millikin Place
group was landscaped by Walter Burley GriflSn from Wright’s olBSce.
1 9 1 1 Proj ect : Andrew T. Porter house, Spring Green, W is.
1 9 1 1 Project : Edward Schroeder house, Milwaukee, Wis.
Project: Frank Lloyd Wright house, Goethe St., Chicago, 111 . (exhibited, [1916])
1912 Avery Coonley playhouse, 350 Fairbanks Rd., Riverside, 111 . (now altered to serve
as a residence)
1912 Lake Geneva Inn for Arthur L. Richards, Lake Geneva, Wis. (unsupervised and
incomplete; now Geneva Hotel)
1912 William B. Greene house, 1300 Garfield Ave., Aurora, 111 . (wing added, 1926, by
Harry Robinson, a former Wright draftsman)
Park Ridge Country Club addition and alterations, Park Ridge, 111 ., (demolished)
Project : Kehl dance academy, residence and shops, Madison, Wis.
Project : SchooUiouse, La Grange, 111 .
Project: Press {San Francisco Call) Building for Spreckels Estate, Market St.
between 3rd and 4th Sts., San Francisco, Gal. (two versions, one isolated, one with
lower link to existing T ower Budding ; exhibited, [1916])
Project: Taliesin cottages (2), Spring Green, Wis. (exhibited, [1916])
1913 Harry S. Adams house, 710 Augusta St., Oak Park, 111 .
1913 Banff National Park recreation building, Banff, Alta., Canada (Francis W. Sullivan
of Ottawa, associated; demolished, 1939)
M. B. Hilly house, Brookfield, lU. (not found; possibly only a project)
1913- Francis W. Little house, II, garage and boathouse, “Northome,” R.F.D. 3, Way-
zata, Mmn. (not completed until WrighFs return from Japan much later; the guest
house is not by Wright)
house, name unknown, Palm Beach, Fla. (unsupervised)
Project: Art Museum
Project: Carnegie Library, Pembroke, Ottawa, Ont., Canada (Francis W. Sullivan,
associated; of two other projects for a double house and a post office in Ottawa
also designed in association with Sullivan no traces remain; ail three projects
exhibited, [1916])
Project : J. W. Kellogg house, Milwaukee, Wis.
[120]
Project: Jerome Mendelson house, Albany, N, Y. (exhibited, [1916])
Project : Block of city row houses
1914 Midway Gardens for Edward C. Waller, Jr., and Oscar Friedman, Cottage Grove
Ave. at 60th St., Chicago, 111 . (designed and possibly begun late in 1913; demol-
ished, 1923)
1914 S. H. Mori oriental art studio, 801 Fine Arts Bldg., 410 South Michigan Ave.,
Chicago, 111 . (modified)
1914- Taliesin II, Frank Lloyd Wright house. Spring Green, Wis. (rebuilt after 1914
fire ; studio and students’ quarters much modified ; rebuilt again after fire, v. 1925- )
Project : Honore J. Jaxon houses (3)
Project: State Bank, Spring Green, Wis., (a building by another architect was
commissioned in 1914; exhibited, [1916])
1914 Project : U. S. Embassy, Tokio, Japan
Project: John Vogelsang dinner gardens and house, Chicago, 111 . (a variant scheme
adds hotel accommodations)
1915 Emil Bach house, 74 1 5 Sheridan Rd., Chicago, 111 .
Sherman M. Booth house, 265 Sylvan Rd., Glencoe, 111 . (unsupervised)
E. D. Brigham house, Sheridan Rd., Glencoe, 111 . (unsupervised)
A. D. German Warehouse, Richland Center, Wis. (incomplete; v. project, [1934])
Ravine Bluffs development for Sherman M. Booth, Glencoe, 111 . (unsupervised;
entrance features, bridge, and 3 houses for rent were buEt; possibly designed at
the time of the Booth house proj ect, 1911- )
Project: American System Ready-Gut standardized houses and apartments for
Richards Brothers, Milwaukee, Wis. (the earliest work on the many alternative
designs for these houses and apartments goes back two or three years; the latest
revisions on the drawings are dated 1916; eventually some of these designs were
executed without supervision; v. 1916)
Project : Chinese restaurant for Arthur L. Richards, Milwaukee, Wis.
Project : Christian Catholic Church, Zion City, 111 .
Project: Model Quarter Section development, Chicago, 111 . (published in City
Residential Land Development Studies in Plannings edited by Alfred B. Yeomans,
[121]
Chicago, [c.1916] ; includes Quadruple Bloch Plan residence areas based on projects
of 1900 and [1903] and various public and commercial edifices as well; cf. Town
of Bitter Root projects, [1909], and Broadacre City, [1934])
1915 Project: Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan (preliminary designs prepared at Taliesin
before W right left for T okio ; exhibited [ 1 9 1 6] , v. [ 1 9 1 7])
Project: Rockefeller Foundation Chinese Hospital
Project: Wood house, Decatur, 111 .
1916 Joseph J. Bagley house, Lakeview and Cedar Aves., Grand Beach, Mich.
1916 F. C. Bogk house, 2420 North Terrace Ave., Milwaukee, Wis. $ 15,000
W. S. Carr house, Lakeview and Pine Aves., Grand Beach, Mich.
Imperial Hotel Annex, Tokio, Japan (including Wright’s own apartment)
1916 Arthur Munkwitz duplex apartments (4), 1102, 1104, iiio, 112 North 27th St.,
Milwaukee, Wis. $20,000 (imsupervised; built from American system plans)
1916 Arthur L. Richards houses (2), 1835 South Layton Blvd. and 2714 West Burnham
St., Milwaukee, Wis. (unsupervised; built from American System plans; the first is
resurfaced)
1916 Arthur L. Richards^ duplex apartments {4), 2720, 2724, 2728, 2732 West Burnham
St., Milwaukee, Wis. (unsupervised; built from American System plans ; resurfaced)
Ernest Vosburgh house, Crescent Rd., Grand Beach, Mich.
Project : Miss Behn (V oight) house. Grand Beach, Mich.
Project: Clarence Converse house. Palisades Park, Mich.
Project: William Allen White remodelled house, Emporia, Kan.
1917- Henry J. Allen house, 255 Roosevelt Blvd., Wichita, Kan.
1917 Aizaku Hayashi house, Komazawa, T okio, J apan^
®Mr. Richards built other houses and duplexes from American System plans at this time in several other cities
and towns, but he cannot remember exactly where.
^The seven years Wright spent in Japan off and on from 1916, the general lack of dates on the drawings, except
perhaps in Japanese, and the failure of Wright’s Japanese associate, Endo, to reply to queries make the information
on Japanese work and projects particularly vague. The termini of the work are probably the 1917 date on the Hayashi
house plans, which are preliminary sketches suggesting that the executed work may have been a year or more later,
and the 1921 date on the Jiyu Gakuen School drawings. But Wright did not leave Japan for good until 1922 and there
is no assurance that the execution of work under Endo’s supervision did not continue after his departure.
[ 122 ]
Stephen M. B. Hunt house, 685 Algoma Ave., Oshkosh, Wis.
Imperial Hotel, Tokio, Japan. million yen (completed, 1922, after some four or
five years in construction)
Project: Aline Barnsdall “Hollyhock House,” Theater, etc., Olive Hill, Los Angeles,
Cal. (Wright met Miss Barnsdall before going to Japan and these designs were de-
veloped concurrently with the Japanese work; the earliest date on a drawing is a
revision of 1 9 1 8 ; v. 1 920)
Project: Odawara Hotel, Nagoya, Japan
1917 Project : Powell house, Wichita, Kan.
1 9 1 8 Fukuhara house, Hakone, Japan (damaged by earthquake, 1923)
Yamamura house, Ashiya, Japan
Project : Count Immu house, Tokio, Japan
Project: Viscount Inouye house, Tokio, Japan
Project: Moving picture theater, Tokio, Japan
1919 Project: Monolith Homes development for Thomas P. Hardy (18), Racine Wis.
(this scheme, as well as the C. E. Staley and J. P. Shampay house projects of this
year, were developed by R. M. Schindler during Wright’s absence in Japan. They
are hardly to be considered Wright’s work, though they issued from his office and
the Monolith Homes drawings carry his signature)
Project: W. S. Spaulding gallery for storage and exhibition of Japanese prints,
Boston, Mass.
1020 Aline Barnsdall house and garage, “Hollyhock House,” Sunset and Hollywood
Blvds., Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave., Los Angeles, Cal. $75,000 (execution of
the project already worked on for several years, v. [i 9 1 7])
1920 Aline Barnsdall Olive Hill studio residence A., Hollywood Blvd. and Edgemont St.,
Los Angeles, Cal. $18,000 (building permit, Dec. 29, 1920; in construction Feb.-
Aug., 1921)
1920 Aline Barnsdall studio residence B, 1645 Vermont Ave., Los Angeles, Gal. $21,000
(building permit Dec. 29, 1920; in construction Feb.-Nov., 1921 ; later altered by
R. M. Schindler)
W. J. Weber house, gth Ave. at 4th St. (city not given on drawings)
[ 1^3 ]
1920
1920 Project; Aline Barnsdall Theater, shops, apartments and houses for rent. Sunset
Blvd. between Edgemont St. and Vermont Ave., Los Angeles, Cal. (final projects
were made at the same time “Hollyhock House” and Residences A and B were in
construction, but sketches for the theater may be much earlier, v. [1917])
Project: Cantilevered concrete skyscraper (v. National Life Insurance project,
[1924])
1921 Jiyu Gakuen Girls’ School of the Free Spirit, Tokio, J apan
Mrs. Thomas H. Gale house or houses^®, Birch Brook, Whitehall, Mich, (unsuper-
vised, date very uncertain)
Project : Cement block house, Los Angeles, Cal.
1921 Project: Edward H. Doheny ranch development, Sierra Madre mountains, near
Los Angeles, Cal.
1922 Project: A. M. Johnson desert compound and shrine, Death Valley, Cal.
1922 Project: G, P. Lowes house, Eagle Rock, Cal. (the house as built later by R. M.
Schindler was much modified)
1922 Pro j ect : Merchandising building, Los Angeles, Cal.
Project: Sachse house, “Deep Springs,” Mojave Desert, Cal.
1922 Project : Tahoe summer colony, Emerald Bay, Lake Tahoe, Cal.
1923 Aline Barnsdall kindergarten, “The Little Dipper,” Olive Hill, Los Angeles, Cal.
$12,500 (demolished, 1924; foundations then made into garden terrace by R. M.
Schindler)
1923 Mrs. George Madison Millard house, 645 Prospect Crescent, Pasadena, Cal.
$18,000 (the separate library and connecting passage, added in 1926 by Lloyd
Wright, does not follow Frank Lloyd Wright’s project, v. [1925] ; garage enlarged,
1931)
Nathan G, Moore remodelled house, 329 Forest Ave., Oak Park, 111 . (1895 house
rebuilt above ground storey after fire of 1922)
Dr. John Storer house, 8161 Hollywood Blvd., Los Angeles, Gal. (begun before an-
^°Mrs. Gale will give no information and she may not have been the client. One house appears to be definitely of
Wright’s design, although unsupervised; two others are probably builder’s copies of this.
[ 124]
nexation of this area by the city of Los Angeles, May i6, 1923; posterior in design
to the Millard house)
Project : Danvin D. Martin house for daughter, Buffalo, N. Y.
1924 Charles Ennis house, 2607 Glendower Rd., Los Angeles, Cal. (being reconditioned
by Wright for John Nesbitt, 1941)
1924 Samuel Freeman house, 1962 Glencoe Way, Los Angeles, Cal. (laundry remodelled
later by R. M. Schindler as separate apartment)
Project: Nakoma Country Club and Winnebago Camping Ground Indian
Memorial, Madison, Wis.
Project: National Life Insurance Company skyscraper for A. M. Johnson, Water
Tower Sq., Chicago, 111 . (a development of the cantilevered skyscraper scheme of
[1920] ; worked over for several years, but essentially complete by 1925, the latest
date found on drawings)
1925— Taliesin III, Frank Lloyd Wright house. Spring Green, Wis. (rebuilding begun
immediately after fire; 1925; further additions in the mid-thirties; minor changes
still being made, 1941)
1925 Project: Mrs. Samuel William Gladney house, Fort Worth, Tex.
Project: Mrs. George Madison Millard gallery, Pasadena, Gal. (the detached
library added to the Millard house in 1926 by Lloyd Wright bears little or no rela-
tion to this project)
1925 Project: Phi Gamma Delta Fraternity House, Madison, Wis. (the fraternity house
as built somewhat later by Law, Law & Potter has little relation, except perhaps in
plan, to the Wright project)
Project: Gordon Strong Planetarium, etc.. Sugar Loaf Mountain, Md.
1926 Project: Oak Park Playground Association playhouses (6), Oak Park, 111 .
1026^^ Project: Steel Cathedral embracing minor cathedrals to contain a million people,
New York, N.Y.
1927 Darwin D. Martin house and garage, “Graycliff,’’ Derby, N. Y. (garage begun 1926,
before house; xmsupervised)
Arizona Biltmore Hotel, in Phoenix, Arizona, with whose design Wright was associated in an advisory
capacity at this time, has often been incorrectly attributed to Mm. The commission was Albert McArthur’s. McArthur,
a former pupil of Wright’s, wished to use Wright’s textile block system of construction. This was actually much modified
when the hotel was built in 1928, but is rather more authentic in the detached cottages.
[125]
1927 Ocotillo Desert Gamp, Frank Lloyd Wright Southwestern headquarters, Salt
Range, nr. Chandler, Arizona (demolished, 1930)
1927 Project: Dr. Alexander Chandler low-cost concrete block houses. Chandler,
Arizona (v. 1932)
Project: Dr. Alexander Chandler San Marcos-in-the-Desert winter resort,
Chandler, Arizona (this elaborate project, including a hotel and several houses, was
worked on for several years before and after the building of the Ocotillo Gamp.)
Project: Dr. Alexander Chandler San Marcos Water Gardens tourist camp.
Chandler, Arizona (probably later than San Marcos-in-the-Desert)
Project: Wellington and Ralph Cudney house, San Marcos-in-the-Desert,
Chandler, Arizona (one of the houses mentioned above)
Project; Owen D. Young house, San Marcos-in-the-Desert, Chandler, Arizona
(another of the houses mentioned above)
1928 Project: Darwin D. Martin Blue Sky mausoleum, Buffalo, N. Y. (in construction,
1941)
1928 Project: Standardized village service stations and city gasoline stations
1929 Richard Lloyd Jones house, "Westhope,” 3700 Birmingham Rd., Tulsa, Okla.
Project: Richard Lloyd Jones house, Tulsa, Okla. (different and earlier than
executed house)
Project; Elizabeth Noble apartment house, Los Angeles, Cal.
1929 Project : Rosenwald F oundation School for Negroes
Project: St. Mark’s Tower for the Vestry of St. Mark’s-in-the-Bouwerie, New York,
N. Y. (published in 1930)
[1930] Project: Grouped apartment towers, Chicago, 111 . (based on the St. Mark’s Tower
project, above)
Project: Cabins for desert or woods (based on San Marcos Water Gardens project
of [1927])
1931 Project: Capital Journal Building for George Putnam, Salem, Oregon
Project: “House on the Mesa,” Denver, Col. (exhibited, 1932, at the Museum of
Modern Art, New York)
Project: Schemes for “A Century of Progress,” Chicago, 111 . (rejecting proposals
[ 126]
that he design individual buildings at the 1933 World’s Fair, Wright gave con-
siderable thought to several alternative structural and design concepts of the exposi-
tion as a whole)
1932 Project: “Conventional House” (practically identical with Chandler block house,
project of 1927)
1932 Pro j ect : W alter D avidson prefabricated sheet steel farm units
Project : Walter Davidson prefabricated sheet steel and glass markets
1932 Project; New Theater (there was possibly an earlier version of this, c. 1928)
1932 Project; Dean Malcolm M. Willey house, Minneapolis, Minn, (different from
executed house, v. 1934)
1933- Taliesin Fellowship complex, Hillside, Spring Green, Wis. (Misses Lloyd Jones
house, v. [1887], remodelled as dormitory; Hillside Home School, v. 1902, adapted
as theater, etc.; new drafting room; construction still continues, 1941)
1934 Dean Malcolm M. Willey house, 255 Bedford St. S. E., Minneapolis, Minn.
Project: Remodelling of A. D. German Warehouse as restaurant and apartments
Project: Broadacre City (exhibited and published, 1935; several years in prepara-
tion. Includes many projects of the previous decade: Nakoma Country Club,
[1924]; Gordon Strong planetarium, [1925]; Steel Cathedral, 1926; Chandler
block houses, 1927; San Marcos Water Gardens tourist camp, gasoline and service
stations, 1928; St. Mark’s Tower and Elizabeth Noble apartment houses, 1929;
Capital Journal Building and “House on the Mesa,” 1931 ; New Theater, Davidson
farm units and markets, 1932; as well as many new projects for colleges, schools,
hospitals, offices, country buildings, factories, hotels, stores, minimum and “two-car”
houses, bridges, aerotor-ports, etc. Based on the programme announced in The
Disappearing City [c. 1932], Revised for exhibition, 1940, with the addition of
various examples of the Usonian house, v. Hoult project, [1936], below, and Jacobs
house, 1937)
[ 1 935] ^ct : Stanley Marcus house, Dallas, T ex. (published in the Architectural Forum,
January, 1938)
1936- S. C. Johnson Administration Building, 1525 Howe St., Racine, Wis. (preliminary
construction started Sept. 3, 1936, building permit issued April 30, 1937; com-
pleted April i, 1939.)
[ 127]
1936 Edgar J. Kaufmann house, “Falling Water,” Bear Run, Penna.
1936 Mrs. Abby Beecher Roberts house, “Deertrack,” R.F.D. i, Marquette, Mich,
(altered)
Project: H. G. Hoult house, Wichita, Kan. (the first Usonian house project)
Project: Robert D. Lusk house, Huron, S. Dak. (published in the Architectural
F£>rwm, January, 1938)
1937 Paul R. Hanna house, 737 Coronado St., Palo Alto, Gal.
1937 Herbert Jacobs house, 441 Toepfer St., Westmorland, near Madison, Wis.
1937 Herbert F. Johnson, Jr., house, “Wingspread,” Wind Point, north of Racine, Wis.
1937 Edgar J. Kaufmann office, Kaufmann Department Store, 400 Fifth Ave., Pitts-
burgh, Penna.
Project: “All Steel” houses development (100), Los Angeles, Cal.
Project: Leo Bramson dress-shop reconstruction, 1107 Lake St., Oak Park, 111 .
(published in the Architectural Forum^ January, 1938 ; a remodelling of the Pebbles
and Balch shop, v. 1907)
Project: George Parker garage, Janesville, Wis. (published in the Architectural
Fomm, January, 1938)
1938 Ben Rebhuhn house. Myrtle Ave. and Magnolia Dr., Great Neck Estates, Great
Neck, L. I.,N. Y.
Taliesin farm group. Hillside, Spring Green, Wis.
1938- Taliesin West, Frank Lloyd Wright winter headquarters in the desert, Maricopa
Mesa, Paradise Valley, near Phoenix, Arizona (still being completed and extended,
1941)
1 93 8 Project : Edith Carlson house, Superior, Wis.
1938 Project: Florida Southern College, Lakeland, Fla. (16 buildings in all; Ann Pfeiffer
Memorial Chapel and three seminar buildings, v. 1940; Library, v. 1941)
1938 Project: “House for a family of $50oo-$6ooo income,” for Life (published in Life,
September 26th, 1938)
1938 Project : Ralph Jester house, Palos Verdes, Cal.
1938 Project: Herbert F. Johnson, Jr., gatehouse and farm group. Wind Point, north of
Racine. Wis.
[128]
Project: Royal H. Jurgenson house, Evanston, 111 . (exhibited, 1940)
Project : George Bliss McGallum house, Northampton, Mass.
Project : E. A. Smith house, Piedmont Pines, Cal. (exhibited, 1940)
[1939] Andrew F. H. Armstrong house, Ogden Dunes, near Gary, Ind. (exhibited, 1940)
1939 Edgar J. Kaufmann guest house. Bear Run, Penna.
1939 Stanley Rosenbaumn house, Riverview Dr., Florence, Ala.
Bernard Schwartz house, Still Bend, Two Rivers, Wis. (based on the Life house of
19383- exhibited, 1940)
George D. Sturges house, 449 Skyway Rd., Brentwood Heights, Cal. (exhibited,
1940)
1939 Tod Company “Suntop Homes,” quadruple house, Sutton Rd. near Spring Ave.,
Ardmore, Penna. (4 more units, i.e., 16 more dwellings, were projected)
Katherine Winkler and Alma Goetsch house, Hulett Rd., Okemos, Mich, (ex-
hibited, 1940)
1939 Project : Lewis N. Bell house, Los Angeles, Cal.
Project: Madison Civic Center, Olin Terrace, Monona Ave. at Lake Monona,
Madison, Wis. (reworked, 1941)
1939 Project : Edgar A. Mauer house, Los Angeles, Cal.
Project: Ludd M. Spivey house. Fort Lauderdale, Fla. (exhibited, 1940)
1939 Project : Usonian house development (7), Okemos, Mich, (only the Winkler-Goetsch
house above was built, and on a different site ; the Erling B. Brauner, J. J. Garrison,
C. D. Hause, Sidney H. Newman, Alexis J. Panshin, and Clarence R. Van Dusen
houses remain unexecuted)
1940 Theodore Baird house, Shays St., Amherst, Mass.
Sidney Bazett house, loi Reservoir Rd., Hillsborough, Cal. (exhibited, 1940)
1940 James B. Christie house. Jockey Hollow Rd., Bernardsville, N. J. (unsupervised)
1940 Community Church, 4600 Main St., Kansas City, Mo. (construction continues, 1941)
1940 Joseph Euchtman house. Cross Country Blvd. near Labyrinth Rd., Baltimore, Md.
1940 Florida Southern College Ann Pfeiffer Chapel, Lakeland, Fla.
1940 Florida Southern College seminar buildings (3), Lakeland, Fla.
[1^9]
1940 Lloyd Lewis house. Little St. Mary’s Rd., Libertyville, 111 .
Charles L. Manson house, 1224 Highland Blvd., Wausau, Wis. (exhibited, 1940)
1940 Rose Pauson house. Orange Rd., Phoenix, Ariz.
1940 John G. Pew house, 3650 Mendota Dr., Shorewood Hills, near Madison, Wis.
1 940 Loren Pope house , Locust St., F alls Church, Va.
Clarence W. Sondern house, 3600 Belleview Ave., Kansas City, Mo. (exhibited,
1940)
1940 Leigh Stevens house and adjuncts, Auldbrass Plantation, near Yemassee, S. G.
(construction continues, 1941)
1940 Project: Crystal Heights hotel, theater, shops, etc., Connecticut and Florida Aves.,
Washington, D. C.
Project: John Nesbitt house. Cypress Point, Carmel Bay, Cal.
Project: Martin J. Pence house, Hilo, Hawaii (two schemes, one based on the Jester
project of 1938 j exhibited, 1940)
Project: Frank A. Rentz house, Madison, Wis. (based on the McCallum project of
[193S]; exhibited, 1940)
Project: Franklin Watkins studio, Barnegat City, N. J.
1941 Gregor Affleck house, Bloomfield Hills, Mich.
1941 Florida Southern College Library, Lakeland, Fla.
1941 Arch Oboler house, Ventura Blvd., Los Angeles, Cal.
1941^^ Proj ect : Margaret SchevHl house, Tucson, Ariz.
^^The following additional houses are now being designed or are already in construction October, 1941 :
1941 John Barton house, Pine Bluff, Wis.
1941 Alfred H. Ellinwood house, Deerfield, 111 .
1941 Parker B. Field house. Airport Road, Peru, 111 .
1941 William Guenther house. East Caldwell, N. J.
1941 Roy Petersen house, West Racine, Wis.
1941 Stuart Richardson house, Livingston, N. J.
1941 Vigo Sundt house, Madison, Wis.
1941 Carlton David Wall house, Detroit, Mich.
1941 Mary Waterstreet Studio, nr. Spring Green, Wis.
1941 Project: Sigma Chi Fraternity House, Hanover, Ind. F. LI. W,
[> 30 ]
Illustrations
13 . FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT HOUSE, 428 FOR-
EST AVE., OAK PARK, ILL. 1889. LIVING ROOM.
The view of the Wright living room empty
shows dearly the open planning in the
Queen Anne tradition. The treatment of the
openings without architraves beneath a con-
tinuous string course is new^ and personal to
Wright. Such refinements of detail enhance
the feeling of spatial flow and suggest that
the interior walls are no more than movable
screens. The small photograph shows the
inglenook with the original furniture and
decorations.
FIREPLACE INGLENOOK.
iis
19. GEORGE BLOSSOM HOUSE, 4858 KENWOOD AVE., CHICAGO, ILL. 1892. 20. PLANS.
Wright’s one executed work of
academic design has a very per-
sonal elegance. It displays his
early ability to rival the Eastern
traditionalists at their own
game. But it has further signi-
ficance. The axial discipline
orders the looseness of Queen
Anne planning, and a new clar-
ity of external design replaces
earlier quaintness. The later
dormers are not by Wright.
Iliitil
- -
^1, D]R, ALLISON W. HARLAN HOUSE, dAIA GREENWOOD
AVE., CHICAGO, ILL. 1 89 2.
Wright’s best house of the early nineties, remark- fi
able for its premonitions of his i-.„ 1] ^.p — 'l l I } F
ture Prairie houses a decade later f H L
such as the hovering roof, the bal-l Li i-t
cony, the articulation of the front and j f i fTC^
the absence of stylistic reminiscence. |U IxJ l"
22 . PLAN
24 . PLANS.
23 . R O B E R T W .
ROLOSON HOUSES,
3213-3219 CALU-
MET AVE., CHICAGO,
ILL. 1894.
These are effec-
tively Wright’s only
executed examples
of the city row-
house. They show
unexpected mastery
of an unsympa-
thetic problem.
25. W. H. WINSLOW HOUSE, AUVERGNE PL.,
RIVER FOREST, ILL. 1893. 26. PLAN.
The Winslow house was Wright’s first inde-
pendent commission after leaving Sullivan.
The fine roman brickwork recalls the
Charnley house; while the rich terra cotta
frieze is like that on the Victoria Hotel, and
the design of the stonework about the en-
trance is close to that of the Wainwright
tomb. Thus the house has generally been
considered very Sullivanian. But as these
works of the Adler and Sullivan office owed
so much to Wright, it is evident that the
house rather continues a particular line of
design which Wright himself had initiated.
27. \ V . 1 1 . \V I TsT .S L O W
HOUSE, AUVERGNE PL.,
RIVER FOREST, ILL. 1 893 .
ENTR.ANCE ETAT.T..
28. REAR.
The resemblance of the
formal plan to that of
the Blossom house, over
which it is a great im-
provement, and of the
sheltering roof to that of
the Harlan house. should
make plain how little of
Sullivan’s influence
there is here. The com-
position of the front of
this house and the re-
fined and more Sulli-
vanian elegance of the
interior detail were
enormously influential
on the work of George
Maher and other mem-
bers of the later Chicago
School in the next ten
years.
The fine composition of
the rear of the house
with its bold conjunc-
tions of horizontal and
vertical elements, its
contrast of solid and void
and of rectangular and
polygonal forms was
hardly understood by
early imitators.
29 . CHAUNCEY L. WILLIAMS HOI
30 . FREDERICK BAGLEY HOUSE, I
The Bagley house is still |
essentially Suburban Rich- I
ardsonian, though much I
chastened in composition and I
detail. Its \’irtucs are almost I
conventional for the period.
The Williams house is much *
more original, with a first i
hint of Japanese rather than I
Queen Anne quaintness. I
3 1 . FRANCIS APARTMENTS, 43O4
FORESTVILLE AVE., CHICAGO,
ILL. 1895.
The Francis Apartments re-
semble the earlier Charnley and
Winslow houses in their urbane
dignity. At the client’s insis-
tence Wright used Tudor forms
in this house. But the design is
rational in character like good
old work, while the piazza
Americanizes the scheme.
32 . NATHAN G. MOORE HOUSE,
FOREST AVE., OAK PARK, ILL.
33. FRANCISCO TERRACE,
34. SECOND FLOOR
PLAN.
This was an impor- ^
tant early low-cost j
housing develop- j;^
ment, unfortunately
now poorly main- ~
tained. The galler-
ies foreshadow ^ —
twentieth century
European practice.
CHICAGO, ILL.
COURT.
35 . FRANCISCO TERRACE, 253-
257 FRANCISCO AVE., CHICAGO,
ILL, 1895. ENTRANCE FRONT.
APARTMENTS,
WEST WALNUT ST., CHICAGO,
The monumental dignity and
simplicity of these low rental
apartment houses is still im-
pressive.
39 . ENTRY.
42. IMISSKS I.I.OVI)
JONES WINDMILL,
HILLSIDE, SPRING
GREEN, WrS. 1896.
Trained as an engi-
neer, Wright in this
windmill and
watertower (still
one of the conspic-
uous landmarks of
his career) dis-
played his struc-
tural ingenuity in
the embrace of loz-
enge and polygon
— hence the name
Romeo and Juliet
— and in the brac-
ing floors within,
like the strengthen-
ing membranes
within a hollow
plant stem. To
Wright biological
analogy was from
the first full of ar-
chitectural sugges-
tion, since he al-
ways emulated a
principle rather
than imitated a
form. The battens
represent a step
toward the later
more structural
use of horizontal
sheathing.
■i—niiiii
fBEiifl
PI
liBB
nH
"JIZJ^Rsxi
=lin
JiMil
, • » '■'3
45. JOSEPH W. HUSSER HOUSE, l8o BUENA AVE., CHICAGO, ILL. 1899.
Developed from the MacAfee and Baldwin projects of the mid-nineties, this is the first of
Wright’s cross-shaped houses. The living floor is raised to make the most of the lake view.
The rooms are barely separated by wall spurs and columns, yet the long articulation of the
plan gives them considerable independence. The rich frieze about the upper storey recalls
that of the Winslow house. The elaborately moulded arches are likewise unexpectedly Sulli-
1 vanian. But this
46. PLAN.
is the last ap-
pearance of
such decorative
profusion. Al-
ready the
masses of the
stable block il-
lustrate a more
severe and ab-
stract tendency.
49. RWER FOREST GOLF CLUB, BONNIE BRAE AVE.,
RIVER FOREST, ILL. [ 19 OI.] PLAN. 50.
As enlarged the Golf ^
Club maintains the
structural and com- rvoi
positional principles 0 J LJi
already mature in i^i
the original front I 0? -
wing of 1 898; though
there is some loss of At IaLA
clarity, perhaps, m 5
the composition of ^ c"'- cT]
the octagonal lounge J .opiHf'KGlc
with its paired chim- r J "1 “U*
neys. The perspec- ; P^‘ _■
tive reveals the ^vay
the partially en- i
closed volumes inter-
sect better than i
photographs. ;
0 U H'O E 1 |!
room.
51. EDWARD C. WALLER DINING ROOM, AUVERGNE PL., RIVER FOREST, ILL. 1 899
The interweaving and .t*
overlapping of spatial
elements in an interior .... ^
reached mature expres-
sion in this remodelled jHHI
52. project; edward g.
WALLER HOUSE, RIVER
FOREST, ILL. iSoO.
53 . WARREN HICKOX HOUSE, 687 SOUTH HARRISON AVE., KANKAKEE, ILL. I9OO.
r- "TXr~ -1 ,=-1 , PLANS, r r I rn , The Hkkoxho,^
I i^j. J IS remarkable tor
i W7 i 54. .H the claritv and
the clarity and
consistency of its
open planning.
The formal but
asymmetrical
composition owes
something to Jap-
anese prints; but
the oriental look
is more due to co-
incidence than to
actual influence.
55. B. HARLEY BRADLEY HOUSE, 7OI SOUTH
HARRISON AVE., KANKAKEE, ILL. I9OO.
The larger Bradley house is less radical in
plan than its neighbor the Hickox house.
But the crossing of axes, more conspicuous
in the external design than in the plan, pre-
pares the way for such a mature master-
piece as the Willitts house two years later.
The plane-like character of the roof slopes,
the sheathing of the wooden construction
with plaster, the stud-skeleton revealed in /
the window mullions, express as clearly ’ t
and boldly as the River Forest Golf Club
Wright’s wholly personal mastery of the
American building tradition. 56. plan.
I4'l-
J^l 1
L ... U-. : wn 1
a _l
57 . B. HARLEY BRADLEY HOUSE, 70I SOUTH HARRISON AVE., KANKAKEE, ILL. I9OO. LIVING
ROOM.
With specially designed furniture and fittings Wright achieved a total unity in his Prairie
house interiors from the first. Although this house is less open in plan than its neighbor, the
Hickox house, the living room space is extended into subordinate areas and well lighted by
the great projecting bay window. The leaded patterns in the glass are characteristic of
Wright’s mature ornamental style based more on his early Froebel training than on Sullivan.
58. PERSPECTIVE r:
FROM LADIES HOME JOURNAL,’
FEBRUARY, I 9 OI,
nqysiin^ <m t.» _ ^
1 /*| :
1 VH
sy
:[z:i
pMf4 J fTfci^---: ' 1 i'x
HAL
rr-
SECOND FLOOR PLAN j I .■CHAMDER';. J
if project: “a HOME IN A PRAIRIE ; j
^ — 1| town” FOR CURTIS PUBLISHING CO.
GROUND FLOOR PLAN 5 O, SECTION.
^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ shows^ the
64, WILLIAM G. FRICKE
HOUSE, 540 FAIR OAKS
AVE., OAK PARK, ILL.
1902.
The bank project,
though significant for
its intended concrete
construction, and the
Fricke house still sug-
gest the nineties.
65. project: “vil-
lage BANK IN CAST
CONCRETE.” For^ncA:-
huilder, August, 1901.
67. THE HOUSE AS ALTERED.
The more mature and slightly larger twin of
the Hickox house of the previous year, the
Henderson house is also superior. The hip
roofs are more serene in feeling and the simple
straight line patterns in the leaded glasses are
unusually delicate.
66. F. B. HENDERSON
HOUSE, 301 SOUTH
KENILWORTH AVE., ELM-
HURST, ILL. 1901.
Unfortunately, as the
photograph indicates,
this house has been dam-
aged by the addition of
a covered second storey
porch over the open ter-
race in front of the liv-
ing room.
^HfB [OI:ii
■aiil^HHilB
piS^^^H
esiSiiM^— Mil
11^
m^jH
k^Bn^^pi
Ira
73 . WARD W. WILLITTS HOUSE, 715 SOUTH SHERIDAN RD,, HIGHLAND PARK, ILL.
This is the fost mas-
terpiece among the
Prairie houses. The
brilliant extension of
the cruciform plan,
the repeated hovering
lines of the upper and
lower eaves, the bank-
ing of the windows,
bring to final maturity
the promise of the j
houses and projects of
the preceding transi-
tional years.
75 . WARD W. WILLITTS HOUSE,
ROOM.
The horizontals of the
house are effectively
crossed by the vertical
window mullions and
wood - strips suggesting
the stud - skeleton be-
neath.
715 SOUTH SHERIDAN RD., HIGHLAND PARK, ILL. 1902. LIVING
No photograph can give a just sense of the
continuous flow of interior space in the
early Prairie houses, but the harmony of
the stained plaster walls, natural wood
trim and the specially designed furniture,
with accents of bright pattern in the
leaded glass, is
characteristically
represented in
this living room.
76 . SECOND FLOOR PLAN.
77 . CHARLES S. ROSS HOUSE,
SOUTH SHORE RD., DELAVAN
LAKE, WIS. 1902.
The finest of the “For-
est” houses which are
the more rustic broth-
ers of the Prairie
houses. The implica-
tions of the River For-
est Golf Club are here
compactly realized in
a lake side summer
house.
79 . project; yahara boat club, madison, wis. 1902. perspective and plan.
Despite the great
production of exe-
cuted work in the
Oak Park years,
some of Wright’s
finest architec-
tural conceptions
found expression at first only in projects. The little Yahara Boat Club was the first design
in which Wright carried to its logical conclusions his interest in abstract composition, unless
perhaps the lost Universal Portland Cement pavilion at the Pan-American Exposition in
Buffalo of the previous year was similar, as seems probable. Here in embryo we have the
spirit of some of the most famous later work of this decade and the next, the formal symmetry
and emphasis on the cantilevered slab of Unity Church, 1906, and the dexterous and subtle
81 . HILLSIDE HOME SCHOOL, HILLSIDE, SPRING GREEN, WIS. IQOQ.
The relation to the hill-slope, the sturdy base of rock-faced,
flesh-coloured stone, the heavy timber mullions above,
produce an effect at once monumental and appropriate^r;
to the countryside. The balance of
the asymmetrical pavilions, the skil- -
ful utilization of different lev^elsj'
within the living room and the gym-
nasium and by the connecting bridge '
contrast with the severe character of
the industrial Larkin Building, de-
signed immediately afterward, and yp'*'
suggest how his native landscape was
ultimately to inspire Wright in the
creation of his own house nearby.
82 . PLAN.
SIDE, SPRING GREEN, WIS. ig02.
LIVING ROOM PAVILION.
84 . LIVING ROOM FIREPLACE.
The batter of the random ma-
sonry, the structural window mul-
lions and the red-tiled roofs give
monumental character to the ex-
terior, which is echoed in the stone
and rough wood of the interior.
85 . SUSAN LAURENCE DANA HOUSE, EAST LAURENCE AVE. AT 4TH ST., SPRINGFIELD, ILL. I903. DINING ROOM. 86
88. GALLERY. BRONZE AND GLASS SCREEN. 87 .
92 . LARKIN COMPANY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, 68o SENECA ST., BUFFALO, N. Y. I904.
The massive front of the Larkin Building expresses consciously the innate monumentality
of industrial architecture. The fine brickwork, the skilfully placed accents of sculpture suggest
how severity may be dignified and lightened without loss of scale.
94. SIDE VIEW.
93. LARKIN COMPANY ADMINISTRATION BUILDING, 68o SENEGA ST., BUFFALO, N. Y. T904.
OFFICE INTERIOR.
The Larkin Build-
ing exi.st.s for its
interior, the office-
floors grouped
around the top-
lighted court and
further lighted
from the high
horizontal win-
dows between the
articulated piers
of the side walls.
97 . LARKIN COMPANY ADMINISTRATION
BUILDING, 680 SENEGA ST., 'BUFEALO, N. Y.
1904, ENTRANCE. 98 . OFFICE FURNISHINGS.
99 . E.-Z. POLISH FACTORY, 3005-3017 WEST
CARROLL AVE., CHICAGO, ILL. I905.
100 . DARWIN 1 ). MARTIN
HOUSE AND ADJUNCTS,
125 JEWETT PKWAY,
BUFFALO, N. V. 1904.
ESTATE PLAN.
The small Barton house
for Martin’s daughter
was begun the year be-
fore the big house vvdth
its conservatory, con-
nected with the house
by a gallery, and its ga-
rage with living quarters
above. There is thus a
complex of related
structures of similar ma-
terials and details rather
than a single house. In
the many interlocking
sub-spaces of the livdng
room in the big house
there is a more ample
development of the or-
ganization of space seen
at its most compact in
the front suite of rooms
of the small Barton
house. But the big house
has also a separate re-
ception hall of consider-
able size.
101. DARWIN D. MARTIN HOUSE, I 25 JEWETT PKWAY, BUFFALO, N, Y. I 904 .
The great size of the Martin house makes possible a subtle extension of the characteristic
Prairie house composition. The fine materials inside and out have stood up well despite the
long period the house has been empty. But the planting has now overflowed the terraced
beds to which it was once confined, giving the exterior an unkempt air. The lower photograph,
which is an old one, shows better the intended relationship between the architecture and
its original setting. The elaborated latin cross plan provides widely varied silhouettes in per-
spective from different angles; thus different photographs hardly seem of the same house.
102. VIEW FROM LAWN .
104. DARWIN D. MARTIN HOUSE, 1 25 JEWETT PKWAY, BUFFALO, N. Y. I<
LIVING ROOM.
The Martin hous<
once containec
some of Wright’:
most successfu
early furniture
The round chain
were repeated ir
1937 for the John-
son house in Ra-
cine. The exterioi
detail shows the
superb masonry,
including bird-
houses of stone.
110. W. A. GLASNER HOUSE, 85 O SHERIDAN RD., GLENCOE, ILL. I 905 .
111. PLAN.
Perhaps the first instance
of an all-year house in
which there is no separate
dining room. The extended
plan and attached octa-
gons give scale and interest
to a one storey house of no
great size.
^ 115 . FRANK L. SMITH BANK, DWIGHT, ILL. I906.
The bank displays a simple, formal dignity rarely
seen in small prairie towns.
Wright was rightly so pleased with the Walter Gerts
project that he proposed it for another client. The
plan, with its free use of solid wall planes and long
glass areas set at right angles,
is very like the boldest Euro- I
pean projects of twenty years r „ j
later.
1 1 7. PROJECT : WALTER GERTS
(aLEX DAVIDSON) HOUSE,
GLENCOE, ILL. (BUFFALO,
N. Y.). 1906.
116 . PLAN.
118 . UNITY
CHURCH, KENIL-
WORTH AVE. AT
LAKE ST., OAK
PARKj ILL. 1906,
SIDE VIEW.
Wright’s first exe-
cuted building of
poured concrete.
The pebble aggre-
gate provides a
textured surface.
«sn —
120. UNITY CHURCH, KENILWORTH
AVE. AT LAKE ST., OAK PARK, ILL.
1906 . INTERIOR OF AUDITORIUM.
121. INTERIOR OF PARISH HOUSE.
The composition of the interiors is
very rich, with interpenetrating cross
spaces at different levels below and
above the balconies.
122 . ROOKERY BUILDING REMOD-
ELLED ENTRANCE, LA SALLE AND
ADAMS STS., CHIC.'^GO, ILL. I905.
123 . UNITY CHURCH, KENIL-
WORTH AVE. AT LAKE ST., OAK
PARK, ILL. 1906. DETAIL OF PIER
“capitals.”
Almost exactly contemporary, the rich marble and
gold detail of the Rookery entrance contrasts with the
geometrical severity of the cast-concrete detail of
Unity Church. The patterns at the Rookery are still
almost SuUivaniari in their curvilinear opulence, suit-
able to the “Moorish” detail of Root's masterpiece
of the mid-eighties.
124 . P. A. BEACtlY HOUSE, 238 FOREST AVE., OAK PARK, ILL. I906.
125 . W. R. HEATH
HOUSE, 76 SOL-
DIERS PL., BUF-
FALO, N. Y. 1905.
LIVING ROOM.
An unusual Prai-
rie house exterior
of masonry and
plaster and a
typical contem-
porary living
room and dining
room.
126. A. W. GRIDLEY HOUSE, NORTH BATAVIA AVE., GENEVA, ILL. I906.
project: a fireproof
HOUSE for $5000” FOR
THE CURTIS PUBLISHING
CO. 1906.
130 . STEPHEN M. B.
HUNT HOUSE, 345
SOUTH SEVENTH AVE,,
LA GRANGE, ILL. I907.
This executed house is
nearly identical in plan
and design with the
project above.
131. project: warren mg Arthur concrete apartment house, kenwood, Chicago, ill. igo6.
132 . PLAN.
Wright’s projects for multiple dwellings in the Oak Park
years rarely came to exeeution. This apartment house
scheme is interesting for its intended construction of cast-
concrete and for the way in which the breaks in plan about
the open court, which let a maximum of light into the
apartments, are ordered and harmonized by the fenestra-
tion scheme and the projecting slab roof. The importance
of material to Wright appears in the contrast between the
solid design of this or the Unity Church and the light open
feeling of the temporary pavilion and the shop front on the
opposite page. This type of low apartment house about a
court open at one end to the street was much used in the
Chicago area and has many urbanistic advantages over
both rowhouses and solid apartment blocks. It is a great
pity this design of Wright’s was not executed.
133. LARKIN COMPANY PAmiON, JAMESTOWN EXPOSITION, JAMESTOWN,
SPECTIVE.
134. PEBBLES AND BALGH DECORATING SHOP, 1 107 LAKE ST., OAK PARK, ILL. I907. (Demolished.)
135 . BURTON J. WESTCOTT
HOUSE, 1340 EAST HIGI-I ST.,
SPRINGFIELD, OHIO, I907.
Two exceptions to the more
usual cruciform Prairie house
type. The Westcott house is a
large example and the Hor-
ner a small one of a type in
which the main block is
nearly square in plan, or at
least appears to be so.
136 . L. K. HORNER HOUSE,
1331 SHERWIN AVE., CHI-
CAGO, ILL. 1908.
With raised living floor and
entrance below, the long
ship-like form of the Tomek
house is anchored at the cen-
ter by the chimney and the
small bedroom storey above.
F. F. TOMEK HOUSE, I50 NUTTALLRD., RIVERSIDE, ILL. I907.
— 142. E. E. BOYNTON HOUSE, 1 6 EAST
|bLVD., ROCHESTER, N. Y.
-The Boynton house has a type
I ' ^|of plan which is extended
Ichiefly along one axis, at right
i'iangles to the street. Later
_ i-owners have glazed the
^'porches. The Evans house,
143. ; 'however, square in plan, is
■i'extended in composition to
Sicrown the hill slope by the
fjflanking porch and porte co-
s- 'Chere on either side.
^ J
150 . AVERY COONLEY
HOUSE, 300 SCOTTS-
WOOD RD., RIVERSIDE,
ILL, 1908. master’s
WING.
The driveway enters
the courtyard at the
rear of the house un-
der the bridge to the
right of the master’s
wing.
The ornament of the
upper walls is partly
of incised lines in the
plaster and partly of
inset coloured tiles.
151 . DETAIL OF WALL
PATTERN.
152 . AVERY COONLEY
HOUSE, 300 SGOTTS-
WOOD RD., RIVERSIDE,
ILL. 1908. LIVING ROOM.
153 . TERRACE.
The sloping ceilings,
stripped with wood and
pierced by grilles for
overhead lighting, are
the most striking ele-
ments in this spacious
Goonley house living
room.
156. ISABEL ROBERTS HOUSE, 603 EDGEWOOD PL., RIVER FOREST, ILL.
LIVING ROOM.
The first Ladie/ Home Journal project proposed a two-storey living room between a lower
library and dining room and in the large Dana house of 1903^ several rooms were carried
high. This was the first example of such dramatic vertical extension of space in a small house.
[it^^
■■S''i;'.:';;V?4
■•;, ' ‘e^r
157 . E. A. GILMORE HOUSE, 120 ELY PL., MADISON, wis. 1908. Knowii as the “Airplane House.
158. FRANK J. BAKER HOUSE, 507 LAKE AVE., WILMETTE, ILL. I 909 . 159. PLANS.
The tall living room of the Isabel Roberts house is here associated with a larger asymmetrical
plan. The stopping of the long horizontal eaves and bands of windows against the high living
room wing and its great vertical bay produces a most effective composition.
160 . MRS. THOMAS
I H. GALE HOUSE,
1 ; 6 ELIZABETH
h CT., OAK PARK,
' ; ILL. 1909.
The most ab-
stract in design
of the early
Prairie houses.
LOVER f-LQ Ofc-
166 . FREDERICK G. ROBIE HOUSE, 5757 WOODLAWN AVE., CHICAGO, ILL, I909. DINING ROOM.
The Robie interiors have been maintained by the Chicago Theological Seminary with all
their original furniture and fittings. The very architectural character of much of Wright’s
early furniture is evident in the dining room table with its corner lighting standards. The
specially woven rugs which, together with the upholstery and hangings, completed the some-
what forest-like harmonies of these years can be well seen here. The wood of the furniture
is usually identical with that of the trim. **
167 . COMO ORCHARDS SUMMER COLONY, DARBY, MONT. [iQIO.] PERSPECTIVE.
The two early schemes for a complete town of Bitter Root are not adapted
to illustration. The final
scheme, of which the
clubhouse and fourteen
cottages were built with-
out supervision, was for a
summer resort for mem-
bers of the University of
Chicago faculty. The
general plan is the most
ambitious of the period
and should be consid-
ered with Wright’s ear-
lier and later urbanistic
schemes.
W
y
■ ... T
— f I
i
hpiopp,
170 . HOTEL, WEST STATE ST. AND SOUTH FEDERAL AVE., MASON CITY, IOWA. I909.
171 . CITY N.\TIONAL BANK BUILDING
AND HOTEL, WEST STATE ST. AND
SOUTH FEDERAL .AVE., MASON CITY,
IOWA, 1909. THIRD FI.OOR PLAN.
7 - -
2-C
gECS
The Hotel gives a
foretaste of the
subtle interplay of
voids and solids
which was to
reach its climax in
the Midway Gar-
dens four years
later and harmo-
nizes well with the
more solid bank,
which flanks it on
the left.
PLAN
This is one of the most 172 . project: lexington terrace, Chicago, ill. 1909,
important unexecuted | - >-' ■
projects of *e period of 1{J
the Frame houses. . - P ■ ' ^ ' • - - ■ f ’|-T 'T | fP '
First projected in 1901,
the Lexington Terrace | * ^ -rpt.
scheme for large-scale | H I- r;;^^ i , p
middle class housing was I ^ „ f '
revived in 1909 with 1--K?— il-zz . "1 Sirr
somewhat simplified fa- < ^ LL ^
cades. Two ranges of ^ ^
apartments were set
back to back with an ! I d % ^ L
open passage between. f " ' 1^ - 4 M
The inner apartments T **■’*■ '• --Lu
opened on the large in-
terior court. The scheme r s?*tj'o Oair's ^ 0 ‘‘iEIj L.
was an advance over ' f ^ t-n .T »
Francisco Terrace, T i'
176 . TALIESIN n, SPRING GREEN, WIS. I914. THE GARDEN.
Originally Taliesin was quite small, but it was replaced on a larger scale after the 1914 fire.
House and garden alike have grown continuously and are still growing.
The late Prairie houses as a group are less interesting than those before 1910, nor were there
many of them. The best, such as the Angster house, are more like Taliesin itself than like
the earlier houses, with very open plans and rather solid massive exteriors. The Angster
house, like many of the houses of this decade, is so set among trees it cannot be adequately
photographed.
It is unfortunate that the Booth house, erected in 1915, is but a pale
shadow of the original project. This remarkable design, illustrated on
y;oR.
185 . AVERY COONLEY PLAYHOUSE, 35O FAIRBANKS RD., RIVERSIDE, ILL. I912.
The Coonley kindergarten project was as ambitious
and important as the Booth house project. Fortu-
nately the smaller executed playhouse preserves with
little loss its virtuosity of poised planes and balanced
masses. This sort of design goes back to the Yahara
Boat Club project of 1902 and leads immediately
into the vastly greater complexity of the Midway
Gardens. The interior is somewhat heavier and more
architectural in its membering than those before
1910, as if with increasing penetration of interior
and exterior space Wright sought to realize an
identity of scale outside and inside his buildings of
this decade.
190. SECOND AND THIRD
FLOOR PLANS.
project: FRANK LLOYD
WRIGHT HOUSE, GOETHE ST.,
CHICAGO, ILL. [ 1911 ]* per-
spective. 189.
The ground floor of the house
would have contained an en-
try and Wright’s offices. But
the chief interest lies in the
vertical flow of space at the
rear between the second and
third storeys.
191. MIDWAY GARDENS, COTTAGE GROVE AVE. AT 60TH ST., CHICAGO, ILL. I 914 .
After hardly a decade of life the Midway Gardens, ruined by Prohibition, were destroyed in
1923. Fortunately they can be fairly clearly recreated from drawings and photographs. The
birdseye perspective shows the tall restaurant building against the street, the open space
beyond set with outdoor tables and flanked by raised and covered terraces, and at the rear
the orchestra shell. The section should help more than a plan to make the scheme clear,
while many photographs display the various aspects of the large and complex whole as it
was in its heyday.
With the Midway Gardens Wright’s
work arrives at a richness and com-
plexity of architectural form only
prepared for in earlier work. No-
where was interior and exterior
space more elaborately interwoven
and freely composed, while the
ornamental effects are of endless
variety and novelty. Concrete blocks
provide surfaces of abstract repeat-
ing patterns which were to be once
more much utilized in the California
w^ork of the twenties. Sculpture and
wall paintings designed by Wright
parallel the most advanced forms of
European painters, barely known at
this time in America through the
Armory Show. And the open frames
of the tower tops, a sort of linear
sculpture of space, reach forward to
aesthetic concepts hardly imagined
abroad at this date. But, alas, the
luxury, the gaiety, and the utiliza-
tion of the outdoors had a sophisti-
cation for which the urban world of
Chicago was not prepared twenty
five years ago.
192. MIDWAY GARDENS, COTTAGE GROVE AVE. AT 6oTH ST., CHICAGO, ILL. I 914 . SECTION.
193. MIDWAY GARDENS, COTTAGE GROVE AVE. AT 6 oTH ST., CHICAGO, ILL. I 914 .
194. MIDWAY GARDENS, COT-
T.AGE GROVE AVE. AT 60 TII ST.,
CHICAGO, ILL. 1914 . STREET
FRONT. 195. UPPER TERRACES.
The detail of the brickwork and
the patterned concrete blocks
shows the underlying solidity
and seriousness behind the fes-
tive trappings. The roof terraces
show the virtuosity of architec-
tural form and ornament at its
finest and most expansive.
196. MIDWAY GARDENS, COTTAGE GROVE AVE. AT 6 oTH
ST., CHICAGO, ILL. I 914 . INTERIOR.
197. DINING ROOM FURNI-
TURE. 198. WIRE FURNI-
The wire furniture designs,
Kf ■ f metal furniture of
’ M. ^ I ’J" ’ the Larkin Building, indi-
^ ' . cate Wright’s wide interest
ll]h' in materials.
'X
199. FRANCIS W. LITTLE HOUSE, “nORTHOME,” R.F.D. 3,
WAYZATA, MINN. 1913- . j
200. PLAN,
The great extension of the Little house and the
surrounding trees make it impossible to photograph
as a whole. The exterior view overleaf shows that
the arches of the project were omitted in execution.
This is effectively a one-storey house, but the din-
ing room and kitchen are below on the left.
The great living room, illustrated on the second
page following, is the most spacious domestic in-
terior Wright had ever
designed, though
doubtless those of the
McCormick project
might have been simi-
lar. Characteristically
the height is measured
for the observer by the
projection at transom level, while the
external pitch of the roof is echoed in
tiie slanting planes at the sides of the
ceiling.
200 a. FRANCIS W. LITTLE HOUSE, “nORTHOME,” R.F.D. 3, WAYZATA, MINN. 1913-
. LIVING ROOM.
201. EMIL BACH HOUSE, 7415 SHERIDAN RD., CHICAGO.
ILL. 1915. 202. PLANS.
The Bach house uses the square plan which was
a frequent alternative to more articulated types
in the Prairie period. But in this later period,
when Wright was active on larger edifices, the
membering of the small houses is often some-
what heavy. The projecting trellises are most
successful elements of detail.
209. JOSEPH J. BAGLEY HOUSE, LAKE\1EW AND CEDAR AVES., GRAND BEACH, MICH. I916.
The group of summer cottages at Grand Beach designed in the middle of the decade are
quite different from the cottages of the opening of the century at Delavan and White Lakes.
The breadth and boldness of
composition, curiously formal
yet very simple, and the
Taliesin-like treatment of the
wood and plaster make these
among the most agreeable of
Wright's smaller houses. The
parti of the Vosburgh house
(next page) resembles that of
the Isabel Roberts house, while
that of the Bagley house has, at
much smaller scale, something
of the pavilion treatment of the
McCormick project. Unfortu-
nately the sites make photo-
graphs difficult to obtain.
MODEL.
214 . project: aline
BARNSDALL THEATER^
OLIVE HILL, SUNSET
BLVD., LOS ANGELES,
GAL. [1920].
MODEL CUT OPEN.
Work on Barnsdall
project began about
1915*
215 . project: mov-
ing PICTURE THEATER,
GINZA, TOKIO, 1918.
216 . HENRY J. ALLEN HOUSE, 255 ROOSEVELT BLVD., WICHITA, KAN. 1917. GARDEN.
The lovely garden of the Allen house, around which the wings of the house, the garage and
a wall form an enclosure, is doubtless a Western version of the garden courts of Wright’s
contemporary houses built in Japan, of which photographs are today unobtainable. Certainly
the L-shaped plan, with one low wing for the living room, is rather new, and emphasizes the
enclosed garden rather than the crossing of axes at the core of the houses before 1910. Reflect-
ing pools are henceforth an important feature of Wright’s larger houses of succeeding decades.
217. HENRY J. ALLEN HOUSE, 255 ROOSEVELT BLVD., WICHITA, KAN. I917. 218. PLANS.
The heavy rough-
surfaced brickwork of
these years has less ele-
gance than that of the
two preceding decades.
But it accords with the
larger scale and the
firmer articulation of
the architectural ele-
ments. The rear tower
was not executed as
designed.
L_j
219. IMPERRL HOTEL, TOKio, JAPAN, [i9i6]-i922. PLANS. The plan of the Imperial Hotel
forms a great H with the large open public rooms in the thick cross bar and the small bed-
room units in the side wings.
222 . IMPERIAL HOTEL, TOKIO, JAPAN, [l9l6]-I922. GENERAL VIEW.
The monumental scale of the Hotel can be grasped by comparing this and the preceding
view with the exterior details which follow.
223 . IMPERIAL HOTEL, TOKIO, JAPAN, [iQlSj-igSS. GARDEN COURT.
Water and evergreens are as important as brick and lava in the composition of the exterior.
224 . IMPERIAL HOTEL, TQKIO, JAPAN, [l9l6]-192:
entrance. m II i
EMPEROR S
STRUCTURAL
DIAGRAMS.
!a>onE|iiEMOim JHEW of buch
BAiEHENT
BOM WCES. OUIER iHELl
loisaii mV AWD vewioily with i
3HKXHEIB.IAID UP FWE COWET HGH i
'MW OaCPctE, POUMD BV HAND
nDORJlAM BAlAHCECWEII.aNrKAlSUPfOn'i
ASATBAYREJIfONAWaTtia FINGEM TO
FBEVENT FAILURE UNOK EARIKHJAKE iTBAIH
228 . IMPERIAL HOTEL, TOKIO, JAPAN, [l9l6]-I922.
Details of the abstract lava sculpture of the exterior.
231 , IMPERIAL HOTEL,
TOKIO, JAPAN, [1916],
— 1922. LOBBY.
Those who hav^c not
seen the vast, richly
decorated public
rooms of the Hotel
find them hard to
understand in photo-
graphs. The lobby in
its materials and spa-
tial composition is
closely related to the
exterior treatment.
232 . BALLROOM.
With its open balconies
the lobby is an enlarged
version of the Midway
Gardens interior. The
subordinate spaces lead-
ing off in various direc-
tions suggest admirably
that this is the core of the
circulation of the whole
structure. The great
trusses of the ballroom
are elaborately decorated
with abstract designs in
colour. The carved lava
panels represent conven-
tionalized peacocks. Of
these there are eight alto-
gether.
233 . project: odawara hotel, nagoya, japan. [1917].
234 . jn^u gakuen school, tokio, japan. 1921.
The Odawara Hotel
project is more Japa-
nese than the impe-
rial in its delicately
articulated structure.
The setting on the
hillcrcst would have
been particularly ef-
fective. The group of
buildings at the Jiyu
Gakuen School are
Wright’s most consid-
erable Japanese work
after the Imperial.
The wood and plaster
construction is more
conventionally
Wrightian and forms
a good background
for the delicate and
varied native flora.
The moderate scale is
well established in the
structural members.
235. “hollyhock house,” sunset and Hollywood
BLVDS., EDGEMONT ST. AND VERMONT AVE,
LOS ANGELES, CAL. I 920 . 236. PLAN.
Wright had met Miss
Barnsdall before leav-
ing for Japan and work
on the designs for her
Olive Hill house and
other projects went on
parallelly with the
building of the Im-
perial Hotel whenever
Wright came on brief
trips to America in
these years. The house
design was essentially
complete with the re-
visions dated 1918, but
construction fell in the
last Japanese years.
238. “hollyhock house,
SUNSET AND HOLLYWOOD
BLVDS., EDGEAIONT ST. AND
VERMONT AVE., LOS ANGE-
LES, GAL. 1920. SIDE VIEW.
239. LIVING ROOM.
The superb Olive Hill site
permitted the great solid
masses of the exterior of the
house to stand clean against
the Sierra Madre moun-
tains to the north.
' V
243. project: edward h. doheny ranch development, sierra madre mountains, near
LOS ANGELES, CAL. I92I.
During the Japanese years Wright had spent some time each year in Los Angeles working on
the Barnsdall commissions and the decade of the twenties opens with a series of important
projects and executed works in California. The largest project for a vast development in the
Sierra Madre mountains was already to make use of the textile block process.
During 1921 Wright also made designs for Cali-
fornia in more conventional concrete construc-
tion. In the store project the chief interest is the
clean surface, twenty years later become com-
monplace in Los Angeles commercial building,
and the way natural light is brought down into
the shopwindows behind a sheltering slab.
More significant than the construction and
plans of the individual Doheny houses is the
general layout by which the mountains
north of Los Angeles would have been en-
hanced by the romantic variety and stra-
tegic placing of many separate structures
rather than ruined by the chaotic and un-
planned developments which were already
taking place in Hollywood. But like W right’s
important earlier projects for large-scale
residential developments this and the con-
temporary Desert Valley project and the
Tahoe Lake Summer colony unfortunately
came to nothing. Its possibilities can only be
glimpsed in the remaining general perspec-
tives, such as that illustrated here.
244. project: merchandising building,
LOS ANGELES, CAL. 1 92 1.
Mm4
24 ' 6 . BIG TRK li TYPE CABIN.
Some families were to be housctl
in cabins on land, more in
houseboats moored in the lake :
a new sort of summer resort.
248 . FAMILY
BARGE. jpiir'
247 . BARGE
TWO. 'Ka
249 . MRS. GEORGE MADISON
MILLARD HOUSE, 645 PROS-
PECT CRESCENT, PASADENA,
CAL. 1923.
The first to be designed of
the California textile block
houses was Mrs. Millard’s
“La Miniatura” in its un-
usual site at the bottom of
a ravine. The entrance is
on the middle lev'^el at the
rear of the three- storey
house. The dining room
opens on the terrace at the
level of the reflecting pool.
The two-storcy living room
opens on the projecting
gallery above. Services and
bedrooms — reached by a
gallery above the living
room — are at the rear. The
simplicity and compact-
ness of the plan and com-
position scheme with the
bold extension of space in-
ward, outward and up-
ward of the living room
are very parallel to the
early projects of Le Cor-
busier, first coming to exe-
cution in the same year.
But the evident thickness
of the textile block -walls,
their patterned surfaces
and sparkling penetrations
make the visual result en-
tirely different, as does the
intimate relation to the site
and the luxurious planting.
254. MRS. GEORGE MADISON MILLARD
HOUSE, 645 PROSPECT CRESCENT,
PASADENA, GAL. I 923 . DETAIL.
252. LIVING ROOM.
253. LIVING ROOM.
The way the perforated blocks ani-
mate the interior with points of light
repeats at small scale the spatial pene-
trations between the piers of the front
windows and around the fireplace
above and below the gallery. The an-
tique furniture which Mrs. Millard
had on sale is unfortunately not very
appropriate to the setting the interi-
ors provide.
M*--*
P!ii:na
[i;iii^l|lli[illl|j|j|
255. DR. JOHN STORER HOUSE, 8l6l HOLLYWOOD
BLVD., LOS ANGELES, GAL. [1923].
256. PLANS
This elegant pavilion has not so happy a
site as “La Miniatura”; but the composi-
tion is looser and freer with changes of
height in the silhouette due to the varying
internal heights of the different rooms
and terraces.
LIVING ROOM.
As the Nakoma Country
Club was to occupy the
historic Winnebago Indian
Camping Ground site,
Wright echoed in the form
of the main roof, as in some
of the Tahoe cabins a few
years before, the pitch of a
wigwam. It is one of the
rare instances of Wright’s
specific inspiration from an
artistic form of the past.
BHU
HI
llll
273. TALIESIN m, SPRING GREEN, WIS. I925- , LIVING ROOM.
Above the low ceiling bands at either side rise the slanting planes, differentiated by varied
wooden stripping, which follow the roof pitch. Japanese screens, Chinese sculpture, and great
tree branches complete the furnishing of the room. The furniture is scaled to the architecture.
TALIESIN III,
SPRING GREEN,
wis. 1925-
The particular
character of
the living
room is car-
ried through
into the bed-
rooms as in all
Wright houses.
Richly tex-
tured fabrics
and furs cre-
ate an effect of
luxury as well
as comfort.
BEDROOM. 274 .
Taliesin is a
Northern
house and
accepts the
blanketing
snow as grace-
fully as the
hills around.
The blue Ming
jar is one of
the fine orien-
tal objects of
art with which
Taliesin is sur-
rounded.
ENTRANCE IN
WINTER. 275 .
276. OCOTILLO DESERT CAMP, FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT WINTER HEADQUAR-
TERS, SALT RANGE, NEAR CHANDLER, ARIZONA. I927. 277.
The Ocotilio Camp was built for Wright and his
assistants to use while designing and building San ss. ^ «
Marcos -in -the -Desert. .y "
The battened lower /
walls with canvas over ' . A
wooden frames above
provide a sort of super- * rAA/.""'
tent admirably suited to
the climatic conditions ■
of the desert in winter. ' ^ ^
Here Wright worked z
both with a new environ- ^ '
ment and with materials I k ■. A ^ ^ ^
hardly considered archi-
tectural before. . . '
278 . OCOTILLO DESERT CAMP, FRANK LLOYD WRIGHT WINTER HEADQUARTERS, SALT RANGE,
NEAR CHAN-
DLER, ARIZONA.
CABINS.
DETAIL.
INTERIOR.
Wrights
power of sim-
ple and ele-
mentary ab-
stract compo-
sition. is boldly
illustrated in
these tent-
cabins.
281. project: san marcos-in-the-desert, near chandler, Arizona. [1927.] perspective
282. texture model.
The samples of the blocks to be used were set
up at the Ocotillo Camp.
The entrance was beneath the main block; above were lobby and lounge, and on top the
dining room and kitchen whose plans are given. Flanking the long facade of the hotel were
the independent houses — two are illustrated on the next page. The second terrace plan indi-
cates how the individual guest balconies were given considerable privacy by interpolated
planting.
287. project: Wellington and ralph cudney house, san
MARCOS-IN-THE-DESERT, NEAR CHANDLER, ARIZONA. [l927-]
The Young project was rather like the Los Angeles houses. But the
diagonal placing of the blocks and the use of window lights of the
same measure as the blocks were innovations. The Cudney project
used the same blocks as the hotel, but its more “reflex” composi-
tion makes the inspiration of the Saguaro cactus more evident.
289 . DARWIN D. M.^RTIN HOUSE, DERBY, N. Y.
oan '927.
Built without the architect’s supervision, this
house is somewhat clumsy in detail compared
with the contemporary work at Taliesin. But
the rich growth of planting now gives it a grace
worthy of Wright,
and it is well ff=^ r nff um iM m L main-
295. project: Alexander chandler block
HOUSE, CHANDLER, ARIZONA. I927. 296. PLANS.
The Chandler block houses, based on the Monolith
Homes project of 1919, were among the most suc-
cessful of Wright’s small house schemes. Despite
their very different construction they lead toward
the Usonian houses of today.
■
■
li
CSfi
Ip
BSMHilfa
299 . RICHARD
LLOYD JONES
HOUSE, 3700
BIRMINGHAM
RD., TULSA,
OKLA. 1929.
ENTRANCE.
The human
figures help to
give a true
conception of
the scale of
this house.
COURT,
301 . RICHARD
LLOYD JONES
HOUSE, 3700
BIRMINGHAM
RD., TULSA,
OKLA. 1929.
DINING ROOM.
The remarkable
interior effect of
the very open
construction
should be clear.
302 .
BILLIARD ROOM.
This is one of the most remark-
able of Wright’s many fine un-
executed projects of the twenties.
The planning produced what is
practically a series of superposed
penthousesj each with its own
large terrace. The bold contrast
of plain concrete surfaces and
large open glass areas, through
which the cantilevers can be
seen, parallels remarkably closely
the principles, supposedly so
antithetical, of the “interna-
tional” architects of Europe at
this time. But the clarity of the
conception and the design is as
much the natural product of
Wright’s genius as the rich elabo-
ration of the projects of the
earlier twenties.
F1R.5T TEB,f!.fiCE
305. MODEL
307. project: st. mark’s
TOWER, NEW YORK CITY,
1929. PLANS AND SECTION.
The cantilever principle of the Chicago skyscraper project
is here combined with most ingenious polygonal planning
in a small apartment tower intended for a New York site.
Somewhat similar interlocked duplexes were used a decade
later in the Suntop Homes in Ardmore, while the general
character of the project is repeated in the grouped towers
of the next year for Chicago and the Crystal Heights hotel
1 %
project for Washington of 1940.
The grouped
apartment
towers of the
later Chicago
project have a
wider urbanistic
significance than
the Noble and St.
Mark’s Tower
apartment proj-
ects of the previ-
ous year, leading
directly to the
great Crystal
Heights scheme
of 1940, which is
also unfortu-
nately still only
a project.
309. PLANS.
308. project:
GROUPED APARTMENT
TOWERS, CHICAGO,
ILL. 1930.
It is curious to recall
how fantastic these
Wright skyscraper
projects of the late
twenties once seemed.
For it should now be
evident to almost
every one that they
were more practical
and straightforward
in every way than
most contemporary
skyscraper building.
310. project: “house on the mesa.” [ 1931 .] model exhibited at the museum of
MODERN ART, NEW YORK, 1 932.
311. PLAN.'
When Wright’s work
was brought into direct
conjunction with that of
the “international” arch-
itects at the Museum of
Modern Art exhibition
in 1932, how much the
“old master” was a mas-
ter and how youthful his
achievement continued
to be was made mani-
fest. Four years later the
Kaufmann house real-
ized the boldness of this
design, but with perfect
adaptation to a quite
different site. For this
project was designed for a Western mesa, while the Kaufmann house was to be cantilevered
over an Eastern forest stream.
J
Ly
_
LJ
I ^ I 312 . project: WALTER DAVIDSON SHEET STEEL
I FARM UNITS. I932. MODEL EXHIBITED AT
j MUSEUM OF MODERN ART. 1940. 313 . PLAN.
Wright, always close to the land in thought
sought in these units to bring to the farmer
the advantages of modern architecture in
general and of prefabrication in particular.
The compactness, the rational organiza-
tion of a complex of dwelling and working
elements, and the relation to road and land
are all worth noting.
314, project: malcolm willey
HOUSE, MINNEAPOLIS, MINN. I 93 ! 2 .
MODEL EXHIBITED AT MUSEUM OF
MODERN ART, 1940.
The Willey project
opens a new cycle of
house designs. The solid
and essentially tradi-
tional construction of
brick and wood is boldly
rethought. The living 315. plan
quarters are placed on
the upper level. The
particular motif of the
balcony parapet of
lapped siding is one that
was destined to be much ■
used in later houses.
’ *3 Ef * 'S'
316. MALCOLM WILLEY HOUSE,
255 BEDFORD ST., MINNEAPOLIS,
MINN. 1934 . 317. PLAN.
318. LIVING ROOM.
The executed Willey house is at
first sight rather more conven-
tional than the earlier project.
subordinate spaces and connected with the
stream below by a staircase. The upper
floors consist of various individual suites each
opening upon its own terrace. The hous(i is
very solid to the rear where the masonry
walls connect with the natural rock below.
But between the parapets and the roof slabs
above, the front walls are all of glass set in
metal frames. The view on the opposite
page from below the waterfall reveals the
audacity of the conception; it is unequalled,
perhaps, in contemporary architecture and
justly one of the most famous modern houses
in the world.
322. EDGAR J. KAUFMAN N
FIOUSE, BEAR RUN, PENNA.
1936. 323. STEPS TO POOL.
The side of the Kaufmann
houses reveals a character-
istic plating of horizontals
and verticals, but the com-
position is richer than
ever, despite the simplicity
of the means. The relation
of the rough ashlar base
to the concrete slabs and
parapets is clearer in the
small view.
324 . EDGAR J. KAUF-
MANN OFFICE, KAUF-
MAN N DEPARTAIENT
STORE, 4.00 FIFTH
AVE., PITTSBURGH,
PENNA., 1937,
325 . CYPRESS PLY-
WOOD MURAL : DETAIL
The walls above and
to the left of the desk.
328 . project;
CAPITAL JOURNAL
BUILDING, SALEM,
OREGON, 1931.
PERSPECTWE.
327 . S. C. JOHNSON AND SON, INC.,
ADMINISTRATION BUILD-
ING, 1525 HOWE ST.,
RACINE, WIS.
'936-1939-
TESTING
SAMPLE PIER,
1936.
The Capital Journal project was the prototype of the
Johnson Building of five years later. There the scheme
of hollow concrete piers reinforced with metal tissue
and supporting only their own lily-pad-like tops was
worked out in theory. The Capital Journal building
was not so large and complex and its side walls would
have been of metal and glass instead of the brick
screens of the Johnson Building.
To test the strength of the new type of piers, one was
erected in Racine on the Johnson site in the summer
of 1936 and loaded far beyond anything it would ever
have to carry.
ir
329.
HALF PLAN
AND
SECTION.
330. S. C. JOHNSON AND SON, INC.,
ADMINISTRATION BUILDING,
1525 HOWE ST., RACINE,
WIS. 331. SECTION OF PIER.
332. PLAN.-aeS3^
The plan and the in-
terior, with the section
of a pier, reveal the re-
markable construction
and the resultant new
space composition of
this famous building.
The special lighting ef-
fect is merely suggested.
333, S. C. JOHN-
SON AND SON,
INC., ADMINISTRA-
TION BUILDING,
1525 HOWE ST.,
RACINE, WIS.
1936-1939-
334. ENTRANCE.
The night view re-
veals more clearly
than the day view
the bands of glass
tubing at the point
where a conven-
tional cornice
would be expected.
This emphasizes
that the walls are
merely non -sup-
porting screens.
335. S. G. JOHNSON AND SON, INC., ADMINISTRATION BUILD-
ING, 1936-1939. EXTERIOR CORNER. 336. CEILING DETAIL.
337. VIEW INSIDE BANDS OF GLASS TUBING,
338, VIEW THROUGH INTERIOR WALL OF GLASS TUBES,
The tubing is used internally for translucent walls.
339. HERBERT F. JOHNSON HOUSE, WIND POINT, NORTH OF RACINE, WIS. I937.
This, according to
Wright, is “the last of
the Prairie houses”. The
plan is “zoned”, with the
living quarters in the
center, the masters’
rooms in one wing, the
children’s in another, the
service in a third and the
guests and garages in a
fourth. Much is made of
the shallow ravines of
the prairie site, so that
the wings of the house
ride the grassed slopes
as if they were floating
on waves, lifted by the
lightness of the project-
ing balconies.
The spiral
stair rising to
an observa-
tory, the tall
chimney and
the balconies
make the most
of the very
high space of
the central
unit of the
house, from
which the four
specialized
arms of the
plan project in
all directions.
341 .
. I.IVINO ROOM.
342 .
The various
f unction.s of
the main liv-
ing space are
separated by
differences of
level and low
screens and
built-in units
of furniture,
beneath the
clerestorcyed
roof, around
the central
chimney.
343. HERBERT JACOBS HOUSE, 44 1 TOEPFER ST., WEST-
MORLAND, NEAR MADISON, WIS. I 937 . PLAN. 344.
The Usonian house type appeared first in the Hoult
project of 1936. The executed Jacobs house of 1937 is
practically identical. The house rests on a concrete
floor slab with the heating pipes below. The walls are
of broad boards and sunk redwood battens inside and
out with a core of plywood. The roofs are of crossed
two-by-fours. The brick-walled kitchen and bathroom,
rise above the rest of the roof for ventilation. The L-
shaped plan partially encloses the garden on which
both living room and bedrooms open through ranges
of french doors.
345 . HERBERT JACOBS HOUSE, 44I TOEPFER ST., WESTMORLAND, NEAR MADISON, WIS. 1937.
The Rosenbaum house is a larger, more perfect version of the Jacobs house.
346 . STANLEY ROSENBAUM HOUSE, RIVERVIEW DR., FLORENCE, ALA. 1 939.
355 . TALIESIN WEST, MARICOPA MESA, PARADISE VALLEY, NEAR PHOENIX, ARIZONA.
. . • TERRACE.
Above the massive
canted base of
rough blocks of red
desert stone set in
concrete, the super-
structure is light
and tent-like, chief-
ly canvas screens
and wooden louvers
held by timber
trusses. The rich
desert flora forms
the chief decora-
tion.
357. TALIESIN WEST, MARICOPA MESA, PARADISE VALLEY, NEAR PHOENIX, ARIZONA. I938- .
ENTRANCE FROM THE POOL.
The deck chair helps to give the human scale of this remarkable structure. The canvas screens
between the wooden trusses can be swung open like those at the entrance to let the air through.
TAOF.SIT'J WEST,
>rARICOPA TVfESA,
PARADISE VAL-
LEY, NEAR
PHOENIX, ARI-
ZONA. 1938- .
358 . GENERAL
I.IVING ROOM.
The Structure of
the trusses over
the masonry
piers and the
li.^'hting effect
of the canvas
screens can be
clearly seen
here.
359 . MR. Wright’s fireplace.
The variety of the interiors is
surprising in this desert camp.
The more extended outer por-
tions are light and tent -like
above the solid foundation
walls. The inner core of the
structure is, on the contrary,
heavy and cavelike. The
monumental scale of the fire-
place, the richness of the
Oriental works of art, the bold
fabrics and the desert flora
combine in an interior har-
mony as fine as that of the
Taliesin living room in Wis-
360 . project: Life “house for a family of $5000-.$6 ooo income.” 1938.
361 . PLANS.
The Life house is considerably larger
than the Usonian type and makes
more use of
masonry. The
executed
Schwartz
house follows
the Life proj-
ect very close-
ly. The interior
is however
typical of the
interiors of the
later thirties,
both in large and small houses, in its
finished use of structural wood and
of fine exposed brick work.
363. LIVING ROOM.
362. BERNARD SCHWARTZ HOUSE, STILL BEND, TWO RIVERS, WIS. 1939.
364. project: ralph jester (martin j. pence) house, palos verdes, cal.
HAWAn). 1938 (1940). MODEL EXHIBITED AT
MUSEUM OF MODERN ART, NEW YORK, 194O. 365.
Entirely different from the other houses of the late
thirties is this project for a house of plywood. As
plywood is strongest when curved, each room is
nearly a complete circle of the appropriate size
opening on a central covered space. The piers are
of rough stone boldly contrasted with the smooth,
grained surfaces of the plywood. Such a pattern of
curves is wholly new in Wright’s architecture and
suggests all sorts of possibilities for the future.
( HILO,
366, SUNTOP HOMES, SUTTON RD. NEAR SPRING AVE.,
ARDMORE, PENNA. I939. MODEL EXHIBITED AT
MUSEUM OF MODERN ART, NEW YORK, I94O.
367. PLANS,
, ■ ‘ p' . : i SECTION.
. .. 1368. GEN-
1 '' I □ -I"' ... / ERAL PER-
p* . a ' SPEGTIVE.
-U' , — iifl « ' -1 Only one of
370, 370a. approach,
FROM BELOW AND
FROM ABOVE.
EDGAR J. KAUFMANN GUEST HOUSE, BEAR
RUN, PENNA. 1939 .
Of the same concrete and local stone, the
Kaufmann guest house is much quieter
than the big house below. But its severity
is dramatized by the curved and stepped
slab roof of the approach.
374. project: group of seven usonian houses, okemos, migh. 1939. model exhibited
AT museum of modern ART, I94O.
KATHERINE WINKLER
AND ALMA GOETSGII
HOUSE, HULETT RD.,
OKEMOS, MICtl. 1939 .
376. FRONT \TEW.
377. REAR VIEW.
This is perhaps the best
Usonian house in plan
and in elegance of
finish. The walls are of
redwood inside and
out; the ceiling of ply-
wood. Unfortunately
the final furnishings
had not been installed
when the photographs
were taken. The partial
seclusion of the “work-
space” and the area in
front of the fireplace
from the main living
room sweeping from
the french doors of the
front to the rear is
most subtly handled.
378. INTERIOR.
379. GEORGE D. STURGES HOUSE, 449 SKYWAY
RD., BRENTWOOD HEIGHTS, CAL, I939.
380. PLAN AND SECTION,
382. LIVING ROOM. 383.
381. STANLEY ROSENBAUM HOUSE, RIVERVIEW DR., FLORENCE, ALA. I939.
DETAIL
CORNER.
384. SIDNEY BAZETT HOUSE, lOI RESERVOIR RD., HILLSBOROUGH, CAL, [ 1940 ]
A California IjllllllllllllllllllllHHI^^PIIIIIIIHH
house based,
like the Han-
na house, on
6 0 ° - 3 0 °
angles but
smaller and
simpler. The
ceil-
ingoftheliv-
room ef-
fectively en-
hances the
sense of
height and
direction.
DINING ROOM.
386 . SIDNEY BAZETT
HOUSE, lOI RESER-
VOIR RD., HILLS-
BOROUGH, CAL.
[1940]*
View from below.
387 . LIVING ROOM.
The dramatic site
on the hill slope is
well utilized with
an enclosed terrace
above between the
wings and an open
porch toward the
view.
388 . LLOYD LEWIS
HOUSE, LITTLE ST,
Mary’s rd., liberty-
VILLE, ill. 1940.
389 . PLANS,
Raised above the damp
river edge, the Lewis
house makes interest-
ing use of varying levels
in an effectively one-
storey house with open
ground storey entrance
loggia below the living
room.
390. BEDROOM WING.
The Lewis living room has
the handsomest and most
harmonious furnishing of
any of Wright’s later houses
in tones of dull brick pink
and somewhat yellowed
green against the brick and
the beautiful cabinet-work
of the light wood sheathing.
The living room opens on a
screened terrace raised up
among the trees.
391. LIVING ROOM.
LLOYD LEWIS HOUSE, LITTLE
ST. Mary’s rd., liberty-
\TLLE, ILL. 1940.
394. ROSE P.MISON
HOUSE, OR.^NGE RD.,
PHOENIX, ARIZONA.
1940. LIVING ROOM.
The superstructure
of the house is of
wood like the Uson-
i a n houses, the
canted parapets of
lapped siding .skil-
fully related to the
batter of the ma-
sonry elements. The
tall living room
opens on a high ter-
race toward the chief
view through french
doors while the other
sides of the house are
solid to shut out heat
and wind and lighted
only by slots cut in
the sheathing
boards. The interior
has curtains espe-
cially woven by
Henning - Rees.
Large saguaros have
been planted and
stone terraces added
to the rear since
these pictures were
taken.
395. VIEW OF LIVING
ROOM TERRACE AND
ENTRANCE FRONT OF
HOUSE.
396 . JOHN C. PEW HOUSE, 365O
y MENDOTA DR., SHOREWOOD HILLS,
NEAR MADISON, WIS. I94O.
FIREPLACE.
PLANS.
399 . PASSAGE.
There is much
similarity nat-
urally in the
interiors of the
houses of the
last few years
and these two
views of the
Manson house,
which is par-
ticularly ap-
propriately
furnished, can
well stand as
typical of
many others.
The brick and
wood of the
structural
walls form the
interior finish.
Although the
rooms flow to-
gether in plan
there are al-
ways secluded
corners, usu-
ally a private
study as well as
the large liv-
ing -room- din-
ing-room
space.
400 . STUDY
FIREPLACE.
401 . CLARENCE W. SONDERN HOUSE,
3600 BELLEVIRW KANSAS CITY,
MO. 1940. 402 . BEDROOM.
A typical Usonian house, unfortu-
nately photographed before the
planting was completed. The bed-
room illustrates well the character
of the sleeping accommodations in
these small houses, relatively re-
stricted but well-lit and ventilated
and with built-in hanging space and
inconspicuous bed frames. The bath-
rooms are similarly finished but are
not large enough to be photo-
graphed. Indeed the finish is the
same throughout the houses.
405 . FLORIDA SOUTHERN COLLEGE, LAKELAND, FLA
PROJECT, 1938; CONSTRUCTION, I94O- .
The ample provision for parking and the direct approach to
the Theater are conveniences all colleges need today and very
few have. Open paved terraces are effectively set
before the chief buildings and around the edge.
The Florida Southern College project, of which
some five separate units had been finished in late
1941, is Wright’s most extensive general plan to
come to realization. The site in a large orange
grove sloping toward a lake is pleasant and not
untypical of central Florida. The existing orange grove and additional hanging plants and
flowers growing out of the buildings should provide the shade and the variety suited to the
needs and the possibilities of the climate.
The boldly asymmetrical lay-
out provides two nuclei, the
Chapel erected in 1940, with
its open, flower-filled top, and
the Library, now in construc-
tion, which is properly the
active center of an academic
institution. Covered walks for
protection against the sun link
the buildings, running on di-
agonals among the regular
groves of trees toward the pool
and lake and the great foun-
tain.
. KANSAS CITY COMMUNITY CHURCH, 3000 MAIN ST., KANSAS
CITY, MO. IN CONSTRUCTION, I 94 I. PERSPECTIVES.
The drawings of the Kansas City Church, now nearing
completion, display the dramatic effect produced by the
cantilevered parking terraces. Presumably when it is com-
K pleted it will also have a refinement and precision of finish
^ comparable to that of the Ann Pfeiffer Chapel in Florida
'X on the opposite page.
410 . PLAN AND SECTION.
411, project: crystal heights hotel, shops and theater, CONNECTICUT and FLORIDA
AVES., WASHINGTON, D. C. I94O. BIRD’s-EYE VIEW.
The Crystal Heights project is so tremendous that no available general plans make it as
intelligible as the bird’s-eye view and the general perspective on this page and the next. At the
angle of Connecticut and Florida Avenues is a moving picture theater, flanked on either side
by tiers of terraces on which shops are arranged. Above is a tremendous parking area, such
as is badly needed in all parts of Washington. Extending out onto this terrace on the Con-
necticut Avenue side are the great public rooms of the hotel. Behind this the towers of the
apartment-hotel are arranged in a comma-like cluster. Within their curve is a park area filled
with trees. Here at last is urbanism at the proper scale for the twentieth century and an
important suggestion for relieving the incredible congestion of present-day Washington.
412 proibct: crystal heiohts hotel, shops and theater, cohkecticlt and FLORIDA
aves WASHINGTON, D. c. 1940. GENERAL PERSPECTIVE, interlocking hotcl suites are
the culmination of Wrights
41 S PLAN OF TYPICAL HOTEL FLOOR. polvgonal tov/cr planning that
^ ' began with St. Mark’s Tower in
■ , ” . . . 1929. The construction is also ot
.' -'0 s i * ' that type, with the floors cantilev-
. - . . , , . ^ . i 'i ■ ered out from a triangular group
; I \ fJLr^ of interior supports, so that the
■ . . • I - i ' ’ exterior walls can be all of glass.
•> * . I •1 rJ Elevators and service facilities
V., ^ J ( are at the core, and extraordi-
4 " ^ ^ ■' narily enough, the core also pro-
, ^ vides flues for fireplaces in all the
% ' ! / y . -T:-. T ; ' larger rooms. The tremendous
■— r T V r scale makes detail a matter of
; y . p j 7 ]" ' irrelevance, but one can imagine
!"’■ Tv . . . .t'-'. . a finish comparable to that of the
: ■'' N ' executed Florida Southern Col-
' ’ '.•.'1 ' , lege buildings.
Index
Index
References to the Chronological List of Executed Work and Projects, pp. 107-130, are by
date (bracketed dates indicate sequence in the Chronological List of items entered there with-
out dates); figure numbers are italicized; sub-entries are cross-references and the word See should
be understood before them; Wright’s houses and house projects are entered under the names of
the clients wherever possible.
Abraham Lincoln Center, [1901],
1903. 4 >
All Souls Building.
Adams Building,
City National Bank.
Adams, Harry S., 1911, 66, 67, 1913
Adams, Mary M. W., 1905, 42
Adler and Sullivan, 6-14, passim,
17, 24, 25, 68, 107 n., 108 n.,
1890, 5, 4; 1891, p; 1892, zo;
1893, 6
Adler, D., and Co., 10
Adler, Dankmar, 8, 10
Affleck, Gregor, 1941, 404, 97
Albany, N. Y„
Mendelson, Jerome.
All Souls Building, [1897], 102
All Souls Church, 4
All-Steel houses, [1937], 94
Allen, Henry S., 1917, 216-218, 68,
70
Amberg, J. H., 1910
American System apartments and
houses, [1915], 205-208, 67, 94,
Munkwitz, Arthur,
Richards, Arthur L.
Amherst. Mass.,
Baird, Theodore.
Amsterdam, school of, 71
Angster, H. C., 1911, zyp-180, 66
Architectural Forum, xxviii,
Bramson, Leo,
Lusk, Robert D.,
Architectural Forum (Cont.)
Marcus, Stanley,
Parker, George.
Architectural Record, xxviii, 11,
68 n.
Architectural Review, xxviii, 31;
[1895]. [1899],
Cheltenham Beach.
Architecture Vivante, xxix
Ardmore, Penna.,
Suntop Homes.
Arizona Biltmore, 77, 125 n.
Armory Show, 63
Armstrong, Andrew F. H„ [1939], 96
Art Institute of Chicago, 85, 106
Art Nouveau, 9, 33
Art Museum, [1913]
Ashbee, C. R., xxviii, 31,
Ausgefiihrte Bauten,
Ashiya, Japan,
Yamamura.
Ashton, Willard H.,
Horseshoe Inn.
Auditorium Building, 6, 8-9, 10, 14
Auldbrass Plantation, 1940
Ausgefiihrte Bauten, xxix, 59,
Universal Portland Cement Co.
Ausgefiihrte Bauten und Entwiirfe,
xxix, 59,
Como Orchards,
Guthrie, William Norman,
Lexington Terrace,
McArdiur, Warren,
[ 133 ]
Ausgefiihrte Bauten und Entwiirfe
(Cont.)
Melson, J. G.,
Quadruple Block Plan,
Steffens, Oscar,
Stewart, George C.
Autobiography, 59, 68
Bach, Emil, 1915, 201, 202
Bagley, Frederick, [1894], 50, 5, 24,
25
Bagley, Joseph J., 1916, 210, 21 1,
66, 67
Baird, Theodore, 1940, 405
Baker, Frank J., [1908], 1909, 158,
lyp, 45, 46
Balch, O. B., 1911
Baldwin, Hiram, [1904], [1905]
Baldwin, Jesse, 1895
Baltimore, Md.,
Euchtman, Joseph.
Banff National Park, Ata., Canada,
1913
Barnes, Charles W., [1905]
Barnsdall, Aine, 80; [1917], 68;
1920, 214, 242, 70, 71, 102;
1923.
Hollyhock House.
Barnegat City. N. J.,
Watkins, Franklin.
Barton, George, 1903, zoo, 41
Barton, John, 1941
Bassett, Dr. H. W., [1894]
Batavia, 111 .,
Gridley, A. W.
Bauhaus, 76
Ba2ett, Sidney, [1940], ^84-^8'], 96
Beachy, P. A., 1906, 124, 42
Bear Run, Penna.,
Kaufmann, Edgar J.
Beaux Arts, 20, 24
Beers, Clay and Dutton, 5
Behn, Miss, [1916]
Bell, Lewis N., 1939
Belvidere, 111 .,
Pettit mortuary chapel.
Beraan, Solon S., 8
Berlage, H. P., 31, 71
Berlin, Germany, 60
Bernardsville, N. J.,
Christie, James B.
Bitter Root Irrigation Co., [1909],
[1910]* 55
Bloomfield Hills, Mich.,
Affleck, Gregor.
Blossom, George, 1892, rp,2o; 1907,
19-21, 22, 23, 25, 28
Blyth and Markley,
City National Bank and Hotel.
Bock, Richard, 27, 1906
Bogk, F. C., 1916, 70
Booth, Sherman M., 1911, 181, 182,
66, 67; [igii], [1915]
Borden house, 4 n.
Boston, Mass.,
Pray Building,
Spaulding, W. S.,
Trinity Church,
Trinity Rectory.
Boynton, E. E., 1908, 142, 143, 42,
44
Bradley, B. Harley, igoo, 55-57, 3 °’
32, 34, 43
Bramson, Leo, [1937]
Brauner, Erling B., 1939
Brentwood Heights, Cal.,
Sturges, George D.
Brickbuilderj [1901], dy, 35
Brigham, E. D., 1908, [1915]
Bristol, R. I.,
Low house.
Broadacre City, [1934]. 86, 87, 88,
90
Brookfield, 111 .,
Hilly, M. B.
Brown Decades, 8
Brown, Charles E., [1905]
Brown, Harry E., [1909]
Browne’s Bookstore, 1908, 52
Buffalo, N. Y.,
Barton, George,
Davidson, Alex,
Davidson, Walter V.,
Guaranty Building,
Heath, W. R.,
Martin, Darwin D.,
Larkin Co.,
Universal Portland Cement Co.
Burnham, Daniel, 24
Burnham and Root, 8, 52,
Root, John W.
Byzantine, g
Cahiers d’Art, xxix
Calloway, Henrietta, 105
Campement d’Ours Island,
Scudder, J. A.
Cantilevered skyscrapers, [1920], 75,
Chicago,
Crystal Heights,
National Life Insurance Co.,
St. Mark’s Tower.
Capital Journal Building, 1931,
525, 525, 86, 89, 92,
Broadacre City.
Carlson, Editli, 1938, 98
Carmel Bay, Cal.,
Nesbitt, John.
Carnegie Library, [1913]
Carr, W. S., [1916], 66, 67
Carson, Pirie and Scott Building, 8,
14. 31
Century of Progress, 85, [1931]
[ 134]
Chandler, Arizona,
Chandler, Dr. Alexander,
Ocotillo Desert Camp,
San Marcos-in-the-Desert,
San Marcos Water Gardens.
Chandler, Dr. Alexander, 1927,
255, 2^6, 72, 79,
Broadacre City,
Conventional House,
San Marcos-in-the-Desert,
San Marcos Water Gardens.
Charlevoix, Mich.,
Waller, Edward C.
Charnley, James, 1890, 11; 1891, p,
7, 12, 17, 19, 20, 22, 24, 30, 102
Cheltenham Beach, [1899]
Chemistry Building, 5
Cheney, Edwin H., 1904, /05-J07,
41. 42
Chicago, 111 ., 3, 4, 6, 7, 8, 10, 13,
ig, 20, 24, 26, 31, 33, 45, 60,
61, 62, 64, 99; [1930], 308, 50p,
82, 101, 102,
Adams, William,
All Souls Building,
All Souls Church,
Art Institute,
Auditorium Building,
Bach, Emil,
Blossom, George,
Borden house,
Browne’s Bookstore,
Century of Progress,
Carson, Pirie and Scott Building,
Charnley, James,
Cheltenham Beach,
Devin, Mrs. David,
Edgewater,
Evans, Robert W.,
Falkenau houses,
Foster, S. A.,
Francis Apartments,
Francisco Terrace,
Gage Building,
Glessner house.
Chicago, 111. (Cont.)
Harlan, Dr. Allison W.,
Heller, Isidor,
Ho Ho Den,
Horner, L. K.,
Husser, Joseph M.,
Hyde Park,
Kenwood,
Leiter Building,
Lexington Terrace,
McArthur, Warren,
McAfee, A. C.,
McAfee, James L.,
MacHarg, W. S.,
MacVeagh house,
Marshall Field Wholesale Store,
Meyer Building,
Midway Gardens,
Model Quarter Section,
Mori, S. H.,
Mozart Garden,
Oakwood,
Perkins, Robert,
Public Library,
Robie, Frederick C.,
Roloson, Robert W.,
Rookery Building,
Schiller Building,
Steffens, Oscar,
Stohrs, Peter C.,
Stock Exchange Building,
Thurber, W. Scott,
Transportation Building,
Vogelsang, John,
Walker Warehouse,
Waller, Edward C.,
Walser, J. J., jr..
World’s Fair,
Wright, Frank Lloyd.
Chicago Architectural Club, 106
Chicago Heights, 111.,
Victoria Hotel.
Chicago and Northwestern Railway
[1903]^ 5 ?
Chicago School, 31, 60
Chinese restaurant,
Richards, Arthur L.
Chippendale chairs, 33
Christian Catholic Church, [1915]
City National Bank and Hotel,
1909, 168-JJI, 39, 53, 66
Citrohan project, 73
Clark house, 108 n.
Clarke, Robert D., [1904], 1909, 8^-
pL 42
Cochran, J. L., 4
Colonial, 4, 17, 19, 21, 33
Commercial Style, 3, 8, 10
Community Church, 1940, 409, 410,
101, 102
Conventional House, 1932, 80
Converse, Clarence, [1916]
Como Orchards, [1910], i6y, 55
Coonley, Avery, 1908, i4>j-iy,^, 41,
44, 47, 48, 53, 66, 85, 93, 102;
[1911], 18^, 61, 63, 66; 1912,
184-186, 62
Cooper, Henry N., [1890]
Copeland, Dr. W. H., 1908, 1909
Craftsman, 33
Crystal Heights, 1940, 411-41^, 82,
101, 102
Cubist sculpture, 63
Cudney, Wellington and Ralph,
[1927], 28y, 288, 77
Cummings, E. W., [1907]
Curtis Publishing Co., 33,
Ladies’ Home Journal.
Cutten, Arthur W., 1911, 66
Cypress Point, Cal.,
Nesbitt, John.
Dallas, Texas,
Marcus, Stanley.
Dana, Susan Lawrence, 1903, 8^-88,
40, 41, 42, 48, 50
Darby, Mont,
Bitter Root Irrigation Co.,
Como Ordiards.
[' 35 ]
Davenport, E. Arthur, 1901
Davidson, Alex, [1906], iiy
Davidson, Walter, 1932, 5/2, _jry;
[^932],
Broadacre City.
Davidson, Walter V., 1908, 46
de Fries, H., xxix
Death Valley, Cal.,
Johnson, Arthur M.
Decatur, 111.,
Irving, E. P.,
Mueller houses.
Wood.
Deerfield, 111.,
Ellinwood, Alfred H.
Degas, H. E. G., 32
Delavan Lake, Wis.,
Goodsmith, Dr. H.,
Johnson, A. P.,
Jones, Fred B.,
Ross, Charles S.,
Spencer, George W.,
Wallis, Henry.
Delavan Lake Yacht Club, [1902]
Denver, CoL,
House on the Mesa,
de Rhodes, K. C., [1906]
Derby, N. Y.,
Martin, Darwin D.
Desbarats, Ont., Canada,
Metzger, Victor,
Pitkin, E. H.,
Scudder, J. A.
Detroit, Mich.,
Wall, Carlton David.
Devin, Mrs. David, [1896], 27;
[ i 906]_
Disappearing City, The, 87
Doheny, Edward H., 1921, 247, 75
Downer's Grove, 111.,
Cutten, Arthur W.
Dwight, 111.,
Ludington, R. S.,
Smith, Frank L.
E-Z Polish factory. 1905, pp, 52, 105
Eagle Rock, Cal.,
Lowes, G, P.
East Caldwell, N. J.,
Guenther, William.
Eckart, Robert, [1899], 35
Edgewater, 111., 4
Eiffel Tower, 82
Eliot, Me.,
Devin, Mrs. David.
Ellinwood, Mfred H., 1941
Elmhurst, III.,
Henderson, F. B.,
Wilder, T. E.
Emmond, Robert G., 1892, iS, ig,
31
Empire State Building, 82
Emporia, Kan.,
White, William Allen.
Endo, Amato, 122 n.
Engineering School, 5
Ennis, Charles, 1924, 257, 25S, 77
Esbenshade, E., [1911]
Estes Park, Col.,
Horseshoe Inn.
Euchtman, Joseph, 1940
Evans, Robert W., 1908,
43. 44
Evanston, III.,
Brown, Charles E.,
Jurgenson, Royal H.
Orr house.
Exhibitions,
Art Institute,
Museum of Modern Art,
Rockefeller Center.
Expositions,
Century of Progress,
Larkin Co.,
Universal Portland Cement Co.,
World's Fair.
Fabyan, Col. George, [1907],
Fox River Country Club.
Falkenau houses, 9
Falls Church, Va.,
Pope, Loren,
Fellows,
Moore, Nathan G.
Field Building,
Marshall Field Wholesale Store.
Field, Parker B., 1941
Fiesole, Italy,
Wright, Frank Lloyd.
Florence, Ala.,
Rosenbaum, Sidney.
Florence, Italy, 59,
Fiesole.
Florida Southern College, 87, 102;
1938, 405, 406, gg-ioi; 1940;
1941, 78,
PfeiEer, Ann.
Flossmoor, III,
Nicholas, Frederick.
Fort Lauderdale, Fla.,
Spivey, Ludd M.
Fort Worth, Texas,
Gladney, Mrs. Samuel William.
Foster, S. A., 1900
Fox River Country Club, [1907]
Francis Apartments, 1895, ^r, 25
Francisco Terrace, 1895, 75-55, 25,
26, 34, 55
Francke, ICuno, 31
Francois Premier, 4
Franklortj Ky.,
Ziegler, Rev. J. R.
Freeman, Samuel, 1924, 255-2^2, 77
Freeman, W. H., 1903
Fricke, WEliam G., 1902, ^4, 35
Froebel kindergarten method, 5, 27
Friedman, Oscar,
Lexington Terrace,
Midway Gardens.
Fukuhara, 1918, 69
Fuller, Buckminster, 82
Fuller, Grace, [1906], 27
Furbeck, George, 1897
Furbeck, Rollin, 1898, 28
Futurama, 88
[>S6]
Gage Building, 14, 31
Gale, Thomas H., 1892, 18, 19, 21,
31
Gale, Mrs. Thomas H., 1909, j 5 o,
x6z, 45, 48, 49, 53, 61, 67, 71,
i02; [1921]
Gale, Walter, 1893, [1895]
Garrison, J. J., 1939
Gary, Ind.,
Armstrong, Andrew F. H.
Geddes, Norman Bel, 70, 88
Geneva, 111.,
Brown, Harry E.,
Fabyan, Col. George,
Fox River Country Club.
German, A. D., [1915], 205, 204, 70,
71; [1934]
Gerts, George E., [1902]
Gerts, Walter, [1902], iiy, 46
Giedion, Sigfried, 3 n.
Gilmore, A. E., 1908, J57, 40
Gilpin, T. E., [1905]
Gladney, Mrs. Samuel William, 1925
Glasner, W. A., 1905, no, ni, 47
Glencoe, 111.,
Booth, Sherman M.,
Brigham, E. D.,
Fuller, Grace,
Glasner, W. A.,
Stone, Elizabeth.
Glessner house, 3, 4, 20
Goan, Orrin S., 1894, 105 n.
Goan, Peter, [1894], 28
Goetsch, Alma,
Winkler, Katherine.
Goodrich, H. C., i8g6, 28
Goodsmith, Dr. H., 1900, 31, 32, 46
Grand Beach, Mich.,
Bagley, Joseph S.,
Behn, Miss,
Carr, W. S.,
Vosburgh, Ernest.
Grand Rapids, Mich.,
Amberg, J. H.,
May, Meyer.
Great Neck, L. I., N. Y.,
Rebhuhn, Ben.
Greene, William B., 1912
Gridley, A. W., 1906, 126, 12^, 44,
45
Griffin, Walter Burley, ii9n.
Gropius, Walter, 71
Guaranty Building, 14, 62
Guenther, William, 1941
Gutheim, Frederick, xxviii
Guthrie, William Norman, [1908]
Hakone, Japan,
Fukuhara.
Hanna, Paul R., 1937, 547-35G 93»
95. 96
Hanover, Ind.,
Sigma Chi Fraternity.
Hardy, Thomas P., 1905, 112-114,
44»
Monolith Homes.
Harlan, Dr. Allison W., 1892, 21,
22, 7, la, 21, 22, 23, 34, 102
Hause, C. D., 1939
Hayashi, Aizaku, 1917, 69
Heath, W. R., 1905, 125, 42, 44. 66
Helena Valley,
Jones, Misses Lloyd,
Unity Chapel.
Heller, Isidor, 1897, 43, 44, 27, 28
Henderson, F. B., 1901, 66-68, 32,
42
Heurdey, Arthur, 1902, yr, 72, 39,
40, 42, 45, 46. 47. 50.
[1902]
Heyworth Island,
Pitkin, E. H.
Hickox, Warren, 1900, 33, 34, 30,
31. 3 S. 34. 42
Highland Park, 111., [1904],
Adams, Mary M. W.,
Millard, James Madison,
Willitts, Ward W.
Hills, E. R., [1901]. 35
Hillsborough, Cal.,
Bazett, Sidney.
Hillside Home School, 1902, 81-84,
39, 49, 50, 54, 102,
Taliesin Fellowship.
Hilly, M. B., [1913]
Hilo, Hawaii,
Pence, Martin J.
Hinsdale, 111..
Bagley, Frederick,
Freeman, W. H.
Holabird and Roche, 10, 14
Ho Ho Den, 26
Hollyhock House, [1917], 1920, 233-
241, 70. 71, 72, 75
Hood, Raymond M., 81
Horner, L. K., 1908, 136
Horseshoe Inn, 1908, 53
Hoult, H. C., [1936], 87, 93, 94, 95
House Beautiful, 33
House on the Mesa, [1913], 310,
3x1, 85, 86, 88, 89, 92,
Broadacre City.
Howe and Lescaze, 81
Hoyt, P. D., 1906, 44
Hunt, Richard M., 4
Hunt, Stephen M. B., [1907], 130,
44; 1917, 66
Husser, Joseph M., 1899, 43, 46, 27,
28, 30
Huron, S. Dak.,
Hoult, H. C.
Hyde Park, 19
lannelli, 63
Ile-de-France, 6
Inamu, Count, [1918], 69
Imperial Hotel, 1915, 68; [1917].
21^-232, 29, 50, 60, 67-71, pas-
sim, 75, 76, 80, 99, 102
Imperial Hotel Annex, [1916]
Impressionists, 26
Ingalls, J. Kibben, 1909, rdj, 44
Inland Architect, xxviii,
Clark house,
[ 137 ]
Inland Architect (Cont.)
Jones, Misses Lloyd,
Moore, Nathan G.,
Spencer, Robert W.,
Unitarian Chapel,
Inouye, Viscount, [1918], 69
international architects, 27, 72, 76,
92, 102
Irving, E. P., 1910, 42
Jacobs, Herbert, 1937, 343 - 345 > 93*
95. 96.
Broadacre City.
Jamestown, Va.,
Larkin Co.
Janesville, Wis.,
Parker, George.
Japanese art, 26, 32, 34, 35, 59, 70
Jaxon, Honore J„ [1914]
Jenney and Mundie, 10
Jester, Ralph, 1938, 364, 363, 98
Jiyu Gakuen School, 192:, 234
Johnson, A. P„ [1905], 44
Johnson, Artliur M., 1922, 75, 80,
National Life Insurance Co.
Johnson, Herbert F., jr., 1937, 339-
34 ^ > 93. 95 ‘> 1938
Johnson, S. C., and Son, Inc., 1936,
323, 330-338, 29, 86, 88, 89, 92,
93, 100, 102
Jones, Fred B., [1901], 35
Jones, Jenkin Lloyd, 4, 5, 25
Jones, Misses Lloyd, 1887; [1887], r,
5, 7, la; [1896], 42, 29,
Hillside Home School.
Jones, Owen, 6, 7
Jones, Richard Lloyd, 1929, spy-
302, 78, 79, 82, 102
Jurgenson, Royal H., [1938], 98
Kankakee, 111.,
Bradley, B. Harley,
Hickox, Warren.
Kansas City, Mo.,
Community Church,
Kansas City, Mo. (Cont.)
Sondern, Clarence W.,
War Memorial.
Kaufmann, Edgar J., xxix, 87; 1936,
320-525, sg, 88, 89-92, 93, 102;
1937. 3H > 3 ^ 5 > 1939. 3 ^ 9-373
Kehl, Professor, [1912]
Kellogg. J. W., [1913]
Kenilworth, 111.,
Baldwin, Hiram.
Kenwood, 19
Kimball, Fiske, 8, 102
Koch, H. C., 5
La Grange. 111., [1912],
Clark house,
Cooper, Henry N.,
Emmond, Robert G.,
Goan, Orrin S.,
Goan, Peter,
Hunt, Stephen M. B.
Ladies’ Home Journal, 31; 1900, 58-
^3^ 33^ 34. 40^ 43> 55; 1906.
-rsp, 44. 45
Lake Bluff, III,
Angster, H. C.
Lake Forest, III.,
McCormick, Harold F.
Lake Geneva Inn, 1912
Lake Tahoe, Cal.,
Tahoe Summer Colony.
Lakeland, Fla.,
Florida Southern College.
Lamp, Robert M., [1901],- [1903];
1904
Larkin Co., 1904, ps-pS, 29, 39, 49,
50-52. 53. 54. 59. 64, 93. 102;
[1904], 108, xopj [1907], J55,
52. 53
LarwiU, [1909]
Law, Law and Potter,
Phi Gamma Delta Fraternity.
Lawrence Memorial Library, 1905
Le Corbusier, 71, 76
Leiter Building, lo
L’Enfant, 101
Leonardo, 8
Lewis, Lloyd, 1940, p88-pgi, 97
Lexington Terrace, igoi, 775, 1909,
-^72. 34. 35. 54. 55
Libertyville, 111.,
Lewis, Lloyd.
Library and museum competition,
1893, 21
Lieber Meister,
Sullivan, Louis H.
Life, 1938, j6o, p6i, 96,
Schwartz, Bernard.
Little, Francis W., 1903, 8 p-pi, 41,
42, 44, 70; 1908; 1913, ipp, 200,
200a, 66
Livingston, N. J.,
Richardson, Stuart.
Lord, James Brown, 17
Lorillard house, 17
Los Angeles, Cal., 60, 101; [1921],
75; 1922, 244,
All-Steel houses,
Barnsdall, Aline,
Doheny, Edward H.,
Ennis, Charles,
Freeman, Samuel,
Hollyhock House,
Jester, Ralph,
Lowes, G. P.,
Mauer, Edgar J.,
Noble, Elizabeth,
Oboler, Arch,
Storer, Dr. John,
Sturges, George D.
Louvre, 21
Low house, 17
Lowes, G. P., 1922
Ludington, R. S., [1906]
Lusk, Robert D., [1936]
Luxfer Prism Go., [1895], 8, 14, 62
McAfee, A. C., 1894, 27, 28
McAfee, James L., 1894
['38]
McArthur, Albert,
Arizona Biltmore.
McArthur, Warren, 1892, 19, 22,26;
[1906], 757, 752, 54,
Wolf Lake Amusement Park.
McCallum, George Bliss, [1938],
Rentz, Frank A.
McCook, Neb.,
Barnes, Charles W.,
Sutton, Harvey P.
McCormick, Harold F., [1907], ipp-
14 1, 41, 44, 47, 48, 60
McGraw-Hill Building, 81
MacHarg, W. S., [i8go], 18
MacVeagh house, 3, 4
McKim, Mead and White, 10, 12,
17, 20, 21, 25
McVicker’s Theater, 10
Madison, Wis., [1939].
Chemistry Building,
Jacobs, Herbert,
Kehl, Professor,
Lamp, Robert M.,
Municipal Boathouse,
Pew, John C.,
Rentz, Frank A.,
Science Building,
Sundt, Vigo,
Yahara Boat Club.
Madison Hotel, [1911]
Magonigle, H. Van Buren, 102
Mahony, Marion, 118 n.
Maillart, Robert, 92
Mansart, J. H., 8
Manson, Charles L., 1940, ppp, 400,
96
Manson, Grant C., xxvii, xxix, 52,
105
Marcus, Stanley, [1935]
Maricopa Mesa,
Taliesin West.
Marquette, Mich.,
Roberts, Mrs. Abby Beecher.
Marquette Island, Mich.,
Heurtley, Arthur,
Marshall Field Wholesale Store, 3,
9
Martin, Darwin D., 1904, 100 - 104 ,
28, 46, 50; [1923]; 1927, 289 ,
290 , 79; 1928,
Barton, George,
E-Z Polish factory.
Martin, Emma, 1907
Martin, W. E., 1903,
E-Z Polish factory.
Mason City, Iowa,
City National Bank and Hotel,
Melson, J. G.,
Stockman, Dr. G. C.
Mauer, Edgar A., 1939
May, Meyer, 1909, 162
Mayan art, 77
Maywood, 111.,
Bock, Richard.
Melson, J. G., [1909], 44
Mendelson, Jerome, [1913]
Metzger, Victor, [1902]
Meyer Building, 1893, (?, 13, 14
Meyer, David,
Mozart Garden.
Midway Gardens, 1914, 191 - 198 , 53,
61, 62-64, 66, 67, 69, 102
Millard, James Madison, [1906], 46,
75
Millard, Mrs. James Madison, 1923,
249 - 254 , 75-77; [1935]
Milwaukee, Wis.,
Bogk, F. C.,
Esbenshade, E.,
Kellogg, J. W.,
Koch, H. G.,
Library and museum competi-
tion,
Munkwitz, Arthur,
Richards, Arthur L.,
Richards Brothers,
Schroeder, Edward.
Minneapolis, Minn.,
Little, Francis W.,
Willey, Malcolm C.
Mission furniture, 33
Model Quarter Section, [1915]
Mohave Desert, Cal,,
Sachse.
Monolith Homes, 1919, 72, 79
Montecito, Cal.,
Stewart, George C.
Montreal, P. Q., Canada,
Shaw, C. Thaxter.
Moore, Nathan G., 1895, 20;
[1923]* 79.
Hills, E. R.
Mori, S. H., 1914
Mosher, John A., [1902]
Morrison, Hugh, xxix, 7 n., 107 n.
Moving Picture theaters, [1908];
[igi8], 215 , 70
Mozart Garden, 1898
Mueller houses, 119 n.
Mueller, Paul, 68
Municipal Boathouse, 1893
Munkwitz, Arthur, 1916, 67
Museum of Modern Art, xxvii,
xxix, 85, 87, 105, 106,
Affleck, Gregor,
Broadacre City,
House on the Mesa,
Jester, Ralph.
Muskegon, Mich.,
Larwill.
Nagoya, Japan,
Odawara Hotel.
Nakoma Country Club, [1924], 269 -
268 , 78,
Broadacre City.
National Life Insurance Co., [1924],
265 - 266 , 80, 81, 82
Neo-Plasticis ts, 62
Nesbitt, John, 1940, 96, 97,
Ennis, Charles.
New Theater, 1932, 102,
Broadacre City.
New York, N. Y., 4> 3L
Empire State Building,
[139]
New York, N. Y. (Cont.)
McGraw-Hill Building,
Museum of Modern Art,
Rockefeller Center,
St. Mark’s To^ver,
Universal Portland Cement Co.
New York zoning law, 80
Newman, Sidney H., 1939
Nicholas, Frederick, [1906]
Noble, Elizabeth, [1929], 505 , 504 ,
81, 82, 85,
Broadacre City.
Northampton, Mass.,
McCallum, George Bliss.
Oak Park, 111,, 6, 59, 64, 86; [1902],
Balch, O. B.,
Bassett, Dr. H. W.,
Beachy, P. A.,
Bramson, Leo,
Cheney, Edwin H.,
Chicago and Northwestern Rail-
way,
Copeland, Dr. W. H.,
Fricke, William G.,
Furbeck, George,
Furbeck, Rollin,
Gale, Thomas H.,
Gale, Mrs. Thomas H.,
Gale, Walter,
Gilpin, T. E.,
Goodrich, H. C.,
Hills, E. R.,
Martin, Emma,
Martin, W. E.,
Moore, Nathan G.,
Parker, R. P.,
Pebbles and Balch,
Roberts, Charles E.,
Scoville Park fountain,
Smith, George W.,
Thomas, Frank,
Ullman, H. J.,
Unity (Universalist) Church,
Woolley, Francis,
Oak Park, 111. (Cont.)
Wright, Frank Lloyd,
Young, H. P.
Oak Park Playground Association,
1996
Oak wood, 19
Oboler, Arch, 1941, 414, 41^, 97
Ocean Springs, Miss.,
Charnley, James,
Sullivan, Louis H.
Ocotillo Desert Gamp, 1927, 2>]6-
280, 78, 97
Odawara Hotel, [1917], 277, 6g
Ogden Dunes, Ind.,
Armstrong, Andrew F. H.
Okemos, Mich., 96,
Brauner, Erling B.,
Hause, C. D.,
Garrison, J. J.,
Newman, Sidney H„
Panshin, Alexis J.,
Van Dusen, Clarence R.,
Winkler, Katherine.
Ordynsky, 70
Orr house, ig
Oshkosh, Wis.,
Hunt, Stephen M, B.
Ottawa, P. Q., Canada,
Carnegie Library,
Sullivan, Francis W.
Oud, J. J. P., 71
Palisades Park, Mich.,
Converse, Clarence.
Palladio, 17, 20
Palm Beach, Fla., [1913], 60
Palo Alto, Cal,
Hanna, Paul R.
Palos Verdes, Cal,,
Jester, Ralph.
Panshin, Alexis J., 1939
Paradise Valley,
Taliesin West.
Paris, France,
Beaux Arts,
Paris, France (Cont.)
Eiffel Tower,
Louvre.
Park Hotel,
City National Bank and Hotel.
Park Ridge, 111., Country Club,
[1912]
Parker, George, [1937]
Parker, R. P., 1892, ry, 18, ig, 21
Parnassus, xxviii
Pasadena, Cal.,
Millard, Mrs. James Madison.
Pauson, Rose, 50, 97
Pavlowa, 63
Pebbles and Balch, 1907, 1^4, 52,
Bramson, Leo.
Pembroke, Ottawa, P. Q., Canada,
Carnegie Library.
Pence, Martin J„ [1940], g8
Peoria, 111.,
Clarke, Robert D.,
Litde, Francis W.
Perkins, Dwight Heald,
Abraham Lincoln Center,
All Souls Building.
Perkins, Robert, 1896, 13 n.
Perrault, 21
Peru, Ind.,
Field, Parker B.,
Peruzzi, 12
Petersen, Roy, 1941
Pettit mortuary chapel, [1906]
Pew, John C., 1940, ppd-ppS, 97
Pfeiffer, Ann, 1940, 40J, 408, 99,
100, 102
Phi Gamma Delta Fraternity, 1925
Philadelphia Savings Fund Society
Building, 81
Phoenix, Arizona,
Arizona Biltmore,
Pauson, Rose,
Taliesin West,
Piedmont Pines, Cal.,
Smith, E. A.
[no]
Pine Bluff, Wis.,
Barton, John.
Pitkin, E. H., 1900, 31, 32, 46
Pittsburgh, Penna.,
Kaufmann, Edgar J.
Platt, Charles A., 60,
McCormick, Harold F.
Pond, Irving K., 31
Pope, Loren, 1940
Porter, Andrew T., 1907; [1907];
1911
Post-Impressionists, 26
Powell, 1917
Prairie houses, 21, 22, 23, 30, 33, 34,
35. 39. 4L 44. 48, 49> 50. 53> 61,
70, 90» 9 S> 96
Pray Building, 9
Press Building, [1912], rSy, 188, 62
Prohibition, 62, 63
Public Library, 21
Pueblo Opera House, 9, 10, 12
Putnam, George,
Capital Journal Building.
Quadruple Block Plan, 1900; [1903],
34. 55
Queen Anne, 4, 12, 18, 20
Racine, Wis.,
Hardy, Thomas P.,
Johnson, Herbert F., jr.,
Johnson, S. C., and Son, Inc.,
Monolith Homes,
Petersen, Roy.
Ravine Bluffs,
Booth, Sherman M.
Ready-Cut,
American System.
Ream, Norman B.,
Cheltenham Beach.
Rebhuhn, Ben, 1938
Rentz, Frank A., [1940]
Richards, Arthur L„ [1915]; 1916,
67, 122 n.,
Lake Geneva Inn,
liicliards, Arthur L. (Cont.)
Madison Hotel.
Richards Brothers,
American System.
Richland Center, Wis.,
German, A. D.
Richardson, Henry Hobson, xxix,
3-5, 7-11, passim, 20, 39,
Suburban Richardsonian.
Richardson, Stuart, 1941
Richardsonian,
Richardson, Henry Hobson.
River Forest, 111.,
Cummings, E. W.,
Davenport, E. Arthur,
Gerts, Walter,
Ingalls, J. Kibben,
Roberts, Isabel,
Roberts, Mrs. Mary,
Waller, Edward G.,
Williams, Chauncey L.,
Winslow, William H.
River Forest Golf Club, [1898], 47,
45; [1901], 4P, 50, 29, 30, 32,
33, 46, 49, 91, 102
River Forest Tennis Club, 1905;
1906, 49
Riverside, 111.,
Coonley, Avery.
Roberts, Charles E., [1896]; [1903],
55
Roberts, Isabel, igo8, 154-1^6, 43,
44. 45. 61
Roberts, Mrs. Abby Beecher, 1936
Robie, Frederick C., igog, 164-166,
40, 79, 102
Robinson, Harry,
Greene, William B.
Rochester, N. Y.,
Boynton, E. E.
Rockefeller Center, 87, loi
Rockefeller Foundation, [1915]
Rogers, James C.,
Thomas, Frank.
Roloson, Robert W., 1894, 25, 24,
25. 105
Romanesque, 4, 9, 10
Romeo and Juliet,
Jones, Misses Lloyd.
Rookery Building, 1905, 12^, 52
Root, John W., 27,
Burnham and Root.
Rosenbaum, Stanley, 1939, 346,
381-383, 95
Rosenwald Foundation, iggg
Ross, Charles S., 1902, 77, yS, 46,
102
Ruskin, John, 5
Sachse, [1922]
Saguaro cactus, 77
St. Louis, 10,
Wainwright Building,
Wainwright Tomb.
St. Mark’s Tower, [1929], 303, 303,
81, 82, 98, 101, 102,
Broadacre City.
Salem, Mass., 4
Salem, Oregon,
Capital Journal Building.
Salt Range,
Ocotillo Desert Camp.
San Francisco, Cal.,
Press Building,
Tower Building.
San Marcos-in-the-Desert, [1927],
281-284, 77, 78, 81,
Cudney, Wellington and Ralph,
Young, Owen D.
San Marcos Water Gardens, [1927],
291, 292, 78; [1930],
Broadacre City.
Schevill, Margaret, 1941, 98
Schiller Building, 3, 13, 14, 28
Schindler, R. M.,
Bamsdall, Aline,
Lowes, G. P.,
Monolith Homes.
[ 141 ]
School of the Allied Arts,
Taliesin Fellowship.
Schroeder, Edward, igii
Schwartz, Bernard, [1939], 362, 363,
97
Science Building, 5
Scoville Park Fountain, [1903]
Scudder, J. A., [1904], 44
Sewanee, Tenn.,
Guthrie, William Norman.
Service stations, 1928, 233, 234, 80
Shampay, J. P.,
Monolith Homes.
Shaw, C. Thaxter, 1906, 42; [1906]
Shaw, R. Norman, 21
Shepley, Rutan and Coolidge, 21
Shorewood Hills, Wis.,
Pew, John Cip.
Sierra Madre Mountains, Cal.,
Doheny, Edward H.
Sigma Chi Fraternity, 1941
Silsbee, J. L., 4-7, passim, is, 17,
ig, 107 n.
Sioux City, Iowa,
Unitarian Chapel.
Smith, E. A., 1938
Smith, Frank L., 1904, 1905, 1x3,
1x6
Smitli, George W., 1898
Sondern, Clarence W., 1940, 401,
402
South Bend, Ind.,
de Rhodes, K. C.
Spaulding, W. S., [1919]
Spencer, George W., [1902]
Spencer, Robert C., 26, 31,
Ullman, H. J.
Spivey, Ludd M., [1939]
Spreckels Estate,
Press Building.
Spring Green, Wis., 64,
Hillside Home School,
Jones, Misses Lloyd,
Porter, Andrew T.,
Spring Green, Wis. (Cont.)
State Bank,
Taliesin I, II, III,— cottages, —
farm group,— Fellowship,
Unity chapel,
Waterstreet, Mary.
Springfield, 111.,
Dana, Susan Larvrence,
Lawrence Memorial Library.
Springfield, Ohio,
Westcott, Burton J.
Staley, C. E.,
Monolidi Homes.
State Bank, [1914]
Steel Cathedral, [1926], 82, 102,
Broadacre City.
Steffens, Oscar, [1909], 44
Stevens, Leigh,
Auldbrass Plantation.
Stewart, George C., [igog], 46
Stickley, Gustave,
Craftsman^
Mission furniture.
Stock Exchange Building, 7, 13, 14
Stockman, Dr. G. C., [igo8]
Stohrs, Peter C., [1909], 53
Stone, Elizabeth, [1906]
Storer, Dr. John, [1923], 255, 355,
77
Strong, Gordon, [1925],
Broadacre City.
Studio, 33
Sturges, George D., [1939], 37Pj 380,
97
Suburban Richardsonian, 3, 4, 11,
17, 19, 20, 21, 24, 29
Sugar Loaf Mountain, Md.,
Strong, Gordon.
Sullivan, Albert W., 1892, i2, 13
Sullivan, Francis W.,
Banff National Park,
Carnegie Library.
Sullivan, Louis H., xxix, 6-14,
passim, 17, 20-25, passim, 27,
35, 48, 62, 68 n., 102, 107 n.;
i8go, 3, 4, 11, 17, i8,
Adler and Sullivan,
Sullivan, Albert H.
Sullivanian,
Sullivan, Louis H.
Sundt, Vigo, 1941
Suntop Homes, 1939, 366-368, g8,
99, 101
Sutton, Harvey P., 1905; 1907, 44
S^aacuse, N. Y., 4
Tacoma Building, 10
Tahoe Summer Colony, 1922, 245-
78
Taliesin I, 1911, 1^4-178, 50, 60, 61,
62, 64-66, 102
Taliesin II, 1914, 64, 65, 67, 86, 102
Taliesin III, 1925, xxix, 26^-273,
29, 55, 64, 65, 79, 82, 102, 105
Taliesin cottages, [1912]
Taliesin farm group, [1938]
Taliesin Fellowship, xxvii, xxviii,
1933, 50, 66, 86, 87, 88
Taliesin West, 1938, front., 332,
353> 355-359^ 5O' 64, 78, 93, 97
Tallmadge, Thomas S., 3 n.
Taylor house, 17, 20, 21
Terre Haute Trust Co.,
Francis Apartments.
Thomas, Frank, 1901, 63-70, 42, 43
Thurber, W. Scott, 1909
Titian, 102
Tod Co.,
Suntop Homes.
Tokyo, Japan, 60, 68, 75,
Hayashi, Aizaku,
Immu, Count,
Imperial Hotel,
Imperial Hotel Annex,
Inouye, Viscount,
Jiyu Gakuen School,
Moving Picture Theater,
United States Embassy.
[ 142 ]
Tomek, F. F., 1907, 137, 138
Tomlinson, H. Webster, 111 n.
Toulouse-Lautrec, H. de, 32
Tower Building, 62
Transportation Building, 13
Trinity Church, 3, 4
Trinity Rectory, 12
Tucson, Arizona,
Schevill, Margaret.
Tudor, 25
Tulsa, Oklahoma,
Jones, Richard Lloyd.
Turnock, E. Hill, 108 n.
Tuxedo Park, N. Y.,
Lorillard house.
Two Rivers, Wis.,
Schwartz, Bernard.
Oilman, H. J., [1904]
Unitarian Chapel, 1887, 3, 5, 11
United States Embassy, 1914, 42
Unity Chapel, 4
Unity (Universalist) Church, 1906,
1x8-122, 35, 39, 49, 53, 54, 59,
64, 102
Universal Portland Cement Co.,
1901, 49; [1910]
University of Wisconsin, 3, 5
Usonian houses, 47, 80, 88, 90, 93-
95, 98, 101, 102; 1939, 374> 98,
Broadacre City.
Van Dusen, Clarence R., 1939
Vanderbilts, 4
Varnish factory, [1905], 52
Verrocchio, 8
Victoria Hotel, 1892, 10, 13, 24
Viollet-le-Duc, E. E., 5
Voight,
Behn, Miss.
Vogelsang, John, [1914]
von Flolst, Herman V., ii8n.
Vosburgh, Ernest, [1916], 2x2-214,
66, 67
Wagnerian, g
Waimvright Building, lo, 12, 13,
14, 17, 23, 62
Waim\Tight Tomb, 24 n.
Walker Warehouse, 9
Wall, Carlton David, 1941
Waller, Edward C., 23, 24, 52, 62;
i 895> 1899, 51, 28, 29, 30;
[1899], 52, 35; 1902; 1903; 1909,
Cheltenham Beach,
Francisco Terrace,
Lexington Terrace,
Rookery Building.
Waller, Edward C., jr.,
Lexington Terrace,
Midway Gardens.
Wallis, Henry, riSoyl;
Goodsmith, Dr. H.
Walser, J. J„ jr., 1903
War Memorial, 102
Warder house, 8
Wasmuth, Ernst, xxviii,
Ausgefilhrte Bauten,
Ausgefuhrte Bauten und Ent-
wiirfe.
Waterstreet, Mary, 1941
Watkins, Franklin, [1940]
Watson, Vernon S.,
River Forest Tennis Club.
Washington, D. C.,
Crystal Heights,
Warder house.
Wausau, Wis.,
Manson, Charles L.
Wayzata, Minn.,
Little, Francis W.
Weber, W. J., 1920
Wendingen, xxix, 71
West Racine, Wis,,
Petersen, Roy.
Westcott, Burton J., 1907, J55
Westmorland, Wis.,
Jacobs, Herbert.
White, Charles E,, jr.,
River Forest Tennis Club,
White, Stanford, 19,
McKim, Mead and White.
White, William Allen, [1916]
Whitehall, Mich., 112 n.,
Gerts, George E.,
Gerts, Walter,
Gale, Mrs. Thomas H.
Wichita, Kan., 60,
Allen, Henry J.,
Powell.
Wilder, T. E., 1901
Willey, Malcolm C„ 1932, $14, 5/5;
1934, 316-^18, 88, 89, 90, 93, 95
Williams, Chauncey L., 1895, ap,
26, 30
Willitts, Ward W., 1902, JS-jS, 42,
43, 46
Wilde, Oscar, 25
Wilmette, 111.,
Baker, Frank J.
Wind Point, Wis.,
Johnson, Herbert F., jr.
Winkler, Katherine, 1939, 375-378 , 95
Winnebago Camping Ground In-
dian Memorial,
Nakoma Country Club.
Winslow, William H., 1893, 25-28,
12, 18, 20, 23, 24, 25, 30
Wolf Lake Amusement Park, 1895,
37> 27- 52
Wood, [1915]
Woolley, Francis, 1894
World’s Fair, 20, 21, 24, 27,
Century of Progress.
Wright, Anna Lloyd,
Taliesin I.
Wright, Frank Lloyd, passim; 1889,
11, 12, 17-ig, 34, 64;
1895, 38-41, 26, 27; [1902], 80;
[1910]; [1911], 183, ipo,
Ocotillo Desert Camp,
Taliesin I, II, III,— cottages,—
farm group,— West.
Wright, Lloyd,
Millard, Mrs. James Madison.
Yahara Boat Club, 1902, 7p, 45, 49,
61, 72
Yamamura, [1918]
Yemassee, S. C.,
Auldbrass Plantation.
Yeomans, Alfred B.,
Model Quarter Section.
Young, H. P., 1895
Young, Owen D., [1927], 285, 286,
77
Ziegler, Rev. J. R., 1910
Zion City, 111.,
Christian Catholic Church.
Zukunftsschmuckj 9
[ 145]
142 487